Why You Can't Trust the Mainstream Media: A Video Marathon | Marathons

PragerU
800 followers
45 Video Views·Mar 31, 2025
Viewer trust in legacy media is at an all-time low. What's behind this? Is there good reason for it? What have been the media's biggest, most damaging lies? Fifteen 5-Minute Videos explore these questions and more in this specially-curated playlist. Enjoy!
Liberal or conservative, male or female, young or old,
Americans love to bash the news media.
Once among the nation's most trusted institutions,
the news media have fallen from grace.
According to Gallup, even as recently as 2000,
a majority of Americans trusted the press.
By 2015, it had fallen to 40 percent,
and lower than that, 36 percent among those 18 to 49.
It's hard to see how this decline will be reversed.
The industry has become politically polarized,
and in the highly competitive age of multiple 24-hour cable news channels
and the Internet, it's under severe financial pressure.
And this compounds an even deeper problem,
failing journalistic standards.
In the 1950s, the media universe consisted mainly
of a few national television broadcast networks
and local TV and radio stations,
most of which got much of their news from major wire services
and the nation's large newspapers.
Most journalists were committed to producing objective journalism,
fact-based stories independent of the government and of political parties.
A reporter's job was to report, not offer opinion or advocate.
Presented with the facts, it was up to readers
to make their own judgments about news events.
Opinions were supposed to be confined to editorial and op-ed pages.
That world no longer exists.
This lack of objectivity and the decline of standards
is one reason, though not the only one,
why newspapers and news magazines are a declining industry.
According to Pew Research,
print revenue from newspaper sales has declined from $47 billion in 2006
to $16 billion in 2014.
Digital sales haven't come close to making up the difference.
Most papers have been forced to cut operating expenses,
slash staff and close bureaus, overseas in particular.
Ironically, there are more stories than ever to cover
and fewer staff than ever to cover them.
This lack of information from professional journalists
has been filled by a new source, social media and the blogosphere.
When the Iraq War, which I covered for the New York Times, began in 2003,
there were roughly 100,000 bloggers.
Only a few years later, there were an estimated 27 million.
The Internet as a news source has obvious pluses and minuses.
On the plus side is that information is spread widely and instantly.
The minuses have to do with the fact
that the quality of reporting varies dramatically.
It's not easy to separate the wheat from the chaff.
Furthermore, many sites, including mainstream sites,
have abandoned traditional journalistic practices and standards
in search of more and more eyeballs.
Objectivity, once the gold standard of reporting,
is now often seen as old-fashioned.
A ratings loser.
When success is measured mainly in terms of clicks,
the outrageous beats the sober just about every time.
Inserting opinion, even in the middle of a news story,
is a way in which journalists can distinguish themselves.
And in mainstream media outlets,
those opinions overwhelmingly tend to be liberal.
This might not be so bad if journalists acknowledged their bias,
but they almost never do.
Yet the bias is obvious.
According to a 2014 study by two Indiana University professors,
reporters who identify as Democrats
outnumber those who identify as Republicans by 4 to 1,
28% to 7%.
The remaining 65% call themselves independent.
But based on my long experience as a reporter,
this is a fiction.
That is, many reporters like to describe themselves as independent,
but they're not.
Not really.
By any fair measure, this group is overwhelmingly on the political left.
The obvious liberal bias has only served to push conservative readers
to those sources that cater to conservative themes,
further polarizing the media landscape.
And unable to attract conservatives,
the mainstream media have chosen to double down
on views and themes that appeal to their liberal constituency.
To give just one example,
when Fox News broke a story in January 2016
about the discovery of top-secret intelligence
on the private email server that Hillary Clinton used
while Secretary of State,
classified information which she had denied ever having sent or received.
The New York Times buried this news story deep inside the paper.
A decline in reporting standards, a decline in revenue,
an increase in bias have made many wary of the people
who provide them with their news.
A certain amount of skepticism is a healthy thing,
but a thriving democracy depends on a dynamic and free press.
As much as people may like to bash the media,
most people would far prefer to trust it.
I'm Judith Miller,
contributing editor of City Journal for Prager University.
Who's the first woman appointed to the Supreme Court?
My guess is that most Americans would answer Ruth Bader Ginsburg.
She's so famous now that she's often referred to by just her initials, RBG.
Elevated to the high court by President Bill Clinton in 1993,
the left-leaning Justice Ginsburg was the subject of not one,
but two movies in 2018 alone.
But she isn't the first female Supreme Court justice.
She's the second.
The first doesn't have a movie named after her.
That's because Sandra Day O'Connor was appointed by a Republican president,
Ronald Reagan.
We hear a lot about the Year of the Woman,
the Women's March, and the war against women.
But if the major media, the New York Times, the Washington Post,
CNN, CBS, and others were more interested in accuracy than advocacy,
it would be that they are promoting the Year of the Leftist Woman,
or the Leftist Women's March.
The major media like to pretend that all women think alike
and that conservative women are just the exception that proves the rule.
But according to a 2018 Pew Research study,
about a third of women are Democrats,
a little less than a third are Republican,
and a little more than a third are independents.
