Is the Australian Economy Doomed?

Global Finance News
11 followers
Apr 15, 2025 #finance #financenews
#finance
#financenews
Australia is an exemplary success story—prosperous, secure, and filled with opportunities. However, a closer examination reveals a fragile framework dependent on unsustainable sectors, skyrocketing housing prices, and increasing inequality across generations. In this video, we delve into the true narrative of Australia’s economic success, the precarious dependencies it maintains, and why tackling these issues could prove quite challenging. Is Australia genuinely thriving, or simply skilled at masking its shortcomings?
Australia is, in theory, one of the richest countries in the world.
Our people enjoy an incredibly high standard of living,
world-leading individual wealth metrics, a relatively enviable work-life balance,
and good access to amenities like education and healthcare.
It's achieved all this while maintaining surprisingly good wealth equality that
rivals places like Japan that have serious checks and balances on wealth accumulation,
and Iceland that has like three people to spread that wealth around between.
Now, that all sounds great, but of course, Australia has its problems.
We are heavily dependent on all the wrong industries.
Industries that have time and time again crippled other economies around the world,
and we're also heavily dependent on all the wrong partners.
We are simultaneously one of, if not the closest modern ally to the USA,
while also being almost entirely reliant on resource exports to China.
That is a strange position to be in at the best of times, but as global events unfold,
Australia is highly exposed to feel pressure from both of these increasingly erratic global powers.
Now, that may be bad enough by itself, but the bigger fear is that these external
pressures will make it harder to keep a lid on a lot of the internal problems
that have been slowly growing under the surface.
Just because we have managed to hide our vulnerabilities thus far,
doesn't mean that they are not there.
And in the case of things like Australia's infamous housing market,
the very fact that we've kept it going for as long as we have is probably making the problem worse.
However, beyond all of this, it's also important to recognise the country's strengths.
Yes, our most popular national exports might be unimproved natural resources,
sketchy university degrees, and YouTube videos about how our country is impossible to live in,
but you know what? At least we still have a trade surplus and one of the largest in the world at
that. So, how has Australia been going? How serious and extensive are these current challenges?
And finally, can they be reasonably addressed without doing more harm than good?
Alright, quick detour from economic doom and gloom.
As I'm speaking, I'm actually travelling through Northern Europe,
currently in Norway, which is just as gorgeous as you'd imagine, hello to any Norwegian viewers.
And honestly, one of the few things I didn't have to overthink before this trip,
staying connected.
I've been using Saly, and it's made things ridiculously easy.
Saly is an eSIM app that gives you mobile data in over 190 countries.
No swapping tiny plastic SIM cards, no filling out forms at some airport kiosk after a red-eye
flight. I installed the app once before I left, picked the plan I needed, and that was it.
Even as I cross borders and bounce between cities, it just works.
And honestly, it's one of those things that you don't realise how useful it is until you're
abroad, checking train times, navigating with Google Maps, trying to find dinner,
and not hunting for dodgy airport wifi or overpriced SIM cards.
I grabbed a regional data plan since I was visiting a few countries,
and it saved me both money and effort.
And if you're a bit of a privacy nerd like I am, Saly's also got inbuilt security features,
you can block malicious ads, spoof your virtual location,
and keep your connection more private while you travel.
So, whether you've got an actual trip coming up and want to stay connected wherever you are,
download the Saly app with the QR code on screen,
and use the code ECONOMICS to get 15% off any data plan.
Thanks again to Saly for sponsoring this video.
So just like there are plenty of individuals that have become rich by being lucky in
unsustainable ways, it's easy to argue that Australia is in the same position.
Obviously, natural resource wealth is a bit like winning the lottery.
It is a fantastic opportunity, but a lot of winners end up squandering this money
only to end up worse off in the long run than had they never had this easy wealth in the first place.
Just like winning a regular lottery, natural resource wealth can make it so that doing
anything else isn't really worth it because it's easier and way more instantly rewarding
to just use the winnings.
