Deputy Director and Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator Xavier F. Salomon enjoys a Great Maiden’s Blush cocktail while discussing a 1795 portrait of Elizabeth Sophia Baillie (née de Vismes) by Sir William Beechey. A work of mysterious origin—and thought for a century to be by the English portraitist John Hoppner—it was only recently attributed to Beechey by Eloise Owens during her time as a curatorial assistant at the Frick.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Xavier Salomon of The Frick Collection explains the re-attribution of an 18th-century British portrait. Long misidentified as a work by John Hoppner depicting Lucy Elizabeth Bing, new research involving a miniature and a scaled drawing proves the painting is actually by Sir William Beechey and depicts Miss Devine, a work previously believed to be lost since 1795.
Good evening, I am Xavier Salomon,
Deputy Director and Peter Jay Sharp Chief Curator
at The Frick Collection.
Welcome to this episode of Cocktails with a Curator.
This evening, we're going to be talking about
this eighteenth-century British picture
in The Frick Collection.
And I am pairing this with this cocktail,
which is called a Grey Maiden's Blush.
And this is made of equal parts of gin,
lemon juice, and elderflower cordial on the rocks,
topped with pink champagne.
Cheers.
The portrait I'm talking about today
is, in fact, a perfect example
of why art historical studies matter
and how great discoveries still can be made
in public collections like The Frick.
This is a work of art
which has been drastically re-evalued over the past year,
and this is the story of how that happened.
So in April 1899,
Henry Clay Frick bought this painting
by the dealer Knoedler.
In his early collecting activities
in the late nineteenth century, in the 1890s,
Frick was particularly interested
in female British portraits.
And actually, many other collectors at the time
in the United States
were particularly keen on these sort of portraits.
It may come as a surprise to many
that these sort of portraits
were actually the most expensive works of art
on the American market at that time,
and that especially English dealers, European dealers,
were very keen to sell many of these portraits,
which until that point were in English country houses,
to American collectors.
And of course, the American collectors,
all pretty much male,
were particularly interested in the female portraits,
not so much the male portrait.
This is a painting that had been acquired
by Knoedler's partner, another dealer, Thomas Agnews,
just slightly less than a year before, in July 1898.
And on the 28th of July 1898,
Agnews bought this portrait
from Moor and Temple estate agents.
And we don't really know much about these estate agents,
who they were and where they got the portrait from.
But in any case, Agnew acquired the portrait
and then, through Knoedler,
sold it to Frick later in the spring of 1899.
The portrait was acquired by Frick
when Frick still lived in Pittsburgh.
And here you see a photograph from around that time
of the parlor at Clayton,
the house where the Frick family lived in Pittsburgh,
where you see three British portraits
that were all acquired between 1898 and 1899.
On the right is the portrait by Romney
of Mary Finch-Hatton,
which is still at the Frick Collection.
And at the center, a portrait which Frick bought,
believing to be by Reynolds,
but in fact was then demoted and sold,
and it's now in a different collection.
And on the left, you see the portrait
that he acquires from Knoedler in 1899.
This is the portrait of Mary Finch-Hatton,
which is, in fact, the painting by Romney,
which is the first British female portrait
that Frick acquires and remains at the Frick
as the first in a long series of British portraits
that will make the collection of Frick
particularly well known.
And here, again, you see the portrait
that he buys from Knoedler in 1899
at the center, surrounded by, again,
Mary Finch-Hatton on the left
and another portrait by Romney on the right.
In the library of the Frick Collection,
and here we are in the 1910s,
once the house on 70th Street was built.
So the portrait that Frick acquires
is attributed to John Hoppner.
John Hoppner was a British portraitist painter
born in 1758 in London
from a family of originally German origins,
and he will die in London in 1810,
having spent all of his career
in the capital of the United Kingdom.
Hoppner was a beloved society portraitist.
He portrayed many of the great celebrities of the time,
members of the royal family,
the great political figures of the time,
and many of the aristocratic ladies of the age.
Just to give you a few examples,
this is his portrait of the Prince Regent,
the future George IV,
the son of George III and Queen Charlotte,
and this, to this day, is still in the Royal Collection.
Hoppner lived through a difficult time
of the sort of 1790s, early 1800s,
the moment of the Napoleonic Wars,
which were changing Europe forever,
and he portrays some of the great British heroes
of the Napoleonic Wars.
So this is his great portrait of Admiral Nelson.
This is still, to this day, in the Royal Collection.
The great full-length portrait
of the victorious admiral of the Battle of the Nile,
the Battle of Copenhagen, and the Battle of Trafalgar.
And also the young Duke of Wellington.
This, of course, is before the great victory at Waterloo.
Hoppner was never to witness
the end of the Napoleonic trajectory
as he died five years before Waterloo.
But he also portrayed some of the great intellectual
and artistic figures of the time.
This is another painting that the Prince Regent
loved very much and kept in his collection
and is, to this day, still in the Royal Collection,
which is a portrait of the German composer
Franz Josef Haydn.
And this was never completed.
You see it in its sort of very sketchy,
rather beautiful solution that Hoppner reaches.