So if there are all these conservative women around,
how does the media make it seem like they barely exist?
They use three strategies.
The first is omission.
If you don't see something, you don't have to deal with it.
Open up a glossy magazine.
Every liberal woman is glamorized,
stylishly dressed, beautifully photographed.
Their personal stories are almost always an inspirational version of Joan of Arc.
They have overcome overwhelming obstacles
to make the world a more compassionate and tolerant place.
Glamour Magazine recognized 11 Democrat women
among their 2018 Women of the Year.
No Republican made the cut.
First Lady Michelle Obama was on the cover of Vogue three times.
First Lady and former fashion model Melania Trump?
So far, not once.
Every now and again, the major media will do a story
about a female conservative to balance things out.
But let's be honest, it's not balance.
It's tokenism.
The second strategy the media uses to diminish conservative women is mocking.
Making fun of a woman's appearance discounts what she says.
You would think the major media would resist this kind of objectification.
But they don't, not if the target is a conservative woman.
Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the White House press secretary,
and Kellyanne Conway, the first woman to run a winning presidential campaign,
are routinely belittled for their hair, their eye makeup, or their weight.
Their significant accomplishments, in contrast, are rarely acknowledged.
Why? Because the media doesn't like their boss,
and it treats women who work for him as traitors to their sex.
The third strategy the media uses to demean conservative women is labeling.
Using stereotypes precludes there being a valid reason
for conservative women to hold the positions they do.
The major media simply can't accept that conservatives
have serious and important reasons for their beliefs.
So they have to come up with answers to explain this seeming anomaly to themselves.
These women must be racist, or self-hating, or just weak-minded.
Here's how Barbara Streisand put it to the Daily Mail in England.
A lot of women vote the way their husbands vote.
They don't believe enough in their own thoughts.
Labeling, like the strategies of mocking or omission,
is just another way to display contempt and demonize conservative women.
Its purpose is to persuade you to not treat those being labeled with respect,
to ignore their ideas, and to even avoid associating with them.
Not surprisingly, the vilification that results
discourages a lot of conservative-leaning women from running for political office,
or even from speaking up.
Who needs that grief?
It takes a strong person to swim against the media tide.
But here's the thing about swimming against the tide.
It makes you stronger.
Maybe that's why Nikki Haley can stand up in the UN and tell the truth.
Or why Candace Owens can question the devotion to progressive policies
that have so hurt blacks.
Or Ayaan Hirsi Ali can take on the cause of truly oppressed women,
those living in radical Islamist societies.
We need these voices, and more like them.
That's why it's so important to encourage a more respectful, inclusive debate.
We should want everyone at the table, both sides of the political spectrum,
listening with civility.
That way we can be better informed and make better decisions.
So if you hold conservative views, you have a particularly important role to play.
You need to speak out to your friends, your family, and your co-workers.
Let them hear your thinking, and then let them make up their own minds.
The media may pretend you don't exist.
They may even mock or label you.
They want to intimidate you into silence.
That's not fair, and that's not right.
Don't let them.
You've probably heard a lot of people recently screaming and yelling about fake news.
Charges fly from all points on the political spectrum.
This story is mistaken. It's fake news.
That statement is incorrect. It's fake news.
But to my mind, these arguments miss the point.
Mainstream American news is all fake,
because the major news outlets are so consistently biased toward the left
that whether any given story they report is factual or not,
their overall reportage is essentially leftist propaganda.
You can complain about the right-wing slant of Fox News all you want,
but left-wing ABC, CBS, NBC, MSNBC, and CNN have combined almost ten times the viewers.
Look, the chief journalist at ABC is former Clinton operative George Stephanopoulos,
the president of CBS News is David Rhodes, the brother of a former senior Obama staffer,
Comcast, which owns NBC, is run by a major Democrat donor,
same for the leadership at CBS, and Time Warner, which owns CNN.
Only 7% of American journalists identify as Republican.
And while a lot of news outlets forbid their reporters to donate to candidates,
96% of those who did donate last time out gave to Hillary Clinton.
These journalists claim that despite the fact they're all Democrats, they can be objective.
It just ain't so.
Psychologists have shown that when people associate almost exclusively with those who agree with them,
they suffer from groupthink and confirmation bias and lose their ability to see events clearly.
Now, it's not that these journalists are liars, exactly.
It's that their bias skews their reporting in very specific ways.
Let me give you Andrew Klavan's three rules of mainstream media journalism.
These can transform any story, whether it's true or not, into fake news.
Rule number one.
Whenever left-wing prejudices are confirmed by a single event, that event is treated as representative.
But whenever left-wing prejudices are contradicted by a single event, that event is treated as an isolated incident.
And if you treat it as representative, you are deemed to be hateful.
So, for instance, a white cop shoots a black suspect.
The mainstream media treats that story as representative of general police racism,
even though studies show cops don't use deadly force more often on blacks than on whites.
On the other hand, if a Muslim commits an act of terrorism and someone is bold enough to point out
that the terrorist act is, in fact, representative of the daily acts of Muslim terror around the world,
this is considered Islamophobic.
