The Insane Engineering of the F-14 Tomcat

Military Aviation Technology
4 followers
The F-14 Tomcat was designed for one thing and one thing only, to intercept state of the art
Soviet supersonic bombers, before they could launch long range missiles that could cripple
the US Navy's largest aircraft carriers. Nothing in the US military's arsenal could handle this
threat. A new generation of aircraft was needed, that could fly up to Mach 2 to intercept these
high flying bombers, be capable of dogfighting at slower speeds when dealing with their fighter
escorts, be rugged and strong enough to handle the extreme landings of carrier based aircraft,
while carrying an enormous load of the most advanced air to air weapons ever created.
And to top it all off, a powerful radar capable of guiding those weapons from an equivalent
distance of New York to Boston. To do all this, the F-14 needed to be a shape shifter,
to adapt to the battlefield at a moment's notice. The swing wing of the F-14 allowed it to play two
roles. A dogfighter and a high speed interceptor. This is the insane engineering of the F-14 Tomcat.
When the F-14 was proposed, variable sweep wings were nothing new. The Germans theorised the
benefits of a plane capable of changing the angle of its wings back in World War 2, and despite the
expected complexity of the design, they followed through with a prototype design as part of the
Emergency Fighter Program. A program created in a last ditch attempt to turn the tides of the
Allied aerial assaults that had crippled the Luftwaffe in 1944. This secretive plane,
the Messerschmitt P-1101, was never completed. And in the final days of the war, as the US military
marched towards Berlin, they stumbled across the innovative machine. Seeing the potential of the
design, it was shipped back to the Bell factory in Buffalo, New York. Six years later, the Bell
X-5 rolled out of its hangar, bearing a striking resemblance to the spoils of war. However, the
X-5 was a flawed aircraft. It would take decades of material science and aerodynamic advancements
to incorporate a complex mechanism like this in a practical operational combat aircraft.
Variable sweep wings allow planes to adapt their aerodynamics on the go.
When flying slower subsonic speeds, a lower sweep is preferable. It allows the plane to
generate more lift with less drag. This is especially useful for a plane that needs to
loiter in the sky for prolonged periods protecting massive multi-billion dollar aircraft carriers.
But, when needed, the F-14 can pin its proverbial ears back and accelerate to Mach 2.3. A highly
desirable mechanism that is usually not included due to the added weight and the cost of maintenance.
To make this practical, the designers of the F-14 would need to shave weight wherever possible,
and they began with the F-14's wing box. The wing box is the foundation of an aircraft.
It's the structural core upon which the entire aircraft is built. It connects the two wings
together and resists the bending moment they generate, while supporting the entire weight
of the aircraft through its connection to the fuselage. And the F-14 was going to be a heavy
aircraft. The heaviest and most expensive fighter aircraft the US had ever developed. Carrying two
massive engines capable of pushing the plane to twice the speed of sound, six state of the art
air to air missiles that only the F-14 could use, 7 tons of fuel, a complex swing wing mechanism,
and a massive internal radar, which was the most powerful combat aircraft radar in service
until the F-22 was introduced. Making the wing box as strong and light as possible was going to be
vital for the F-14, and this was complicated even further by the need for a pivot connection
for the outboard wings. Most wing boxes are constructed from aluminium, but Grumman made
the decision early in the design process to manufacture the wing box of the F-14 from titanium.
A notoriously difficult and expensive material to work with,
but it's benefits in strength to weight ratio were exactly what they needed.
To work with this material Grumman needed to develop a massive one of it's kind titanium
manufacturing facility that used a unique manufacturing process. Electron Beam Welding.
Electron Beam Welding, as the name would suggest, uses a focused beam of high speed
electrons to bombard a metal surface to generate heat with kinetic energy. This method was used
because titanium is highly reactive with oxygen, and when heated it becomes even more reactive.
During the welding process oxides form and contaminate the weld pool, resulting in an
extremely weak weld. So we need to weld titanium in a vacuum to ensure oxygen is not present.
But that creates an issue because most welding techniques use combustion, which needs oxygen
to generate the necessary heat. Electron Beam Welding solves that problem.
This wing box was an engineering masterpiece. An incredibly strong and lightweight piece of
structural engineering. Reducing the weight of the wing box by about 15% in comparison
to an aluminium wing box. And that was only because of this manufacturing technique.
