Oil prices are surging. Inflation is rising. Interest rates are climbing.
And now… recession risk is no longer a theory — it’s becoming reality.
In this breakdown, we unpack: → The global conflict driving market chaos → Why the RBA may have made a critical mistake → How rising energy and food costs will hit Australians → Why recession risk has jumped dramatically → What this means for YOUR money, property, and future
This isn’t media spin. This is what’s actually happening.
Watch until the end — because what comes next could reshape Australia’s economy for years.
00:00 – Markets Drop Fast: What Just Happened 00:24 – War Escalation Changes Everything 01:30 – Inflation Is No Longer “Temporary” 02:00 – RBA’s Shock Interest Rate Decision 03:00 – “They Don’t Know What They’re Doing” 04:00 – Broken Economic System Exposed 05:00 – Cost of Living Crisis Is About to Explode 06:00 – Recession Risk Just DOUBLED 07:00 – Middle Class Taking the Hit 08:00 – Australia’s Energy Failure Explained 09:00 – Politicians Missing in Action 10:00 – Budget Chaos Incoming 11:00 – Why This Could Get Much Worse 12:00 – Banks About to Tighten Lending 13:00 – Food Prices & Farming Crisis 14:00 – Market Decline & What Investors Should Do 15:00 – Property Market Warning Signs 17:00 – “We Haven’t Seen This Since The 90s” 18:30 – Credit Crunch Incoming 19:20 – Final Warning: Risks Are Rising Fast
AI Generated·May contain errors
Well, good morning, everyone. We're recording this on Thursday morning.
John, it's very easy to summarize the market. We are down 140 points at the moment,
and it's basically a story of oil is up and everything else is down. How do you see it, John?
Well, the market's reflecting an escalation overnight of an attack on the Iranian gas
resource and production. It's a serious escalation. I think markets were okay until it happened,
and now we're in turmoil. I think the risk is now what could have been a one-month
wall with some sort of ceasefire agreement that's been pushed back substantially. And
we're now dealing with a risk of this event going on further than it should be.
The Israel government will have to justify what they've done. It appears it's with American
support. Let's see what the justification is, because I think it has created an issue with
Qatar. It has ramifications for Turkey, and it broadens this conflict. Now, maybe it was always
going to be broadened. Maybe we were kidding ourselves. I don't know. But this has certainly
brought the broadening issue at the forefront. Markets are reacting. Inflation issues are now
front of mind. We can no longer say inflation is a short-term issue. It's going to be more prolonged.
Supply issues become an issue, particularly for Australia. And the adjustment of interest rates
has to be thought about, about whether we're trying to support inflation or beat inflation,
or whether it's a ridiculous argument. John, on Tuesday, the RBA increased rates to 4.1.
But interestingly, the decision was split down the middle, virtually 5 to 4. And the market took a
lot of solace from that, in the sense that it means that the RBA weren't united in increasing
rates. But since then, the price of oil, as we were talking about, has gone from 100 to 110,
and perhaps it's going to go higher. Jim Chalmers talking about inflation peaking around the 5%
level. Where does the RBA go from here? Well, I don't know where they've gone. If the RBA was
meeting today rather than Tuesday, quite obviously they probably wouldn't be putting up interest
rates. And I said last week, this meeting should be delayed until more information and more facts
come to play. The Federal Reserve last night said exactly what I said. They're waiting and seeing.
They didn't cut interest rates last night. They didn't put them up. They just said,
we need to wait and see. And they gave the speculative ambit issues between what could
happen short term, what could happen long term, where oil could go to, where it might go to on
the downside. Essentially, they said they don't know. If you don't know, don't do anything.
The RBA of Australia, who's in exactly the same position, it doesn't know, did something. And I
think they now regret having done it. I don't know why we had to have a meeting this week,
why it couldn't be put back a few weeks, why we couldn't meet in April. This sort of dogmatic
approach to monetary policy has got to stop. The next day, the Treasury of Australia started
doing mathematical calculations on what-if scenarios, including a 5% inflation rate.