The leftist media cherry-picks when an event illustrates a larger narrative.
That's fake news.
Rule number two.
When a scandal breaks on the right, the news is the scandal.
When a scandal breaks on the left, the news is who wrongfully disclosed that scandalous information.
Thus, when the media wanted to raise suspicions that Donald Trump was somehow in league with the Russians,
they freely quoted illegally leaked information from intelligence sources.
But when Congressman Devin Nunes announced he had information that the Obama administration
might have misused intelligence against Donald Trump's transition team,
the story became, how did Nunes get that information, and did he do it legally?
The scandal meter is heavily weighted to fall to the right.
Fake news.
Rule number three.
Individual extremists on the right are highlighted, but the overall extremism of the left is ignored.
In one of the fakest fake news stories in recent history, the mainstream media rose up as one
to tar conservative Tea Party members as racist, when all they really wanted were lower taxes
and less government spending.
Reporters gave the Tea Party disparaging nicknames, represented their almost universally peaceful
gatherings as ugly and violent.
And whenever an individual Tea Partier said something wrong, it was cited as evidence
that the movement itself was tainted.
Meanwhile, the continually violent, vandalizing, anti-Semitic socialist movement that went
by the name of Occupy Wall Street was hailed by journalists as an important social development,
right up to the moment it vanished without a trace, except for the piles of litter its
protesters left behind.
Peaceful Tea Partiers wanted the small government prescribed by the Constitution so they were radicals.
Violent Occupiers wanted the widespread government intrusion of socialism so they were heroes.
Very fake news.
Newsweek editor Evan Thomas was once criticized when his magazine essentially convicted some
white Duke University lacrosse players of raping a black woman, a rape it turns out
they did not commit because it didn't happen.
Thomas defended himself, saying,
The narrative was right, but the facts were wrong.
The mainstream media almost always get their left-wing narrative right, whether the facts
support it or not.
That's called confirming your own prejudices.
It's called bias.
It's called fake news.
I'm Andrew Klavan for Prager University.
If you're a movie buff, you've probably seen a picture of a director, thumbs joined
together, index fingers forming a square, showing the camera operator how to frame the
shot.
The camera can't see everything, right?
The art of directing is framing every shot so the audience sees exactly what the director
wants them to see.
We all do something like this in making arguments, whether personal or political.
It's not necessarily a bad thing—we only have so much time to make our points—but
there is a downside.
Often, arguments end up unfairly skewed by the information they include or leave out.
If you understand how framing works, you'll have a better chance of seeing through weak
arguments and appreciating good ones.
Let's look at some examples.
Take socialism.
Socialism is enjoying renewed popularity, especially among young people.
Why is this?
Given the failure of the socialist model in places like the former Soviet Union, Cuba
and Venezuela?
The answer is that socialism has been very cleverly framed by its proponents.
Socialism, we are told, is morally superior because it makes people more equal.
Those who have more than their fair share have to give it back.
What could possibly be wrong with leveling the playing field?
Who's against equality?
When framed that way, socialism is made to seem the only moral choice.
So, if you're opposed to it, you're framed as regressive, selfish, and pretty much a jerk.
Another example of framing is the issue of religious freedom.
The American Civil Liberties Union website says that the free exercise clause of the
First Amendment gives you the right to worship, or not, as you choose.
The government can't penalize you because of your religious beliefs.
It sounds good, but only because of the framing.
The Constitution doesn't speak about the right to worship and to hold beliefs.
Those are a given.
The Constitution specifically defends the free exercise of religion.
And that means freedom to act on your religious beliefs and not to be forced to violate them.
And that also includes the right to influence others, just as secular people can.
Yet people who want to exercise their religion in these ways are framed as bigots.
Martin Castro, former chair of the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights for the Obama administration,
wrote that religious freedom is a code word for discrimination, intolerance, racism, sexism,
homophobia, and Islamophobia.
So, even if courts uphold your religious freedom, you're still a hater.
Speaking of hate, hate speech is another example of framing.
Hate speech is not free speech, is a common refrain on college campuses.
And what counts as hate speech?
Whatever people who say hate speech is not free speech find hateful.
And that number is growing at an alarming pace, according to several recent studies.
There are many other examples.
People who question climate change policies are framed as science deniers.
People who oppose abortion, even late-term abortion and a healthy pregnancy,
are framed as waging a war on women.
So, how does someone who wants to present the other side of these arguments deal with this framing tactic?
First, reject biased framing.
Now that you know what framing is, you'll be able to spot it.
That's half the battle.
Say something like, do you think that's the whole story?
Let me suggest another way of looking at it.
Second, get yourself up to speed on the big issues.
Don't expect someone else to fight your battles.
Read up. Memorize some bullet points.
You know what they're going to say.
You hear their arguments all day in the major media and in your classrooms.
But here's where you have an edge.
It is unlikely they've ever heard your arguments.
You might be surprised what happens when they do.
Third, set some basic ground rules.
Bury the insults. No name-calling.
General statements are fine, but they need to be backed up with examples.
Make it clear that you're prepared to hear their arguments.
In turn, they have to commit to hear yours.
