'The Battle of San Romano' (c. 1435–1460) by Paolo Uccello

Renaissance Art (c.1350–1620)
243 followers
7 Video Views·May 3, 2025
Dr. Caroline Campbell, Director of Collections and Research, explores the beauty, violence, and visual complexity of The Battle of San Romano by Paolo Uccello, revealing how the artist combined dramatic storytelling with groundbreaking experiments in perspective and composition.
Hello, everybody.
It's really gratifying to see such a lovely, loud crowd today.
I'm Caroline Campbell.
I'm the Director of Collections and Research here at the National Gallery.
And I've chosen, as part of our series of lunchtime talks,
to talk about Uccello's Battle of San Romano.
And this is a painting which, in many ways,
I think, brings together the good, the bad and the ugly,
in whatever way you can work out as I try, as I talk.
What I find really interesting about this picture
is that it's a great example, in some ways,
of what makes the National Gallery so special
above any other collection of great paintings in the world.
And that's the fact that, at the National Gallery,
we're very lucky to have examples of paintings
by many of the very greatest artists who've worked in painting
over the centuries,
from the 13th century to the early 20th century,
but often, in that case,
we have probably what is their very greatest work.
And this is certainly the case of the picture that I'm talking about today.
So, what I want to do
is to take you through various stories about this painting
and, through them, I think also to really unpick
some of the issues which seem to me important,
not just about this work,
but about Italian Renaissance art in general.
And one which I'm going to start with
is really the idea that we think of the Italian Renaissance
as a great moment of innovation,
as indeed this picture most definitely is,
but it's also a painting that is made
under a backdrop of a lot of violence and trouble,
some of which is manifested in this picture
and some of which I'll talk about as I go along.
It's also a painting that's been enormously valued
for all of its history,
and one of the most interesting moments in its history
was when we discovered about 20 years ago,
not we at the National Gallery,
but a great scholar called Francesco Cagliotti,
that this picture had actually been stolen by Lorenzo de' Medici,
who is a figure who we think about as being key to the Italian Renaissance,
a great power for the good,
but he took this picture forcibly from its owners.
Why would that happen?
So, I want to begin by telling you a bit
about the artist who painted this work.
This is by Paolo Uccello, who was active in Florence,
but actually in many places throughout Italy
during the 15th century.
Uccello was born to a family who come from just outside Florence.
He seems to train mainly, not actually with a painter,
but one of the greatest sculptors, Lorenzo Ghiberti,
the great goldsmith who's responsible
for the two doors on the Baptistery in Florence,
most famously, of course, the Gates of Paradise,
but it's likely that Uccello, as a young man, as an apprentice,
works with Ghiberti on the first of those set of doors.
That's an important point to make
because there's much more fluidity between art forms in the 15th century
than we've often thought, and indeed it's very much true of artists today,
but when you look at this work
and you see the way in which the artist has thought about form
as a three-dimensional sense,
even though he's conveying it on a two-dimensional panel,
I think you can really see how that early training
had an awful lot of impact on Uccello's career.
Uccello is an artist who's thought very much of a Florentine,
but he spends important parts of his career working outside Florence.
We know, for instance, that he goes to Venice,
he's commissioned to work on mosaics in the Basilica of San Marco.
Sadly, those are destroyed,
but again, it's a very interesting example of him working
in a way that is not simply pictorial.
He's also active in Padua, he's active in Bologna,
he's active in Urbino,
so he's one of these very typical Renaissance artists
in that he travels a great deal, he's open to ideas,
but the most important idea, I think, really,
is ultimately this sense of three-dimensionality and sculpturality.
Not only does he train with Uccello,
but one of his greatest friends is the sculptor Donatello.
And it's fascinating to think, although we don't know,
of the conversations that they would have had
as they're both thinking in their different ways
of trying to create things which look three-dimensional,
which look natural,
but also are very clear that they're made by these artists.
They're not reproductions of things,
they're things which have real integrity in their own right.
So we know that this painting is made at quite an early point
in Uccello's career, I would say his mid-career,
in the late 1430s,
and Uccello goes on to work until the 1470s.
He's an artist with a long career, he interestingly has two children,
one of which is his daughter, a Carmelite nun,
who are also painters,
and he's most known, I think, for paintings such as the Battle of San Romano
and the wonderful Hunt in the Forest,
which some of you will know in the Ashmolean,
for the reason that he manages to make things happen
in a perspectival sense.
We often read in histories of the Renaissance
that it's the moment when perspectival views are really introduced into painting.
That's not totally true, artists could have done them before,
they somehow just chose not to,
but Uccello was one of the people
who most obviously is using perspective in his paintings.
And you can see this very, very clearly in this work,
in the way in which he's constructed his narrative.
