Let's take a look at one of the most unusual - and unstable designs in aviation history: the X-29!
The Grumman X-29 was an experimental aircraft that intensely tested a combination of the use of canards, forward swept wings, fly by wire, composite materials and other cutting edge aircraft technologies. Featuring a highly aerodynamically unstable design which first flew in 1984, the last X29 flight was conducted in 1992 and the program contributed greatly to aviation research. Today we will look at the development of the X29 along with some of the key challenges and milestones of the program during its operational testing.
This video is an opinion editorial commentary. Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for fair use purposes such as criticism, commentary, parody, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research.
All works used in this video (Images, audio etc) belong to their respective authors (This does not include the audio commentary or licensed BGM).
Forward swept wings (FSW) were tested in the 1930s by NACA, and the X-29 flew at Edwards Air Force Base. The F16 was a competitor and the F16XL was developed around the same time. The first jet FSW aircraft was the JU 287 1944
Let's take a look at one of the most unusual and unstable designs in aviation history, the X-29.
The Grumman X-29 was an experimental aircraft that intensely tested a combination of the use
of canards, forward swept wings, fly-by-wire, composite materials, and other cutting-edge
aircraft technologies. Featuring a highly aerodynamically unstable design which first
flew in 1984, the last X-29 flight was conducted in 1992 and the program contributed greatly to
aviation research. Today we will look at the development of the X-29 along with some of the
key challenges and milestones of the program during its operational testing. Here are some
quick specifications for the X-29. Length 48 feet 1 inch. Height 14 feet 9.5 inches.
Wingspan 27 feet 3 inches. Maximum speed Mach 1.8. Empty weight 13,800 pounds.
Maximum takeoff weight 17,800 pounds. Engines one General Electric F404-GE400
afterburning turbofan engine producing 16,000 pounds of thrust with afterburner.
Forward swept wings have been of interest to aircraft designers for decades.
There were several gliders prior to World War II that featured forward swept wings
and NACA, which was a predecessor to NASA, conducted some wind tunnel tests of forward
swept wings at Langley in 1931. One of the first powered aircraft to feature a forward swept wing
was the Bugatti R100, which was a 1937 designed air racer intended to compete with the Messerschmitt
fighter team. However, due to the outbreak of World War II, the aircraft never flew.
During the war in 1943, Germany was working on the Junkers Ju-287, a testbed bomber that
hoped to make use of the inherent advantages of a forward swept wing. Developed by Dr. Hans
Wacht, the four-engine Ju-287 was test flown in 1944 with fixed landing gear, but ultimately was
too late in the war to reach production status. As the jet age dawned, North America explored
forward swept wing designs for its legendary P-51 Mustang. The forward swept wing, or SFW
derivative of the Mustang, was to have tricycle gear and use both the Allison V-1710G6R piston
engine in the nose and the aft ventrally mounted Westinghouse 19XB28 jet engine.
While very intriguing, this Mustang never made it past the concept phase.
Following World War II, the HFB-320 Hansa jet was produced and flown in 1964.
Designed by the same lead engineer who worked on the Ju-287, interestingly the HFB-320 was and is
the world's only forward swept passenger aircraft. Some 47 examples were built, with the type being
retired in 2004. However, both the Ju-287 and HFB-320 suffered from weight issues, typically
in the wing. One major challenge with forward swept wings was the amount of stress induced by
the wings. Strengthening the wing is possible, but using conventional materials incurs weight
penalties. The full advantages of forward swept wings could not yet be realized.
In the 1970s, composite materials were introduced. Composites were lighter and in some cases stronger
than steel. As a result, entire new possibilities in aircraft construction became viable,
effectively allowing for new designs to be explored which were not previously possible
or practical using conventional materials. Consequently, in 1977, the Defense Advanced
Research Project Agency or DARPA and the U.S. Air Force issued proposals for a research aircraft
designed to explore the forward swept wing concept. Along with forward swept wings,
the aircraft was also to validate studies which had predicted better control and lift qualities
in extreme maneuvers and possibly reduced aerodynamic drag, as well as fly more efficiently
at cruise speeds. In response, three companies submitted proposals. General Dynamics took their
F-16 and made a forward swept wing version of it and dubbed it the SFW-16. This F-16 version never
advanced beyond the concept phase, but was part of a family of experimental wing designs to the
F-16 airframe, which also included the F-16XL. Some speculate that the SFW-16 entry was not
chosen since there were many F-16 research projects active and proposed at the time,
and the consensus was that the F-16 was over-represented. Rockwell had also submitted
a design and had actually been working on several prototypes which led to their SFW submission.
Rockwell had just finished work on their Highly Maneuverable Aircraft Technology or HIMAT
demonstrator. The HIMAT was a remotely piloted fly-by-wire aircraft which made use of canards
and a forward swept wing. The Rockwell entry was known as the Sabrebat and Rockwell went as far
as producing a full-scale model which was showcased at the Paris Airshow along with
running several ads and publications at the time. And finally, Grumman submitted their proposal.
Grumman's entry was the 712 or G712, which would ultimately prove to be the winning design and
receive the designation X-29. Interestingly, the X-29 was made up of components from existing
aircraft. The forward fuselage along with the nose gear were from an F-5A Freedom Fighter,
while the control surface actuators and main landing gear were from the F-16. The General
Electric F-404 series engine was similar to the one used on the F-18 Hornet as well as the F-20
Tiger Shark. The F-20 had used the F-404-100 engine while the X-29 used the F-404-400 engine.
