Fact-Check: A Video Marathon | Marathons

PragerU
799 followers
Apr 3, 2025
Wondering what the facts are on the issues? This quick, curated video compilation lays them all out. Enjoy!
Much has been made of the Paris Climate Agreement signed by the leaders of 178 countries in 2016.
French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius, speaking for many, called it a historic turning point.
The head of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Gina McCarthy, echoed the minister's
remark when she testified before the House Committee on Science, Space and Technology.
The Paris Agreement was, she said, an incredible achievement. But when pressed by committee members
to explain exactly how much this treaty would reduce global temperatures, she would not, or
could not, say. This combination of grand pronouncements and vague specifics is a good
strategy for Paris Agreement fans to take. Because the agreement will cost a fortune,
Consider the Obama administration's signature climate policy, the Clean Power Plan. Using the
same climate prediction model that the UN uses, I found that the power plan will accomplish almost
nothing. Even if its cuts to carbon dioxide emissions are fully implemented, not just for
the 14 years that the Paris Agreement lasts, but for the rest of the century, the Clean
Power Plan would reduce the temperature increase in 2100 by just 0.023 degrees Fahrenheit.
The president has made further and grander promises of future U.S. carbon cuts, but these
are only vaguely outlined. In the unlikely event that all of these extra cuts also happen and are
adhered to throughout the rest of the century, the combined reduction in temperatures would be 0.057
degrees. To put it another way, if the U.S. delivers for the whole century on the president's
very ambitious rhetoric, it would postpone global warming by about eight months at the end of the
century. Now let's add in the rest of the world's Paris promises. If we generously assume that the
promised carbon cuts for 2030 are not only met, which itself would be a UN first, but sustained
throughout the rest of the century, temperatures in 2100 would drop by 0.3 degrees, the equivalent
of postponing warming by less than four years. Again, that's using the UN's own climate prediction
model. But here's the biggest problem. These minuscule benefits do not come free. Quite the
contrary. The cost of the Paris climate pact is likely to run to one to two trillion dollars every
year, based on estimates produced by the Stanford Energy Modeling Forum and the Asia Modeling
Exercise. In other words, we will spend at least 100 trillion dollars in order to reduce the
temperature by the end of the century by a grand total of three-tenths of one degree. Some Paris
agreement supporters defend it by claiming that its real impact on temperatures will be much more
significant than the UN model predicts. But this requires mental gymnastics and heroic assumptions.
The climate action tracker, widely cited by Paris agreement fans, predict a temperature reduction
of 1.6 degrees Fahrenheit by the end of the century. But this prediction is based very heavily
on the assumption that even stronger climate policies will be adopted in the future. Actually,
98% of the assumed reductions will come only after 2030, which is what the current Paris
agreement covers. And even such wishful thinking won't achieve anything close to the two degrees
Celsius reduction that has become the somewhat arbitrary but widely adopted benchmark to avoid
the worst effects of global warming. The actual promised emission reductions under the Paris
agreement literally gets us just 1% of the way to the two degrees target. 99% of what would be
required is put off until after 2030. The Paris agreement is the wrong solution to a real problem.
The right solution will most likely be found through green energy research and development,
like that promoted by Bill Gates and the Breakthrough Coalition. Mr. Gates has announced
that private investors are committing $7 billion for clean energy R&D. Instead of political hot air
and ever larger government subsidies of today's inefficient green technologies, those who want
to combat climate change should focus on dramatically boosting green energy innovation.
The U.S. already shows the way. With its pursuit of fracking making it safer and more efficient
every year, America has drastically reduced the cost of natural gas. This momentous switch from
coal to lower CO2 gas as a source of energy has done far more to drive down carbon dioxide
emissions than any recent government climate policy. Turns out that those politicians who
gathered in Paris, France could learn a lot from Paris, Texas. I'm Bjorn Lomborg,
president of the Copenhagen Consensus Center. We face an existential threat. Life as we know it
is on the line. We have 12 short years to change everything or it's game over. This is the
terrifying scenario that's used by many leading politicians to justify a Green New Deal, an
unprecedented increase in government power focused on the energy industry. The core idea
of a Green New Deal is that government should rapidly prohibit the use of fossil fuel energy
and impose 100% renewable energy, mostly solar and wind. This may sound appealing,
but consider what it would entail. Today, 80% of the energy Americans use to heat their homes,
farm their land, run their factories, and drive their cars comes from fossil fuels,
coal, oil, and natural gas. Only 3.4% comes from solar and wind, despite decades of government
subsidies and mandates to encourage their use. The reason we don't use much sunlight and wind
as energy is that they are unreliable fuels that only work when the sun shines and the wind blows.
That's why no town, city, or country has ever come close to 100% or even 50% solar and wind.
