Episode 1 | Father Wants Us Dead, season 2: UNCLE PAUL | A true crime podcast series

NJ.com
NJ.com
99 followers
1 Video View·Nov 12, 2026

In 2018, firefighters responded to a burning mansion in Colts Neck, one of New Jersey's most exclusive communities. They made a shocking discovery: A family of four had been massacred. And not by a stranger, but by a loved one.
---------------------
Father Wants Us Dead — called one of the best true crime podcasts of all time (Entertainment Weekly) — is back with a new season about family murders and the secrets behind them.
Season 2, ‘Uncle Paul,’ investigates the slayings of the Caneiro family: Keith Caneiro, his wife Jennifer, and their kids, Jesse and Sophia. What first appeared to be a tragic mansion fire in affluent horse country turned into one of New Jersey's most shocking murder investigations. We’ll take you inside a world of brotherly love, betrayal, money and murder as we try to answer the question at the heart of this case: Why?

Content warning: Father Wants Us Dead: Uncle Paul deals with violence. Listener discretion is advised.

You can visit FatherWantsUsDead.com for photos, surveillance and body cam videos and other extras. You can email any questions and comments to [email protected].

In this video, photos and videos of the crime scenes are by NJ.com photographers, the Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office and fire investigators. We are grateful to share photos and videos of the late Caneiro family provided by Cortni Burgess, Brian Bott and others. Trial photos are by Asbury Park Press photographers Thomas Costello, Doug Hood and Tanya Breen via pool. Trial video is by Law & Crime via pool.

Father Wants Us Dead is a production of NJ.com and The Star-Ledger.

The podcast is reported, written, produced and hosted by Rebecca Everett, an investigative crime reporter and podcaster. Our executive producers are Christopher Kelly, Jessica Beym, Jeff Roberts, and Jess Mazzola.

The podcast is recorded and mixed by Alex Graves at Sound on Sound Studios in Montclair, New Jersey. James‬‭ Shapiro is our associate audio engineer.‬ Music by Jacob Stone. Sound effects by Triple Scoop Music.

Special thanks to all the sources who agreed to speak with us.

Investigative reporting and projects like these require a lot of resources. If you want to support this kind of journalism, please consider subscribing to NJ.com. But you can also help us by following the show on the platforms below and leave us a review:

Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/father-wants-us-dead/id1621739108

Spotify: ⁠https://open.spotify.com/show/2Jr7PKc0ahznohUWe3lAVO

Please check out our other true crime podcast series:

Someone’s Hunting Us, about a little known serial killer and the girls and women who took him down: www.someoneshuntingus.com

In the Shadow of Princeton, about the cold case murder of the Princeton grande dame, Cissy Stuart: ⁠www.theprincetonmurder.com⁠