A titanium wing box that used bolted connections would have weighed almost 50% more. With this
solid foundation, the engineers of the F-14 could start piling on the weight. Starting with the
engines. The F-14 needed extremely powerful engines with afterburners to be capable of
reaching Mach 2.3, and to get up to those speeds the plane would need to fly through subsonic,
transonic and supersonic flight regimes, which the plane needed to adapt to with more than just
it's variable wing sweep angle. Jet engines need subsonic air entering their compressors
to function. Once the plane begins approaching supersonic speeds, the engine inlet needs to slow
down the air before it reaches the engine. Grumman wanted to simplify the engine inlets as much as
possible. Their experience with the F-14's predecessor, the F-111, taught them that curved
inlets mounted on the fuselage needed to be avoided. The inlets of the F-14 are a simple box
shape, which allowed the aerodynamicists at Grumman to simplify their analysis to a 2D problem. While
moving away from the fuselage ensured they received as much high quality undisturbed air as possible.
This is a cross section of the F-14's inlet. After an initial fixed ramp set at 3 degrees,
there are three computer controlled compression ramps that vary with Mach number. The flight
computer calculates their optimum position 40 times a second. At subsonic speeds the ramps
remained open. They could even over collapse on take off and landing to allow even more air to
get into the engines during the plane's lowest speed flight regime. However, at about 0.8 Mach
the throat area begins to narrow to slow down the incoming air and continues to decrease the
throat area to about 60% of it's maximum area at Mach 2. Now, this may seem counter intuitive.
At more familiar subsonic speeds you likely know that fluid flow velocity increases through a
narrowing channel like this, but the opposite is true for supersonic flow. These ramps are actually
carefully positioning the shockwaves that are forming in the inlet, and it's these shockwaves
that slow the air down to subsonic speeds. Another panel moves to adjust the height of this slot
that leads to a bleed air door. This duct removes the slow moving boundary layer air that forms on
the compression ramps and exhausts it to the upper surface of the wing. Amazingly, these bleed air
doors also helped future proof the F-14, as the inlet was oversized for the original engines by
about 10%. This bleed door removed some of that additional unnecessary airflow, but when more
advanced engines were installed the duct's opening was narrowed. This decision would prove to be an
incredible foresight for the F-14 as we will see. Finally, the diffuser panel also actuates,
with it's angle increasing with speed. The airflow is subsonic at the exit of the compression ramps,
so this diffuser can cause a larger decrease in fluid velocity through the expanding inlet area.
The final half of the inlet consists of a constant area section where the inlet makes
it's final transition from it's square shape to circular at the engine compressor fan entrance.
To achieve this shape, the engines needed to be spaced far enough apart to avoid any
intersection with the fuselage. However, if you look closely you will notice there is actually
more space than needed between the nacelle and the fuselage. The exact distance they were spaced
was actually determined by the space needed to fit two Phoenix missiles, side by side,
in the tunnel created between the two engine bays. This created a huge amount of area between
the engines that could become a lifting body for the aircraft. Decreasing the work the wings needed
to do, and decreasing the strength needed for the critical wing pivot. While also providing the
additional space needed to house the mechanism that would control the wingsweep angle, but more
on that later. There is some controversy surrounding the F-14. In 1984 Navy Secretary and Naval Flight
Officer John F. Lehman stated that the F-14 was, "...probably the worst airframe engine mismatch
we have had in many years." The engines initially installed into the F-14 were simply not fit for
purpose. The TF-30 was an engine developed for the F-14's predecessor, the F-4D Missileer,
and the F-111. It was the world's first turbofan engine fitted with an afterburner,
which provided the power needed to carry the incredibly heavy F-111. But both of these planes
were bombers, which weren't expected to perform aerobatic stunts like the F-14. This was a problem
because it was extremely susceptible to compressor stall, where certain manoeuvres caused lower
quality air to enter the engine and cause the aerofoils of the compressor to stall. This meant
the compressor stopped pushing air into the combustion chamber and the engine lost power,
sometimes flaming out dramatically. This issue killed many pilots, including the first death
of a female fighter pilot in US military history, Kara Hultgren. As she was approaching the USS
Abraham Lincoln, she realised she was off the landing centreline and attempted to correct by
yawing left. The nose of the F-14 then disrupted airflow into the left engine and caused a
compressor stall. The F-14's engine placement made the situation even more dangerous, as the further
the engine is from the plane's centre, the more authority it has to yaw the plane in an engine out
situation. This increased the yaw even more and resulted in the left wing losing lift. This rolled
the plane over so quickly that Kara could not eject on time. This asymmetric thrust issue could
even put the F-14 into a deadly flat spin, as depicted in the crash that killed Goose in Top Gun.