And yet Green New Deal proponents say they can do the impossible. If only we give the government
control of the energy industry and control of major users of energy, such as the transportation
industry, manufacturing, and agriculture. All of this is justified by the need to do something
about the existential threat of rising CO2 levels. We're told on a daily basis that prestigious
organizations like the United Nations have predicted mass destruction and death if we
don't get off fossil fuels. What we're not told is that such predictions have a decades-long track
record of getting it wrong. And by wrong, I mean completely missing the dartboard wrong.
For example, in 1989, the Associated Press reported a United Nations prediction that
entire nations could be wiped off the face of the Earth by rising sea levels
if the global warming trend is not reversed by the year 2000. We're now two decades past 2000,
we're not missing any nations, and human beings are living longer, healthier, and wealthier lives
than ever before. But aren't things bound to get worse? Haven't scientists established that
CO2 is a greenhouse gas with a warming influence on the planet? Yes, but that's only a small part
of the big picture. Although CO2 causes some warming, it's much less significant than we've
been told. Since we started using significant amounts of fossil fuels in the middle of the
19th century, we've increased the percentage of CO2 in the atmosphere from 0.03% to 0.04%,
which correlates with an average temperature increase of about 2 degrees Fahrenheit. It also
correlates with significant global greening, because CO2 is plant food. All of this is far
from unprecedented territory for our planet, which has existed with at least 10 times today's CO2
levels and a 25 degree warmer average temperature. What is truly unprecedented, though, is how safe
we are from climate. The International Disaster Database, a nonpartisan organization that tracks
deaths from climate-related causes, such as extreme heat, floods, storms, and drought,
shows that such deaths have been plummeting as CO2 emissions have been rising. How is this possible?
Because of the fossil fuel energy that emitted the CO2, which has empowered us to climate-proof
our environment with heating, air conditioning, sturdy buildings, mass irrigation, and weather
warning systems. Fossil fuel energy has not taken a naturally safe climate and made it
unnaturally dangerous. It's taken our naturally dangerous climate and made it unnaturally safe.
Fossil fuels are not an existential threat. They are an existential resource because they
increase something much more important than the level of CO2 in the atmosphere. The level of human
empowerment, increased life expectancy, income, health, leisure time, and education are all tightly
linked to increased access to fossil fuels. Does this mean that we shouldn't look for lower carbon
energy alternatives? Of course not. But the alternatives should lead us toward more abundant,
more reliable power, not less. The most promising form of alternative energy
is not unreliable solar and wind, but reliable carbon-free nuclear energy. Sweden gets 40%
of its electricity from nuclear, France over 70%. While nuclear energy is smeared as unsafe,
it has actually been demonstrated by study after study to be the safest form of energy ever created.
And yet, Green New Deal proponents, who say that we have 12 years to save the planet from
rising CO2 levels, vigorously oppose nuclear, in addition to all fossil fuel use. By opposing
every affordable, abundant, reliable form of energy, the Green New Deal won't protect us from
an existential threat. It is an existential threat. I'm Alex Epstein, author of The Moral
Case for Fossil Fuels, for Prager University. Have you ever heard of unobtainium? It's the
magical energy mineral found on the planet Pandora in the movie Avatar. It's a fantasy,
in a science fiction script. But environmentalists think they found it here on Earth in the form of
wind and solar power. They think all the energy we need can be supplied by building enough wind
and solar farms, and enough batteries. The simple truth is that we can't. Nor should we want to,
not if our goal is to be good stewards of the planet. To understand why, consider some simple
physics realities that aren't being talked about. All sources of energy have limits that can't be
exceeded. The maximum rate at which the sun's photons can be converted to electrons is about
33 percent. Our best solar technology is at 26 percent efficiency. For wind, the maximum capture
is 60 percent. Our best machines are at 45 percent. So we're pretty close to wind and solar
limits. Despite PR claims about big gains coming, there just aren't any possible. And wind and solar
only work when the wind blows and the sun shines, but we need energy all the time. The solution,
we're told, is to use batteries. Again, physics and chemistry make this very hard to do. Consider
the world's biggest battery factory, the one Tesla built in Nevada. It would take 500 years
for that factory to make enough batteries to store just one day's worth of America's electricity
needs. This helps explain why wind and solar currently still supply less than three percent
of the world's energy, after 20 years and billions of dollars in subsidies.
Putting aside the economics, if your motive is to protect the environment,
you might want to rethink wind, solar, and batteries because, like all machines, they're
built from non-renewable materials. Consider some sobering numbers. A single electric car battery
weighs about half a ton. Fabricating one requires digging up, moving, and processing more than 250
tons of earth somewhere on the planet. Building a single 100 megawatt wind farm can power 75,000
homes. It requires some 30,000 tons of iron ore and 50,000 tons of concrete, as well as 900 tons
of non-recyclable plastics for the huge blades. To get the same power from solar, the amount of
cement, steel, and glass needed is 150 percent greater. Then there's the other minerals needed,
including elements known as rare earth metals. With current plans, the world will need an
incredible 200 to 2,000 percent increase in mining for elements such as cobalt, lithium,
and dysprosium, to name just a few. Where is all this stuff going to come from? Massive new mining
operations, almost none of it in America, some imported from places hostile to America,
and some places we all want to protect. Australia's Institute for Sustainable Futures
cautions that a global gold rush for energy materials will take miners into
remote wilderness areas that have maintained high biodiversity because they haven't yet
been disturbed. And who's doing the mining? Let's just say that they're not all going to be union
workers with union protections. Amnesty International paints a disturbing picture.
