買新款X1還是老款X3?寶馬最暢銷SUV的對比試駕評測:這次X1居然能以下犯上了?【車之感深度車評】
车之感
25粉絲
9 次觀看·2025年10月21日
兩部BMW最佳銷售車是BMW X1
對上BMW X3
SUV對上Thomas & Autogfuel
4K全螢幕 全長度
先來看看前方的X1
前方有更大的雙屁股
BMW的新設計更堅硬更強烈
顏色是X1的藍色湖泊
藍色引擎的綠色輪圈
藍色引擎的顏色非常有趣
X1也有更深的藍色
這部是X3的藍色雙屁股
X3的雙屁股也很大
X3最近也正式推出了
但尺寸不及X1大
兩部車有著相似的特徵
兩部車都配備了M Sport Pack
所以兩部車的中間位置是黑色的
X3當然是X1的大兄弟
前方的車身比較堅硬
X3的車身偏高
但這兩部車的設計相符合你的想法
前方的轉向燈
有趣的是
這部車是X1的
因為它有雙轉向燈
你也看到它有震動效果
也許你也看到
現在更明顯的是
這部車的日常燈
這部車的L形
X3的L形
X1的L形看起來像Topsy-Turvy
看到嗎
在旁邊的尺寸差別
這部BMW X1
4米50或177英尺
而這部X3
21釐米或8英尺更長
這部X3的尺寸是4米71或185英尺
所以確實有著不少的尺寸差別
在設計上
你會看到這部車的尺寸稍微高一點
類似SUV的設計
這部X1的尺寸稍微低一點
你也可能會猜到
這部車的轉向燈
兩部車都配備了M Sport Pack
來比較一下
例如這部車
每部車都配備了彩色的輪框
我覺得看起來很酷
很有運動感
這部車的輪框
從17英尺到20英尺
這部車的輪框是19英尺
而這部X3的輪框是18英尺到21英尺
所以每部車的輪框是一英尺高
但這部車的輪框是20英尺
所以確實是非常相似的尺寸
你喜歡哪部輪框
在這部車的旁邊的尺寸差別
在下方留言告訴我
最後說說這部車的懸吊
也相似
這部車的懸吊是底座懸吊
這也是一個很好的選擇
再說一遍
M Sport有相似的懸吊
而這部車的懸吊有不同的標誌
對
我覺得這部車
只是個人喜好
但兩部車的懸吊設計都非常漂亮
你覺得呢
在下方留言告訴我
換句話說
這部車的懸吊是X3的冠軍
來比較一下
這部車的懸吊是X1
這部車的懸吊是更新的懸吊
比較高光澤
有點像現代懸吊
這部車的懸吊是X3的經典懸吊
你會選擇哪一種懸吊
對我來說
我知道
正常的懸吊在這裡
沒有高光澤的懸吊
懸吊在旁邊
所以
對我來說
我會選擇那一種懸吊
來看看X1的內部
這部車的懸吊是封閉的
但它還是有正常的開關
還有一個懸吊
我覺得這是一個很好的補償
尤其是在外觀和機動性能方面
仍然有著經典的開關聲
絕對是
門是硬朗的
高級的鋼絲紅色
中央裝置
還有這個金屬的懸吊
我非常喜歡這個顏色
特別是外觀是藍色
然後
這個金屬或鮪魚的內部
是很酷的
不同顏色都可以選擇
還有黃色或黑色
還有這個
都是Viganza的材質
所以這是新的高級鋼絲紅色
你可以看到它在
完全光滑的部分
讓我們稱之為
還有被破壞的部分
為了適當的空調
在坐下
一個穩定的
讓我們進去
你已經有一個很不錯的進出
它基本上
對
它感覺就像一輛SUV
雖然它是比較小的
但是你會有很好的舒適
它是非常柔軟
還有頭部空間
這裡有189
602
沒有窗戶
完全沒有問題
即使有窗戶
你會像一個高人一樣
駕駛席有一個手動控制
上下
但是過程非常順暢
順帶一提
Viganza的窗戶
是運動座椅
還有一個底座
有塑料
但是沒有肩膀支撐
X1的內部座椅觀
是清潔和更加現代化
這裡有這個
融合曲面螢幕
兩個個人螢幕在那裡
你沒有這個
iDrive控制器
我肯定會錯過它
但是它看起來更清晰
但是對我來說
觸控螢幕不太理想
這裡很漂亮
感應臺
座椅
質量非常好
整體建造質量
這個汽車非常出色
尤其是這個部分
數碼器
清晰
現代
好閱讀
我覺得這只是視乎個人喜好
如果你喜歡X3
或者X1
你可以看到它是一個很好的螢幕
好廣闊的融合
這是BMW的選項
有點過重
我覺得
但是你會知道
你真的需要哪個
這裡左邊
你總是有熱鍵
溫度總是在這裡
或者氣候
當你操控
座椅的溫度
對我來說
有點太複雜
你擁有所有功能
但是我不想做到
在駕駛
然後你看到這個
融合操控
你會有一點點
典型BMW
運動感
但是再一次
它是非常清潔和融合
然而我們還是有一個
它的音量頂蓋
杯箱插槽
是不適合的
這很奇怪
當然
杯子飛移
但這裡有一個好處
它是手機的座椅
你可以把它固定在這裡
背面
有一個導流充電片
這也很棒
因為不會過熱
我們來看一下座椅
有個好設計
在中間的操控臺
兩個USB-C插頭
我們進去
我們有同樣好的座椅材料
看起來還不錯
裡面的座椅
是硬的
在座椅背部
它有一個好的結構
So it doesn't look hard pack actually
And then it's soft touch here with the
Sensatec material at the inside of the doors
Harman Kardon sound system also in the rear
And well you have this recess here in the seat
But it needs to be a little bit higher
That the recess really fits for the knees very well
So for tall adults in the rear
When tall adults are driving
Kind of a problem here in the X1
Not the best
Headroom is no problem at all
And the seat comfort is also very good
Yeah again
This seat needs to be a little bit higher
Then it would also work for me
But I usually have the seat in the lowest position then
In the middle seat here
Works too as for my height
Also from the comfort
Just again this legroom thing
Yeah it's a shorter SUV
And you do feel that here
However you can also
Adjust the back pad here of the seat
That's good and also from the build quality
And this here plug-in hybrid model
When you have a pure combustion engine X1
Then you can also get the movable bench
By 13 centimeters or 5 inches front and back
And yeah this helps to be a little bit more flexible
However the plug-in hybrid bench is not higher
Interior of the X3 now
First of all door closing sound
It's actually good as well
But I feel the X1 was even better there
Then inside of the doors
Also the sensor tech
A little bit harder I feel though
Galvanization of the buttons here
For the window mirrors nice
But make no mistake
This is a 100 euro extra
And that can't be that
They make so many extra options
Then the interior
A little bit more classic traditional setup
Also buttons on the steering wheel
Same for both
Seats here also sensor tech
Available in different colors
Perforation as well
So this has been induced with the facelift
However the material is very good
Already yes
But the veganza in the X1
Is a little bit softer than this one here
When you get inside
The seating position is kind of different
Yes
You sit a little bit higher
You have more grown up SUV feeling
But then again
The seat ergonomics
Like of the seat itself
Is better in the X1
Together with the more soft material
That adapts more to your body
