10000 Steps a Day - What Is The Science? - Dr Gill ______ Sponsored video FlexiSpot Brand Month Promotion – Up to 50% Off – https://bit.ly/4iWzlQj My FlexiSpot E7 Pro Desk – https://bit.ly/3Z5wkWy My FlexiSpot BS14 Chair – https://bit.ly/44Mu3DB 📅 From May 12th, 11:00 AM to May 20th The earlier you buy, the better the deal – get up to 50% off the BS14! The earlier you buy, the better the deal – get up to 50% off the E7 Pro! 🎁 Win your order for free! 100% off at midnight (BST) on May 12th – Limited spots available! #FlexiSpotUK
------ We are a very sedentary world today. As a result, we now have to actively look to ensure that we are keeping healthy through our levels of activity. Whilst the original 10,000 steps may have originated from an unlikely source, it turns out the science isn't as far removed as we might expect
In this video, we look at the 10,000 steps a day, and how it can be part of a healthy activity schedule, and whether or not there are any valid alternatives to quantifying our activity goals.
Hello and welcome back to the channel.
Today's a video I've been thinking about
for some time and I finally put that had
that little bit of a push in order to
sit down and put if not pen to paper
then fingers to keyboard in terms of
research. Now, as many of you know, I've
got an 18-month-old son slash ball of
screaming
[Music]
rage, and that's had a horrific impact
on my ability to exercise, whether it's
going running or
cycling. Yes, I do try to use a running
pram, but frankly, with my gangly frame,
it's not particularly
comfortable. And I've just found that
I'm not doing as much as I should be.
So, with the view of trying to keep
active within my day, I thought it would
actually be interesting to look what the
science is behind the 10,000 steps a day
target. Now, this research wasn't just
for my own personal interest. In the UK,
obesity levels are on the rise. In 1993,
15% of the population was classified as
obese. That number's now swollen to 29%
of the
population. That's according to data
from 2022.
Yes, I know it's three years old, but
it's the latest government data as
published in February for
2025. Always surprised me how slow
things are to actually come out with
official data. Now, I say this because
this isn't just a personal interest
video for me. At least 25% of my
consultations as a GP, even when I'm not
explicitly dealing with a weight
rellated issue, can legitimately have
outcomes that are improved by addressing
a patient's potentially increased body
weight. As a simple example, diabetes,
hypertension, sleep apnea, joint pain,
depression, heart disease, and
interesting enough,
osteoarthritis are all conditions where
helping a patient attain a healthy
weight may improve their symptoms in
some
way. So to that end, the concept of
doing 10,000 steps a day is often
recommended to patients looking to lose
weight. Heck, it's a simple target and
just about as easily suggested. do
10,000 steps a day. Next patient,
please. The problem is
that where does this number come from?
Where's the science? And although I
recommend doing 10,000 steps a day is
literally an advice line that's going to
take, you know, fewer than 10 seconds.
Actually, doing those 10,000 steps a day
is going to be somewhat time consuming
for most patients. So, is it the right
recommendation given the investment
they're going to have to make to it? So,
let's do a brief history lesson and turn
the clocks back to
1964, specifically in Tokyo, Japan,
October 1964, when you got the Summer
Olympics starting
up. At the same time, to capitalize on
the focus on activity and fitness that
takes over a country when you've got an
Olympiad rocking up there, there was a
Japanese company My apologies for pronun
pronunciation here. Yamasa Toki
Kiko. They created the first personal
fitness pedometer called the Mano Kai.
Now the name there Mano Kai derives from
the Japanese words man meaning 10,000
and po meaning steps with K system.
Again, I can't apologize enough if I've
gotten those pronunciations wrong.
Now, that's interesting enough, and it
does seem to align nicely with the idea
of an an athletics fixture occurring and
the want to try and challenge your
countrymen to do more. And let's be
clear, you know, the challenging nature
of 10,000 steps is probably why it was
chosen. But the reality behind choosing
10,000 steps doesn't seem to be quite so
scientific.