The marketing of state-of-the-art technologies are a stark contrast to the children carrying
bags of rocks. And then the mining itself requires massive amounts of conventional energy,
as do the energy-intensive industrial processes needed to refine the materials
and then build the wind, solar, battery hardware. Then there's the waste. Wind turbines,
solar panels, and batteries have a relatively short life, about 20 years. Conventional energy
machines like gas turbines last twice as long. With current plans, the International Renewable
Energy Agency calculates that by 2050 the disposal of worn-out solar panels will constitute over
double the tonnage of all of today's global plastic waste. Worn-out wind turbines and
batteries will add millions of tons more waste. It'll be a whole new environmental challenge.
Before we launch history's biggest increase in mining, dig up millions of acres in pristine
areas, encourage childhood labor, and create epic waste problems, we might want to reconsider our
almost inexhaustible supply of hydrocarbons, the fuels that make our marvelous modern world
possible. And technology is making it easier to acquire and cleaner to use them every day.
The following comparisons are typical and instructive. It costs about the same to
drill one oil well as it does to build one giant wind turbine. And while that turbine
generates the energy equivalent of about one barrel of oil per hour, the oil rig produces
10 barrels per hour. Costs less than 50 cents to store a barrel of oil or its equivalent natural
gas. But you need $200 worth of batteries to hold the energy contained in one oil barrel.
Next time someone tells you that wind, solar, and batteries are the magical solution for all
our energy needs, ask them if they have an idea of the cost to the environment.
Unobtainium works fine in the movies, but we don't live in the movies. We live in the real world.
I'm Mark Mills, senior follow at the Manhattan Institute for Prager University.
Like the fair-minded progressive that I was, I thought a $15 minimum wage was an absolute good.
Then I had a head-on collision with reality. It's a funny thing about reality. It just is.
You can't wish it away. So here is my cautionary tale. For over three decades, I had a good job
working as a server. I have worked in some amazing, award-winning restaurants in Seattle.
I enjoyed the work, met wonderful people, and I was making really good money. I wasn't making
much per hour, that's true. But in my business, the magic is in tips. On a typical night, I would
make on average $25 to $50 an hour. Believe me, I earned it. I took pride in my work. I wanted
every dining experience to be a memorable one for my guests. I also loved my job for this reason.
I had flexibility. I could plan my work schedule. That was very important to me because I had a
growing son. It was a good life. Then, in 2015, the Seattle City Council raised the minimum wage
from $9.47 to $15 an hour, a 58% hike. Great for the working stiff, right? Well, hang on,
because here comes Mr. Reality. The business owner, the person who signs the checks,
has to find a way to pay for this massive new expense. For Walmart or Microsoft or a large
restaurant chain, this might not be a problem. For a local restaurant owner, it's a nightmare.
Contrary to popular opinion, most restaurants don't have big profit margins. In fact,
most are razor thin. Seattle restaurant owners, faced with this shock to their bottom line,
raised prices, reworked their menus, and created new compensation models. Some did away with tips
altogether, substituting a flat service charge as a way of navigating the climbing wage.
That change in the tipping model caused a dent in my pocketbook. The rise in the wage did not
cover the loss of tips. And, of course, they cut back on employee hours and support staff, too.
But for many establishments, none of these cost-saving measures worked. Restaurants,
some that had been in business for decades, many family-owned, closed, including the ones I worked
for. Good servers don't grow on trees, and I was able to score an interview at another amazing
restaurant. Then, before I could even confirm the interview, that one closed, too. Same reason.
The $15 minimum wage cut their profits down to nothing. So let me add this up for you.
I make a lot less money now than I did before Seattle decided to do what was supposedly in
I used to be able to pay my bills as they came due. Now it's a juggling act. I used to have
enough money to support my son's extracurricular activities. Now I often just say no. Before the
minimum wage increase, I had one job and worked four days a week. After the wage hike, I had two
jobs and worked six. With my skills and a tipping culture, I used to average 18 to 20 percent or
Now, instead of tips, I get a flat 14 percent, part of the 20 percent service charge the restaurant
owner taxed on the bill. I still pride myself in providing good service, but the incentive to go
the extra mile is gone. There is no way to maximize my income. And what's Seattle's answer
to my problem? To raise the minimum wage again. The progressive idea is that you should be able
to make a fair wage. But if you have no job or are working more for less, how is that fair?