So you have somewhat more cooler
Command driving position
From the general feeling
But then again the seating comfort
Is definitely better in the X1
Here of course
You also have a lot of headroom
With 189 or 642
In here a corporate overview
Of the BMW X3
The bigger one
Same as also real buttons
On the steering wheel
But then here we still have
A manual climate unit
That's a better user interface
I feel screens
They are separated in digital instruments
And the main infotainment unit
And the base version starts smaller
And here the optional higher trim solutions
Then the screens are a little bit bigger
Than in the X1
Digital instruments
Oh, they have here the old styling
But I mean I also like it
So that's personal preference
I would say both do the job
Infotainment system is here the OS 7
So the older version
On the one hand it's easier
Also here on the left side
You can see this is then the car menu
Where I have the driving information
Pretty quickly available
That is better I think
And you can also see
I can also control from below
Because I still have this lower control
So both pro and con
Apple CarPlay integration
Also works very well
The thing is that here
It sometimes is a little bit slower
And fails a little bit more
Often with the wireless connection
But that's the one advantage of the OS 8
Where it's quicker and more reliable
Here is lower middle console
Yeah, I just like to control down here
So while driving it's easier
And also the real shifting lever in the X3
It takes more space
It also stands out
Yeah, I know what you're thinking
But I just think it's a little bit better
To have this feeling
This connection to the vehicle
And then the front part
Here the
OK, that happened
Interesting
That's not that good
I get a kind of get stuck here
Here the cup holders
That is better
They are adaptive
That's better than in the X1
And the inductive charging
X3 interior in the rear
A stronger middle tunnel
Because of the rear wheel drive platform
Inside of the doors here
With a soft touch sensor tech
So that's a little bit better
I would say
But what about the space
And the legroom and so on
Shoe tab of course
Signature auto-gefühl move
Yeah, I mean here the seat itself
Is a little bit higher by default
So you have more space for your feet
Even though when the seat is in the lowest position
And then also fits well with the recess
So let's say maybe a little bit better
But it's more about the height
So if you put the X1 driver seat
A little bit higher
It's more or less comparable
Here maybe a little bit more
So but not that it would justify
The length of the car
It has additionally headroom
No problem at all
And in the middle seat
Is it comparable
Yes, you have this bigger tunnel here
As I said
You can also sit here
So yeah, the rear space
A little bit better here with the X3
But not the largest difference
Is the difference then in the trunk
Now it's time for the big trunk comparison
Or is it big
That's cool, right
So let's start here with the X1
And the main thing for me is
Is there a length difference
I know what you're thinking
Here there is almost 90 centimeters
Or 35 inches
490 liters here
Also for the plug-in hybrid
You have some more space underneath
For example for the charging cable
And then 450 liters for the X3
In this plug-in hybrid version
Although here I remember this step
Also from the US spec version
From pure petrol engine
To put replacement tire underneath
And yeah, liter figure wise
A little bit limited
And now the astonishing thing is
When you measure here
The standard trunk length
It is less than 90 centimeters
Or 35 inches
Especially with that step here
So yeah, charging cable
Needs to be put on top
No space underneath here
So that's astonishing, right
I mean it's really the way longer vehicle
Here with the X3
But the rear space
Just a little bit longer
Trunk even a little bit shorter
Yeah, it's all about
That this one just has the longer hood
Engine comparison
I just love that shot
So very interesting
2 liter 4-cylinder
Petrol and diesel for both
But then on the lower end
A 1.5 liter 3-cylinder for the X1
