V Shape Recovery or Bear Market Rally? (Here is What History Says)

Coin Crunch
8 followers
May 17, 2025
V Shape Recovery or Bear Market Rally? (Here is What History Says)
Well, the stock market soared as the U.S. and China agreed to roll back tariffs imposed.
Look at these markets. These markets are as green as Dan's jacket.
A pair of dramatic White House announcements adding rocket fuel to the markets today.
And the Dow surged more than 1,100 points yesterday,
with the U.S. and China agreeing to that dramatically reduced tariffs.
Everyone is watching it. A $54 trillion asset class has been recovering
after a crash with a violence only comparable to the pandemic and the great financial crisis.
A record 60% of households have exposure to the stock market today.
And the question that's on everyone's minds is whether this rally is actually sustainable.
Well, we're going to be diving into the hard historical data in order to answer that question
in this video. First, let's establish the three potential scenarios that are in front of us.
A V-shaped recovery with stocks immediately recovering back to their highs and resuming
their bull market. A deeper pullback taking the stock market down past the low it made on the
7th of April. And finally, a consolidation where price stays within a range for weeks,
perhaps months, before eventually resuming higher. We're going to look at each scenario
to understand what it would take in order for these to happen. And more importantly,
evaluate which one of these is the likeliest to occur today.
Let's start with the possibility of a V-shaped recovery. In order for this scenario to take
place, we basically need to see a 180-degree flip on the economic outlook. This would basically mean
that all of the concerns that were priced in during this correction at the beginning of 2025
would completely disappear into irrelevance over the coming weeks and months. The news of a trade
deal between the US and China is leading many to believe that the skies are clear for stocks to
moving higher from here. And indeed, we've seen this kind of V-shaped recovery happen before in
history. The most recent example is of course COVID, where the stock market crashed by 35%,
only to snap back up all the way back to its all-time highs, almost in a straight line.
We also saw this type of distinct V-shaped recovery towards the end of the Great Financial
Crisis. Within just a few months, investors went from expecting a total collapse of the financial
system to expecting a very strong rebound in economic growth. The problem is that in both of
these V-shaped recovery examples, huge amounts of monetary stimulus were likely responsible for
these V-shaped recovery rallies. We can see this by simply adding the US Federal Reserve's balance
sheet, which reflects how much liquidity the Fed is injecting into the financial system. And we see
that the two biggest jumps in liquidity injections occurred right before these two V-shaped recoveries.
This is not something that we're witnessing today, so the V-shaped recovery scenario is
already off to a bad start. But it's not all bad news for this scenario. There are some things that
are going for it. For instance, stock market earnings, so how much money companies are
actually making, have been very resilient despite the 20% drawdown in the stock market.
This chart shows us the earnings per share estimates of the S&P 500. And if we zoom in
closer on the 2025 earnings, we can actually see that earnings estimates are higher today in May
than they were in January before the correction started. At the beginning of the month,
giants like Microsoft, Meta, Apple, and Amazon all reported stronger than expected earnings.
And there's some real driving factors that are pushing these earnings higher. The weakness that
we've seen on the US dollar recently is helping make the international revenues of these companies
look bigger. A weak US dollar also has a stimulative effect on the economy. We've had
lower gas prices that have helped keep consumers' heads above the water. And the Federal Reserve has
been lowering interest rates over the past year, which could also be starting to have some
stimulative effects on the economy. These are all factors that we've been talking about over the last
few months and explain why the stock market and stock market earnings have been so resilient in
2025. But none of these factors are stopping the storm that is brewing right over all of this.
Tariffs are being implemented. As of now, the United States has imposed an average tariff rate
of 3.6% on China. This is a brand new number calculated following the new negotiations that
have taken place. The US Treasury Secretary has mentioned that this number would be the floor
for tariffs on China. They've also imposed an average 3.4% effective tariff rate on the entire
world, plus a 3.1% reciprocal baseline rate, plus 0.4% specifically on Canada and Mexico.