It's been suggested that the reason for
selecting 10,000 steps is as much to do
with the Japanese kangji because the
symbol or number for 10,000 apparently
looks like a man
walking. I kid you not, an international
health activity goal. one that takes
some effort and time to achieve might
not be based on a particular health
threshold, but rather just that it was a
number that had a good resonance with
Japanese culture. Now, before everybody
looks at their Garmin, Fitbit, Apple
Watch, etc. as though it's been lying at
them for years. That original 10,000
step target, whilst arbitrary, given its
ubiquity, it's not surprising that
subsequently there's been considerable
research into
it. And astonishingly, it turns out it's
not that far from the mark. Now, I say
that the crucial tenate of modern
medicine is acknowledging something is
good for us. Eg. chewing willow bark
reduces pain, but then determining why
and how much is needed to get that
benefit. I.e. Willow bark is a
painkiller because it turns out it
contains aspirin. Now we find that 300
mg of aspirin can be used to treat a
headache. So that's our scientific
principle there. To that end, no one is
questioning the concept of being active
is good for us. But research has been
focused on where the sweet spot is, as
in how much activity, how much time
invested will generate diminishing
returns.
And astonishingly, it turns out that the
original inventor of the
Mampoke wasn't actually that far off the
mark. The evidence is that the sweet
spot might actually be approximately
7,500
steps. But before we go into the sweet
spot, I have to highlight that this is
actually a sponsored video and it's
sponsored by Flexispot,
who make my standing desk. Now, that's
quite important because um when they
originally reached out to me to say,
would I be interested in doing a
sponsored video, I was already planning
to do this 10,000 steps uh video and I
thought actually it dovetailed quite
nicely because I already owned the desk
that they were trying to give me. So,
instead, they sent a Flexis Spot chair.
I'm very careful about accepting
sponsorships on the channel because I
think it needs to align and for me given
this video is about 10,000 steps and
keeping active the concept of talking
about a product that I already own i.e.
I'm nently support seem to be quite
sensible. So, one of the things that I
like about my Flex Spot desk when I'm
working from home is I can try and stay
standing when I'm talking to my
patients. But if I've been trying to
look after myself and been trying to do
exercise, um I've recently done a tempo
training um bit for a race that I've got
coming and my thighs are rather sore at
the moment. I've still got the option to
hit the button and have the desk go
down. Although the desk goes down, but
the camera doesn't. Uh, yeah, that was a
bit of a fail on my side. But my point
is that actually I think that standing
desks are a great product in of their
own right. They're an effective way of
increasing activity in what could
otherwise be a sedentary day.
And yeah, these ones seem to be very
very robust, which is why I spent my
money on it before. So, with that in
mind, we'll say thank you to Flexispot
for the chair that goes with the video.
Um, and let's get back into some of that
science, shall we? To that end, I've got
a wonderful infographic that I keep on
my computer and show to patients. Now, I
don't have the origin of it. I've tried
to actually find who I can attribute it
to, but anything other than the Daily
Infographic just leads to a dead link.
And even the Daily Infographic is just a
name I found. So, keeping that in mind,
I can't attribute it who it should
belong to. The point is from this
infographic and reality, our world isn't
designed to keep us healthy as humans.
Now, a fundamental part of our world is
the amount of time we spend sitting
down. And given that most of us aren't
able to radically change our work
circumstances, actually opting for a
standing desk might be a very reasonable
way to improve our step count and our
activities if nothing else. Now, here's
the question for you. Genuinely, I'd
really be interested to know your answer
to this. How would you feel if you went
to the doctor and they had a standing
desk and they offered you the option,
shall we keep standing or would you
prefer us to sit down for the
consultation? Please put your comments
um down below because I'd be really
interested to see what the group mind
thinks here because frankly I'm
wondering whether as well as having a
standing desk in my home office if there
might be utility to having one at work
as well if only just to show that I'm
walking the walk as it were in terms of
trying to be active. So with that in
mind let's actually look at some of the
research into step counts. The first
paper I've got is from JAMAMA. So the
Journal of American Medical Association
in 2019 and they looked at the
association with step volume and
intensity with all cause mortality in
older women. Now with that they looked
at nearly 17,000 women and they found
that hazard ratios either risk of
something happen progressively declined
with increasing step counts before
leveling off at around about 7,500 per
day. Now to reiterate the risk of
mortality dying in women of an average
age about 72 decreased with increasing
step counts. To give you more data on
that, the most significant hazard ratio
decrease was
58%. I.e. in the most active group, they
found that it was a 58% reduction in
risk of death compared to the most
sedentary group. Now, that sounds very
impressive, but that's statistics for
you. Let's reframe that. If your risk of
death is 0.2% 2% per year and you drop
it to 0.1% per year. That's still a 50%
reduction in risk. So isn't quite as
impressive as things first sound. But
let's reframe it another way. Taking
information from the study. You say they
followed up these patients over 4 and a
half years. And over that time frame,
5.4% of those near 17,000 women died.
