From the Operating Table Scandal to the Deeper Truths of Medical Privilege Routes 【20250507】 #Truths of Medical Privilege Rout

江峰時刻
38.9K followers
7.1K Video Views·May 7, 2025
👉合作洽談 ► [email protected] (新郵箱)
✅江峰的其他平台👇
1⃣推特 ► https://is.gd/EEuqcX
2⃣臉書 ► https://is.gd/HPilZ0
Welcome back to Jiang Feng's World.
In mid-April, Xiaofei, the Deputy Director of Thoracic Surgery at Beijing's China-Japan
Friendship Hospital, was publicly accused by his wife. Xiaofei not only had an extramarital affair
with resident Dr Dong Shiying, but he also previously had multiple encounters with the
head nurse of the thoracic surgery department. What is even more shocking is that Xiaofei,
in order to accommodate Dong Shiying, demanded a change of nurses, leaving a fully anaesthetised
patient on the operating table for as long as 40 minutes. On April 27th, the China-Japan
Friendship Hospital quickly responded by expelling Xiaofei from the party and terminating his
employment. That evening, Xiaofei responded by expressing his disagreement, attempting to regain
his job and insisting that there was nothing wrong with his medical ethics. The time away from the
operating table was only about 10 to 20 minutes. After Xiaofei was dealt with by the hospital,
the main storyline shifted to 27-year-old Dong Shiying, focusing on Ms Dong's educational
background and family network and the entire medical education system. Dong Shiying's identity
was thoroughly investigated, revealing a stunning gilded path of privilege. She attended Barnard
College at Columbia University for her undergraduate studies. She studied economics,
which is completely unrelated to medicine. Although Barnard College carries the Columbia
University name, its admission threshold is much lower than the core Ivy League schools.
There are rumours that Ms Dong transferred there from a community college with a weak academic
foundation. Yet, despite being such a cross-disciplinary candidate, she astonishingly
joined the four-year, four-project programme at Siyi Hospital in 2019, which allows one to become
a doctor of medicine after four years. Ms Dong's doctoral advisor is an orthopaedic academician
and her dissertation focused on medical imaging. Her doctoral degree was obtained during her
internal medicine internship in thoracic surgery, after which she quickly entered the top-tier
Class A hospital, the urology department of the Cancer Hospital of the Chinese Academy of Medical
Sciences. This resume can be described as a textbook example of privilege and purity.
Even more outrageous are Dong Shiying's academic achievements.
There are many doubts. In just a few years, she has spanned six major medical fields,
publishing 11 papers on cutting-edge topics such as gynaecological imaging and AI applications in
thoracic surgery. She even had her name included in the compilation of the bladder cancer diagnosis
and treatment guidelines. Netizens found a paper from 2019 on ResearchGate that Ms Dong participated
in, with the corresponding author prominently being her father, Dong Xiaohui, and also featuring
the name of her mother, Mi Zhenli, an executive at a central state-owned construction enterprise,
supporting medical papers. The reality of a metallurgy expert guiding AI in medicine is so
surreal that it shocked the academic community. It is said that his doctoral dissertation was
only 27 pages long. In contrast, other medical doctoral theses at Peking Union Medical College
often exceed 100 pages. With such a comparison, how can grassroots students not be outraged?
Netizens also dug up old photos from Dong Shiying's childhood, a art exhibition. At 10 years old,
she collaborated on a painting with a 12-year-old child. Her name was listed first and she even had
a solo photo taken, while the other child was only seen with their head down, drawing on the ground,
without even showing their face. This clearly shows that the allocation of resources
started in childhood and the preferentially planned life trajectory is evident. Her grandfather,
Dong Baowei, is a renowned medical expert in the military and a reviewer for the National
Natural Science Foundation. Her mother, Mi Zhenli, is the vice president of the University of Science
and Technology Beijing, researching the supply chain of orthopedic materials. Her father,
Dong Xiaohui, is the general manager of the China Metallurgical Construction Research Institute
and holds 37 patents in medical architecture. Her aunt, Ban Xiaojuan, is a professor in the
Computer Science Department at the University of Science and Technology Beijing. This family
is like an all-encompassing fortress covering medical, academic, industrial, and educational
fields, collectively safeguarding her academic ascent. In the acknowledgements of his doctoral
thesis, he wrote, this family is my fortress. This phrase in English was interpreted by netizens
as a straightforward boast about the family's protective umbrella. During her residency
training at the China-Japan Friendship Hospital, Miss Dong not only shortened the three-year
residency to one year, but also refused to rotate positions. She only wanted to intern in Xiaofei's
thoracic surgery department, so she even asked her grandfather's fellow disciple, academician
Qiu Guixing, to intervene. This is akin to using a provincial leader's secretary to excuse a primary
school student from class. Faced with the persistent pressure of, if you don't help me, I'll tell your
fellow disciple, academician Qiu was left with no choice. In fact, Dong Xiying's career plan was
never to become a frontline clinical doctor. Instead, she plans to manage doctors in the future.
