Medieval Shield walls have become a favorite of today’s moviemakers. But if you take a closer look, it’s clear that the historical shield wall has little to do with the heroic, spectacular, and often acrobatic mess we see in films  In reality, fighting in a shield wall was unspectacular brutal soldiering. However, in film, battles are an occasion for a hero to prove himself. Such scenes are climactic and popular media is often much more interested in good drama than in historical authenticity. Nevertheless, the medieval shield wall is a controversial topic not only among history buffs but also among historians. Still, there are some things that can be said about the historical shield wall with a fair degree of certainty - and thus some aspects of pop media depictions can be identified as myths. In this video, we’re going to tackle four common misconceptions about medieval shield walls.
Medieval shield walls have become a favorite of today's movie makers. But if you take a closer
look, it's clear that the historical shield wall has little to do with the heroic, spectacular and
often acrobatic mess we see in films. In reality, fighting in a shield wall was unspectacular,
brutal, soldiering. However, in film, battles are an occasion for a hero to prove himself.
Such scenes are climactic and popular media is often more interested in good drama than
historical authenticity. Nevertheless, the medieval shield wall is a controversial topic
not only among history buffs, but also among historians. Still, there are some things that
can be said about the historical shield wall with a fair degree of certainty. And thus,
some aspects of pop media depictions can be identified as myths.
In this video, we're going to tackle four common misconceptions about medieval shield walls.
As military history fans, we're happy to announce that this video is sponsored by War Thunder.
War Thunder offers a highly immersive combat experience with every vehicle incredibly
detailed and modeled down to their individual components. All of that comes in 4k resolution
with an authentic sound design to immerse yourself in. For us, the vehicle damage model is just
astounding. It's actually dynamic, so both the vehicle and the crew suffer actual damage. In War
Thunder, you can play more than 2000 tanks, helicopters, and ships in dynamic PvP battles,
which makes it the most comprehensive vehicle combat game on the market. All of these vehicles
are customizable, for example with camouflages or 3D decorators such as bushes and equipment.
From a historical perspective, it's nice to see that their collection of vehicles spends over 100
years of development, all the way from the 1920s to the present day. You can play War Thunder on PC,
Xbox Series X and S, PlayStation 5, or the previous console generation right now.
Get yourself a huge bonus containing 500,000 silver lions, three vehicles, a 50% XP booster,
a seven-day premium account booster, and much more by using the link in the description below.
A medieval battle was not a chaotic model of men dodging and leaping, striking to the front and
side, all intermingled with each other, at least not in an open field battle. Anyone who would have
fought like Uhtred of Bebbenberg in the Last Kingdom would not have survived for long. Most
fighters would certainly not have the skill and bravery to fight like that, but more importantly,
foot soldiers had to form a tight, cohesive formation in order to stand a chance on the
battlefield. The Anglo-Saxons, defending Sand Lake Hill against the Normans at the Battle of
Hastings in 1066, for example, formed quote an impenetrable body, end quote, by quote
covering themselves in front by the junctions of their shields, end quote. According to the
historian Clifford Rogers, it is such close formations that are referred to by the term
shield wall, but the term itself doesn't necessarily refer to a fixed tactical formation.
Depending on time and place, shield walls could look very differently. So could their popularity,
depending on the nature of the conflict. In case of surprise attacks and raids, which were,
for example, a core element of Viking warfare, it was less likely that a shield wall was used
than in an open field battle. But no matter where or when, if an army chose to fight in a shield
wall, the ultimate objective was to keep the formation, because what made it effective in
the first place was its cohesion. When the men stood shoulder to shoulder, they were protected
from three sides and could focus exclusively on what was happening in front of them. While there
are examples in which heavily armed fighters were put in front of the first row, for example when a
cavalry attack was expected, the mass of the fighters was always very tightly formed. This
is because a formation that broke up meant chaos and could have fatal consequences, as Christine
de Pizan, a French writer and philosopher who lived at the turn of the 13th and 14th centuries
explains. This is why it was imperative, quote, to keep a formation in line and tight and cohesive
like a wall, end quote. When they formed such a wall, the army had the best chance to succeed
and the individual had the greatest chance to survive. If the men further to the back moved up
closely, this gave the formation stability through mass. If the men stood shoulder to shoulder,
the front row was closed and all fighters standing there had the best possible protection.
According to Jean de Bruy, a French admiral in the Hundred Years War, known as the Scourge of
the English, infantrymen should be arrayed so tightly that an apple thrown at the formation
could not pass between their bodies. So,
fighting in a shield wall was all about keeping the formation as tight as possible, while trying
to disrupt the enemy's formation in order to create a weak spot, which could then be exploited.
Usually, the formation was broken up once the battle was over, either to flee or to pursue
the loser, but there was definitely no room for a bunch of raging swashbucklers.