Now, Australia was not completely immune from this trap.
Our goods exports are some of the least diverse in the world,
and are primarily comprised of natural resources that we don't even bother to refine,
and agricultural products.
This is a problem because it means a huge component of our economy
is at the mercy of global natural resource prices and trade
agreements which are currently being called into question.
Fortunately, our direct trade with the USA is quite minimal,
and we actually import much more from the country than we export to it,
but even still, a general global shift towards increased trade
protections would not be a good thing for Australia.
To make matters worse, our second largest goods export is coal,
which is seeing stagnant consumption, partially due to its terrible environmental impacts,
but largely simply because more competitive alternatives are becoming viable.
Another common side effect of an over-reliance on natural resources
is that it can breed corruption because it creates such an easy treasure trove to pilfer from.
Now, not to spoil too much just yet, but Australia's highly robust institutions
have been one of the key reasons why the country has remained so prosperous for so long,
despite making so many classic mistakes.
But even then, they are not beyond criticism.
We have largely failed to tax our resources effectively in a way that
would redistribute natural resource wealth into general prosperity.
Rather embarrassingly, we have tried, but the lobbying power of natural resource
companies won out against planned proposals to change rents on natural resource extraction.
If that wasn't enough of a kick in the donger,
in certain industries we have started paying companies to take resources from us.
In this year alone, the government has provided
nearly $15 billion in subsidies and tax breaks to the natural gas industry.
Now, this could be justified if it was used to lower local energy costs,
but that hasn't happened, and we've actually ended up
buying a lot of our own gas back from international suppliers.
It's a little bit silly.
So yeah, Australia has failed to do something that even Venezuela figured out relatively quickly.
Then, of course, there is the issue of housing.
Australian real estate is unbelievably expensive in our handful of major cities.
There are a few reasons why it got so bad, and unfortunately,
not much has been done to reverse it.
For starters, we have a highly multicultural society that has been both open to lots of
immigration and very attractive to immigration from everywhere around the world.
Now, a lot of that immigration has come in the form of people who are drawn to
the relatively high salaries and living conditions offered in Australia,
and they, of course, need a place to live.
But a lot of immigration is also already very wealthy people from
countries with similarly high incomes that are moving here because it has
some of the most livable cities in the world.
Of course, assuming that the person doing the living is already relatively wealthy.
In an effort to tamp down on this source of demand for housing,
the government has imposed a ban on foreign home purchases for the next two years,
which sounds like a reasonable policy.
However, these purchases only represent a tiny fraction of all sales,
and it doesn't include purchases made by people on residency visas,
which is where most of this demand is coming from,
with elevated levels of immigration to the country.
Another similar problem actually comes from a surprising strength that adds
some much-needed context to our resource dependence.
Our goods exports are pretty abysmal, but when services are included,
we generally do a lot better.
Now, service exports don't get as much attention because it's a lot harder to
visualize than goods being loaded onto ships and floated across to another country,
but about a third of all of our exports are actually these intangible sales.
The big one is tourism.
When people come to Australia and spend money here,
that technically gets counted as an export by economists because money is
flowing from foreign countries into Australia just like it would for any other export.
Even something like this YouTube video that you're watching right now
counts as a service export.
I, an Australian, made this video when Buy Little Business here in Australia
will receive payment from Google, a US-based company, as well as the US-based sponsor.
Now, fortunately, we can't build an economy on YouTubers,
but we have tried to build one on students.
Back to the housing market.
That ban on foreign buyers doesn't exclude people that are simply here
to get a degree on a student visa.
Now, maybe that is reasonable.
People that are living in the country, even temporarily,
perhaps should have the right to buy the place where they live.
Perhaps not.
I'm sure there'll be a spirited discussion about that in the comments section.
But either way, this has encouraged a lot of students to come here,
not with the intention of really getting a degree,
but more as a way to either get access to the real estate market
or a job market through an easily accessible visa program.
