Traditional Bows: Longbows- Centaur Vs Big Jim

The Saga of Past Longbows
6 followers
May 16, 2025
What's going on everybody?
Today I've got two new bows in the mail.
One's a Big Jim Buffalo, it's a one-piece longbow.
This bow is 45 pounds at 28.
It's got a pretty awesome feel and grip, and it's a really, really pretty bow.
Good specs, 45 pounds for me, 64 inches long, and it should be an awesome shooter.
I've never had one of these bows, but it's just a really, really pretty bow.
It's got a lot of good features on it.
I think I'm going to really love the grip on it and the riser.
It's got a little bit of heft to it, but it's a really, really nice shape riser.
And this bow right here, we're all familiar with these, the Centaur Triple Carbon Elite.
This bow is just straight up awesome looking.
Just like any other Centaur, he makes a really, really, really awesome feel and grip.
Straight into carbon limbs, and he's got some antler tips on these.
So I'll just show you the other side.
It's carbon to antler tip, and he does a really, really,
Jim does a really good job of making a bow.
We're going to do a little review on both of these bows.
I'm going to keep one of them, so we'll see which one we like better.
This bow right here is 64 inches long, and it's a 38 pound at 28 bow.
So we're shooting a 38 versus a 45.
But let's get our overall opinion on it, and maybe y'all can help me decide which one to keep.
All right, the first bow we have is the Big Jim Buffalo.
Like I said, this bow is a 64 inch long bow.
It's 45 at 28, and it's a really, really pretty bow.
Just a really awesome design riser.
It's got a just super, super beautiful bow.
Got the Buffalo emblem on it.
I believe this is some horn tip, and the same on the limb,
limb tip, same, same bone.
So the grip on this bow is a, it's a little bit, it's a little bit narrow.
It's a pretty narrow grip.
It's thin, and I think it's, I think I'm going to like it.
It's pretty easy to get your hand in there, and as far as, as far as pointing the bow,
it feels like it's going to be one I can take and point pretty easily.
So let's see how this thing shoots.
All right, so I had to move my camera a little bit closer to the target.
This wind out here is pretty bad today.
I think we're about to move this knock point up as well.
Let's go ahead and do that while we're standing here.
These, these knock points, these, these knock points are pretty low.
Y'all give me a second.
All right, I got these knock points moved up in here.
Let's see, let's take a shot with this Big Jim and see how it feels.
I'm gonna shoot it right into the little block target right here.
Oh man, that's pretty smooth right there.
That's a pretty smooth bow.
Wow, I've never had one of these before, but it's pretty smooth.
The draw, it's about the same feeling.
Wow, all the way back.
Not bad speed either, especially in this wind.
Let's shoot this heavier arrow.
We'll shoot this in the deer target.
These are the first three shots and they're going exactly where I'm looking.
All right, so the wind caught that one.
I did see a little bit of slowing down with that arrow,
but let's take three more and see what it'll do.
All right, so like usual, the wind is kicking out here.
I'm going to take two shots in the deer bottles
with the two lighter weight arrows because they'll be able to fly a little bit better.
Right where I was looking.
Oh, it's quiet.
Man, this thing is quiet.
Easy to shoot.
Oh man, I don't know.
This thing feels awesome.
Wow, what a grip.
The grip's thin, but man, it feels good.
It's easy to hold and there's nothing funny feeling about it.
Let's shoot a few more times and we'll see how it does.
Not bad speed out of this bow.
It's really pushing this arrow.
Good shot.
Shoots where you're looking.
You can get a good full grip on this bow too.
It's quiet, it's fast.
Pretty good shooting bow there.
Really impressed with it.
I don't know, I'm surprised I haven't bought one of these in the past.
Let's shoot the Centaur now.
All right, so here's the Centaur.
It's the Centaur Triple Carbon Elite.
Y'all know Jim makes an awesome bow.
These are just a really, really pretty design bow.
With the carbon he makes, it goes into the wood to carbon, the fades.
It's just a really, really good bow.
This bow is lighter than the Big Jim's as far as mass weight and it's a bit thinner.
The grip, right now I'm liking the Big Jim grip a little better.
This one doesn't have as much heel on it.
It's more of a lower grip.
I'm thinking it's going to make a little difference on my shooting, but we're going to see.
Let's take the first two shots with the Centaur.
I'm going to have to adjust these knock points for sure.
Let's see, that's a little better.
I may have to move this up, but let's see how it shoots.
It's a 38 pound versus a 45.
Oh man, okay, right off the bat, I knew that was going to happen.
Right off the bat, it shot that arrow funny.
Dude, this thing is smooth as butter.
All right, missed the target with that.
Let's go get these two arrows and we'll take two more shots.
So I was kind of wanting to get a speed comparison between these two bows.
The Centaur, it's wood and carbon and then the Big Jim's is all wood.
We're going to see which one has a little bit more speed.
This bow is also a 38 pound bow versus a 45.
Honestly, the Big Jim's is almost as smooth as this bow is what I was trying to say.
This bow, you can kind of feel it on that back end, but man, it's smooth.
I'm telling you, pretty fast for a 38 pound bow.
Right where I'm looking, man, this thing shoots good.
Wow, let's shoot a few more.
Man, I'm going to give my honest opinion here.
I don't know which one I like better.
This Centaur, I'm trying to stay really open-minded about it because I love Centaurs.
I got a Supercurve coming in here in the next few days.
It's a 40 at 28.
This is 38 at 28.
So the 40 at 28 Supercurve, I can only imagine how it's going to be.
This thing is smooth as butter.
All right, we got a little bit of, I think the wind's doing that.
We got a little bit of lift off of that.
I'm going to cant the bow a hair and see if it does any better.