Movie makers and audiences love the epic moment when one army charges another. In reality,
this was not to be recommended. Running into an intact shield wall, such as here in Vikings,
was as pointless as it was suicidal. There would have been almost no chance of breaking through,
unless the enemy formation already had a weak point. At the same time,
running attackers would expose themselves because they would have to break formation
or at least loosen up to run. Jean de Bruy wrote, quote,
So, not only was it unwise to run into a shield wall, it was equally unwise to run as a shield
wall. The shield wall was, in essence, a defensive formation that functioned best when
deployed statically. Nevertheless, at least one of the two sides had, of course, to advance to
make contact. While doing so, the main concern was to minimize risks. For example, a formation
could advance step by step, keeping together as tightly as possible. Or, alternatively,
break formation, run forward, slow down just before making contact, then link back together
and finally confront the enemy in a closed line. The second option was probably also
chosen by the Norman heavy infantry, who were the first to advance against the Anglo-Saxons
at Hastings. As the Anglo-Saxons had the high ground, however, the Normans had a two-fold
disadvantage. They had to run uphill while the Anglo-Saxons could shoot at them from above.
Under these circumstances, they stood no chance. By the time they reached the enemy shield wall,
their line had many gaps and they could no longer form a closed shield wall. So, any advance meant
a significant disadvantage and was even likely to disrupt the ranks of the formation. Marching
forward slowly was a risk. Running frontally into a shield wall was nonsense, if there wasn't a
significant weak spot to exploit. In general, there are not enough missile weapons in movie
depictions of shield walls. Archers weren't the only ones who were shooting at the enemy.
In many movie battles, the archers hold back after an initial hail of arrows and make way for
charging infantry or cavalry in order to avoid hitting their own fighters. In reality, an
advancing medieval shield wall was incessantly pelted with projectiles. The men further to the
back, who couldn't participate in the fighting directly, did their best to throw spears, axes
and other projectiles, such as rocks, at their opponents. The Norman heavy infantry at Hastings
had to learn this as well. Because, while they were climbing up the slope, the Anglo-Saxons were
throwing, quote, javelins and spears of all sorts, extremely lethal axes, and stones fixed to pieces
of wood. Under this deadly hail, you might have thought that our men would be crushed, end quote.
The use of missile weapons is also nicely depicted on the Bayeux Tapestry, an embroidered cloth
depicting the Norman conquest of England. The tapestry shows various fighters throwing spears
and axes. In the depiction of the Battle of Hastings, various men in the back rows are
holding several spears waiting to throw them. Usually, all thrown weapons were aimed at the
face, because until the 13th century it remained mostly unprotected, and even after that the face
was more thinly armored than other parts of the body. A simple fist-sized stone could do great
damage to a face, let alone an axe thrown by a practiced hand. In fact, throwing weapons caused
as much damage in a fight between two shield walls as the swords, axes, and spears in the
front ranks. Movies like to focus on swords, but spears, thrown or hand-held, are reported to be
one if not the most common weapon used in shield walls by various sources. Historians also agree,
the effectiveness of thrown axes, spears, and even stones should not be underestimated,
especially because they could achieve effortlessly what the men in the front rows struggled to do
with their spears in hand under great risk. Weapons used as projectiles could open up a gap
in the enemy's line and thus create a weak spot. As far as we're concerned, we couldn't find a
single movie battle in which the use of projectiles is properly depicted, but feel free to point them
out to us if you know any examples. Infantry had a hard time against well-armored and well-trained
horsemen charging them. According to the historian Clifford Rogers, a single horse might produce a
sort of reversed turbulence wake among the footmen, even knocking them down in series,
like a bowling ball into tenpins. If two or more horses broke through, the chaos was even worse,
and if a horseman even managed to get to the back of the formation, he could attack them
from their most vulnerable side. This would often lead to a complete breakup of the formation.
So, when foot soldiers ran at cavalry like the Great Heathen Army in Vikings,
they actually stood little chance. However, infantry had possibilities to defend itself
against such a charge, even if they had no field fortifications or favorable terrain
at their disposal. Again, one possibility was to throw missile weapons. This could be very effective,
since there was always a chance to distract or kill a charging horse, even a well-trained one
by hitting it with a spear or stone, but this alone couldn't possibly stop all horsemen.
To deal with the rest, the infantry had to react in time and correctly. Again,
the precondition for success was that they would stay in close formation and did not panic.
The key to a successful defense against cavalry was to amass a sufficient number
of bodies tightly packed together that would almost form a solid mass. This mass of men
weighed more than the horse and could thus stop it. Still, the impact of a charging horse would
have been far from pleasant. In the best cases, the horse was stopped in its tracks and then
crushed the man in the front rows, while, according to Clifford Rogers, its rider would often be
catapulted onto the enemy formation. For the men in the front, this defensive strategy could be
lethal, but it allowed the formation to remain intact and continue to fight, which gave everyone
else a much higher chance of survival. The effect of this could be greatly enhanced if the men in
the first rows ramped their spears in the ground or used field stakes, so that the horses would be
impaled on impact. An early example for the successful use of pikes against cavalry is the
Battle of Bannockburn in 1314. There, quote, many horses were impaled and many good men felled under
their hooves, had no chance of getting up again, end quote. Still better yet were the chances if
the infantry used long pikes. These could be anchored in the ground more firmly, and their
length allowed for more points to be placed in front of the first row. This was one of the main
reasons why infantry increasingly adopted long pikes. There is a whole bunch of other stuff that
could be addressed, but let's leave it at that for today. If you'd like to learn more about what
fighting in medieval shield walls looked like, we recommend our bibliography and the reading
list in the description. Thanks again to War Thunder for sponsoring this video. Don't forget
to make use of the large free bonus pack by using our link in the description below.
And consider supporting us on Patreon.