This path often involves obtaining a medical doctorate, then working at Xixi Hospital,
transitioning to a career position, and moving into hospital management roles.
After reaching the associate senior title, she would then be parachuted into the health commission
or disease control departments to take on leadership roles. A medical doctoral student
angrily stated that Miss Dong, who couldn't even get into a 985 university, was able to plagiarise
and co-author papers through the 4 plus 4 programme and easily obtain a medical doctorate
within four years. We take five years to complete a medical undergraduate degree,
eight years to finish a master's in medicine, and 11 to 14 years to earn a doctorate.
And even then, there's no guarantee of getting into Xixi Hospital. Yet, those with privileged
backgrounds not only can work at Xixi Hospital, but will also become our leaders in the future.
It's worth pondering that families like Dong Xin's, in the eyes of the True Power Corps,
are merely ordinary peripheral figures. They are precisely the group most easily
sacrificed in high-level power struggles. This class has enough privilege to provoke
public discontent, yet lacks sufficient strength to protect themselves during a complete reshuffle
of power within the major systems in current China, in the context of intensifying efforts
to clean up the debts and privileges of the powerful, Dong Xin happens to fall into the
typical category of being not very capable, but having a prominent background, making it both
necessary to address and easy to be driven by public opinion. What is even more intriguing
is that there are reports suggesting Dong Xin will be appointed as the director of Xiongan
Hospital in the future. Xiongan, being a national strategic project personally planned by Xi Jinping,
signifies that whoever can secure an important position there is a signal of political alignment.
Now that Dong Xin has been exposed and sparked nationwide discussion,
does it imply that the political forces behind him are losing power?
The incident involving Dong Xin not only reveals issues of medical ethics
and academic integrity, but also involves serious corruption problems.
Investigations show that Dong Xin's father, Dong Xiaohui, the general manager of Zhongye
Construction Research Institute, is suspected of seriously violating integrity discipline,
and Dong Xin himself is also involved. From August 2015 to January 2016,
while serving as a senior executive in a state-owned enterprise,
Dong Xiaohui illegally invested, as an individual shareholder,
and acted as the legal representative of Beijing Junxiao Equity Investment Center,
subscribing to 3 million yuan in shares. He later added an additional 1.2 million yuan,
totaling 4.2 million yuan. This behavior clearly violated several regulations on the integrity of
state-owned enterprise leaders. More seriously, in January 2016, Dong Xiaohui transferred the
legal representative status and all shares of the investment center to his daughter,
Dong Xiying, who held them on his behalf until November 2018. It is worth questioning why the
Dong family dared to openly violate regulations after the 18th National Congress. Why was Dong
Xiaohui's unit able to undertake the project supervision for the engineering construction
projects of the units where Dong Xiying and her mother worked? The China Metallurgical
Construction Research Institute, where Dong Xiaohui worked, was supposed to focus on
metallurgical industrial construction projects. Why was it able to get involved in the medical
construction field? These intertwined lines of interest are far more worth investigating than
the operating room controversy. From a political maneuvering perspective, the Dong Xiying incident
might serve two purposes simultaneously. Firstly, it diverts public attention away
from the economic crisis and trade war. When people are preoccupied with discussing the
hospital scandal, the questioning of how the top leadership is handling the severe external
environment naturally diminishes. Recently, although U.S. President Trump stated that he
does not wish for a complete decoupling between the U.S. and China, nor does he want the Chinese
economy to suffer, but... However, U.S. Treasury Secretary Besencourt's remarks were much tougher.
He even threatened to impose a full embargo on China. At this critical moment, is there a power
reshuffle happening within China? And is Dong Xiying merely a pawn in this storm?
Secondly, this might be a test of purging specific factions within the top leadership.
Misconduct within hospitals has often been handled quietly in the past,
rarely attracting nationwide attention. Xiaofei's wife only publicly reported his infidelity six
years later, and the timing is so precise that it raises suspicions of a possible orchestrator
behind the scenes. The most direct victim in this turmoil is Xiaofei. He is a doctor who entered
Peking University Medical School from Shaanxi and underwent eight years of rigorous training.