With accidents rising, the US Navy even had to implement special flat spin training for its
pilots. Thankfully, the F-14 began to be upgraded with the superior F-110 engine in 1984, facilitated
by some of that future proofing of the engine inlet. This engine was developed specifically
for fighter aircraft, and featured inlet guide vanes that helped generate smooth
laminar flow for the compressor and prevent compressor stall. However, the TF-30 continued
to be used. You can easily tell the difference between the F-14's with the older TF-30 engines
and the newer F-110 engines by the engine outlet nozzle, which look entirely different.
The F-110 was superior in every way imaginable. It had 32% higher thrust, which allowed it to take
off from aircraft carriers without the need for afterburners, which decreased fuel consumption
on takeoff considerably. The F-110 engine was so much more fuel efficient that the F-14Bs that
came installed with it could stay in the air for 34% longer, and it was smaller and lighter than
the TF-30. The TF-30 had 16 stages of compression, while the F-110 had just 12, making the engine
shorter by nearly 1.4 meters, which required the afterburning section behind the turbine to be
longer to fit into the F-14 airframe. This is what 20 years of engine development looks like.
Between the two engines were two weapons rails, and when needed the F-14 could be loaded with
up to 6 of the most advanced air to air missiles ever created. This image looks like it's AI
generated. There is just too much going on, but this was an actual configuration the F-14 could
fly. These are 6 Phoenix Missiles. The Phoenix Missile was an extremely advanced air to air
weapon designed specifically for defending the US Navy's fleet from supersonic bombers. However,
it could only work in combination with the F-14's powerful radar. The AWG-9 radar installed into the
F-14 had an output power of 10.2 kilowatts. In comparison, the F-4's radar had less than 10%
of this power at 1 kilowatt, and is twice as powerful as the newer F-15's radar. This power
output allowed the F-14 to identify and lock onto targets further than any other fighter aircraft
in the US military's arsenal. When released, the solid rocket motors of the missile would
accelerate it up to Mach 5 while climbing into the stratosphere. The Rocketdyne Mk-47 motor that
powered the Phoenix Missile had a maximum burn time of 3 minutes, which is all it needed to
reach its target at maximum range. Incredibly, the F-14's radar could not only lock onto a single
target like most radar of the day, it could track 24 individual targets and help guide all 6 of the
F-14's Phoenix Missiles simultaneously in its track and scan mode. However, this did decrease
the missile's chances of success over tracking a single target, especially if the targets were
constantly changing direction and spread wide apart. In this track and scan mode, the radar
would sweep the sky in front of it every 2 seconds. The velocity and position of the detected aircraft
was then logged and the tracking computer would create a virtual target that estimated the
location of the target using the older data until the scan was repeated. In those 2 seconds the
radar could lose track of the target and the Phoenix Missile would be on its own. However,
if it was within 18 kilometres of its target, the Phoenix would have switched over to its own
radar system. Itself an expensive piece of equipment that was about to be disposed of.
It guided the missile towards the target in its final moments, feeding data to the flight
computer, which steered the missile with tail mounted control surfaces. These control surfaces,
mounted behind the missile's wings, lowered drag and offered extremely good manoeuvrability,
allowing the missile to outmanoeuvre any bomber. During testing the Phoenix Missile even made
17G turns successfully. Even the lightest, most agile fighter planes like the F-16 are limited
to 9G manoeuvres. However, the missile was rarely used outside of testing. It was a weapon designed
for a cold war scenario that never developed. Only global superpowers had technologies capable
of targeting the US Navy's fleet at these distances, and thankfully those technologies
were never used. And even though the F-14 was capable of carrying 6 Phoenix Missiles,
it never would in regular operations, as this would put it over the landing weight limit
of its aircraft carrier and force it to jettison a weapon with a 1.3 million dollar price tag.
Landing on an aircraft carrier with a plane this heavy was no easy feat. The F-14's landing hook
had to be strong enough to arrest the plane's landing over an extremely short distance. The
landing hook catches these arresting wires, which slowed down the aircraft with the help of hydraulic
arresting gears below deck, but this did not always go according to plan. In 2002 the arresting hook
broke off on landing. The plane dipped below the deck of an aircraft carrier with full afterburners
on, at which point the pilot and radar intercept officer ejected. An investigation into the
fractured arresting hook found that it had been embrittled by hydrogen after a refurbishment.
The investigation deduced that sodium hydroxide that had been used to strip the aluminium coating
of the arresting hook had generated enough hydrogen to embrittle the underlying steel.
Taking off from the deck of an aircraft carrier is an equally adrenaline pumping experience.