Now, to be fair, the government has significantly cracked down on so-called diploma mills,
which were essentially completely fake universities set up only to let people get a student visa.
But even some of our largest educational institutions are dependent on this cash inflow,
and it ultimately means that things like the big talk about a foreign investor ban
are a minor inconvenience rather than a hard policy fix.
So yes, Australian real estate is a highly desirable global asset class.
But to add napalm to the fire, our tax policies heavily, heavily,
heavily incentivize property investment.
Now, we've addressed the exact mechanism of negative gearing
and capital gains tax incentives in our last video on Australia.
So as always, we don't want to repeat too much here.
But the current tax structure is to the point where for certain high-income earners,
it's considered irresponsible to not have at least one or two investment properties.
This has not only encouraged property investment,
it's also encouraged property investment using lots of debt.
Australia currently has the second highest levels of household debt in the world,
falling only behind Switzerland, which is a bit of an outlier due to their unique banking systems.
So yeah, while government debt for Australia looks great compared to most global economies,
debt owed by Australian individuals is at pretty alarming levels.
And unfortunately for most Australians, it isn't because of some advanced financial strategy.
It's just a necessity to get a home.
Even for regular Australians, the push to buy a home is extreme because it's
very hard to manage personal finances effectively while renting.
Rents have increased alongside property prices.
So they've generally gotten more and more expensive every year,
whereas having a mortgage and paying off a home is slightly more predictable,
even with interest rate changes.
There is also, of course,
the added benefit of the fact that eventually a mortgage will be paid off,
whereas paying rent is endless.
Beyond this, laws protecting renters in Australia are quite weak,
and laws protecting homeowners are very strong.
So strangely, people who can't pay their mortgage because of something like financial hardship
are much less likely to lose their home than someone who can't pay their rent.
Additionally, housing in Australia is so expensive
that it's just become almost an essential component in retirement planning.
Without a paid-off house, people would need an immense retirement income to
afford both regular living expenses plus ever-increasing housing costs.
Unfortunately, from the demand side of real estate,
most government initiatives to address the housing crisis have revolved around
making it easier for people to buy their first home with grants,
tax exemptions, and financial assistance,
rather than just making housing cheaper in the first place.
Policies that just give every new homebuyer an extra $100,000 in purchasing power
usually only work to drive the prices of homes up by an extra $100,000.
Now, we will actually address that particular issue later because,
well, that might be exactly the intention.
The final thing on the demand side that needs a bit of nuance is incomes.
Incomes for regular Australians are amongst some of the best in the world.
We have very high minimum wage laws,
and while some businesses try and skirt around them, they're generally well-enforced.
However, at the extreme high end that generally drives big asset bubbles,
incomes are not as competitive as in places like Silicon Valley,
New York, London, or even Hong Kong.
That means that there's not the same inflow of people moving to a city like Sydney
to land a six-figure job where it doesn't matter how much they pay in rent,
the demand is coming from somewhere else.
Anyway, tax policies, immigration, personal desperation, and generous incentives
all work together to add a lot of demand to a market that has struggled to provide adequate
supply and arguably it's the supply side that's actually been the bigger problem.
Yes, Australia has a lot of land per capita, but not a lot of major cities.
Housing in most areas is actually really cheap,
but the housing where most people want to live is amongst the most expensive in the world.
Within these cities, urban sprawl has done its thing,
and all of the familiar problems of zoning laws restricting
adequate housing are present and accounted for.
The incentives to change this have always been a bit difficult.
Australia still has a relatively high homeownership rate,
and since people consider their homes such an integral part of their personal finances,
they really don't want it to lose value, even if they have no intention of selling.
There is generally politically popular support for affordable housing,
as long as it's not their homes that are becoming affordable.
Australia is also a federation made up of individual states,
similar to the USA, Canada and Germany for example.