Look particularly in the foreground,
at the lances that are lying apparently haphazardly
along the bottom of this battle scene,
and you can see that they all go to trying to give you
a sense of the vanishing point and of the perspective.
This is a very carefully constructed painting,
but Uccello wears his learning very, very lightly
so that he also convinces you it's a realistic scene.
We do know, incidentally,
that Uccello was somebody who did have a lot of learning,
like Piero della Francesca, like Leonardo.
He was an artist who transcended simply the art form that he worked in.
He was very interested in mathematics,
and there's a wonderful story, which sadly I think is untrue,
but I wish it was, of him saying to his wife,
what a wonderful thing is this perspective in bed at the end of the day.
One could only imagine her possible reaction,
but there's this sense of joy in the invention that he's undertaking
that very much comes through in the creativity of his work.
He did unfortunately not have such a brilliant end to his life,
and one of the most melancholy documents I know about a 15th-century painter
is the tax return that Uccello puts into the Florentine state as an old man.
In essence, he says, in very, very brief Italian,
I'm old, I can't work, I'm sick, I have a wife, that's it.
And you can sort of conjure a sense of bleakness really around those bare words.
But back to the painting.
I've told you a little bit about the artist.
I want now to tell you a little bit about different aspects of this great work.
Firstly, what are we seeing represented here?
Well, very obviously, if you look at this, this is a battle scene.
If you look at the part of the painting near me,
you can see that there are cavalry who are charging in
behind a man who is holding a great banner
and is wearing a most extraordinary hat.
I've never seen anyone wear a hat quite like that,
certainly not on a battlefield,
and I think we can be absolutely confident
that the condottiere, or the military leader we see represented here,
was not wearing this when he charged into action.
What Uccello is doing is taking an actual event that happened
and making it into something which is a history painting,
so bringing the best parts of that story and creating it as a visual whole.
It's an incredible theatrical work.
It's also a very chivalric work,
and that's important because chivalry,
or an interest in knights and armour and tournaments,
was one of the things that absolutely obsessed 15th-century Florentines,
as much as the classical world that we often hear about
really wanting to be like the knights of Burgundy
or, indeed, of the medieval romances they read about,
was very, very important to the commissioners and patrons
of paintings such as this.
So, the scene that Paolo Uccello is representing here
was a fairly brutal, very, very unpleasant skirmish
that happened in a part of a long and very protracted war
between the Florentines and some of their enemies,
the Genoese, the people of Lucca,
and the people of Milan in the early 1430s.
This was particularly, this battle, the Battle of San Romano,
was part of a desire to take control of Pisa.
Now, Pisa, which of course today is most famous for its Scuola Normale
and its Leaning Tower,
was in the 15th century the main port that Tuscany had out onto the world,
and who controlled Pisa would control access to all sorts of important markets.
So, the Florentines desperately wanted it, but so did everybody else.
This picture, this episode,
became an episode that was proper for depiction in a painting
because the Florentines won.
I don't know if any of you have been to San Romano.
The train actually stops at it between Pisa and Florence
on that long, very sort of protracted journey across the Tuscan plain,
and it's a perfectly nice place, but it's not an exceptional place at all.
It's rather strange next time you go through it
to see its semi-industrial buildings
and to imagine what Uccello shows us here.
So, what he shows us is an idealisation of a battle,
and the most important thing I would say about that,
and you've probably already noticed,
is that there is no blood.
This is a bloodless conflict.
You feel that the knights who are fighting very, very dramatically,
with their lances over here,
are actually as if they're in a game.
There's something very, very unreal about it.
And that's enhanced, of course,
by the fact that not all of them are wearing armour,
and those that are seem to be wearing a mixture
of the sorts of armour that you might have worn into battle,
but combined with parade armour.
So, there's always an element of fantasy in what he's representing here.
The most fantastical element, of course, is the hat that I mentioned,
and that's being worn by the military leader of the Florentine forces,
a figure called Nicolo da Tolentino,
who was actually killed, who died very unfortunately,
or very ignominiously,
three years after this painting, in prison in Milan.
But the year after the episode that's represented in this painting,
the battle that took place in 1432,
in 1433, he's recognised basically as a hero by the Florentine state.
And those of you who visit Florence will probably know the great monument
that's been put up to him, the painted monument in the cathedral,
by Castagno, of him on horseback,
looking every bit like a sort of Roman soldier,
a great Roman dignitary.
We see another great version of the idealised commander here too,
going into battle, as he never would have done,
with his hat and also with his bastone,
or his marshal's symbol of authority.
Interestingly, in a combination of history and making things up,
Uccello gives him the bastone, or the baton to hold here,
but he wasn't actually, if I recall correctly, allowed to do this
until about a year after the event which is represented here took place.