And then, may the best argument win.
If nobody budges, that's fine.
You've had a respectful exchange of ideas.
If nothing else, that's a victory for civil discourse, and we certainly could use more of that.
Just don't forget to look out for biased frames.
They're great for making movies, but not for finding truth.
I'm Jeff Myers, President of Summit Ministries, for Prager University.
The Communist government of the former Soviet Union thought that by controlling access to information,
they could keep their citizens in line.
Consistent with the Orwellian nature of the Soviet Union, the country's most important newspaper was Pravda.
Pravda is the Russian word for truth.
But Pravda was not truth.
It was full of lies.
But here's the thing.
Almost no one in the Soviet Union was fooled.
They knew they were being lied to.
Ironically, unlike most citizens in the Soviet Union, citizens in 21st century America are fooled by their news media.
We think we're getting the real story from our major media, but we're not.
When we tune into the networks or read the New York Times or the Washington Post,
we're actually getting a sharply slanted version of the news.
Slanted to the left.
This should deeply concern people on both sides of the political divide.
To make informed decisions of free society needs a press it can trust, not one that is hopelessly biased.
In 2017, Project Veritas sent out undercover reporters to see how committed the major media was to objective news gathering.
Specifically as it regarded the newly elected president, Donald Trump.
Our first report focused on CNN.
A producer there, John Bonifield, acknowledged the lack of evidence for his network's efforts to link the Trump campaign
and the Russian government in a plot to rig the 2016 election.
Bonifield told us,
I think the president is probably right to say, like, look, you are witch hunting me.
You have no smoking gun.
You have no real proof.
So why was CNN so relentless in hammering the Russia collusion narrative?
Ideology, the election wasn't legitimate, and ratings.
As Bonifield noted, the Trump-Russia collusion story was good for business.
Next, we released another series of reports, these on The New York Times.
First, we heard from Nick Dudik, the paper's audience strategy editor.
Dudik told our undercover reporter he was responsible for choosing which New York Times videos go on Facebook, YouTube, and Instagram.
Dudik boasted, my imprint is on every video we do.
And what was that imprint about?
Well, as Dudik, who worked on both the Obama and Hillary Clinton campaigns, told our reporter,
he hoped to use his position to make the president's life as difficult as possible.
I will be objective, he told our reporter with undisguised sarcasm before revealing his true intentions.
No, I'm not. That's why I'm here.
Dudik told us he returned to journalism precisely in order to remain politically active.
Next, we met Dez Hsu, an editor for the paper.
She made it clear where she stood.
I think one of the things that maybe journalists were thinking about is like,
oh, if we write about Trump and how insanely crazy he is, and how ludicrous his policies are,
then maybe people will read it and be like, oh wow, we shouldn't vote for him.
According to the Times' own handbook on journalistic ethics,
journalists may not do anything that damages the Times' reputation for strict neutrality
in reporting on politics and government.
So, given such a breach of the Times' own standards,
we expected the newspaper to come down hard on Dudik and Hsu.
Instead, they came down hard on us.
Executive Editor Dean Baquet said I was a
Yet, when the Times publicized a 2012 undercover video of Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney
saying that 47% of Americans wouldn't vote for him because they were dependent on the government,
they praised it as offering a rare glimpse of Romney's personal views.
In fact, in his attack on us,
Baquet unwittingly gave the whole American media game away.
A real journalist, he told a panel at the National Press Club,
has to have in his or her heart a desire to make society better.
The Times' editor is wrong.
Real journalists want to pursue the truth.
Then they let the citizens use that truth to build a better society.
When journalists shape news to fit their vision of a better society,
they're not doing their job.
Perhaps this wouldn't be so bad if the major media would just admit their political motives.
But they don't.
On behalf of their own narrow agenda, they lie, distort, and exaggerate.
And they expect us to call it Pravda.
But with each passing day, fewer and fewer Americans are willing to do so.
I'm James O'Keefe, founder and president of Project Veritas, for Prager University.
Using it to influence our elections.
Spreading propaganda.
Disguising it as news.
Pretty scary stuff.
I'm not talking about Russia, that's amateur hour.
The media organisation I'm talking about operates right here in the USA.
Out in the open, legally.
It has a large staff of on-air personalities, reporters, cameramen, and editors.
It operates out of state-of-the-art studios in Washington DC, London, Rio,
and half a dozen other major cities.
It produces videos, news reports, and documentaries.
It has tens of millions of social media follows.
Their content is viewed and shared by countless young people across the Western world.
In short, they're targeting us.
CNN, right? Wrong.
Fox News? Wrong again.
The answer is AJ+.
If you've spent time on social media, you've seen their stuff, I promise you.
This isn't the work of a scrappy start-up in Silicon Valley.
AJ+. is bankrolled by the government of Qatar.
Never heard of Qatar?
Most people haven't.
It's a tiny Persian Gulf state with lots of oil money.
Billions of dollars they're not afraid to spend on causes they believe in.
Causes like the terror group Hamas, which runs the Gaza Strip.
Without billions from Qatar and its ally Iran,
Hamas would blow away in the next desert sandstorm.