When launching the pilot will hold this switch to kneel the plane, which releases pressure from the
nose landing gear shock strut. This lowers the nose landing gear by 14 inches and releases the
lock on the launch bar, which can then be lowered into position by a member of the deck crew
and connected to the C-shaped shuttle. These shuttles have been powered in a number of ways
over the years. The majority of them are powered by a steam piston system, but the new Gerald R.
Ford class carriers are now equipped with an electromagnetic rail system. These catapults
are incredibly powerful and can accelerate the F-14 up to 290 km per hour or 180 mph in just
2 seconds. The fastest cars in the world can't even come close to that acceleration, with most
struggling to hit 60 mph in 2 seconds. This is obviously a dangerous operation and one of the
reasons the nose gear is compressed, like this, for launch, is to create an automatic nose up
moment when the launch bar is released. When this happens, the stored energy in the strut
pops the nose of the plane up and helps it to clear the deck safely. At this point in flight,
the F-14's iconic swing wings are in the front most position, helping the plane generate as
much lift on takeoff as possible. The wing sweep angle could be varied in flight from 20 degrees,
used during takeoff and landings, to a maximum of 68 degrees, which was reached at 0.9 mach.
There was however a special setting of 78 degrees, which overlapped the wings and allowed the F-14
to be stowed more compactly on the aircraft carrier. The sweep angle was controlled automatically by
the flight computer to optimise the plane's lift to drag ratio. This was particularly helpful in a
dogfight where a pilot has enough to think about without considering the physics of transonic airflow,
because wing sweep is designed to manage how supersonic airflow interacts with the wing.
This is how it works. Take a straight wing for a small Cessna. Airflow over a wing perpendicular
to the free stream air has one component, the chord wise flow, which is air that flows over
the chord of the aerofoil. The chord is the imaginary line running from the leading edge
to the trailing edge of an aerofoil. Chord wise flow is how the wing generates lift and it does
this by accelerating the air travelling over the aerofoil. However, because the air accelerates,
it can hit supersonic speeds before the plane does. Different wings can accelerate this flow
at different rates. The speed at which the flow over the wing achieves supersonic speed
is called the critical Mach number, and generally we want to make that number as high as possible
to achieve a better lift to drag ratio. The variable sweep wing allows this.
Let's look at the airflow components over the F-14's wing at it's lowest sweep angle,
20 degrees. Here we can separate the airflow into two components. The chord wise flow,
which is now offset by a 20 degree angle relative to the free stream, and the second component,
the span wise flow, which flows along the length of the wing and does not accelerate,
and thus does not lower the critical Mach number. At lower speeds, where supersonic airflow is not
a worry, you want as much of that airflow to be chord wise. We need that lift. This is especially
true for a plane like the F-14. It's heavy and needs to land on extremely short runways in the
middle of the ocean. The slower it can fly and approach the better. However, as the speed of
plane begins to climb, we are generating more than enough lift, thanks to the increased airspeed,
and thus can afford to convert some of that airflow into span wise flow.
We do this by increasing the sweep angle. Once at supersonic speed, the primary concern is no
longer critical Mach number, but with preventing the supersonic cone emanating from the nose of
the aircraft from intersecting with the wings and lowering the lift to drag ratio. So, in theory,
adding a swing wing has a lot of benefits, but it is rarely implemented due to the complexity
and weight of the systems needed to make it happen. It needs a heavy duty pivot,
capable of transferring the force of lift to the wing box. One way this can be simplified
is by reducing the burden of lift on the wing. The total wing area was 52.5 square meters,
but with the lifting body of the plane, the total lifting area was 93 square meters.
This reduced the bending load on the pivot significantly.
The control surfaces of the F-14 break from tradition in some ways. There are no ailerons
to control the plane's roll. Instead, roll is controlled by these spoilers at lower speeds,
but were locked when the swing wing reached an angle of 57 degrees at higher speeds,
at which point the plane's roll was entirely controlled by the plane's horizontal tail,
dubbed the taileron. This taileron used another wonder material of the era,
boron fibre composites. Today, carbon fibre composites would be used, but during the
development of the F-14 this new age material had not yet reached maturity. Boron fibre is
produced by passing boron trichloride and hydrogen over a heated tungsten wire. So,
technically they are boron coated tungsten fibres, and they have excellent tensile strength.
Rivaling the highest quality carbon fibres, but are vastly more expensive.
Boron fibre with epoxy resin composites were used in the taileron to reduce weight.
The edges of the taileron were constructed from aluminium,
since they would experience more wear and tear.