So, what painters always do is they play with what you see.
Another remarkable way in which Uccello makes this scene in fantasy
is the fact that this is a battle scene
that is surrounded by fruit and by flowers.
I fortunately never had to go into battle,
but I'm sure that most people who have,
have not really seen oranges, pomegranates and roses
arranged around the participants in the battle,
as if it's some sort of lovely backdrop to it.
And something I did want to emphasise
is that the decorative elements of Uccello's painting
are really important and considerable.
You will see that there is quite a lot of gold in this picture,
for instance, in the stuff that the horses are wearing.
And also, if you look closely at the end of the talk,
you'll see that the gold has been very carefully worked.
It's been treated in the same way
that painters of Uccello's time would treat halos in religious paintings.
So, it's been punched with a particular tool and then it's been burnished.
And the idea of this is that the painting looks three-dimensional
and when you would have seen it in different light conditions,
you would have possibly got the illusion
in that the figures are almost moving
and that you're not seeing a representation of a battle,
but something which is actually happening in the room in which you are.
There are some ways in which this is much less evident today
than it was in the 15th century.
The first, of course, is that you're seeing it on the walls of the gallery
and the second is that some of the materials that are used
have really faded and changed
and that's what happens in paintings of this date.
What I particularly want to point out to you is the silver.
Now, silver is this material which would have dominated
how this picture would have looked visually in the 15th century.
Silver tarnishes incredibly quickly.
Even within Uccello's lifetime, it might have changed.
And so, all the metal, all the armour of the soldiers,
which would have been silver, now looks grey.
So, we've got a very different colouristic sense of this picture
than we would have done.
Something else that's happened is that a lot of the red
was painted with a pigment called vermilion
and vermilion also tarnishes and darkens in ways
when it's exposed to pollution of any description.
And if you wander around the Sainsbury Wing afterwards,
you will see lots and lots of examples of black and vermilion.
You in fact see them in every museum across the world.
It happens everywhere.
So, all the areas of red would have been much, much, much brighter
than they are today.
So, we are seeing in some ways a very different painting.
Something else that we're seeing about this painting
that's different to the way Uccello originally made it
is that if you look very carefully at the top left hand
and the top right hand corners,
you will probably be able to see
that they look rather different to the rest of the painting.
And that's been something which has really troubled
art historians, conservators and scientists
looking at this work for about the last 100 years.
Because why are these different?
And there's a complicated story which I'm now going to tell,
which is a combination of intrigue, of physical examination,
of documentary study and of really bad behaviour
that you couldn't quite believe.
The first record we have of these pictures,
the first record that people have known for a long time,
is in a Medici family inventory taken in 1492
after the death of Lorenzo the Magnificent.
Now, as often happens still today in grand houses,
when somebody dies, somebody goes round and records where everything is.
And sometimes, if you're lucky,
who the artist was and what they were actually worth.
And in the Medici inventory, it says that in the camera terrena,
in the ground floor camera or chamber,
which was Lorenzo's,
there were three paintings of the Battle of San Romano.
One of them was this painting, one of them was a painting in the Louvre
and one of them was a painting that's in the Uffizi.
And the three paintings were made together as a set by Uccello
in the 1430s.
Now, it's been very, very odd to get to,
stylistically, the fact that these pictures date to the late 1430s
and why we first then knew of them in the Medici Palace in 1492.
And all sorts of complicated theories were brought up
as to why this might have been possible
and which could explain the fact that significant changes were made
to the top of this picture and, indeed, of the two others
at some point in its early history in the 15th century.
So, as I said, if you look carefully at the top,
you'll see that there are additions to the panel
and if you look very carefully in Raking Lights,
which is if you stand and look at it from the side,
you might be able to see
that originally this painting had an arched top
and it was cut very dramatically.
We've estimated that all three of the pictures
probably lost about 64 centimetres in height
at some point in the 15th century,
so they were intended to be in a much bigger space
than the space in which they're recorded in Lorenzo de' Medici's camera.
And when they're recorded in Lorenzo de' Medici's camera,
they're clearly very valuable paintings,
not so much by their monetary value,
but more from the fact that this is the place they were.
The camera or the chamber was the most important room
in a patrician palace for the man who was responsible for it.
It was the place where he would bring his privileged guests,
it was the place where he would go himself,
so the things that were in there were obviously significant.
So, what was really fascinating was that 20 years ago,
a great Italian art historian called Francesco Cagliotti
found some fascinating documents in an archive in Florence,
and this demonstrated that the paintings
had not been made for the Medici at all.
And this was difficult for many people
who had interpreted, for instance, the oranges that you see in this work
as being a Medici symbol.
