Ted Cruz Slams Schiff in Explosive Senate Hearing on Rogue Judges and Universal Injunctions

Ted Cruz
1 follower
But hey, they found a judge who says, you know what?
We, the Democrat party, we are the party of illegal aliens.
We are the party of murderers and rapists and gang members.
And the Democrat party exists here to fight, to keep murderers and rapists
and gang members in your communities.
There's a reason the Democrat party is at 26% approval nationwide.
The use of nationwide injunctions against the administration that has
proven so breathtaking in its lawlessness and who is engaged in, in
such a, a surge of illegal actions, the, the effort to do away with this
singularly vital tool, I think you called it at this time would be
disastrous for the country.
I have to admit, I'm enjoying listening to my Democrat colleagues suddenly
discover the virtues of the rule of law.
After four years where they brazenly supported the most lawless department
of justice and the most politically weaponized department of justice
our nation has ever seen.
We just heard the Senator from Rhode Island talk about the
imperative of protecting judges.
And yet not, not a single Democrat Senator cared about the violent
protesters that showed up outside Supreme court justices homes, including
I might note female justices like justice Amy Coney Barrett, threatening
their family and Joe Biden's attorney general didn't do a damn thing in
refused to enforce the law to protect those judges.
Why?
Because he agreed with the violent protesters and he wanted to
intimidate and threaten those judges.
Professor Bray under our constitution, who should decide elections,
the voters or unelected judges?
The voters are the ones who should vote in the election of according
to the, the laws and the laws sometimes have to be applied by the judges.
And under our constitution, who is charged with making policy decisions,
elected representatives elected by the people or unelected federal judges?
I think the question of policy Senator is a little broader
than the particular case.
So the basic law should be enacted by Congress.
That's where the fountain of policy decisions of the elected branch, right?
Law is the, is the province of the court policy is the province
of the elected branches.
These are not complicated.
Professor Bray, let me ask you this.
Do the federal courts have power to issue remedies for people
who are not parties to a case?
That's a question I agree is not complicated.
They do not have that power.
Is the phrase nationwide injunction or universal injunction found
anywhere in the constitution?
It is not.
The first 150 years of our Republic, how many nationwide injunctions were issued?
Uh, my view is that there were not any until 1963 zero.
Now fast forward.
How many, how many nationwide injunctions were issued
in the entire 20th century?
Um, it's a small number.
I would, I would think it would be a dozen, give or take.
It's not large.
27 actually excluding Trump's first term.
How many nationwide injunctions were issued in the last 20 years?
Far more than that.
32 from 20, uh, 2001 to 2024 against Biden, Obama, and Bush 32.
And how many nationwide injunctions have been issued
in the last two months alone?
There have been quite a few 37.
Let that sink in.
There have been no more nationwide injunctions in the past two months
against president Trump than in the entire 20th century, there have been
more nationwide injunction against president Trump in the last two months.
Then both terms of George W.
Bush, both terms of Barack Obama and Joe Biden's term.
We saw during the Biden presidency, lawfare indicting president Trump four
times using the machinery of justice to attack him, and that was an attack on
democracy because Democrats today hate democracy.
Democrats today are angry at the voters for reelecting Donald Trump and
electing a Republican Senate and Republican house, and they engaged in
lawfare to stop democracy from operating.
Understand this is the second phase of lawfare.
Second chart.
This is the second phase of lawfare.
Now that their efforts to indict president Trump and stop the
voters from reelecting him have failed.
They're going and seeking out individual radical judges to try to shut down
policies and they are forum shopping like crazy, give me any loon judge put
on the bench by Obama or Biden who disagrees with the policy, we just saw
a judge flagrantly ignore US immigration law concerning TPS being revoked.
US law explicitly said there's no judicial review for that, but hey, they
found a judge who says, you know what?
We, the Democrat party, we are the party of illegal aliens.
We are the party of murderers and rapists and gang members.
And the Democrat party exists here to fight, to keep murderers and rapists
and gang members in your communities.
There's a reason the Democrat party is at 26% approval nationwide because they
put radical policies ahead of rule of law.
Nationwide injunctions are an abuse of power.
It is the judiciary acting as policy deciders, and it is incumbent on this
committee and this body to rein in the abuse of power from these unelected
radical judges who are trying to overturn the election because they
disagree with what the voters decide.
Thank you, Senator Cruz.
When the justice department dismissed a corruption case against the mayor of
New York city, not because of a lack of evidence, not because of any
misconduct by the prosecutors in the case, but because of the most serious
misconduct of the attorney general and the top leadership of the justice
department, because the justice department wanted to leverage that case
against the mayor by dismissing the case without prejudice so that they
could use him as a political pawn to help effectuate their immigration policy.
That just happened today.
It is one of any number of serious abuses of the rule of law by this justice
department, instead of having a single hearing on what the department is doing
or a single hearing on all the other plainly unlawful acts of this
administration.
No, instead of having a hearing on any of those things, Republicans are having
a hearing on the one tool that can be used to try to mitigate the harm of
these illegal actions.
Now, I completely concur that whether nationwide injunctions are a good thing
or a bad thing has depended entirely on who they're being used against.
I count no less than 26 of my Republican colleagues who were vigorously supportive
of a nationwide injunction against the use of Mipha Pristone.
And no problem supporting a nationwide injunction in that case.
And of course, on the Democratic side of the aisle, we are applauding
injunctions against the unlawful actions of this administration.
Where I think I come down at this moment in time gets to your point,
Professor Vladeck, and that is the use of nationwide injunctions against
the administration that has proven so breathtaking in its lawlessness.
And it was engaged in such a surge of illegal actions,
the effort to do away with this singularly vital tool,
I think you called it, at this time would be disastrous for the country.
It doesn't mean there is not going to come a time when we should agree on
a bipartisan basis to place limits on this capability.
I think we should, in particular on the abuse of form shopping,
on picking judges solely on the basis of their political predilection or
who appointed them for the purpose of a nationwide injunction.
But this is not the moment to do it.
This is the moment, frankly, we should be focusing on the illegality,
not on the tool to constrain it.
That doesn't mean we're powerless to work on legislation on this.
And I think many of us have concurred with the idea of legislation that takes
effect after this term, when we don't know who the next president is.
Senator Cruz, you and I went to the same law school.
There was a wonderful professor at the college named John Rawls who wrote a book.
You probably read about the veil of ignorance,
where you cast a veil of ignorance over society and society would develop
rules to govern that society not knowing their attributes, their race, their religion,
their gender, none of that.
Well, far be it for me to advocate a further veil of ignorance over this body.
We are ignorant enough, but
perhaps the ignorance of not knowing who the next president is is useful here.
We should come up with a sensible reform of injunctions and forum shopping.
But there's no way this is going to have bipartisan support unless we defer it,
its application until after this administration,
when we don't know which way it will cut.
I think the same is probably true about filling judicial vacancies.
We have just come to this broken place.
Where probably the only way to get things done of this significance is to postpone
their application until we don't know who the president will be.
