----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- We take Newton's laws of gravity for granted. Surely the inverse square law is the most accurately tested law in physics, right? WRONG. Ironically, gravity has been tested more accurately in the cosmos, than in the laboratory. Today we discuss a fascinating lab experiment putting the inverse square law to the test!
“Experimental progress towards testing the behavior of gravity at the 20-micron distance scale,” M.P. Ross, J.S. Johnson, I.S. Guerrero, N. K. Dunkley, H.F. Leopardi, C.D. Hoyle, Journal of Undergraduate Research and Scholarly Excellence Pp. 1 – 7 (2018)
“Novel Tests of Gravity Below Fifty Microns,” Jeremy S. Johnson, Noah K. Dunkley, Gabriela D. Martinez, Anthony E. Sanchez, and C.D. Hoyle (Faculty Advisor), Proceedings of the National Conference on Undergraduate Research (NCUR), 463 – 471 (2017)
how do we know the inverse Square law
truly holds over all length scales from
the largest scales in the cosmos to the
smallest these are small but the ones
out there are far away we've talked in
other videos like this one with
Professor morai mgrm about his theory
which is called M modified Newtonian
Dynamics which explains away the need
for dark matter by instead invoking a
new form of gravitational force that
operates not on local scale SC but on
Cosmic scales between galaxies and
internal dynamics of galaxies to explain
the peculiar rotation curves of galaxies
first observed by ver Rubin Vera Rubin
was trained right here at UC San Diego
by none other than my late great
colleagues Margaret and Jeffrey Burbage
but this is about a short range gravity
experiment not on Galaxy scales like
this but on the laboratory scales and
results are described in this paper
which you can find yourself for free on
the archive at the link that's shown in
the screen now so why should we test
gravity at short distance scales it's
kind of nicely summarized here Gravity
has not been tested well below the
submillimeter scale where you might be
able to First sense the effects of
quantum gravitational effects those are
obviously much much smaller than the
millimeter scale but they're not as
small relatively speaking as say from
the tabletop or laboratory scale on
Earth to the entire Cosmos that the
modified Newtonian gravity proposals
seek to Define life is like this I want
to make that smaller gr and quantum
mechanics are incommensurate
incompatible with each other and so
you'd like to study that close to the
regime scale which both effects are
operative namely on the smallest scales
and on the gravitational force fields
that we can test in the laboratory and
lastly if we could unify the standard
model of particle physics in general
relativity we could potentially have the
so-called Theory of Everything and that
may come in our lifetimes or it may not
come at all there's no guarantee that
forces and Fields have to be unified
just because that approach has worked so
successfully throughout the past 100
years in the Golden Age of physics that
we've been enjoying for quite some time
so what is the inverse Square law well
that's merely the fact observed and
capsulated Newton's famous equation that
the gravitational force field between
two gravitating mass of objects depends
on the product of their masses times a
universal constant called capital G
Newton's constant and and the inverse of
the square of the distance between them
there could be alterations of this
inverse Square law at small scales that
has so far evaded our detection because
it's so difficult to measure the effects
of gravity when you're talking about
things that are smaller than say the
link scale of your fingernails it's
actually easier to detect gravitational
forces between planets and say the Moon
and the Earth than it is between objects
that are separated by Micron distance
scales as paradoxical as that may sound
you'd think it' be easier to measure
forces over short distance scales and of
course these divergences of the force if
you go to zero separation formally
Newton's law is predicting an infinite
force between two massive objects but
what does that really mean can you
really get two massive classical objects
to be located an infinitesimal distance
away no you can't but the question is as
you approach infinitesimal distances
from finite distances can you get a Devi
from 1/ R squ Behavior that's what this
research that Alyssa and her adviser
worked on at humbal state so where are
we currently well there are a series of
experiments that have been carried out
these are really classical physics
experiments that are being done with
modern technology at the University of
Washington they're so-called atash
experiments and the joke is that their
name of the experiment is atash where
wash is for Washington and they're
looking for this equation that would
parameterize a new Gra gra itational
potential rather than diverging as 1 / R
the force goes as the gradient or the
derivative with respect to R of the
potential so if the potential varies as
1 / r that means the force will go as 1/
R 2 in this case the potential doesn't
go just as 1 over R the first leading
term in the equation for v as a function
of r potential energy as a function of r
does depend as inverse on the distance
but then there's a modification a
so-called Uka term which traces its name
to the famous Japanese physicist yukawa
who predicted the behavior of subatomic
particles in the strong nuclear force
pons and so forth that was governed by a