There were more problems that the swing wing created that the engineers needed to find
solutions for. When the wings were retracted, a large portion of the trailing edge sat above
the rear fuselage. To achieve a continuous contour behind the wing and the fuselage,
without any un-aerodynamic gaps, an inflatable canvas bag was installed here.
It was inflated with engine bleed air when needed.
Another problem the F-14 faced was it's centre of lift shifting backwards at supersonic speeds.
This would cause the nose to dip downwards and require the plane to actuate the horizontal
stabiliser to counteract it. This is something that affects all supersonic planes, but it was
made even worse by the fact the entire wing actually shifted backwards as the plane gained
speed. To avoid the drag needed to counteract this motion, the engineers of the F-14 fitted
it with two extendable vanes on the leading edge of the wing glove. These were extended
automatically by the flight computer. As the plane accelerated, the vanes would extend
outwards and generate more lift ahead of the plane's centre of gravity, counteracting
the rearward movement of lift on the main wing. This lift forward of the centre of gravity
also helped the plane to perform 7.5g turns at Mach 2. An incredible amount of aerodynamic
pressure that really drives home how incredible that titanium wing box was.
However, in practice the vanes were rarely needed. While the F-14 was designed to fly
up to Mach 2.4, the World War 3 scenario that would require it to never came to pass.
The added weight and maintenance associated with these vanes were deemed unnecessary,
so crews frequently removed the actuators and welded the vane doors shut. In later versions
of the F-14, the mechanism was simply removed in the design completely. Requiring 30 to 60 hours
of maintenance for every hour flown, the F-14 was ultimately retired in 2006 after 32 years
of service. With the collapse of the Soviet Union and the advancement of interconnected
stealth multi-role fighters like the F-35, the US Navy simply could not justify the price of this
specialty aircraft. But, it's precisely the specialty that makes it a wonder of engineering.
If you enjoy watching high quality aviation documentaries like this,
I have some recommendations for you for other creators. Paper Skies makes wonderful aviation
history videos, focusing largely on Soviet era aviation that I rarely talk about.
Neo made this documentary on the crash investigation of MH-17 and Mustard created
one of the best animated aviation documentaries I've ever seen on the B-2 Spirit called Tip of
the Spear. Maybe you like the business and logistics side of aviation, in which case you
could watch this 45 minute documentary about the opening of an airport on the remote island of
St Helene by Wendover Productions. All of these creators are Nebula creators,
and all of the documentaries that I mentioned are exclusive to Nebula.
Before I go into an entire spiel about how great Nebula is, I know many of you are sick of signing
up for yet another subscription service. So, if you simply want to support our channel and get
lifelong access to all of Nebula's exclusive programming, we are offering lifetime memberships
for a limited time for $300. Unlike other subscriptions, you can buy once and never pay
again. For the holiday period we are also offering gift cards for you to gift family members and
friends, and if you want to give them a trial of Nebula before doing so, all Nebula members
now have guest passes to give out that don't require credit card details to use. On Nebula
you can watch our five part Battle of Britain series, where we recreated the central command
of the Battle of Britain to show in intricate detail how Britain won their most impactful
victory of World War 2. We show you how incoming raids were plotted on the huge central map with
colour coded tiles, and how the commander kept track of what squadrons were available
using a light up board mounted on the walls. We spent over a month recreating this room using
archived footage and photos. An investment of time for a single animation asset that we simply can't
afford on YouTube. For less than the price of a cup of coffee every month, you can get access to
all of Nebula's originals, along with their entire catalogue without any ads. You can also easily
download videos to watch on the go, all for just $3 a month. This channel depends on the funding
Nebula provides us. If you have been subscribed to this channel for more than three years,
you have seen the huge increases in production quality that Nebula has facilitated.
Growing from 2D animations that myself and my team mate Mike thought ourselves how to do,
to having a full team of incredibly talented 3D artists that rival any TV production.
This is expensive work and we would love to grow our team even more. Something we can only do with
your support, as YouTube ad revenue simply does not cover the bills. Last year we actually made
a financial loss for three months in a row. YouTube is simply a volatile platform where
we depend on the whims of advertisers. Nebula is our life raft in a volatile sea of social media.
This is a common theme across YouTube creators. Nebula's goal is to enable and level up our entire
roster of creators. That's why I and other creators started Nebula. To remove the financial uncertainty
that forces us to rush projects. To remove the algorithms that force us to analyse data points,
instead of what really matters, the audience on the other side of the screen.
So, if you want to check out all of the fascinating exclusive content on Nebula,
go to nebula.tv forward slash real engineering or click the link in the description to get 40%
off our yearly subscription today for the incredibly low price of $3 a month for the whole year.