Now, I can't believe Treasury and the RBA don't have the same models.
This nonsense that we have two entities running economic policy of Australia,
supposedly for the benefit of Australia, and they don't actually share their models is beyond
belief. I just wonder why Treasury didn't put out their model before the RBA meeting.
And my final point is, as you say, it was a 5-4 vote. So it was virtually a split. And it appears
to me that maybe it was a split and the RBA governor voted for it. Who knows? We don't get
the votes. The Federal Reserve releases their votes straight away and who voted what. And we
don't know. There's a commercial element on the RBA board and there's a bureaucratic element on
the RBA board. Now, you wouldn't have to be drawing too long a bow to say the bureaucracy
voted for an interest rate increase because they failed Economics 101. And the commercial
side of the RBA board said, no, let's wait. There's things happening in the real world.
We need to wait. Now, I don't want to keep on going with final points, but in the papers this
morning, we've already got major retail managing directors and CEOs saying that consumer sentiment
has plummeted. Yeah, it's not surprising, John. I mean, it's not just oil that's going up.
Australia imports 85% of its fertilizer from the Middle East and urea from Saudi Arabia, Qatar,
UAE. And this is going to affect food prices and the pressure mounting on households,
not just on interest rates going up, but on food costs.
What are the chances that Australia spins into a recession six months down the track?
Well, I think it's now even money because it's really going to be determined by how long this
war goes on for. And as I said in recent weeks, I was working on the view that it would be about
a month before we had a ceasefire. After last night, the chances of a ceasefire in the next
week or so are zero. Diplomacy, which I hate anyway, but at some point diplomacy has to come
into play. And in my view, America and Israel had their foot on Iran and what they've done last
night is kick it. I don't understand that. I really don't understand that. Obviously,
they should have been working to a process to control what was going on in that war zone
rather than escalate it. The European Union would like to come in on a diplomatic
side and start trying to negotiate some sort of ceasefire. That's gone out the window.
So we're in for a longer period than it should have been before we get to a ceasefire position
if we can get there. That's what we're looking at now. So it really has escalated things.
If interest rates and more so inflation, I mean, the interest rate decision of quarter percent was
bizarre. And as one commentator said this morning, we've virtually had half a percent interest rate
increase plus another quarter percent increase through petrol. So we've whacked up interest
rates and the cost of living by 0.75 for those, particularly for those who are borrowed,
which is young households. You know, the guys who are working, trying to bring up a family
and paying tax so part of the population can stay at home and retire. You know, we've got
completely destabilised the economy and it hasn't happened overnight. It's happened over 30 years,
as I said last week. It's been building up. We now don't supply ourselves with enough energy,
even though we export to the world. We don't make enough money out of energy,
even though we export it to the world. We've completely sold off our energy exports,
85 percent owned by foreigners. We have a quarter of a trillion dollar wealth fund or whatever it
is, National Wealth Fund. We've just had a change of deck chairs yesterday, management walking out
and all that. What's it investing in? Should it be investing in refineries? Should it be
investing in building infrastructure for electricity, you know, as opposed to
through hedge funds, the world stock markets? I mean, it's bizarre. And meanwhile, the taxpayer,
the guy I just talked about, who's paying extra for his mortgage, is paying tax so the government
pays pensions on defined benefits to people who retired 20 years ago. Honestly, it is so bad what
we're doing here in this country. It needs to be fixed. And I listen to politicians every morning
and I go, these guys have inherited the mess from ex-politicians who created the mess.
And all we're doing is passing the problem to a generation of politicians
who can rightly say it's not our fault. But we can say, but you're part of a party who,
you know, Labour and Liberal who have been passing the baton back over the last 30 years.
And not one of you have thought about the consequences of a Middle East war
and why Australia should be self-sufficient in energy.