the probability of being in the group
that regrettably passed away was higher
the lower the activity level of those
women was. Now, that's not to say that
10,000 steps isn't a valid target, but
they were saying 7,500 seemed to be the
sweet spot and after it you had
diminishing
returns. So, we're going to take that
and run with it. There was a fascinating
study in 2022 again from JAMAMA but this
time one of their subgroups JAMAMA
neurology. Here they looked about 7,000
adults with the average age of 61 years
and followed them over nearly 7 years.
In doing so they found that 9,800 steps
was associated crucial word there with
again a 50% reduction in the risk of
developing dementia.
Now, personally, my biggest health fear
isn't actually dying. Don't get me
wrong, I'm not exactly casually walking
across the road with my eyes closed, but
dying something we'll do. It doesn't
seem to make so much sense to be quite
as concerned about a guaranteed event.
For me, my biggest fear is dementia or
at least a degenerative brain disease
given that my job can kind of be boiled
down to being a brain on a stick. So
it's not surprising that you know that
level that sort of concern is you know
my area. So given the evidence there is
quite strong that walking 9,800 steps a
day on average could potentially half my
risk of
dementia. Even if that risk of dementia
for me is 1% sign me up for a standing
desk and a pair of dancing shoes. I am
going to really target that 10,000 steps
a
day. I might not get it, but I'm now
after having done this research, I'm
really going to try and do it. So,
staying with the concept that 10,000
steps a day isn't the only show in town.
A companion study again in JAMAMA, but
this time internal medicine. Honestly,
I'm surprised that all of my references
do seem to come from one house of
journals. Actually, they're all
different. uh divisions of the same
journal. So anyway, that showed for
every 2,000 steps a day you do, you
could lower your risk of premature,
crucial word, death by between 8 and 11%
whether or not we're looking at
cardiovascular disease or cancers. Now,
I'm going to step back from the pure
numbers for a second and say we do need
to be cautious about proclaiming that
walking and shuffling about is going to
prevent all ills. After all, there is
the typically cautious and specific
language in these papers, i.e. risk of
premature death and that the studies
have found
associations. Very importantly, they're
not demonstrating causality here. Now, I
realize I've used this example before in
other videos, but there is an
association between the reduction of
births in Belgium and the number of
stalks nesting in Belgium. But I think
we can all reasonably assume that the
decline in Belgium birth rate isn't due
to the reduced number of stalks not
being able to deliver as many babies
before. So we do need to have a modicum
of caution against all of this data
where we're talking about
associations. However, personally, I'd
be inclined to take a pill that gave the
same promise that these exercise studies
are suggesting, particularly given we
know the side effects of exercise. If
I'm going to stretch that analogy a
little bit further, though, what if it's
not actually the pill of
exercise? What if there was an inhaler
of exercise that had the same
benefits? What I'm alluding to here is
there's a suggestion that the number of
steps isn't actually the key factor
here, but it's just an easy metric to
measure. What if the being active
compound that
being was the key here? What if that
duration of activity was the thing that
was giving the benefit? So, let's
reframe our 10,000 steps for a moment
because that's actually a considerable
distance for the average person. It's
about 8 kilometers. And in terms of
active minutes, that's going to set you
back between 90 and 150 minutes per day
based upon the average walking speed of
3 to 5 kilometers an hour of an adult.