But Hamas is only part of Qatar's terror portfolio.
The Qatar government bankrolls the Muslim Brotherhood,
Al-Qaeda in Yemen and Syria,
radical extremists in Libya,
and Hezbollah in Lebanon.
In other words, a rogues gallery of murderous Islamist terror groups.
Qatar's propaganda arm is the Arab news service Al Jazeera,
which owns lock, stock, and America-hating, Israel-hating barrels.
Al Jazeera made a splashy attempt to break into the US media market in 2013.
They bought a cable franchise for $400 million from former Vice President Al Gore.
They signed up some major American TV journalists
and opened up shop in New York and Washington.
But the effort failed.
Americans just couldn't cozy up to the idea
that a news network they had rightly associated with Osama Bin Laden could be trusted.
But Al Jazeera didn't disappear.
They just rebranded into the much nicer-sounding AJ+.
And they concentrated their efforts on the internet
and a market that didn't have a Bin Laden fixation,
or much connection to 9-11 at all.
Young people.
And they've been amazingly successful.
Their productions are well-produced, slick, and left.
In fact, they're so left,
that they make videos railing against leftist white women
for being insufficiently sympathetic to leftist women of color,
especially women of color who are gay or transgendered.
It's hard to ignore the irony
that a media operation fully funded by a country that oppresses women and gays
makes this kind of content for an American audience.
But the irony goes deeper.
The young and hip presenters at AJ+,
depict America as racist through and through, past and present.
Black Lives Matter has no greater media ally than AJ+,
nor do avowed socialists like Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.
AJ+, jumped on her bandwagon early on,
making a video in the summer of 2018 about then-candidate Ocasio-Cortez,
entitled, Socialist Rising.
Why, you might ask,
would the government of a Middle Eastern country
care about influencing young Americans?
The answer is this.
Anything that weakens the U.S. is a victory for them
and their radical form of Islam.
If they can convince young Americans that the U.S. is a bad place,
young Americans are less likely to defend it,
and less likely to support its efforts to fight Islamic terror.
And if America is bad, then anyone it supports must also be bad.
America supports Israel.
Qatar, like its allies in the Iranian theocracy, wants Israel destroyed.
So AJ+, turns out video after video,
news report after news report,
portraying the democratic, free, liberal Israel
as a repressive, apartheid state,
despite the fact that Muslims living in Israel have more rights,
such as freedom of expression and the equality of women and gays,
than Muslims living in Qatar.
In AJ+,'s world,
Israel attacks their peaceful neighbors in Gaza for no good reason.
No need to mention the rocket attacks randomly directed at Israeli civilians.
Weaken America, weaken Israel.
To Qatar, a few billion dollars for a few decades is a cheap price to pay
if it can achieve those goals.
But you don't have to play into their game.
The next time you see an AJ+, video or so-called news report,
consider the source.
Or better still, swipe left.
I'm Rahim Kassam for Prager University.
Politicians lie.
We all know that.
This is not an indictment of all politicians.
It's simply part of the game.
It's our job as informed citizens to figure out the truth.
And that's where journalists and the media come in.
They are supposed to help us ferret out fact from fiction.
So when they get a fact wrong, that's bad.
When they get a fact wrong, know it's wrong,
and don't correct it, that's worse.
That's not getting a fact wrong.
That's a lie.
And that's journalistic malfeasance.
The best, or maybe worst, example of this
followed a presidential press conference
at Trump Tower on Tuesday, August 15, 2017.
You remember what happened that previous weekend.
A group of white supremacists held a white pride rally
in Charlottesville, Virginia.
The ostensible reason was to protest the removal
of a statue of Confederate General Robert E. Lee.
An Antifa group showed up to counter-protest.
The mayor and the police were totally unprepared
to deal with the violence that ensued.
Tragically, a young woman, Heather Heyer,
was run over and killed by a neo-Nazi.
The press conference itself was raucous.
The media was antagonistic.
The president was combative.
Out of it all, one phrase eclipsed the thousands
of words exchanged.
The media reported that President Trump
described neo-Nazis as very fine people.
Only he didn't.
In fact, he didn't even hint at it.
Just the opposite.
He condemned the neo-Nazis in no uncertain terms.
So then, who were the fine people he mentioned?
The answer?
He was referring to another group
of Charlottesville demonstrators who came out that weekend.
Protestors who wanted the Robert E. Lee statue removed
and protestors who wanted to keep the statue
and restore the park's original name.
This is what President Trump said
about those peaceful protestors.
You also had some very fine people on both sides.
You had people in that group that were there
to protest the taking down of, to them,
a very, very important statue
and the renaming of a park from Robert E. Lee
to another name.
A few moments later,
in case there would be any misunderstanding,
he makes his meaning even more explicit.
I'm not talking about the neo-Nazis
and the white nationalists.
They should be condemned totally.
Lest you have any doubts that good people
were in Charlottesville to protest the removal
of the Robert E. Lee statue,
the New York Times confirmed it
in a story they published the next day, August 16th.