How is it fair to my friend who worked his way up from Busboy to Sommelier, the fancy name for the
person who manages a restaurant's wine list? He lost his job when his restaurant closed due to
the minimum wage increase. Or my former boss who went from a cook to an owner and couldn't survive
the double blow of the minimum wage law and the coronavirus. And it's not just a Seattle problem.
In New York City, raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour pushed the restaurant industry into a
recession. To stay afloat, 75 percent of owners reduced employee hours and 47 percent eliminated
jobs. San Francisco is in the same boat. Mandating minimum wage laws might be a winner for progressive
politicians and ivory tower economists, but it's a loser for those of us who have to live with the
consequences. Unless fair-minded people speak out, those consequences only figure to get worse as
more states and maybe even the federal government succumb to the false promise of raising the
minimum wage. I'm Simone Barron with the Full Service Workers Alliance for Prager University.
All labor has dignity and the way that we give labor dignity is by paying people the respect
and the value that they are worth at minimum. Progressive politicians love to talk about
raising the minimum wage. It makes them sound caring, compassionate, concerned. They're on the
side of the worker standing against a greedy employer. The current call is for a national $15
an hour minimum wage, more than double the current federal rate of $7.25. We have to make
one fair wage and we have to raise the national minimum wage to $15 an hour, nothing less.
The left casts the minimum wage debate as a war between employee and employer. It's not a job,
it's indentured servitude. But most business owners pay their workers as much as they can.
Finding and keeping good people is the hardest part of any employer's job. If we adopt a national
minimum wage of $15, here's what will happen. A lot of people will lose their jobs or have
their hours reduced. According to a 2014 Congressional Budget Office study, just a $10
minimum wage would cost half a million jobs as businesses terminate employees. Obviously,
far more jobs would be lost at $15 an hour. To survive, employers would have to reduce hours,
even for workers who manage to keep their jobs. That's a pay cut. It is good for business
everywhere. It's good for small business. It's good for workers. The only thing it's not good
for is the major chain corporations that depend on the exploitation of people. Businesses will close
and the jobs they created will disappear. A recent report from researchers at the Harvard
Business School found that each $1 increase in the minimum wage results in a 4-10% increase
in the likelihood of restaurants closing. An over $7 an hour increase to $15 would be devastating,
not only for restaurants, but for small businesses and their employees. It's good for small business.
It's good for workers. Fewer people will open businesses. $15 an hour is a very steep hill
to climb. Would-be entrepreneurs will do the math on labor costs and realize it's just not
worth the risk. This is a real cost to the economy that we can't measure. A company that never exists
never employs anyone. Most of all, I'm thankful for all of these workers for realizing that
everybody here deserves dignity and everyone here deserves a beautiful life and the ability
to raise your family. If a $15 minimum wage doesn't help workers and doesn't help employers,
who exactly does it help? Well, maybe just the progressive politicians who manage to mislead
voters into believing that it's the right thing to do. Sounding caring, compassionate, and concerned
is all well and good, but having a job is better. I'm Andy Puzder for Prager University.
The immigration battle is at a boiling point over children being separated from parents,
and the current administration is using different tactics to sort of justify what's happening.
Family separation is perhaps the most emblematic moment of his presidency so far. It was cruel,
sloppy, needless, racist, and ultimately exactly what we should have expected.
Images of families being forcibly separated at the U.S.-Mexico border and
immigrant children laying in cages is nothing short of horrific. Parents and children aren't
just being separated at the border, you know, they're being separated throughout this country
by ICE. Yes. I think we need to abolish ICE, that seems really clear. Border Patrol came out with
stats saying that one-third of the children that they tested that are brought to the border in
family units are not biologically related to the people claiming to be their family members. That
is horrifying. I would hands down rather have a child separated from someone claiming to be their
parent until they are biologically proved to be related to that person because of the fact that
sex trafficking exists. It is irresponsible for people to say that we need to reunite families
because of this reasoning. I cannot harp to you how dangerous it is for these kids. These kids
don't choose to be in this circumstance. They're innocent in this. But if we're not protecting them
through our legislative policies, then we're part of the problem and I will never back down
from that stance. Every sensible immigration policy has two objectives. One, to regain control
of our borders so that we decide who enters. And two, to find a humane way to deal with the
11 million illegal immigrants who now live among us. Start with the second. For both practical and
moral reasons, America cannot and will not and should not expel 11 million people. That leaves
us with two choices. Ignore them or figure out a way to legalize them. Ignoring them hasn't worked,
but there's also a huge problem with legalization. It creates an irresistible incentive
for new illegal immigrants to come. We say, of course, that this would be the very last,
very final, never again, we're not kidding this time, amnesty. And everyone knows it's phony.
That's what was said in 1986 when we passed the Simpson-Mazzoli immigration reform.