Now, while these are much lower numbers than what many were initially concerned about,
they still impact roughly $2 trillion worth of trade in total, which would have an estimated
impact on GDP of about a 1.5% contraction. For reference, the Great Financial Crisis saw US GDP
contract by about 3%. So, although tariffs may not trigger a full-blown recession, it's very
likely they will slow the economy down. And that, in our opinion, reduces the odds of the V-shape
recovery scenario happening. Now, just because we don't believe this scenario is the likeliest,
doesn't mean that we're going short on the market right now. If you want to have access to our
entire allocation strategy, we share every detail of it to our clients at Braavos Research. We've
made double-digit gains in the last couple of months on trades like BYD, GOLD, NRG, ADMA.
The markets have been presenting plenty of opportunities to take advantage of, and there's
going to be plenty more in the rest of 2025. So, if it's not going to be a V-shape recovery,
are we going to see a much deeper pullback on the market? Well, in this scenario, we need to
see things deteriorating. Or to put it more simply, things need to get worse than they are today.
There's many examples throughout history where things have gotten worse, even much worse,
after a brief market bounce. A great example of this is in May of 2008, where the stock market
rallied significantly after a deep stock market correction, but eventually the rally failed,
and the stock market took out the previous low, declining much further in the months that
followed. The same thing happened a few times in 2001. The market rallied off its lows a few times,
but each time, the economic situation deteriorated, and the stock market eventually
rolled over and went down much further. If this scenario were to happen today,
I believe most people are aware of what that would mean. It's what everyone has been talking
about non-stop since the whole tariff situation started. In fact, we already had the first
negative quarterly GDP print for the first quarter of 2025. If we zoom out, we can compare this,
for example, to the first quarter of 2008, where this negative GDP print was the first
of multiple negative GDP numbers that followed during the duration of the Great Financial Crisis,
or we could compare it to this reading from the first quarter of 2001 that was also followed by
an additional contraction in the economy. Both 2001 and 2008 are examples of actual economic
recessions, and the stock market suffered much larger drawdowns during these periods,
north of 50% contractions. Seeing further contractions in GDP today would also mean
the stock market could experience a much larger decline than what we've already seen.
But as you may have noticed, we've also seen negative GDP prints occur outside of economic
recessions. These are isolated episodes of economic weakness, like in 2022, in 2014,
and in 2011. All of these were actually great moments to be buying stocks in order to benefit
from the economic growth that followed. The difference between these singular GDP contractions
and these clusters of GDP contractions can be summed up in one word, layoffs. When we look at
initial jobless claims in the United States during the first quarter of 2001 and the first quarter of
2008, which coincided with those initial negative GDP prints, we see that initial jobless claims
were rising in a material manner during these periods. In other words, layoffs were picking up.
When we look at what initial claims were doing in 2022, 2014, and 2011, which correspond to those
isolated negative GDP prints, well, we see that they were generally stable. Layoffs were not
picking up. And today, the truth is we have not seen any sort of pickup in layoffs, despite the
negative GDP print. Could layoffs begin to pick up over the coming months as we see the impact of
tariffs take place? Sure. But right now, the truth is there is still a very real possibility of the
economy avoiding a recession, especially if those factors that I talked about earlier, low oil prices,
lower interest rates, and a weak dollar help stabilize the economy and stock market earnings.
So that leaves us with the last possible scenario, the consolidation or partial retracement. This is
where the stock market would basically chop around for a while, digesting the bad news, but the
economy avoids a recession in 2025, and eventually the market looks to a brighter future. We've seen
this happen many times in the past. A great example of this is 2011. Following a 20% decline
as a result of the European debt crisis, the stock market consolidated for multiple months,
digesting the news before ultimately moving higher. The same thing happened in 1998 when the
Asian financial crisis triggered a 20% stock market correction, raising recession concerns.
The stock market chopped around for a few months, digesting the news, but the economy did avoid a
recession and stocks were able to recover. In our opinion, it might be boring and it might get less views,
but that's the scenario that we think is the likeliest today. A great way to think about it
would be to say that the uncertainty from tariffs caused a temporary economic slowdown, but have not
yet triggered a full-blown recession. If the economy avoids a recession in 2025, although the
market could continue chopping around, it would eventually recover back to its highs. Luckily, we
don't need to be able to predict the exact path of the S&P 500 to profit from markets. We've made
easy profits over the last couple of months. We just booked a 50% gain on NRG and a 17.5% gain
on Zigen, and we just initiated a trade on IHS that's already up over 10%. If you want to catch
our next trades, make sure to go to our website and test our service out.