Good people can go to Charlottesville,
said Michelle Percy, a night shift worker
at a Wichita, Kansas retirement home
who drove all night with a conservative group
that opposed the planned removal of a statue
of the Confederate General Robert E. Lee.
After listening to Mr. Trump on Tuesday,
she said it was as if he had channeled her
and her friends who had no interest
in standing with Nazis or white supremacists.
There's another simple test that we can employ
to prove that the president was not referring
to the neo-Nazis as fine people.
It's so obvious, it's painful to mention.
The president's daughter and son-in-law
are Orthodox Jews.
His grandchildren are Jewish.
And if that's still not enough to convince you,
how about this?
Does anyone believe that Donald Trump
thinks there are good Antifa,
the leftist thugs who are counter-protesting
the neo-Nazi thugs?
After all, if those two groups
were the only ones involved,
and there were fine people on both sides,
that means the president believed
that there were fine Antifa people.
Even MSNBC should have found that
hard to swallow.
Again, the very fine people on both sides
President Trump described at the press conference
were the people who wanted to remove
the Robert E. Lee statue
and the people who wanted to keep it.
Both of these groups were non-violent protesters.
Fine people with very different ideological views.
The scandal of Charlottesville
is not what President Trump said
about neo-Nazis.
It's what the media said President Trump said
about neo-Nazis.
It's a scandal because news reporting
is supposed to be about gathering facts,
not promoting an agenda.
In Charlottesville,
they got it exactly backwards.
We have been living with the consequences
ever since.
Plainly put, ABC, CBS, NBC, NPR,
The New York Times, The Washington Post,
and the others spread a malicious lie
that has poisoned our national dialogue.
They should apologize to the American people
for what they have done.
Don't hold your breath.
Actually, I have a better idea.
Let out a big sigh of relief
because now you know the truth.
I'm Steve Cortez,
CNN political commentator
and columnist for Real Clear Politics
for Prager University.
One of the most significant events of this century
happened early afternoon of August 9, 2014.
It took place in Ferguson, Missouri,
a city on the outskirts of St. Louis.
So embedded in the popular mind is this event
that if you just say the name Ferguson,
everyone knows what you're talking about,
police brutality and racial injustice.
President Barack Obama referred to it
in a speech before the United Nations
in September 2014.
I know the world also took notice
of the small American city of Ferguson, Missouri,
where a young man was killed
and a community was divided.
So yes, we have our own racial and ethnic tensions.
The president understated the case.
The shooting in Ferguson led to nights of riots
and gave fuel to a new social movement,
Black Lives Matter.
Given its historical importance,
it would be useful then to make sure
we have our facts straight.
So here's a quiz to test your knowledge.
First question, true or false,
a young unarmed black man, Michael Brown, 19,
was killed by a white police officer, Darren Wilson.
The answer is true.
True or false,
Wilson stopped Brown for no good reason.
False.
Wilson, driving a police SUV,
had just received a call on his radio
that a local convenience store had been robbed.
He saw two men walking in the middle of the nearby street
who met the description of the store thieves.
Wilson drove up to them.
When he asked the two men to move to the sidewalk,
one of the men, Michael Brown, refused.
Officer Wilson then attempted to get out of his car,
but Brown blocked the door,
punching the officer through the open window.
As Brown tried to grab Wilson's gun,
a struggle ensued.
Wilson managed to fire his gun,
wounding Brown in the hand.
True or false,
Michael Brown's back was turned to Officer Wilson
when he was shot and killed.
False.
After being shot in the hand,
Brown ran away from the police car.
Wilson got out of the vehicle and pursued him.
Brown then suddenly turned
and charged Officer Wilson.
Here's how one witness whose testimony
closely fits the forensic evidence
described the scene.
Brown ran towards the officer full charge.
The officer fired several shots at him
and Mike Brown continuously came forward
in the charging motion.
And when he stopped,
that's when the officer ceased fire.
When he charged once more,
the officer returned fire with,
I would say, three to four shots.
And that's when Mike Brown finally collapsed.
The Brown family's own medical expert,
respected pathologist, Dr. Michael Baden,
also conceded this point.
The wounds Brown suffered were consistent
with Brown charging toward Wilson,
not running away.
True or false,
before Michael Brown was shot and killed,
he raised his hands above his head
and shouted,
False.
Federal investigators from the Department of Justice
found no credible evidence
that Brown ever raised his hands
in a don't-shoot gesture
or in any way heeded the officer's commands
for him to surrender.
The federal report concluded
that witnesses who originally stated
Brown had his hands up in surrender
recanted their original accounts,
admitting that they did not witness
the shooting or parts of it.
Investigators also concluded
Brown never uttered the now iconic phrase.
Again from the report,
the media has widely reported
that there is witness testimony
that Brown said,
don't shoot,
as he held his hands above his head.
In fact,
our investigation did not reveal
any eyewitness who stated that Brown said,
don't shoot.
Where did this phrase come from then?
The best guess is that it was made up
by Brown's companion,
Dorian Johnson,
immediately after the shooting.
Witnesses described him saying,
the police shot my friend
and his hands were up.
And like a game of telephone,
the phrase spread quickly
throughout the neighborhood,
morphing into,
hands up,
don't shoot.