And it was left this way and entered the Royal Collection.
But Hoppner was also famous for his portraits,
group portraits of children.
And so here you see the children of the Douglas family,
now at Watersden Manor,
the home of the Rothschild family.
So this is one of the grand portraits of children
that Hoppner produces in the late 1790s and early 1800s.
But he was well known also for portraits
of aristocratic ladies.
And this is the second Hoppner that Frick acquires,
all the way towards the end of his life in 1915,
by the time he's building the house
and moving into the house at 1 East 70th Street.
This, to this day, still hangs where Frick had it,
over the mantelpiece in the dining room at the Frick,
presiding over a whole room of British portraiture.
And this represents Ladies Sarah and Catherine Bly,
and it was painted around 1790.
So when Frick acquires, in 1899, the portrait by Hoppner,
Agnew and Knoedler,
who presumably had come up with this attribution,
unless the attribution already came from the estate agents
from Moreham Temple who sold the portraits to Agnew,
it also came with the identification
of a very specific person.
And the sitter in the portrait is described at the time
as the daughter of Admiral Bing.
Subsequent studies in the catalogs of the Frick Collection
and all the studies on this painting
identify this woman as Lucy Elizabeth Bing.
Lucy Elizabeth Bing was born in 1794 and dies in 1875,
and she is the daughter of Vice Admiral George Bing,
who becomes the sixth Viscount Torrington.
The main problem with this identification
is the fact that Hoppner died in 1810,
and when Hoppner died, Lucy Bing was sixteen years old.
So this is a problem that has been referred to
in much of the literature around this portrait,
and yet it has never really been solved.
The sitter clearly looks older than a sixteen-year-old girl.
And the other problem is that a portrait of Lucy Bing
is not documented at any point in the career of Hoppner.
So this is a portrait that has remained,
more or less, hidden upstairs at the Frick.
This usually now hangs on the second floor at the Frick
and is not among the works of art
that are visible on the first floor.
And this remained like this until very recently,
and until one of the Frick's curatorial assistants,
Eloise Owen, started looking at this picture,
very much interested in it
because a private collector got in touch with her
with a miniature of the same sitter,
clearly based on this portrait.
And as she was researching the portrait and the miniature,
she came across a very important piece of evidence.
The portrait had been engraved,
but it had been engraved in the late nineteenth century
when it was believed to be Hoppner's portrait of Lucy Bing.
And this print was probably commissioned
around the time when Agnews acquired the portrait.
But going back to the painting and the miniature
that Eloise was presented with,
she managed to connect it to this drawing.
And the miniature was attributed to Henry Bone.
And Henry Bone is a British artist
who made copies of famous paintings,
based, well, made in miniatures,
that were made as sort of replicas
of celebrated works of art.
And so before making the miniatures,
he would base the work on a scaled drawing,
a sort of squared drawing made this way
so that it could be exactly copied
in a smaller version in miniature.
And three albums of these drawings by Bone
showing many celebrated works.
For example, the album includes Holbein's Thomas More,
which is also at the Frick,
but it includes, clearly, the Frick portrait.
But the inscription below it reads,
"'Mist the Veam After Beachy' for Captain Bailey, 1795."
So different artist, different sitter,
and suddenly a very different story came to light.
And Eloise has just published
this very important piece of research
in the Burlington Magazine in April of this year.
So this is brand new information,
which actually allowed us to date the portrait,
but also come up with a different attribution
and a different identification of the sitter.
So the portrait is, in fact, by Sir William Beachy
and not by John Hockner.
William Beachy was an exact contemporary of Hockner.
He was born five years earlier, in 1753, in Oxfordshire,
and he died almost thirty years later, in 1839.
He had a much longer career.
He also started working for the royal family
and ended his life as the official painter
for King William IV, who was George IV's younger brother.
Beachy was well known for his very irascible temper,
but also for the great generosity
he showed towards young artists.
He was a pupil of Zoffany,
but he ends up supporting a large number of young artists,
including John Constable.
And when we look at Beachy's career,
we realize that, in style, he is very similar to Hockner,
and he also ends up painting
many of the same sitters that Hockner painted.
And if you think of this period,
in the late 1790s, early 1800s, in London,
the three great painters of this generation
are Hockner, Beachy, and Lawrence.
And here is Beachy's portrait of the old Queen Charlotte,
the Prince Regent's mother.
This is now at the Courtauld Gallery in London.
And so from very early on,
Beachy paints works of art like this,
grand works of art for the royal family.
He paints the Prince Regent himself.
And if you look at this portrait
and think back to the Hockner,
it is not that different.
Clearly, different pose, different outfit,
but the two are working around the same sitters
around the same time.
This is one of my favorite works by Beachy,
and this is actually, again, a portrait of Admiral Nelson.
But this is an unfinished sketch,
clearly designed to be used
on a much grander, full-scale portrait.
And this is now at the National Portrait Gallery in London.
Beachy, like Hockner, became very famous
for his portraits of children,
group portraits of children.
And again, these are very similar when you see them.
