Raking Member Jerry Nadler delivers opening remarks

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
Jan 8, 2026
Hearing: Full Stream Ahead: Competition and Consumer Choice in Digital Streaming
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman,
the entertainment and media landscape
has been transformed in recent years.
Many of these changes have brought
undeniable benefits such as streaming
services that give viewers more options
at their fingertips than ever before.
But many of these changes have also come
at a cost as lacks antitrust enforcement
and ways of consolidation have
concentrated power in just a few major
players. And one thing has seemed to be
constant over the last few decades. a
merger involving Warner Brothers. It
began with the disastrous AOL Time
Warner merger in 2000, then the
short-lived partnership with AT&T in
2019, then its latest incarnation since
2021 as Warner Brothers Discovery, and
now once again, Warner Brothers is up
for sale to another media giant. This
time it has accepted a bid from Netflix,
the global leader in streaming services
and a major content producer in its own
right to control Warner's streaming and
studio assets, including such mammoth
properties as DC Studios, HBO and HBO
Max, and Warner Brothers motion picture
and television groups, as well as
Warner's 128 million streaming
subscribers.
What we know today about this proposal
raises a host of questions about its
effect on the pricing, production and
distribution of content going forward.
We have also heard with great alarm we
have also heard great alarm from the
movie theater industry which despite
claims from Netflix that it will keep
theatrical businesses operating largely
as they are takes seriously comments
from its co-CEO
who called movie theaters quote an an
outmoded idea and quote not
consumerfriendly.
Further, labor labor groups like the
Writers Guild of America and the
Director's Guild have have raised
concerns and say that this proposed
merger is not in their interests or the
public's. Serious concerns have been
raised about whether this deal, which by
some measures would give the merch
company over 30% of the streaming
market, could reduce competition,
diminish consumer choice, raise
subscription prices, threaten jobs,
wages, and working conditions in the
creative industries, and reduce
diversity of content and viewpoints.
Netflix argues that this merger would
allow it to better compete with the
range of other platforms that are
battling for eyeballs and attention from
viewers, including other streaming
giants like YouTube, traditional movies
and television, social media, and more.
But if Netflix must get bigger in order
to compete, that is a sign of a market
that is already highly out of balance.
Under the Netflix deal, Warner's cable
channels, including most notably C CNN,
would be spun off into a separate
business that would not be part of the
sale. But another major media
conglomerate, Paramount Skyance, has now
made a hostile bid to control all of
Warner's properties, including CNN. Even
though the Warner Brothers board has
rejected the Paramount bid for now,
Paramount could still pursue a buyout of
Warner Brothers. A potential merger with
Paramount presents its own set of
antitrust concerns by collapsing what
are now five major movie studios down to
four, thereby reducing competition and
substantially increasing concentration
within an already concentrated industry.
Not only could this bring higher prices
and less choices for consumers, but it
could also bring fewer jobs and lower
wages for content creators. The
Paramount bid also brings its own unique
set of circumstances of concerns because
it would place CNN under the control of
the Ellison family. The same
billionaires who have curried favor with
Donald Trump by imposing control over
the content of CBS News. Just weeks ago,
Barry Weiss, the controversial minder
placed in charge of CBS News, spiked a
story on 60 Minutes that would have shed
light on the Trump administration's
lawless campaign to send migrants to be
tortured in an El Salvadoran prison.
Excuse me. Presumably, the Ellison have
similar designs on making CNN more Trump
friendly. A merger with either Netflix
or Paramount would result in a behemoth
that poses significant antirust and
other public policy concerns that
require careful scrutiny. I have long
believed that the unchecked
concentration of economic power in any
industry poses a danger to economic
fairness and to our democracy. While I
do not prejudge the merits of any
proposed merger, I am concerned with any
deal that would significantly increase
the concentration in a market that is
already highly concentrated. Such
increased concentration could not only
harm consumers, but we have also heard
great concern from the creative guilds
who have borne the brunt of decades of
media consolidation that historically
has been followed by fewer jobs,
downward pressure on wages, and reduced
creative opportunities. That is why it
is so important that any merger be
reviewed with careful and impartial
analysis by the antitrust regulators.
Unfortunately,
under the Trump administration, the
antitrust review process has been
dangerously corrupted and politicized.
Just last month, we heard from a former
senior Trump administration antitrust
official who testified that under this
administration, the rule of law is being
replaced by the rule of lobbyists and
corporate interests. We know that the
White House routinely intervenes in
Justice Department matters, often to
benefit the president and his cronies.
And already Trump himself has said,
quote, "I'll be involved in that
decision." When asked about the Warner
Brothers deal, does he intend to put his
thumb on the scale in favor of Paramount
as a reward for his friends, the
Ellison's who, according to press
reports, have already promised to
implement quote sweeping changes over
CNN if they were to take control.
that this is not a far-fetched scenario.
There were troubling reports that Trump
tried to block the AT&T Time Warner
merger as retaliation for CNN's critical
coverage of him during his first
administration and campaign. Mr.
Chairman, we have seen this movie before
and the sequel is almost always worse. A
hallmark of the second Trump
administration has been a determined
effort to ex to exercise control over
the independent news media, whether
through fi frivolous lawsuits against
media outlets, limiting press access to
the White House and the Pentagon, and
gutting funding for public radio and
PBS. The White House must not be allowed
to use the merger review process as
another tool in its campaign to bend the
media to its will. A proposed merger,
whether it be with Netflix, Paramount,
or some other suitor, must be analyzed
on its own merits. What we know already
about the antitrust review process under
this administration calls for serious
congressional oversight. But
unfortunately, our Republican colleagues
have turned a blind eye to their
oversight responsibilities during this
Congress. And today, just one more
missed opportunity. It is vitally
important that we examine the Warner
Brothers merger closely to ensure that
any deal will protect competition,
consumers, and workers. And I appreciate
our witnesses being here today to lend
their expertise. I look forward to
today's hearing, and I yield back.