Picked up and amplified by the media,
it then became an anthem for activists.
True or false?
A local grand jury investigation
and a federal investigation
both concluded that Officer Wilson
was justified in his use of force.
True.
The local grand jury
and the federal investigation
supervised by Attorney General Eric Holder
reached the same conclusion.
Officer Wilson did nothing wrong.
There was no basis on which to prosecute him.
Here's how Heather McDonald
of the Manhattan Institute
put it in her book,
The War on Cops.
It was not a question of evidence
not supporting high-threshold
civil rights charges.
It was a question of evidence
eviscerating virtually every aspect
of the pro-Brown, anti-Wilson narrative.
There's another way to put this.
The statement that an innocent black man
was killed by a racist cop
in Ferguson, Missouri,
is a lie.
Those who say otherwise
are either willfully deceiving you
for their own purposes
or are wholly ignorant of the facts.
Now you know.
Act accordingly.
I'm Larry Elder
for Prager University.
Imagine a group of activists
so powerful that they could
beam their propaganda
directly into your brain.
Now also imagine
that they're so sophisticated
they actually get you
to pay them to do it.
Unfortunately, you don't have to imagine it.
It's real.
It's Hollywood.
As big as the internet has become,
Hollywood,
and here I'm talking specifically
about television,
is still king.
Not only does it reach
hundreds of millions of people
with its messaging,
it embeds that messaging
in seemingly innocuous stories.
Stories that distract us
from the hardships of daily life.
Stories that make us feel good,
compassionate, and decent.
We watch TV, in other words,
because we like it.
And just as Americans
didn't think much
about the carcinogens
in the cigarettes they smoked
for decades,
most Americans don't think much
about the toxic politics
in the television they watch.
But those who create
that content do.
They spin out hour after hour
of slickly produced
left-wing propaganda,
and they give themselves
awards for doing it.
They applaud each other's courage,
even though all their friends
think exactly as they do.
I spoke with nearly
a hundred members
of the Hollywood community
when I wrote my book
Primetime Propaganda,
and many of them
openly admitted
they inserted
social justice messages
into their shows.
How they do it
is both clever and effective.
Hollywood writers,
producers,
directors,
actors,
create characters
we keep wanting
to spend time with,
then have those characters
act in ways most of us
would judge wrong.
Then, in effect,
they ask us a question.
Isn't it really okay
that Rachel from Friends
decided to have a baby
without first marrying Ross?
After all,
you like Ross,
and you like Rachel.
How can what they do be bad?
It hasn't always been this way.
For decades,
Hollywood promoted
traditional American values.
That changed,
as did so much else
in the late 1960s and 70s,
when Hollywood stopped
celebrating American values
and started transforming them.
For example,
in the early 1970s,
abortion was
a hotly contested issue.
A year before
the Roe v. Wade
Supreme Court case,
the top-rated TV sitcom,
Maud,
featured a storyline
in which the title character
of the show
has an abortion.
The LA Times described it
as a watershed moment
in TV history.
Why?
Well, because it removed
the stigma of abortion.
Millions of Americans
sitting in their living rooms
saw a beloved character
do something
they did not approve of,
and they felt sympathy.
Something similar happened
in the early 2000s.
Vice President Joe Biden
was right
when he said that
Will & Grace
had a major impact
on how Americans think
about same-sex marriage.
Before the hit NBC show,
though most Americans
had a live-and-let-live attitude
toward private sexual behavior,
few supported the idea
of men marrying men
or women marrying women.
But seeing the charming
and funny Will Truman
live his life
week after week
paved the way
for a much wider acceptance
of same-sex marriage.
Current shows like
Orange is the New Black
and Transparent
are trying to affect
the same change
on the issue of transgenderism.
You may think
these are all good things,
or that some are
and some aren't.
That's not my point.
My point is that
Hollywood has had
a tremendous influence
on our culture,
and that influence
has been all
to the left side
of the political spectrum.
And it isn't just
social issues.
Chevy Chase
liked to boast
that he helped
Jimmy Carter defeat
Gerald Ford in 1976.
He may be right.
Week after week
on Saturday Night Live,
Chase portrayed Ford,
probably the most
athletic president
in American history,
as a bumbling,
uncoordinated idiot.
In the early 2000s,
Comedy Central
had a show,
That's My Bush,
that openly mocked
the 43rd president.
And of course,
Hollywood despises
Donald Trump.
From crime dramas
to the late-night comedy shows,
he's relentlessly ridiculed.
Somehow,
Hollywood managed to take
an eight-year hiatus
from mocking presidents
during the Obama years.
But maybe that's
just a coincidence.
All of this programming
has an effect.
Scientific studies suggest
that watching TV
acts like a
habit-forming drug.
According to the
market research firm
Childwise,
teenage boys spend
eight hours per day
in front of screens,
much of it
consuming Hollywood propaganda.
Dedicated religious parents
might expose
their children
to two hours a week
of religious instruction.
Hands-on parents
might spend
30 minutes a day
discussing essential values
with their kids.
Hollywood gets up
to 40 hours a week.
Every week.