The plug-in hybrid is also based on that
And on the other side
The X3 here with the longer hood
Houses also 6-cylinder engines
Especially for the performance models
Today it's both about
The plug-in hybrid
Interesting thing is here
That the battery is bigger with the X1
So higher electric range for the X1
Welcome to Thomas'
Comparison driving lounge
We're starting with the BMW X1
In this case with the plug-in hybrid 30e
What you immediately realize
Is when you go off the throttle
You always or most of the time
Have some kind of recuperation
It is however also adaptive
Here in that standard mode
So for example
When there's no one in front of me
The car is just rolling
And I don't see any recuperation
Inside the city
When the car is in front of me
I go off the throttle
And it does directly go into
The regenerative braking
And it does decelerate
Although you're just leaving
Your foot off the throttle
Like in an electric vehicle for example
It's really good to know
But this adaptive system
It's not that you know
Predictable in a way
That's the con side
But then again
It helps to adapt to the situation
My modes
I can pick the sport mode
A little bit more complicated
Than it used to be
I would say
And you can also go to the S shifting mode
And then we can accelerate
From 50 kilometers an hour to let's see
120
And we have to stop for a moment
Because there's a car next to us
To overtake them on the left lane
In the US
We could overtake on the right side
But we can't do it in Germany
Unlimited speed is possible
In here on this motorway
When the traffic allows it
And when we're already at speed here
At 115 kilometers an hour
Let's go
150
And 170 kilometers an hour
So pretty good in the acceleration
In the whole X1 lineup
This plug-in hybrid here
Is one of the quickest
With 5.7 seconds
To 100 kilometers an hour
Or 62 miles an hour
The iX1 is just a little quicker
5.6
And the quickest then will be
The M350i
The 2 liter 4-cylinder
Tuned to this M performance model
So to speak
Here the plug-in hybrid
Has the 1.5 liter 3-cylinder
You maybe heard that
Did you
Tell me in the comments
And it sounds somehow sporty
And cooler than the 4-cylinder
I'm always skeptical however
With the 3-cylinder engines
Because they decrease the
You know the CCM
So they decrease the displacement
And put up the horsepower figure
To total system output
With the electric motor
Of course 330 horsepower
And I'm always more a fan of
More liters and higher displacement
But less horsepower
So the engine is not that tuned
That much
But it delivers definitely
And when you really hit the throttle
You feel that in the first moment
You get some kind of electric boost
This is by the way
Always available the electric boost
Even if the battery is depleted
Because they always keep
Some kind of a buffer
That the electric boost
Is always available
You can also pull this
Left shifting lever
So even when you are for example
Not in the sport mode
And also here now
In the normal personal mode
Then design changes
That's pretty cool spectacular
You can pull this lever here
And then you get to the sport boost mode
And you basically have the same experience
And then we just had
So this is also some kind of shortcut
When you don't want to switch
Through the modes
And wow that is quick you know
We were always driving 150 kilometers now
It does well here on the German Autobahn
Wind noise is here at 160 kilometers
Now pick up here a little bit there
But I mean this is on a very high level
It's generally a pretty silent vehicle
And it also feels so well and planted
So you do get the grown up SUV feeling
Although it's the smallest SUV
In the BMW lineup
We have the adaptive suspension here
So it's also a little bit stiffer
In the sport mode
And 90 inch wheels
So we have a good sporty feeling here
Lane change at higher speeds
Such a good test here
It's really a lot of fun
The steering here is pretty crisp and precise
More precise than in the BMW 3 Series actually
And I have no idea
Why the steering feeling in the BMW SUVs
Is better than in the
Should to be benchmark 3 Series sedan
