Ranking Member Jerry Nadler delivers opening remarks

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
May 15, 2025
Hearing: The MATCH Monopoly: Evaluating the Medical Residency Antitrust Exemption
Subcommittee on Administrative State, Regulatory Reform, and Antitrust
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman,
it's a little difficult to take
seriously a hearing that Republicans
bill as an effort to improve healthcare
in this country when their colleagues
and other committees are busy gutting
Medicaid and other programs, which will
have a devastating impact on the health
of millions of Americans. Apparently,
Republicans think that what really ails
our health care system is that
low-income Americans, people with
disabilities, and children have too much
health care. That is the only
explanation because of course it
couldn't just be a cynical ploy to fund
massive tax cuts for billionaires in the
backs of the of the most vulnerable
among us. And these same Republicans who
claim they want to quote make America
healthy again have remained silent while
the Trump administration systematically
dismantles our entire public health
infrastructure. Under the leadership of
America's number one vaccine skeptic and
conspiracy theory promoter, Robert
Kennedy Jr., The Department of Health
and Human Services has fired more than
20,000 experts, eliminated entire
agencies, deleted important data sets
and public health tracking tools, and
cut or threaten to cut billions of
dollars in grants for scientific
research. At the same time, the
administration is waging an ideological
war on institutions such as universities
and the National Institutes of Health
that develop the groundbreaking research
that underpins most medical advances.
The NIH alone has suffered a $ 1.8
billion cut and by some estimates as
much as $2.7 billion. That will
undoubtedly set back research into
cancer treatments, infectious disease
prevention, and much more by many years.
Meanwhile, Republicans cheer as the
administration's immigration policies
chase out foreignborn students and
researchers and send a clear message to
anyone abroad who might wish to bring
their talents and innovation to our
country. You are not welcome. Taken
collectively, these actions represent
the dramatic effort to undermine,
destroy, and limit health care research,
access to critical health data, and
access to care. The impact of these cuts
will likely fall most deeply on
marginalized communities. But we will
all suffer the consequences. That is why
today's hearing on the national
residency matching program seems beside
the point. The healthcare system is
facing an outright assault from the
Trump administration. And yet we are
being called upon to examine the
residency matching program. This is not
to say that there are no issues related
to the match worth exploring in due
course. Any valid criticisms of the
program warrant appropriate
consideration, whether they concern
salary, hours, working conditions, or
other matters that call out for
refinement. And as part of that
revisiting, we could account for
collective bargaining, which has led to
approximately 20% of the resident
physician workforce becoming unionized.
But we should also recognize that the
match provides an effective system for
placing more than 40,000 doctors a year
across more than 6,500 residency
programs and tracks throughout every
region of the country that suits the
needs of both students and hospitals
alike. It's important to remember that
the match was created in 1952 to solve
problems in the placement process that
were created by unfettered market
competition. Before the match was
instituted, residency programs competed
with each other to make offers earlier
and earlier so as to preempt other
programs. This resulted in students
receiving limited time offers as early
as the beginning of their junior year of
medical school when they had limited
exposure to clinical practice before
they had done rotations. Attempts to
delay the matching process by
withholding student information until
senior year led to exploding offers with
extremely s short fuses. This system
served no one, and the match was created
to address these market breakdowns. Over
70 years later, it is still largely
working as intended, avoiding what would
otherwise be chaos, even as the needs of
candidates and residency programs have
evolved. While no system is perfect,
many of the Republicans criticisms
simply do not hold up under careful
scrutiny. For example, Republicans have
taken aim at foreign doctors who enter
the match, arguing that they are
displacing American students. But
statistics show that 99% of all US
medical school graduates enter residency
or full-time practice in the country
within six years of graduation. There is
simply little evidence to suggest that
foreign medical school graduates are
taking slots from US residents. Rather
than scapegoating immigrants,
Republicans could address a real issue,
the need for additional residency slots
overall. But that would take an
investment in new funding from the
federal government. And we have already
seen where the Republicans priorities
lie. Finally, if the majority wishes to
address flaws in the health care system,
they need only look at the important
work this subcommittee did under
Democratic leadership. We examined
issues related to consolidation and
market concentration across the
healthcare industry, and we passed
several pieces of legislation addressing
the rising cost of prescription drugs.
Many of these issues had bipartisan
support, and there's much we can do
together. But instead, Republicans want
to distract us from their disastrous
healthcare policies with a hearing on a
minor issue. We can do better. I
appreciate our witnesses for appearing
today. I look forward to hearing from
them. And I yield back the balance of my