One of the biggest challenges with forward swept wings are the extreme stresses that the wings have
to endure. As lift is generated, twisting forces are applied to the wing's leading edge which
produces a higher angle of attack and then in turn produces more lift along with even more
twisting force. In a phenomenon known as aeroelastic divergence, this self-amplifying feedback loop
can rapidly lead to structural failure. If conventional metals are used to produce a
forward swept wing, an extremely stiff wing would be needed to resist the twisting effect.
However, this would cause the wings to be prohibitively heavy, negating any design
advantages. To mitigate this, the X-29 made extensive use of composites such as carbon fiber.
The X-29's wings use a laminate design which produced coupling between the bending and torsion
forces. In this way, as lift increases, the wingtips would bend upward while the torsion
loads attempt to twist the wing upwards, but the coupling resists by twisting the wing downward
which stops the divergence process from occurring. Along with the composite wings,
the X-29 implemented what is known as the three surface configuration. This meant that the X-29
used canards, forward swept wings, and aft strake control surfaces to maintain control.
The canards and wings worked together to reduce wave and trim drag while the aft strakes provided
control in situations where the center of gravity was off and assisted the canards.
Along with the three surface configuration, the X-29 also placed its center of gravity well
aft of the traditional aerodynamic center. This combination made the X-29 highly unstable,
and it was thought that this high instability would lead to a super maneuverable aircraft.
To assist the pilot in controlling the X-29, sophisticated flight computers were implemented
and had to provide some 40 corrections per second. This flight control system was composed of triply
redundant digital computers, which were themselves backed up by three more analog computers. And
while any of the three computers could fly the aircraft on its own, the redundancy allowed for
error checking. Essentially, each computer would vote on the best inputs to maintain flight control
and this was compared against the other two to check for errors. This was critical since
the X-29 was so unstable that it could break apart before the pilot had time to even eject.
Inherent instability is used in many fighters today such as the F-16 and F-18, but the X-29
took it to the extreme. For comparison, the F-18 has an instability factor of only 5%,
while the X-29 was 35% unstable. The first X-29 flight took place on 14 December 1984
out of Edwards Air Force Base with Chuck Sewell at the controls. Upon taking to the skies, the
X-29 became the third forward swept jet-powered aircraft to fly, the previous two being the
aforementioned German Junkers Ju 287 in 1944 and the HFB 320 Hanza jet in 1964. Interestingly,
these three aircraft each flew 20 years apart, 1944, 1964, and 1984. The X-29 proved to be so
reliable that four months after its first flight, it became a NASA test program. Almost exactly a
year later in December of 1985, the X-29 became the first forward swept aircraft to break the
sound barrier in level flight. Ultimately, two X-29s were produced. Aircraft number one had
tail number 003, while aircraft number two had tail number 049. Aircraft one was flown in flight
regimes that avoided maneuvers which could result in departure from controlled flight.
To fully explore the flight envelope of the X-29, aircraft two had a spin recovery parachute
installed and as a result participated in high angle of attack testing. This allowed the X-29
to maintain maneuverability up to angles of attack or alpha of 25 degrees, while a maximum
alpha of 67 degrees was recorded in a momentary pitch-up maneuver. In the end, the two X-29s flew
a total of 242 times between 1984 and 1992. In these flights, the X-29 was able to demonstrate
some new technologies and applications, as well as new uses of existing technologies.
Some examples include aircraft control and handling during extreme instability,
the use of a double-hinged trailing-edge flaperon at subsonic speeds, vortex control,
demonstration of military utility, and aero-elastic tailoring to control structural divergence.
The X-29 is easily one of the most iconic and recognizable of the X-planes. Ultimately,
the X-29 accomplished its mission to demonstrate that a highly unstable aircraft could be flown
safely with high G-loads and deliver excellent maneuverability. So why did the type not enter
into production in some capacity? Despite the use of composites and a laminate design,
there still was high structural stress applied to the wings. A combat version of the X-29 would
undoubtedly be exposed to significant stress loads, and that's before considering battle damage being
applied to the wings or fuselage. Still, it's fun to imagine a combat production version of the
X-29 and what that would have looked like. Here is a 3D rendered concept of an F-29 Retaliator.
Let me know what you think in the comments below. The investigation of military applications for
forward swept wings did not end with the X-29. About 5 years after the last X-29 flight in 1997,
the Russian Air Force Sukhoi Su-47 took to the skies. While showing some promising results,
the Su-47 did not enter into production and only one flying example was built.
More recently in Russia, the KBSAT SR-10 trainer was developed as a prototype. Featuring forward
swept wings, the extensive use of composites, and the front half of what looks like a Super Hornet,
the SR-10 first flew in 2015 but ultimately was not adopted by the Russian Air Force.
The X-29 remains one of the most unique looking aircraft to take to the skies,
and contributed immensely to the art and science that is aerodynamics and the study of composite
materials. Today, one of the X-29s can be seen at the National Museum of the United States Air
Force at Wright-Patterson in Dayton, Ohio, while the other X-29 is located at Edwards Air Force
Base. What do you think? Was the X-29 one of the best X-Planes? Would you have liked
to have seen it gone into production? Let me know in the comments below.
Thanks for watching. If you enjoyed this video, go ahead and click the subscribe button and then
click the real subscribe button so you don't miss an episode. I'd also like to take a moment to
thank my Patreons who directly support this channel. If you'd like to become a Patreon,
I'll leave a link in the description below. Stay safe, and see you next time.