Yeah I talked about that to BMW
And I hope they will increase it
Or improve it for the next 3 Series
Overhaul will of course
Keep you updated with that
One more acceleration here
So you have more than enough power
With this plug-in hybrid here
No doubt about that
And also a lot of driving fun
This compact dimension
That speaks for the X1
Also in driving
I will expect from my experience
That the X1 is more fun to drive
At least that's what I think right now
When we soon hop over to the X3
We will of course testify that
Or have you seen that
Here this personal driving mode
It does not hop back to the manual
To where I was before
So we always have to then
For example go back
Or go back to the GPS again
That's something I think
They need to improve
Then with the next software version
The OS 9 will also be available soon
When you watch this video
At the production date
Soon also in the X1
Also retrofitted to other X1
Or then already in the X1
When you watch this video
Maybe a year later
Or something like that
You know decreasing the speed
Then we have recuperation
That's of course a good thing
With the plug-in hybrid
So we can use the recuperation
Yes
But the big question is also
With the plug-in hybrids here
Does it make sense
In a way of built-in hybrids
Like a Toyota system or something
No it does not
So when the battery is depleted
Like now
It just gives you like a 7 liters
From 1 kilometers consumption
So 35 mpg US
40 mpg UK
That's nothing special
It does not help so much
With low fuel economy
You know so yeah
That's not what the system is meant for
This is meant to be charged
Then it makes sense
That you can drive electric
Inside the city and so on
So this is the use of this plug-in hybrid
But do not expect to drive it empty
And then have a great fuel efficiency gain
Like in a built-in hybrid system
As I said like from like Toyota system
Is a different emphasis definitely
Here now switching the motorway
So cool here with the steering
The sporty design and the feel of it
I really feel immediately at home
In this vehicle
That's the cool thing
Look at that Kia Rio
That generation
That design should be forbidden right
Yeah sometimes I also can be like
So I always try to be very objective
You know but sometimes in this case
I can also be like
I mean modern Kia design is really awesome
And in some ways
They're even overtaking the Germans
We've also seen that
Now once again
Let's try this boost mode one time
Wow wow wow wow wow
This is giving me the boost indeed
Pretty impressive
I mean you look at that big from the outside
And it doesn't look that sporty
But it delivers you know
Wow that's pretty good
And the sport boost stays actually still in there
And now we're almost 190 now
So almost 200 kilometers an hour
Almost 125 miles an hour
And it still delivers
It does a very good and calm job here
Yeah really good
I can still control it very well
And here the 19 inch wheels
And the adaptive suspension
Setting on the sport mode
Does a very good job indeed
So I have to say however
Here when the road is even
Great awesome
I love that
But when the road is not that even
I'm not the biggest fan of that
So what I would advise
Is to go with smaller wheels
If you want better
Everyday comfort
Maximum 18 inch wheels
For this vehicle
I would say
Because you just profit so much more
When you have more rolling comfort
In your everyday driving life
When you pick smaller wheels
And then when you think about
Hey I want to configure an X1
And don't spend so much money
Like this test vehicle here
66,000 euros
All the bells and whistles
Then you might as well
Also stick with the base suspension
And when you have the base suspension
It's even more important
Not to go for the biggest wheels
To keep the driving comfort
So always have to keep that in mind
Yeah but definitely
Feels really at home
On the motorway as well
But also in the city
Of course if you compare X1 with X3
You just find a better parking space
Inside the city
You have you know
Smaller turning circle and so on
You can enjoy this car more in the city