It turned out to be the largest legalization program in American history. Nearly 3 million
people got permanent residency. There was no enforcement. We now have 11 million new illegal
immigrants in our midst. The irony of this whole debate, which bitterly splits the country,
is that there is a silver bullet that would not just solve the problem, but also create
a national consensus behind it. A vast number of Americans who oppose legalization and fear
new waves of immigration would change their minds if we could radically reduce new, i.e. future,
illegal immigration. And we can. First, build a barrier. Call it a wall, call it a fence,
call it what you will. Add cameras and sensors, add drones, beef up the patrols. All that matters
is that we regain control of the border. Fences work. The triple fence outside San Diego
led to a 90% reduction in infiltration. Israel's border fence with the West Bank
produced a similar decline. Even holier-than-thou Europeans have conceded the point. Hungary,
Macedonia, Bulgaria, Austria, Greece, Spain, why even Norway have all started building
border fences to stem the tide of Middle Eastern refugees? Then enforce two other measures.
A national e-verify system that makes it just about impossible to work if you're here illegally,
and a functioning visa tracking system. Since 40% of illegal immigrants are visa overstays,
the wall fence will, of course, be ugly. So are the concrete barriers to keep truck bombs
from driving into the White House. Sometimes function has to supersede form. And don't tell
me that this is our Berlin Wall. When you build a wall to keep people in, that's a prison. When
you build a wall to keep people out, that's an expression of sovereignty. Of course, no barrier
will be foolproof, but it doesn't have to be. It simply has to reduce the river to a manageable
trickle. Once we do, everything becomes possible, including dealing with our 11 million illegal
immigrants. So let's fix that. Track the visas, do e-verify, build a damn barrier. It's ridiculous
to say that it can't be done. And who would certify that the border is back in our control?
I would have a neutral party, perhaps a commission of retired jurists, issue the judgment. Once they
do, we legalize the 11 million, granting them the right to stay and work here. We can't give them
citizenship. That's a bridge too far. You don't get to join the political destiny of the country
by entering it illegally. But any children born here would be American,
which means that over time, the issue resolves itself. The American people are legitimately
angry at the price American society has paid due to illegal immigration. But they are also
a generous people. Once they're assured that we do indeed control our borders, that anger will abate.
A national consensus will emerge. Radical border control followed by radical legalization.
No mushy compromise. A solution requires two acts of national will, putting up a wall along
with e-verify and visa tracking, and absorbing those who broke our laws to come to America.
This is not a compromise meant to appease both sides without achieving anything. It's not some
piece of hybrid legislation that arbitrarily divides illegals into those with five-year-old
roots in America and those without, or some such mischief-making nonsense. If we do it right,
not only will we solve the problem, we will get it done as one nation.
I'm Charles Krauthammer for Prager University.
We will keep this promise to the American people. If you like your doctor,
you will be able to keep your doctor, period. If you like your healthcare plan,
you'll be able to keep your healthcare plan, period.
We weren't as clear as we needed to be in terms of the changes that were taking place. And I am
sorry that they are finding themselves in this situation based on assurances they got from me.
It's very easy for a politician to stand up before voters and say healthcare is a right,
and then passionately advocate for single-payer or free healthcare or Medicare for all,
whatever term they might use. But before we consider the merits of the government managing
your healthcare, and that's what this all boils down to, maybe we should ask a more basic question.
What do we mean by healthcare? Because if you get sick, and here we're talking major illness or
you're in serious pain, you don't just want healthcare. You want quality healthcare. And
where is your best chance of finding that? The answer is right here in America. For skilled
doctors, cutting-edge medical treatments, and care without long delays, no other country rivals
the United States. Not even close. Nobody from Texas is going to Canada for medical treatment.
It's almost always the other way around. Sure, our healthcare system has lots of issues,
and we should address them. But do we really want to upend all the advantages that we do have and
start from scratch? Because that's what would have to happen if we completely turn healthcare
over to the government. So let's imagine we make the change. We hear a lot about how great free
healthcare would be, but it's only fair we look at the downside. The first is that government-run
healthcare takes medical decisions away from patients—that means you—and puts them in the
hands of bureaucrats. They decide, for example, how many MRI machines are going to be available,
or under what conditions you can get back surgery, or a bypass, or even whether you qualify for
cancer treatment. That's how it works in the United Kingdom, under its single-payer system.
Because it has finite resources, the National Health Service, or NHS, sharply restricts access
to treatments like hip and knee replacements, cataract surgery, and even prescription drugs
to deal with common conditions like arthritis and diabetes. If you suffer from any of these
ailments—and many others in the UK—you may just have to live with the pain. And let's hope you
don't have a medical emergency. In a January 2018 article in the New York Times, patients in
emergency rooms around London are described as having to wait 12 hours before they are tended to.