So it's extraordinary how missing in action the political class has been on both sides of the
aisle in terms of building up Australia's resilience. We're very dependent on East Asian
trade. We've got these two refineries. We're dependent on oil imports, on fertilizer imports
and so on. John, what happens on May the 12th when the Treasurer brings down the budget? It
doesn't seem the right time to be introducing, you know, tax changes to CGT or whatever he's got
planned. Well, he's got no choice because the Prime Minister I think is making a speech today
saying the tax system is out of date. Well, come in Spinner, it's been out of date for decades.
So it's not only today, it's been out of date. Now, you're right, it's going to be a chaotic,
it could be a very chaotic period to make changes to the taxation regime. And always the excuse is
it's not a good time. It's not a good time now. There's never going to be a good time.
You know, hard decisions have to be made. But I can tell you the writing of the budget speech
will probably have to wait to a minute before he goes on TV because where we're sitting with the
world today, who knows what's going to happen tomorrow? What's going to happen in the next few
hours? It's become a more serious problem. It was a serious issue anyway, but it's become more serious
in the last 24 hours. And I just think our listeners have to be aware of that and our
clients. I mean, we have now moved into a higher risk of a recession in Australia, significantly
higher risk of elevated inflation for a significant period of time. Our Reserve Bank, who I think is
lost in space, a governance of the economy in economic policy where we have Treasury and the
Reserve Bank and the business sector not joining together and coming up with a proper solution to
deal with the problems we have today. And then an over governance of the taxation policy where we
know it's crook. But you know, how do we fix it? You know, and these things just build up and it
takes a bad moment like now. It's always, you know, change happens when there is a calamity.
It's easier to make change happen. So I would go the other way, Paul, and say, look, a calamity,
if we have one, is probably the best time to make changes because people will be desperate for
change. Yeah, they say that a politician should never waste a crisis and use it to make necessary
changes. I just want to drill down. You're saying that a recession is now becoming a probability
as opposed to kind of a small percentage risk. That's a big call. I don't want to sound like
an economist saying it's a 50-50 chance, but it's more if it was a one in four chance a couple of
weeks ago, it's now 50-50. The odds are moving for a downturn driven by consumer activity.
And the bigger risk which we've got to watch is the cost of debt to business, the cost of funding
where the banks all of a sudden start reviewing, as they will do, as they should do in any credit
analysis, start looking at the macro environment, start seeing inflation rising, the cost of doing
business rising, the cost of energy rising, cost of petrol rising, cost of moving goods rising,
and the risk of labour rate increases rising if we get, you know, a bit of madness coming in the
three or four months of the fair work and the government not coming in with very focused tax
cuts to push away wage increases. It'd be quite right for the banks to start saying, no,
we're not doing fixed rate lending, which is too uncertain. We want to have stronger credit,
want better security. We're not going to increase our cash flow ratios against debt servicing.
That's what happens when you get a downturn like this, and that in itself causes
a deeper economic chasm than it needs to be. So I'm trying to predict what might happen,
being reflected what is going on in the real world. And I don't see at this point in time
why things won't tighten up credit naturally from the banking system and demand will tighten up
independent of that interest rate increase because the cost of living is going through the roof.
And then it hits, I mean, I'll give you another number this morning, which I heard,
farmers planting wheat, the next crop based on current costs. If they put a crop in the ground
now, it's about twice the cost than it was a year ago. Now there might be some exaggeration in that,
but there's a serious cost increase in just planting our base commodities, which become
servicing Australia's food needs and also export. So we have a problem and we can't duck and weave
and the risk is higher than it was for a recession. John, year to date, the market is
down about 2% and we're off about 6 to 8% from our peak. The reporting season that we had was
actually relatively good, but we've lost all the gains made through that. I know that internally
we've been kind of selling two stocks for every one stock that we buy. Is that how people should
be responding or just say, you know, the next six months might be pretty volatile and pretty scary,
but if you stay in there, you know, in a year's time, we'll be ahead. And that's what history
tells us. Well, put it this way, you know, equities are perpetual. So the market goes
up and down. So I don't want people who are long-term investors, ride it. You have to ride it.