However, those states are each highly reliant on their
housing market to provide funding to their individual budgets.
Every time a house is purchased in Australia, there is a fee, called stamp duty,
paid by the buyer that can be as much as 6.5% of the total purchase price.
This money goes to the respective state government where the house is sold,
and was originally meant to just cover the expense of changing or
stamping new land ownership records.
But obviously as houses get more expensive,
the more money can be made from these fees, and now it's a huge part of the budget.
This also disincentivises existing homeowners from ever selling their properties because
even though this fee is paid by the buyer,
someone who sells their home is probably going to end up buying a new one eventually,
taking a significant financial hit in the process.
This has resulted in a lot of people who could downsize and put a larger
family-friendly home onto the market just choosing to hold onto it, further limiting supply.
Finally, building in Australia is very expensive.
Construction is a labour-intensive process, and again, Australia has a very high income floor.
Skilled tradesmen are also highly coveted because many of them are drawn to the extremely
high salaries they can earn in remote mines extracting natural resources.
So, indirectly, people that want to build a new home are
competing with multi-billion dollar mining companies.
So yeah, most individuals don't want to fix housing, state governments don't want to cut
off their revenue source, and the federal government doesn't want to seize up one
of the country's largest employers.
Now, none of these factors are unique to just Australia,
but it really has a potent mix of them that has made life for the average Australian quite difficult.
However, it's important to address these issues in context,
because part of the reason this problem is so bad is because Australia has so much going for it.
The first is wealth equality, which is arguably the defining issue of the modern global economy.
Australia does not have outstanding income equality.
After accounting for taxes and social programs,
we're about middle of the road and significantly behind Canada,
which is arguably our most comparable peer.
However, by wealth equality, we do extremely well,
only really falling behind places like Slovenia, Slovakia, Iceland, and Belgium,
which have far more social taxation and welfare policies,
and also it must be recognised smaller populations.
We also fall behind Japan, which actually has high levels of income inequality,
but they more than make up for this with some of the highest levels of inheritance taxes in
the world, which makes it much harder for generational wealth to stockpile.
So what is going on here?
Australia doesn't have inheritance taxes, and all other things being equal,
higher levels of income inequality should lead to higher levels of wealth inequality.
If some people earn a lot more than other people,
they can save and invest more than them too, which compounds over time.
But in Australia, that hasn't really happened,
at least not to the same degree as other comparable economies.
And the question is, why?
Well, big disclaimer time.
Wealth is much harder to measure than income,
because all the data needed to calculate income inequality is collected to process income taxes.
Whereas the true value of illiquid assets like cars,
home furnishings, and even houses can be a bit harder to put an exact figure on.
And yes, Australia still has a lot of extremely rich people,
but generally we are a more even playing field,
partially because just owning a home means that a good chunk of Australians
have a lot of wealth tied up where they live,
This helps to pull up the base so to speak.
Now having a lot of money in home equity doesn't necessarily matter if
every other home in the country is equally as unaffordable.
In the words of syndrome, when everyone's super, nobody is.
These headline figures also mask over a different type of inequality
that could actually be more damaging.
A lot of these systems to build up a broad base of wealth have come at the expense of young people.
A study found that through various systems, a working-age Australian making $100,000 AUD,
the equivalent of around $63,000 USD,
pays two and a half times more tax than the average Australian aged 65 or older,
who earns the same amount.
That, combined with the fact that older Australians have had more time to get
into the housing market before it got as unaffordable as it is today,
has understandably caused some intergenerational animosity.
Now the good news is that despite the general doom and gloom,
Australia actually has a lot of tools it could use to address the issue.
The real question is, why hasn't it?
Well, the country is currently on the verge of a major election,
and both sides are promising to have the solution to problems they
secretly probably don't want to fix.
But that's something that we have addressed in detail in our new video
on our geopolitics-focused channel, Context Matters.
You should be able to click to that one on your screen now.
Thanks for watching mate, bye.