Corridors are jammed with beds carrying the frail and elderly. To deal with the situation,
hospitals were ordered to postpone non-urgent surgeries until the end of the month. That hardly
seems like an improvement over what we have in the U.S. A second big problem with single-payer
systems is that they are expensive. Really expensive. A recent study by the Mercatus
Center at George Mason University found that a Bernie Sanders-style Medicare-for-all health system
would cost a tidy $32.6 trillion over 10 years. That's on top of what the federal government
spends on health care today. And this is not a new number. Other studies have found the cost
to be roughly in the same range. So how would we pay for it? Kenneth Thorpe, a professor at
Emory University and health policy official in the Clinton administration, spells it out.
If you are going to go in this direction—Medicare-for-all—the tax increases are going
to be enormous. Not just for the rich, Thorpe estimates, but for working Americans and the poor,
too. Charles Blauhaus, the author of the Mercatus study, puts it this way.
Even a doubling of all projected individual and corporate income taxes would be insufficient to
finance these added federal costs. And he considers that a conservative estimate.
Canada knows all about exploding health care costs. In Ontario, the country's biggest province,
those costs took up 46 percent of its entire budget in 2010. By 2030, that number is projected
to be 80 percent. In other words, in a few years, Ontario will have little money to pay for anything
except health care. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, government-run systems depress
the search for new cures. Biomedical research spending in the U.S. far outpaces that of any
country with nationalized health care, even when you account for differences in population or size
of economies. That's one reason medical breakthroughs rarely come from countries
where the government controls health care. They come from the United States, where the government
doesn't. The lion's share of biomedical research and development spending in the U.S., over $70
billion in 2012, comes from the private sector. Discovering new medical cures and technology is
a profitable business. And thank goodness it is. Those profits drive innovation. Take away the
profits, and you will surely take away the innovation. Single payer, free health care,
Medicare for all, they might sound great. But like all visions of utopia, they ultimately produce
a lot more harm than good. I'm Lon He Chen, fellow at the Hoover Institution at Stanford
for Prager University. There's two arguments, right? One argument is we need to keep going,
protect the weak, protect the sick, but let's open up the economy. The other argument is
stop placing money over human lives, and let's shelter in place until we come up with some sort
of a decision, and let's figure out some way to develop some sort of a universal income,
universal basic income plan or something like that to feed people during this time.
This notion, though, that you can just sort of send checks out to everybody and things will be
fine is not true, obviously. Some people have this absurd view that the economy is like some magic
horn of plenty. It just makes stuff. There's a magic horn of plenty, the goods and services,
they just come from this magic horn of plenty. If somebody has more stuff than somebody else,
it's because they took more from this magic horn of plenty. Now let me just break it to
the fools out there. If you don't make stuff, there's no stuff. You can't just
legislate money and solve these things. If you don't make stuff, there is no stuff.
Now Los Angeles, we have over 50% of the people who live here are now unemployed,
over 50% unemployment. That is ridiculous. How do we fix that?
Well, there's no way to fix it by the government doing another round of stimulus. The only way to
fix it is getting people back working again. Our economy, our modern day economy, with the amount
of leverage we have in the system, that means the amount of debt that we have in our country,
can't absorb just everybody sitting idly. It's very hard just to flip the switch back on and
have everything resume like it was prior. We have to get back to work. We have to get our economy
going. Thank you all for being here today. I'm Dr. Bob Hamilton. I'm a pediatrician from Santa
Monica, California. I've been in private practice there for 36 years. Today I have good news for
you. The good news is that children, as a general rule, are taking this virus very, very well. Few
are getting infected. Those who are getting infected are being hospitalized in low numbers.
And fortunately, the mortality rate of children is about one-fifth of 1%. So kids are tolerating
the infection very frequently. They're actually asymptomatic. I also want to say that children
are not the drivers of this pandemic. People were worried about initially if children were
going to actually be the ones to push the infection along. The very opposite is happening.
Kids are tolerating it very well. They're not passing it on to their parents. They're not
passing it on to their teachers. Dr. Mark Woolhouse from Scotland, who is a pediatric infectious
disease specialist and epidemiologist, said the following. He said there has not been one
documented case of COVID being transferred from a student to a teacher in the world.
In the world. I think that is important that all of us who are here today realize that our kids
are not really the ones who are driving the infection. It is being driven by older individuals.
And yes, we can send the kids back to school, I think, without fear. And this is the big issue
right now. As Congressman Norman alluded to, this is the really important thing we need to do. We
need to normalize the lives of our children. How do we do that? We do that by getting them back
in the classroom. And the good news is they're not driving this infection at all. Yes,
we can use security measures. Yes, we can be careful. I'm all for that. We all are. But I
think the important thing is we need to not act out of fear. We need to act out of science. We
need to do it. We need to get it done. What's up, guys? This is Will with PragerU back on the
streets on Hollywood Boulevard today talking to people about coronavirus deaths and what they
actually know about it. Let's do it. There are 350 million people in America. What percentage
would you say of those people have died of COVID-19? 14 to 21 percent. 14 to 21? I was
going to say 15. One percent. Yeah. One percent. Yeah. Would it shock you if I told you it was
0.056 percent? Really? Wow. These are from the CDC. Does that shock you at all? I mean,
that number is a lot smaller than I thought. You know how many children in California have died
from COVID? You have to guess. Probably a couple of thousands. Maybe a couple hundred. I don't
think that many. How many people do you think under the age of 25 have died from COVID in America?