You get less stress
Especially in narrow European cities
For the US maybe not that relevant
But for Europe
It is actually very relevant
Therefore a lot of people
Especially in the European cities
Rather go for the X1
But the question is
When we directly hop over to the X3 now
How does it feel in driving
This extra in price and size
Is it justified
Is it so much more sophisticated
Or is the X1 just right enough
Now let's switch to the X3
Also in the 30E version
Go to the sport mode
Also combine both powertrains
And start from 60 kilometers an hour
Let's go
120
That's 140
So also
Let's say decently quick
But not as quick as the S1
S1
It's not an Audi
As the X1
So the X1 plug-in hybrid was 5.7 seconds
This one here is 6.1 seconds
In the acceleration figure
And let's just accelerate further
There we hear some more power boost
From that engine
Here a 2 liter 4-cylinder engine
So yeah
We also hear and feel that
More displacement here
In these higher speed regions
More than 200 kilometers an hour
125 miles an hour
Yeah and it feels so stable on the road
Here with the M Sportback
Adaptive suspension
A little bit stiffer in the sport
Top speed here
214 kilometers an hour
So like 135 miles an hour
Wow
Feels really good high speed as well
And also noise insulation wise
Good job
20 inch wheels
We have mounted here
We do feel when the road is even
It's fine
But you do feel some bumps notably
So similar what is 19 to the X1
20 is for the X3
Of course bigger segment
And they also allow bigger wheels
But for both
I would go at least one size below that
To give you just more comfort in driving
It drives super well
Also you know
Here when going left and right and so on
But then again
Just rolling comfort
When the road is not that good
20 inch is just a little bit too much
But the suspension is doing a good job
Love the adaptive suspension by BMW
Same suspension setups
Possible base or fixed sport
Or the adaptive suspension
So that is kind of similar with both vehicles
Of course different platform
Different technology a little bit
Steering wise
I have a better feeling in the X1
Because here in the X3
I would say
It feels a little bit less natural in a way
So here it's kind of like a little bit more dead
But then when you go a little bit more to the side
Then it suddenly becomes a little bit too hectic
You know
So I feel the steering is not that well
Balanced here as it is in the X1
So definitely prefer the X1 steering
As for the whole feeling
How you feel connected to the vehicle
We can also go back to the normal hybrid mode
And we also hear less sound pronunciation
Part of that is also artificial
Basically all manufacturers use that meanwhile
But you can still accelerate in this hybrid mode
Then goes all the way through
Let's do a high speed lane change
As well
Well done
Keeps really really calm
You feel that you sit a little bit higher in the X3
It feels a little bit more sophisticated
As for the driving position
It feels more SUV even than the X1
So this is something that is definitely pro X3
On the other hand
You feel the size and the weight
That the X1 is just a little bit more agile
Especially then in tight corners
Then the question is
What is more important to you actually
At all times also go back to the sport mode
In the sport mode
We always have this kind of RPM preload
Goes gear lower and so on
We also have the combined power of both drivetrains here
Difference in all electric driving
So what is possible the maximum scale
The X3 a little bit older
Overall vehicle has less capacity in the battery
In the plug-in hybrid version
So something like 40 kilometers
Of pure electric range 25 miles
Whereas the X1 more like 60 kilometers
Of pure electric range like 40 miles
So the X1 has an advantage there definitely
The X3 however
It is a rear wheel biased platform
That's what I like about the X3
When you accelerate out of the corners
Although this one here from the whole chassis
And so on
Feels less sporty than the X1
Cause just bigger
More weight and so on
And the handling overall is more fun with the X1
So I think that you have more fun