If you know Florence and you know the Medici,
you'll know that the palais or bowls are their emblem,
and there was a feeling that these orange bowls in here
was really an amplification of how this was a Medici commission.
But rather, these paintings were recorded in an inventory
of another family, the Bartolini Salimbeni,
and we got to discover this because after Lorenzo de' Medici died,
two years later, his son Piero was chased from Florence,
and the Medici, who had been the de facto rulers of Florence
for quite a long time, were no longer in control,
and various people who felt they'd been hard done by the Medici
tried to claim things that really belonged to them
or complained about things that had been done
during the time of Lorenzo's lifetime.
And one of the people who came in 1495
was a member of the Bartolini Salimbeni family,
and he said that this painting
and the two other paintings of the subject,
now in the Uffizi and now in the Louvre,
had belonged to his father.
They had been in his father's palace,
he had inherited them with some of his brothers,
and then they had been forcibly removed from his townhouse
by Lorenzo de' Medici's carpenter
and taken to the Palazzo Medici,
which is an extraordinary story.
And what seems to have happened
is that when Leonardo Bartolini Salimbeni died in 1476,
he left six sons,
and there was a great disagreement about the estate.
He had left all his possessions to his three younger sons
because he felt they hadn't been well looked after,
but the three older sons, of course, complained and said this wasn't right.
So there was a process of arbitration,
and guess who was asked to arbitrate the discussion?
None other than Lorenzo de' Medici,
who was at that point really the ruler of Florence,
indeed, if not in name.
And what seems very likely to Francesco Caglioti
and to myself and others
is that Lorenzo saw the pictures at that time
and he really coveted them.
And because of the authority that he had,
he was able to essentially get the pictures out of the family house
and bring them into his own chamber in his palace,
which is a fairly astonishing story
and shows not just the chutzpah of Lorenzo,
but actually the real authority that he did have in Florence at that time,
that he could basically force people to do that,
but that there was a sense of huge animosity from the family
and the minute that they had the opportunity to get the pictures back,
they did, they tried.
The pictures didn't stay with them forever, though,
because later on in the 16th century,
they're recorded in the Medici Palace again,
so they seem to have made journeys
depending on how the politics of Florence was going at that time.
But I tell you that story
not just because I think it's a fascinating example
of how pictures can really mean things to people
who aren't the people they're originally made for,
but also because it really gives a more complex dimension
to our understanding of the Florentine Renaissance
and the people involved in it.
It reminds us, I think,
that paintings are things that inspire really passionate emotions
among us and among the people who've looked them in in the past,
so much so that on occasion,
they're prepared to do things that really are illegal
in order to get them into their possession.
But I think it also reminds us,
and this is a salient fact given the subject of Uccello's painting,
the subject of battle,
and turning a really quite horrible military conflict
into something which really looks very dignified,
is that beyond all the things that we hugely value,
that have immense cultural merit
and do huge things to enrich our lives,
such as this painting and the other paintings in the National Gallery,
there is a nasty undercurrent often going on underneath them.
And that's not simply something that's bad per se,
it's also something, it's that infinite conflict between good and evil
which really ends up in the production of works like this
and the stories that they tell.
And the stories that this picture tells, of course,
doesn't just end in reconstructing its 15th-century context,
and its wonderful and complicated story,
but in the resonances it continues to make in our lives today.
And I'm very aware that there are many significant art forms
and artists working in various different means of production
who find this a truly inspirational painting.
And I don't know if any of you had the great joy
to go to the Proms a few years ago
and see that wonderful pair of French pianists,
the Lebec sisters,
perform a piece of music composed in America in the 1950s,
which is based on this and the other pictures in this series.
And I really recommend you try and find a copy of their recording
because you get a great sense from music of the battle taking place,
of the ceremonial nature of it, of the clash,
and ultimately the good resolution that we don't see in a cello's painting.
But there's another resonance which is even more immediate.
And actually, in London at this time,
if you cross town and go to a private gallery,
you can see the responses to this painting
by an Afro-American artist called Richard Reid,
who came to London in 1979
and was absolutely blown away by this painting.
He is a figure who is really being discovered again
by art historians, by curators, by collectors.
His work was more or less lost, it was all in one place.
And so if you're interested in thinking
that the resonances of a work of art can have
long beyond the time that it was created,
I really recommend that you go and see these paintings.
But I think that's really all I have to say to you today.
I just want to remind you to really think about Uccello's great painting
not just as a representation of battle,
but about the battle that acquiring and keeping on to a painting like this
can really have for collectors.
And aren't we lucky that the battle is over
and that the picture is here on the National Gallery,
never to go anywhere else for the rest of its history.
Thank you.