Total number of people. 40,000. 40,000. 10,000. 10,000? Is 360 people under the age of 25 have
died from coronavirus? Two children in all of California. Damn, that's... I mean, that...
How many do you think is the percentage of people who have died from COVID that are above 55 years
old? 30 percent. I would say between 20 to 25 percent. 92 percent of all COVID deaths are over
the age of 55. Oh, damn. See what I'm saying? No elderly people. Where are you a nurse at?
In Indiana. Okay. Yeah. Are you seeing a lot of COVID patients come in there?
Somewhat. Our numbers are spiking back up, but the ICU beds aren't full, so we're happy,
and we're not seeing as many deaths. Were they ever full? No, they were never full.
Is that surprising? I wasn't surprised, no. I feel like it can be over-exaggerated a little bit.
Only 6 percent of COVID deaths were actually caused by COVID just alone? That all the other
94 percent of people had pre-existing conditions before? Yeah, I didn't know that, but I did read
some article that hospitals have an incentive to call it a COVID death, so they get more funding
from the states and the federal government. Yes, they do. And any death of anyone is sad.
But we're closing down all the schools in California because of two deaths of children
in the state. Do you think that that's a fair thing to do? Hell no. No, I don't.
Me, I don't think, and I say it in my state too, that we should necessarily shut down the schools,
because I feel like that the more kids are exposed to the virus, the better their chances are.
It helps boost the immune system, so for me, that's a plus for them to go to school.
Why do you think people don't hear about these kind of things?
Media hype, you know, media these days, fake news, whatever, they want to, you know,
scare people, you know, who knows? Over a 99 percent survival rate of the virus, so.
Yeah, I'm more worried about the flu, you know what I mean, or being run over by a bus crossing
Hollywood Boulevard, you know what I mean? Struck by lightning, to be honest.
Yeah, and we don't get much lightning out here, you know what I mean?
Of course, any deaths are sad, but the way that the media is portraying it and the politicians are
makes it seem like this is the end of the world for us, which I think is a bad precedent,
except for Americans today. And that's where I think the
control thing comes in. I think they're setting us up for a big failure later on,
saying, lock it down again. Just conditioning us for something.
I don't know what it is, but I think there's just more behind it.
The next thing you know, your gun rights are gone, you can't leave the house without an okay,
you're waiting in a bread line, you know what I mean?
Why do you think things are still continuing to be shut down and schools closing and things like
that? I think it's a political ploy for power
to keep us in line. I was just tired of getting told to have
to wear a mask everywhere I go. Obviously, me wearing a mask for three
feet isn't going to stop the spread. As soon as I get to the table, I'm going to take it off.
It just makes no sense to me. I get some regulations, you know,
washing your hands, doing this, keeping your distance, whatever, I'll do that. But I just
think that's overboard. You're not doing anything but causing inconvenience at this point.
It's destroying small businesses in this country. I mean, the big corporations like Target and
Walmart, they're fine. Small businesses, they're all shutting down and that's because of these
elitists who are doing this. Yeah.
So I was actually pretty surprised at the answers we got today. It turns out not everyone is a sheep,
not everyone listens to the mainstream media and what the left has to say. Of course,
all the deaths from COVID are sad and terrible deaths, but we should not keep our country
locked down. We need to open things back up. Thank you guys so much for watching this video.
This has been Will Will with PragerU. Make sure you share this video, comment your thoughts down
below. See you in the next one. Peace. Like coronavirus?
I have no idea what coronavirus is. You just wear the mask for fun?
No, because I need braces. You need braces? Oh, fair enough.
They have no facts. They don't do any research. They don't do any type of higher learning when
it comes to what they believe. All they know is what the media narrative tells them to believe
and that's all they parrot. The organization is fake. I personally believe that the BLM movement
is fake. It has nothing to do with advancing the lives of black people.
They actually say they want to break up the family home.
Exactly. Their main goal is to break up the patriarchal nuclear family. They want the men
removed out of the family, which is what Democrats want also. If BLM really cared about black lives,
why would it be solely isolated to incidents where a black life is taken at the hands of a
white cop? That happens less than 1%. Now, wait, wait, wait. Now, I like to equate this to,
it's the same as if I was in a horrific accident. I have a massive head wound. I have a leg fracture
and a scratch on my finger and here come the first responders and they want to tend to the
scratch on my finger and I'm telling you, what about the wound on my head? What about my fractured
leg? That's what the BLM movement is. They're tending to the scratch on my finger and that's
not even what it's about. If you want to help us, let us tell you how you can help us. Don't
come in and tell us how you want to help us and don't tell me that I'm oppressed because I'm not
oppressed. I'm a black American. I'm a proud black American. I'm not oppressed. I'm not oppressed.
