Did My Girlfriend's Parents Commit Fraud? 📈 Are you on track with the Baby Steps? Get a Free Personalized Plan. https://ter.li/5h1r0i
Next Steps: • 💵 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ter.li/99xl4y • 🏘️ Get Organized and Prepared to Buy or Sell a Home - https://ter.li/7i7mou • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
brought to you by the Every Dollar app.
Start budgeting for free today. So, I
have a question. I'm planning on
proposing to my girlfriend here coming
up soon. Um, but back in November, she
told me that her father had transferred
all of her parents' investments to her
so that her sister could get a larger
financial aid package. I basically said
to not tell me anything more because I
think this might be fraud. Um, she said
her dad talked to someone and he said it
was all fine. And then a month ago, I
went to ask for her hand uh to her
parents. They said yes, but her dad kind
of led me into saying that I would be
willing to sign a prenup and he doesn't
know that I know about the asset
transfer. Then last weekend, I brought
up the situation saying that I wasn't
comfortable combining finances and
signing marriage papers with these
assets and putting my name under them.
Again, she tells me their dad said it's
above board, but I felt like it was
maybe fraud. I told her that if she went
uh to a lawyer and basically had him
call me and said that it was a call
above board, I'd be fine with it. Um,
but I'm just kind of wanted to get your
opinion on this. Is it fraud or am I
just kind of being paranoid about this?
Um, I'm not sure if I can make the
judgment on whether it's criminal fraud
or not. Um, it's definitely morally
wrong. Hey, George here in the control
booth and I bet you're wondering what
they're going to say next. Get out of
debt. Sell the horse. yada yada yada.
The advice may be predictable, but the
internet is anything but. You see, your
personal info is out there up for grabs
by shady companies ready to add more
scam and spam to your life. And that's
why I use Delete Me. Delete Me will
scrub your data from all of these sites
so that you can focus on the Ramsay show
instead of who's buying and selling your
info. And Ramsay fans get 20% off at
joineddeeme.com/ramsey or by using the
link in the description below. So go
take control of your privacy as soon as
this call is over. It's definitely
morally wrong. Yeah. Okay. That's what I
think. The Pell grants that they qualify
for by posing to be poor people are for
poor people, right? And these people are
not poor people. Correct. So I don't
know I don't know if it's above board
quote unquote or not, but it's morally
wrong. It's like saying um I'm going to
I'm going to not have act like I don't
have a job. Well, now that would be
fraud. If I have a job and I collect
welfare checks, uh saying I don't have a
job, that'd be fraud. Uh but it'd be
like um I I'm not gonna um I have the
ability to work and make a lot of money,
but I refuse to because I that way I
qualify for free government, whatever.
Right? Same kind of thing. And and and
it's just it's morally wrong at a
minimum. It is approaching the criminal
side. And the bigger problem, let's
let's change the word. It's ethically
horrendous.
Correct. Yes. It's ethically
ridiculously bad. This guy has no
ethics.
Okay. He's willing to
lie to the government to get poor
people's lo uh legal uh uh student
assistance,
right? Pell grants PEL grants are income
and
assetbased. And that's the only thing
that qual that's the only thing that in
in a possible financial aid package that
would come up is the Pell Grant. Okay?
nothing else unless the local unless the
college had a an income based
scholarship program or something, but
most of them don't. Um, so
uh uh but yeah, it's ethically wrong.
That's what you're saying. And that
that's that's why you got this that's
why you got slime on you and you want to
take a shower after you met with him.
Yes. Yeah. So, no. Um full stop.
Yeah. Have her transfer back and full
stop. Yeah. Just Yeah. I'm not going to
participate in this. We are going to
have a standalone life that does not
involve something that I feel like is
unethical.
Yeah. Yeah. It's it's really been
weighing on me. So, I I really
appreciate that that way. Prenup prenup
doesn't cover it.
You can't prenup away a lack of ethics.
Yeah. And what's frustrating is she I
appreciate that. Yeah. And what's
frustrating Cody is she's, you know, in
a sense possibly the one that's going to
be punished in the middle of all of this
cuz Cody, you're going to say, "No, I
can't. Like, I'm not I'm not signing a
prenup. I'm not doing this. I can't
combine finances right now. Like, this
is a sticky situation. I don't feel
comfortable attaching my name to all of
this." And so, she either has to choose
to be between her dad and her I mean,
yeah. grown up and to say, "Okay, I have
to now think beyond what my dad says is
okay and actually start, you know,
having this like problem solving on my
own with my future husband with my
future husband and deciding that which
is going to be a a you know, a break.
That's going to be a hard thing for her
to do. But if she does it, then that kud
kudos to her, right? Of like, okay, this
would be a You can be gentle and you can
be kind. You don't have to accuse him of
being a liar like I am or being
unethical. You can just say, you can put
it all back on you and just say, "Look,
I don't feel right about this and I'm
not and I can't go forward
participating. I'm so sorry. Don't don't
don't call her dad names. Doesn't do any
good." It's not going to change him.
Okay? He's never going to he's never
going to say, "Oh, wow. No, my
daughter's boyfriend told me I was
wrong, so now I think I'm wrong." The
chances of that are zero. Okay. Yeah.
Exactly. So, I mean, you know, really
it's it's it's your relationship with
her that's on the line. I mean if you
guys you just say look you know you know
here I'm I'm I'm making this up real
time. I'm spitballing here. Okay. But
you could just say something like um uh
you know I I I got some counsel because
I'm I was confused about this and it
bothered me. Okay. And so I I take all
of the weight of the problem on you and
and um and and just say I just can't go
forward with this and the count. And
here's what I would couch it in. All of
my understanding of your daughter and I
setting up a household is that we are to
leave and cleave. We're to leave our
parent, our mother and father, and
establish our own standalone household.
And this does not allow us to do that.
Yes, sir. And I have to be able to do
that to have a high quality relationship
with your daughter. And so you guys have
got to take these assets back. Well, I
would have prenup doesn't do it. And I
can't I can't go forward if we can't
have a standalone household. The
intertwining of these two households is
not is is not healthy. Well, and I think
even before that conversation though, he
needs he he and her need to be on the
same page to even go forward with it
because if she's like, "No, no, I this
is what we're going to do. My dad says
you, you know, he decided to prenup.
Sorry, this is it." And she doesn't
budge. Well, and if she says, then yeah,
you're you're making a call here. But
dude, I I I you know, if you let's say
she says that, you go, "Okay, I'm going
to cave. I'll sign everything. We're
going to get married." What's the
probability you're married 10 years
later? almost zero.
Yeah. So, I mean, from from a single
argument that then brings up everything.
No, it's not a single argument. This is
an argument over
integrity. It's okay to lie to get a
program that I don't qualify for. What
else is she going to be lying about?
Because she thinks it's okay to lie
because her dad taught her this, right?
So, I mean, that's not cool. Yeah. She
needs to realize what's going on. And if
she doesn't realize it, she's got a
conversation. And you can't just cave
because that condones the whole stupid
thing and makes it look like it's okay.
And then extrapolates into other stuff
and 10 years later you got an explosion
on your hands. Yeah. It's more of a It's
more I'm sorry. That's so painful. A
revelation of character than anything
else. And so painful. That's hard. Yeah.
I mean, if your parents rob banks for a
living and you think it's okay, maybe we
shouldn't get married. You know, it's
kind of where it's about where it lands.
Although that is a criminal act. This is
not a criminal act. I get it. I'm being
melodramatic. But still, that's the
deal. Create your free every dollar
budget today. The simplest way to budget
for your