This is the very large portrait of the Oddie children,
which is now in the North Carolina Museum of Art in Raleigh,
which shows brothers and sisters from this family.
But also another celebrated work by Beachy
is this one, which shows Sir Francis Ford's children,
and is now at Tate Britain in London.
This is actually, in many ways,
a very upsetting and strange picture,
but very much of that age
and very much showing the double standards,
in a way, of society at that time.
So this shows a brother and sister
from this aristocratic family
who encounter, in an imaginary wood in a garden,
a beggar boy who's actually a little bit older than them.
And so this is this really terrible
and harsh, in a way, encounter
between children of very different social backgrounds.
And of course, what Beachy is doing with this picture,
and many of his pictures and pictures of the time
had this very moral undertone,
is the fact that while the boy,
the future head of the family,
sort of looks somewhat down on the beggar,
the girl is giving him a coin.
And this is because, of course,
women's role in society, aristocratic women's role,
one of their roles was charitable works.
So a really strange work for us in the twenty-first century,
but very much a work that captures
the beliefs and thoughts of the late eighteenth century
in the United Kingdom and in many parts of Europe.
So through the miniature of Henry Bone
and through Eloise Irwin's discovery,
we now know that this is a portrait by Beachy
and not by Hoppner.
If you've looked at the portraits that I showed you,
you can see that in many instances
the style of the two painters is somewhat similar
and there's been much confusion
between the two over the last few hundred years
in terms of art history.
But while the mythical portrait of John Hoppner,
of Lucy Bing, as I mentioned earlier,
is never documented and we don't know about it,
this portrait, a portrait of Miss Devine by Beachy,
is very well documented.
And until this year, it was considered lost.
So in 1795, Beachy shows this portrait at the Royal Academy.
It's documented and it is described.
And people mention it as being a very beautiful portrait
for its breadth of light, for the harmony of coloring,
and a number of other points.
And Beachy and Hoppner are often compared,
usually favorably for Beachy,
at the Royal Academy when the show portrait's
in the same show.
So this is another case in 1795
where Beachy's portrait is lauded at the Royal Academy
much more than any of Hoppner's works
that are exhibited at that point.
And the woman is Elisabeth Sophia Devine,
who was born in 1775 and will die in 1804.
She was born in London and grew up in London,
but her family, the Devine family, as the name suggests,
was originally of French origins.
There were Huguenots that escaped to Britain
during the religious wars
and escaped from France to a Protestant country, to the UK.
When she's portrayed in 1795, she's twenty years old,
so the age makes a lot more sense
than the supposed portrait of Lucy Bing.
And what we know about Miss Devine is actually very little.
She became an orphan.
Her father died when she was fourteen years old.
And the Henry Bone miniature in the drawing
mentions that it is made for Captain Bailey.
And Captain Bailey was her mother's father,
her maternal grandfather, who was Captain Thomas Bailey,
who was the lieutenant governor of Greenwich Hospital.
And it is likely that the grandfather
took the place of her father, taking care of her,
and possibly commissioned this portrait
and the miniature to keep.
And the portrait may have been made, we don't know,
but it could be, in view of a possible marriage.
Elizabeth Sophia was an only daughter,
and so clearly her mother and maternal grandfather
were very interested in her future.
And so it is likely that the Beachy portrait
may have been made in view of a future possible wedding.
She ended up marrying, in fact,
but a few years later, in 1801,
and she marries her first cousin, John Bailey.
So John is the son of her mother's brother.
And the two lived together, as far as we know,
until her death only three years later, in 1804.
We don't know what she died of,
but Elizabeth Sophia Levine Bailey dies in 1804,
aged twenty-nine, with no children.
And so this is really the end of her story,
as far as we know.
So this is a portrait that enters a period of total obscurity
because we don't really know what happens to it.
We assume that John Bailey must have kept
the portrait of his widow after her death,
but how and where it was
between 1804 and 1898, for about ninety-four years,
we don't really know.
And during this period,
the fact that the lady portrayed
was not a particularly celebrated historical character,
was someone who had died without having a family,
so the memory of her identity
was lost, presumably, very early on.
And it then, for unknown reasons,
reached this new attribution to John Hoppner
and this new identity as Lady Bing.
And, in fact, for the last hundred years and more,
while it's been at the Frick Collection,
this painting has always been catalogued
and discussed as John Hoppner's portrait of Lucy Bing.
But we now know, thanks to Eloise Doan's work,
that this is actually the first and only work
in the Frick Collection by William Beachy.
And, in fact, it shows Elizabeth Sophia de Wiem,
and we now know exactly who the sitter is.
So the study of art history is something
that still brings new information
as we work on the collection at the Frick
but in any other museum.
And that is part of the importance of research.
All of the stories that I've been recounting
over many evenings in Cocktails with a Curator
are all based on the research done
by generations of art historians before me,
by myself, by my colleagues.
And museums should remain, for the future,
as important research centres
where the history of our works of art,
of our past, is better understood
for us to know and understand it in a better way.
I look forward to welcoming you all next week
with another episode of Cocktails with a Curator.
Good evening.