Definitely with the X1
Yes however
Just in the case of accelerating out of the corners
And we will soon do it here
When we switch the autobahn
So accelerating out is better with the X3
Because of this rear wheel bias
Even if you have done an all-wheel drive version
Because when you have more power on the rear wheels
It kind of helps you swinging out of the corner
So to speak the rear axle overtakes the front axle
Not that extreme
Of course we don't drift or something
But just that you can imagine
Why it kind of feels sportier
And with the axle bias
That one here
Nice engine
It is also fun
It is a fun SUV
It is a driver's SUV
Also if you compare it to other ones
But oh here now
Also in the corner
The steering feel is just a little bit off
It is like a little bit like in the BMW 3 Series
Must have been to do like with the platforms
They also use the same steering wheel for that
Accelerating out here now is cool
The engine gives me a little bit more livelihood
Than the one in the 3-cylinder in the X1
Of course the 2-liter 4-cylinder is also available for the X1
Just not for the plug-in hybrid
So that is actually cool
You do have fun with it
But I really have to say
Yes driving straight
So imagine you have long routes
Where you just drive straight
Then maybe like this
More sophisticated high position might help you
Just go back to the normal hybrid mode here
A little bit calmer
But as soon as you go a little bit in corners
The X1 is just more fun
Steering input wise
The whole handling
A little bit lower position
It gives you more
Let's say more safe controlled feeling
I would also say
It's not that this one is not safe
Or not controllable
Just in a direct comparison
The X1 you feel more one with the vehicle
In the X1 and in the X3
It's good
Definitely also to the brand outside competitors
But brand internal comparison here
The X1 just gives me more fun
Another important thing is here
Long term driving comfort
These seats here already have the perforated sensor tech
Which is cool
Definitely
But the Veganza seats
Which is kind of like an evolved
Sensor tech in the X1
They also give you more comfort here while driving
They are softer
They adapt more to the body
At the same time the X1 sport seats
Which most X1s are equipped with
Give you actually more shoulder support
Here than these ones here while driving
And I'm surprised
Because usually the higher segment
This one here delivers always more seating comfort
More long term comfort
And in this case
If you ask me right now
Would I drive 300 kilometers
Or I don't know
Like 150 miles of Autobahn
German motorway
Right now with the X1 or the X3
It would be indeed the X1
And again not because the X3 is bad in any way
Just because the seat ergonomics
How they played it out and so on
Is so good overall in the X1
Still the X3 has a lot to offer
As I said this higher seating position
You somehow get a more
Like better traveling feeling
If you want
If you think about the road trip or something
And again seat comfort
It might also depend on the individual body
So I recommend to visit dealer
And maybe test seat in both of them
I can just give my experience
Also with my height and so on
And I also love that I
While driving can control the temperature
In an easy way
So just before a corner
I'm really confident
I can also do the sport mode
Really confident to change that
I also need just one press of a button
To go to the sport mode
The X1 I need then to do press
And then in the infotainment system
Here one press of a button
And then also you know
Here pressing up or down
For changing the temperature
So with this more conservative layout
I enjoy the X3 a little bit more
With this more direct
More old school interface
That is something that is also important
To me while driving
However both still have real buttons
At the steering wheel
So that is kind of equal
Here still having fun with the X3
No doubt about that in the corners
Also you know we did some GLC
With X3 review for example
Both also very interesting SUVs
You can also check out that one
Later on
Yeah