By all means,
enjoy television.
I do.
But remember,
the people making TV
don't merely want
to entertain you.
They want to influence you.
They want you to think
like they think.
And unless you're aware
of what they're trying to do,
chances are,
you will.
I'm Ben Shapiro,
editor of The Daily Wire
for Prager University.
We camp out for days
to buy tickets
to your sold-out shows,
then shout for you
to reach down from the stage
to touch our hands.
Faster than science
would believe
humanly possible,
we learn the lyrics
to your every song
and master the choreography
to your every dance move.
We devour your movies,
TV shows,
and Netflix specials.
From that angle,
I suppose it's easy to believe
that after all the adulation,
all the fan mail,
and all the magazine covers,
you may have actually come
to believe
that we care
what you think.
But you're wrong.
Nobody cares what you think.
Nobody.
Well,
maybe your mother
and your therapist do,
but we don't.
Not even a little.
Allow me to spell
this one out for you.
I go to a Lady Gaga concert
to hear her belt-out tunes
that remind me
of my messy college days.
But watching her
desperate protest
against the results
of a free and fair election?
Hardly an event
I'd ever care to see again
in my lifetime.
I follow Beyoncé
because, let's face it,
nobody does
a breakup anthem better.
But can someone please tell me
why I should care
if she's for Hillary
or for Garfield the Cat?
And here's to you,
Marc Jacobs.
You design
a killer pair of shoes.
But as a political philosopher,
you leave a lot
to be desired.
In fact,
it's difficult
to comprehend
why you thought
it necessary
to publicly refuse
to dress our First Lady.
And to the scores
of celebrities
who threaten
to move out of the country
if we don't vote your way?
Wow.
Just how long
on a private jet
must one travel
to reach that level
of narcissism?
This may rock
your glittery world,
but we don't care
whether you stay in America
or move to another country.
Why would we care
where you live?
On the one hand,
we should find
all of this amusing,
but on the other,
it's actually
deeply offensive.
It's offensive
that you confuse
our admiration
for blind faith.
When Eminem raps
and I have to either
pick him
or the President
of the United States,
I don't know
whether to laugh
or cry.
Which is why
it's important
that I take this moment
to offer each
and every one
of you celebs
a free ride
back down
to planet Earth.
What happens
outside of your
gated communities,
chauffeured SUVs,
and personal assistance iPhone
is the real world.
It's the rest of us
working very hard
to earn a living,
working toward
that weekend break
when we can perhaps
afford to treat ourselves
to your concerts,
your movies,
and your handbags.
You see,
we want to enjoy
what you do.
Sing, dance,
act, design.
It's a wonderful gift
you have,
and it's extremely valuable,
not only to you,
but to us.
Entertaining people,
making them laugh
or cry
is something that you
should take pride in.
You enrich our world
with your talent.
But when you go
on a political rant
on late night TV,
or call your fans
racist and sexist,
my God,
these people are your fans.
Just because they don't
think or vote
the way you want them to,
you cross a line.
You lose touch
with reality.
You become
just another shill
for another politician.
Who wants to be
a fan of that?
I'm Candace Owens
for Prager University.
The media needs
more balance in coverage
and a wider range
of viewpoints
represented in every newsroom
at every level
and in each position.
In the past few years,
I haven't felt proud
to be a member of the media.
I'm sure there are
other journalists out there
who feel the same way.
I found myself
reading news copy
that I didn't believe
was fully truthful
or only told
part of the story.
And I began to feel
that I was contributing
to the fear
and division
in this country
by continuing on
in this profession.
It's been a serious
struggle for me
and I no longer
want to do this job anymore.
You've probably heard
a lot of people recently
screaming and yelling
about fake news.
Charges fly
from all points
on the political spectrum.
This story is mistaken.
It's fake news.
That statement is incorrect.
It's fake news.
But to my mind,
these arguments
miss the point.
Mainstream American news
is all fake
because the major
news outlets
are so consistently
biased toward the left
that whether
any given story
they report
is factual or not,
their overall reportage
is essentially
leftist propaganda.
You can complain
about the right-wing slant
of Fox News
all you want,
but left-wing ABC,
CBS,
NBC,
MSNBC,
and CNN
have combined
almost ten times
the viewers.
Look,
the chief journalist
at ABC
is former Clinton operative
George Stephanopoulos.
The president of CBS News
is David Rhodes,
the brother of a former
senior Obama staffer.
Comcast,
which owns NBC,
is run by a major
Democrat donor.
Same for the leadership
at CBS
and Time Warner,
which owns CNN.
Only 7% of American
journalists identify
as Republican.
And while a lot
of news outlets
forbid their reporters
to donate to candidates,
96% of those
who did donate
last time out
gave to Hillary Clinton.
These journalists
claim that despite
the fact they're
all Democrats,
they can be objective.
It just ain't so.
Psychologists have shown
that when people
associate almost
exclusively with
those who agree with them,
they suffer from
groupthink
and confirmation bias
and lose their ability
to see events clearly.
Now,
it's not that these
journalists are liars,
exactly.
It's that their bias
skews their reporting
in very specific ways.