I think prices are on the way down. Who knows where they'll bottom. It'll depend on the macro
events, which we're watching weekly and reporting back to you. Then you look at the other side of
it, something like petrol or oil, you know, in the marketplace, not in the ground, but in the
marketplace is finite. And what happens is when the price goes up for petrol, people want to buy
more because they're worried about running out. When stock prices fall, unless you've sold at a
higher price and raised capital to buy it back, you're forced to ride. Now what I've, and what
Climb Capital has been doing in the last month as the prices rised, we don't invest in the rear
window. And what the February results were, was looking back and for a period of time in February,
it was quite right to project that that growth momentum in profitability and consumer behavior
was steady to up, and you could project. Now that's dramatically changed with the war. And
again, it's dramatically changed overnight. So now what we learned in February can be dismissed.
And I think we're seeing reports now of consumer activity declining, consumer confidence declining.
And I think our next thing will be the banks, as they always do, will start restricting credit.
And that's a jolt to the economy, because this economy, you can see it through the property
market has been very much driven by credit and debt. I've been saying for so many years,
you take credit away from the property market, and it would be nowhere near where it's priced
at today. Now the other factor is the cost of that credit. If the cost of that credit goes up,
the property market declines. We could get a double whammy here where the
supply credit and the cost of credit changes, and that'll put a serious impact on the residential
property market, and you get a second whammy to confidence of the consumer, those who are geared.
Even the people who are ungeared all of a sudden see that their second pillar of their retirement,
their property asset, is in decline. It might be flatlining before it declines. And all of a
sudden, it's just their consumer activity, consumption. So you can see, I don't want to get
desperately negative, but as an economist, I can... Because we haven't seen this, Paul,
since the 1990s. We haven't seen this since Paul Keating. And we've got a whole lot of people in
the economy managing money, giving financial advice, waxing lyrical about what can happen.
I don't want to be just an old guy in the corner. I came in in the 80s in the recession,
and that was an oil recession. Lived through a property boom and collapse in the early 90s,
and we haven't... Extreme speculation, 2000, GFC, excessive lending to the property market in
America, poor credit controls, massive printing of money, COVID, IT developments, the artificial
intelligence as we had recently, and now we've got a war. I mean, honestly, I'm trying to draw
a bit of experience here. No hair, gray hair. And I just have to say, look, we have to go way
back in the history, in living history, to see what could happen. Now, the credit crunch I'm
talking about is not induced by the Reserve Bank moving up interest rates. It's the broader market
becoming concerned about lending to entities, people or businesses who will see a tightening
either in their living standards, their free cash flow, or the cost of doing business and
their operating margins. I think every bank economist would be sending a memo to their
credit departments, look, we're changing our views on the economy, slow down, cost of business going
up. Please adjust your credit analysis. Yeah. John, I think we will have to leave
there. It's quite clear what your message is, which is that the risks have ratcheted up quite
dramatically. And now it's not the time to jump on the moving train, wait for the dust to settle,
wait for the market to accommodate these increased risks. And then we'll pick the
eyes out of those stocks that appeal. Look, and I also don't want to, you know,
people should be aware, we do this view Wednesday, Thursday, Friday. If something
happens dramatically, we will have another podcast. And it just so happens that what's
happened overnight has corresponded to our podcast today. But if things dramatically change, good or
bad, we'll do another podcast quickly. So people, we're not like the Reserve Bank who meets on a
Tuesday in March and May. We are flexible and we'll respond to what happens. Yeah. Can I also
just say that on CLIMB's website, frequently put out quick bites, which are short analyses of
something that's interesting in the market, whether it's the price of oil or, you know,
how much fertilizer we have to import. These are meant to just keep the audience in touch with
what's going on and what our thinking might be. Exactly. Thanks, John. We will see everyone next
week. Maybe sooner. See you. Yep.