He is a true representative of those who became doctors through formal channels. Yet after the
incident, he was the first to be dismissed. This can be interpreted as a typical tactic
of targeting an outsider, a common strategy in Chinese political struggles aimed at quickly
calming the situation, while avoiding the complete exposure of deeper systemic issues.
Dong Xiying has not yet faced any explicit punishment, leading the public to question
whether the privileged children who take shortcuts can continue, as long as they do
not cause direct medical accidents. In terms of positions, Beijing serves.
The Peking Union Medical College 4 plus 4 medical education program
has admitted 148 people from 2018 to June 2023. How many of them, like Dong Xiying,
have academic embellishments? Let's take a look at the doctoral thesis of Dong's classmate,
Xian Xiaoming. It is only 26 pages long. Another junior, Jin Shanmu, has a thesis that is only
13 pages long. Originally, he was from the geology department of Peking University.
Then he studied paleontological fossils, and later became a doctor of medicine. Now he is
already a postdoctoral fellow and can provide tumor treatment at Zihi Hospital. Let's also
look at Sheng Xicheng, who, by leveraging his status as an art student, managed to get into
a prestigious domestic university with reduced scores, and eventually, through the 4 plus 4
program, was able to become a doctor. There's another even more outrageous case, a person
named Han Jiashu, who in 2023 posted on Douyin, claiming he graduated as a doctor of medicine
at the age of 23. He earned the title of a prodigy, but recently got so flustered that
he deleted the video, the 4 plus 4 program at Zihi. There are also Qiu Jing'an and Qiu Jingting,
who graduated from performing arts vocational schools. These names sound like they could be
descendants of academician Qiu. What positions do these people hold in the medical system now?
Some netizens have already made their list public and warned everyone to avoid them when seeking
medical treatment. A medical industry insider said this about the 4 plus 4 program,
I've said it before, it's something the medical bigwigs created to curry favor.
A few years ago, a student asked me to write a recommendation letter.
The student had very strong qualifications, and the recommendation letter I wrote was also
very strong, yet in the end, they were not admitted, and was even disgusted by the teachers
from the Zihi program. At that time, I considered writing a letter to politely question them.
However, that student later joined another program and changed their path, so I let it go.
Then, there was a hot news story from last year about a graduate from Peking University's Guanghua
who retook the college entrance exam just to study medicine.
In the end, they went to Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine. At that time,
I couldn't help but feel that this indirectly confirmed it. The Zihi 4 plus 4 program is
essentially a place for the second generation to guild themselves. Logically, that student from
Guanghua had high scores in the college entrance exam back then, and during their undergraduate
years, they even went to a biology lab, so they must have prepared the relevant prerequisite
courses and applied for the 4 plus 4 program, but still couldn't get in.
I remember that when the program first started, it was quite prestigious.
It seemed like only a few domestic universities were eligible, while it was a bit more lenient
for foreign ones, but still required being in the top 50. Because of this big scandal,
I reviewed the admission list again. Oh my. Even students from City University of Hong Kong are
included. I guess for the second generation, it doesn't matter where they study. Even if
an ordinary person is a top student, it wouldn't work. After the incident escalated, I searched
for Dong Siying on CNKI and couldn't find a single journal or doctoral thesis. You have
to understand, the decision to retract a paper is not in the hands of the author.
It's not that easy to have CNKI, which is used to being arrogant, take down all the papers. You
first need to convince the journal's editorial department or the school to issue a retraction
letter to CNKI. Only after CNKI receives it will they review and process it. Moreover, the author
needs to provide sufficient and reasonable reasons for the retraction, and CNKI will also strictly
review the application. The communication and coordination work is both complex and lengthy.
For a normal person to complete this process, even 10 days to half a month would be considered fast.
But it seems that Dong Siying's retraction could be settled with just a phone call.
And retractions do leave a trace. CNKI will mark the retraction next to the paper's title
and the author's name. And the abstract of the paper can still be viewed, but the full text
cannot be accessed. But when you look at Dong Siying's retraction, there's nothing in the search
results. It's completely clean. Retracted at will. This is even more impressive than publishing at
will. Once again, Dong Siying makes people understand what having a background means.
The more you think about it, the scarier it gets. The depth of the connections behind
Dong might be beyond what ordinary people can imagine. By the way, the admission list for
Zihi's 4 plus 4 program. It has already been deleted, just like they don't let you see Miss
Dong's papers. If you enjoyed this episode, remember to give it a like and leave a comment.
We'll continue our discussion in the next episode.