Now, here's where I find things become
problematic when we move away from that
10,000st step target to other forms of
health advice. Bear in mind to say do
10,000 steps is
easy. When we look at other things, the
recommendations become less clear-cut
for the patient. Now, the NHS recommends
aiming for 150 minutes of moderate
activity in a week or 75 minutes of
vigorous
activity. Well, if we're getting 10,000
steps a day, taking a conservative
estimate that's going to take us 90
minutes, we're already smashing that
moderate activity level for the
week. Kind of. The thing is moderate
activity is considered to be where
you've got an exercise level that you
can talk at but not
sing. Yeah, I'm not a great fan of that
particular someone who doesn't sing. But
perhaps a better metric is walking
briskly so that your heart rate rises.
Okay, makes sense. But how much heart
rate are we talking about? Oh, I can
give you the answer for that. It's
between an increase by 50 to 70% of your
maximum theoretical heart
rate. And this is where things start to
get less simple. Now, there is a simple
calculation to determine your maximum
heart rate. And that's done taking your
age, multiply it by 0.7, and then
subtract from
28. After reaching for my calculator, my
theoretical maximum heart rate is now
179 beats a minute, which if I'm honest,
feels about right these days. So,
moderate exercise, we're aiming for a
heart rate between 50 and 70% of your
maximum. So, we'll call that about 90
beats a minute for me, which actually is
probably get um probably what I get when
I'm walking anyway. Certainly, if I look
at the recorded walks I've put on my
Garmin, you know, you can see on a
normal pace, I'm getting a heart rate
about 95 beats a minute. So, does kind
of align, although I do walk relatively
briskly anyway, much to my wife's
irritation. I've got long legs. Now,
heck, this is beginning to feel a bit
circular, though. And this is why I
wanted to do the video. Before doing the
research for this, I was aware that the
10,000st step goal was just a marketing
gimmick. And my plan had actually been
to create a video to share with patients
when I was trying to get them to improve
their activity levels. I'd say there's
not much evidence to support 10,000
steps a day, but the NHS will advise you
to 150 minutes across the week.
So it turns out whilst that 10,000 steps
was just a random number, by chance it
did land close to the physiological
benefit for humans. Even if 10,000 steps
a day is too much of a stretch, there's
still evidence that 2,000 steps a day is
still
helping. Conversely, active minutes are
a better metric of your active levels
given your heart rate's now taken into
the equation. But that's a pain in the
neck to calculate and then monitor if
you're frankly not already an owner of a
sports watch and not already interested
in monitoring your numbers. The thing
that's the core tenant of helping a
patient is that an intervention for it
to be effective there's got to be a low
barrier for entry and we see this as
mentioned earlier about inhalers. If you
give the patient the wrong type of
inhaler, so for example, one that they
have to suck rather than one they can
just breathe with, it doesn't matter how
amazing the drug is, that patient still
probably won't use that inhaler as they
should do because it's not easy for
them. The same is true here. Activity
minutes are
better, but they're a pain in the neck.
So although the 10,000 steps was a
random dart thrown at a board, it seems
they managed to hit the bullseye. So,
I'm actually not going to change my
practice. I'm going to keep recommending
patients aim for 10,000 steps a day
initially. If they feel like increasing
the difficulty level, we can look at
intensity uh minutes as well. So, it's
all about helping the patient and
identifying what works for them.
So, that in mind, staying with what
helps and what works for patients, I'd
be really interested to know what your
thought would be if you came into my
consultation room and found me using a
standing desk. Is it something you'd be
pro or something you'd be anti? Please
put it in the comments down below
because I'm genuinely interested. So, I
do hope this has been a useful video for
you. If you'd like to see me do more
videos that are specifically patient
focused, where I'm trying to break down
some of the advice we normally give or
try to help somebody get to grips with
that advice, particularly while talking
about the evidence base for it, please
put in the comments down below what
other videos you'd like me to tackle.
With that in mind, I'll say thanks for
watching this far. Cheerio, and I'll see
you in the next one. Bye-bye.