So it has been a very interesting
Experience in the driving part
But now the question is
If we combine all the different factors
Exterior, interior, driving, technology
And pricing
Why is pricing a small thing
Which one should you take home
Which one would I take home
Does it differ from market to market
Can I make a thinking pose
And walk at the same time
That's the first question
And the second question is
Which one would I take home
Can you tell me
So the BMW X1, BMW X3
They're both very successful SUVs
And I said best sellers at BMW
The X1 styling wise
Really satisfied with it
The X3 just has this
More massive SUV stance
So from the exterior look
I kind of prefer the X3
But just because you know
I like this more bold SUV styling
This one still for a smaller SUV
Or crossover
It does look bold
No doubt about that
Interior styling wise
I'm all the way with the X1
From the styling
However, I do prefer
The more classic traditional user interface
With the X3
With the turning knob
For the infotainment system
For example, with the manual climate unit
However, then again
The X1 has a better infotainment system
As for how fast and responsive it is
And also how secure and safe
The connection to the smartphone is
That is actually better
With the wireless connection
In the OS 7 system
Is sometimes not that good actually
The crucial difference
However, in the interior
Is the seating comfort
And they're both good
And also the artificial leatherette
Or the man-made leather
That one is a very good quality
In both vehicles
However, even better in the X1
So it's softer
And also the seat ergonomics
Is way better in the X1
Not that the X3 would be bad
The X1 just tops it
And to me
It's also one of the most comfortable vehicles
In this segment
Or in this compact segment overall
And that's why
For the interior
I would still go with the X1
Because I feel
The seating comfort
Would then be more important
Than the manual climate unit to me
Yeah
Maybe I have to live then
With 22 degrees Celsius
Or 72 degrees Fahrenheit
Automatic
I don't like it
But I would live with that
For the seat comfort
And then of course in driving
That was super interesting
I like the rear-wheel drive
Or this rear-wheel bias concept
With the X3
Of course it does offer
The possibility of a six-cylinder
Then again
The X1 feels more balanced
And kind of lighter in the corners
And so on
It is more driving fun then overall
Yeah
Fuel economy doesn't make the largest difference
The plug-in hybrid
Is of course
The better system here in the X1
More efficient
Bigger battery
No compromise in the trunk
And so ever
Yeah
And then you have to think about
That the size on the exterior
Does not represent the size difference
In the interior
Almost same legroom in the rear
The X3 just a little bit longer
Trunk wise
The X1 is even a little bit longer
At least in the plug-in hybrid versions as well
So there is no huge advantage
You get with the X3
Price difference
Very interesting
As the vehicle stand here right now
With all the bells and whistles
66,000 euros
And 80,000 euros
So it's a 14,000 euro difference
And interesting
When you take off the extra options
It is still the same price difference
That's the European difference
In the US
The difference is not as large
So there you don't pay so much extra for the X3
So in Europe
It's a clear choice
Go with the X1
Also with the more narrow roads
And so on
In the US
It's even a little bit trickier
Because the price difference is not as large
And also you have
Most states more open wide roads
So the X3 gets more attractive
Yeah, it's also built in the US
That's also
It's probably better or more attractive
From the pricing there
Goes from the Spartanburg plant
Whereas the X1 is built in Germany
In Regensburg
Regensburg is the German pronunciation
Listen and repeat
Regensburg
It's like
It's like rain castle
Is the name of the city
Interesting, isn't it
Yeah, so overall I think
Combining the facts
And especially seating comfort
Overall winner today is the BMW X1
But what do you think
Tell me in the comments
And join us for more comparison episodes