I'm one of the freest persons on this world. Kneel for no man. I only kneel to God. As you can see,
as you can see, black conservatism is the new punk rock. You know what I mean?
We're the rebel. You want to be cool? Come join our cause, baby.
What are the five biggest issues facing blacks in America? Here's my list.
Problem number five, the victim mentality. Nothing holds someone back more than seeing
himself as a victim. Why? Because the victim is not responsible for his situation.
Everything is someone else's fault and the victim sees little chance of improving his life.
How can he get ahead if someone is holding him back? All this makes the victim unhappy, frustrated,
and angry. This is how too many blacks see themselves, as victims. So much so that their
victim status becomes their primary identity and their ruling ideology. I call it victimology.
Unfortunately, many black churches preach this victimology. Many black parents pass it on to
their children. Inner-city schools teach it to their students and the black media reinforce it.
Meanwhile, the NAACP and other black grievance groups fundraise on it. Problem number four,
lack of diversity. Blacks repeatedly demand an honest dialogue or debate about race,
but how can there ever be an honest dialogue about race between blacks and whites when there
is virtually no honest dialogue between blacks and blacks? It's hypocritical. And if a black
doesn't think whites are ultimately responsible for black people's problems, they're labeled a
sellout, Uncle Tom, or race traitor. As long as this type of group think exists, race reverence
of the Al Sharpton, Jesse Jackson type will continue to be celebrated while independent
black thinkers such as Professors Thomas Sowell and Walter Williams will be shunned. The honest
race dialogue and debate that first has to happen is not between blacks and whites, but between
blacks and blacks. We demand diversity from others, but need to practice it ourselves where
it really matters, in thought, opinion, and even political affiliation. Problem number three,
urban terrorism. As just about everyone knows, but too few talk about publicly,
in majority black cities, violent black-on-black crime is rampant. A Department of Justice study
from 1980 through 2008 revealed that blacks accounted for almost half of the nation's
homicide victims, 47.4%, and more than half of the offenders, 52.4%, all while being 13%
of America's population. The Tuskegee Institute conducted a study of all known lynchings of blacks
that occurred between 1882 through 1968. During this 86-year span, which is essentially the post-
Civil War era up to the Civil Rights era, 3,446 blacks were reportedly lynched. Presently,
black-on-black murder eclipses the number of blacks lynched over the course of 80 years,
roughly every six months. Unbelievably, the culpability for this disproportionate amount
of mayhem actually lies with the menacing 2-3% minority within the black populace.
I call them urban terrorists. And since they are literally spawned from problem number two,
the black community protects them. Problem number two, proliferation of baby mamas.
The disintegration of the nuclear family has led to an astronomical increase of single-mother
households. According to the Moynihan Report, in 1965, nearly 25% of black children were born
to unwed mothers. The report's author, Daniel Patrick Moynihan, said this was a disaster in
the making. He was, of course, vilified by so-called black leaders and their progressive allies.
But he was right. Today, the out-of-wedlock birth rate is nearly 75%, and even higher in
some urban areas. To be clear, baby daddies share this responsibility with baby mamas.
Yet, while baby daddies are blamed and rarely shown compassion, baby mamas are rarely blamed
and receive both compassion and support. This lopsided dynamic and the previously listed
pathologies stem directly from the number one problem facing the black community.
Problem number one, unquestioning allegiance to so-called progressive policies. Unwavering
loyalty to progressive liberal policies is the primary reason these dire conditions persist.
It both makes them possible and perpetuates them. It's no coincidence that progressivism
is the common thread that binds predominantly black cities where single-parent homes,
failing schools, rampant poverty, and crime predominate. Look at cities like Detroit,
Philadelphia, and Baltimore. They've been run by progressive Democrats for decades.
If their liberal policies were at all effective, these cities should have become models of economic
growth and prosperity. Instead, they're models of dysfunction. By fostering and exploiting the
victim mentality, discouraging self-examination, subsidizing baby mamas, and making excuses for
black thugs, so-called progressive policies don't alleviate the problems that afflict the black
community. They aggravate those problems. You may have noticed that racism did not make the list.
Why not? It's simple. There will be no solution to the problems afflicting black America
until more blacks recognize that the issues plaguing our community are ultimately self-inflicted.
Does racism exist? Sure. But there are other problems far more serious. And waiting until
there are no more races will mean waiting and making excuses forever.
I'm Talib Starks for Prager University.
Please consider making a tax-deductible donation.