ukawa term that fell off as an
exponential not as an inverse power LW
and so by modifying the coupling from
just being one inside the square
brackets to being one plus this
exponentially decaying term which is
parameterized by two numbers the link
scale over which it decays which is
Lambda and amplitude which is an energy
scale which is Alpha you have this
two-dimensional parameter space of Alpha
and Lambda so the amount of the
deviation and potential Alpha is plotted
here on the right as a function of the
inverse of the link scale over which the
deviation from inverse Square law take
place in the humble State University
experiment Hsu they predict they could
get down to even lower values than these
World beating experiment at uh
University of Washington and they're
working with the same team members as
you'll see in read the paper we'll show
the paper here those authors are
collaborators at the University of
Washington so at humbl State University
the lab that Alyssa was working in with
her adviser look like this so they have
a gravitational research lab where
they're doing what's called torsion
pendulum a torsion pendulum is a
pendulum that doesn't tick back and
forth by swinging like a grandfather
clock but instead twist back and forth
like a plate on a on on a string the
amount of twisting as you bring in a
closer plate to the torch pendulum's Bob
again it's not oscillating in a plane
it's oscillating about an axis back and
forth and they measure that deviation as
they bring in another material perhaps
made of a different substance as the
main pendulum is made up of so they've
got a torsion pendulum with equal masses
so they have two plates separated by
some distance and this makes what's
called a composition dipole if they're
different materials you could do with
similar materials or you can do it with
different materials and the actual
Foundation of this experiment goes back
to Cavendish in the 1700s making these
measurements of torsion pendulums as
well it's a classic experiment we do in
physics Labs but this is on steroids
with the humble State University's team
and approach to it so the attractor Mass
causes the uh deflecting Mass to
oscillate and that creates a Time
dependent torque on the pendulum and
then you measure the period of the
pendulum the size of its oscillation as
a function of the separation between the
attractor mass and the Pendulum Mass
itself and this allows you to look for
deviations in What's called the weak
equivalence principle or in the inverse
Square law and again this could be
parameterized by these two parameters
Alpha and Lambda so this is not an easy
experiment to do in fact I tried a
version of the cavish experiment 30
years ago as a freshman at Case Western
Reserve University go Spartans in that
measurement I got an answer that was
some 10 orders of magnitude off from the
acceptable value of capital G in
Newton's constant uh that's embarrassing
but lucky for me the tenure committee at
UC San Diego never knew about those
freshman lab blunders that yours truly
made gravity is incredibly weak their
interactions electrostatic interactions
magnetic interactions the test masses
have to be brought in from different
distances and changed and measured over
those distances there can be variations
in temperature as there often are dially
throughout the day the building has its
own environmental effects it has
vibrational effects students come into
the laboratory environment they go into
classrooms there's traffic on the
streets all these things can be sensed
by this exquisitely sensitive machine
built at humal State University they
have to keep isolated as best as
possible the experimental apparatus from
the surrounding environment but you
can't launch it into space at least in
the budget of a California State
University like UCSD or humbold State
University so they make use of
incredible Precision control over the
environment including vacuum shielding
magnetically electrostatic grounding
what's called an active leveling system
that is the key enabling devices some
level the tilts in the apparatus can
affect the measurement at the Micron
level and that's very important for
ruling out so-called systematic errors
errors in the system not in the
fundamental forces and it can confuse
you that you've measured a deviation
from the inverse Square law when
actually it was just a deviation of your
apparatus's tilt so they actually build
in what's called temperature
compensation where they can stretch or
Shrink the length of a leg of their
apparatus to compensate for thermal
variations in the laboratory or in the
apparatus itself they can measure this
as they have here and they can see the
tiny this is millionths of a radian
radians about 57° so you're measuring 57
And1 millions of a degree tilt and
you're doing that with very high
accuracy over many many day long
experimental data acquisition periods
it's really quite impressive that they
can do this and they need to do this to
make contributions that people will
believe to our understanding of gravity
at small scales here's a block diagram
schematic diagram of how the
compensation works what's called a PID
or proportional integral derivative
control system this is what's called a
Servo system that uses Corrections and
measurements like a thermostat does it
measures the difference between what you
set the temperature at and what the room
is actually reading then applies heat or
cold to compensate but you can overshoot
very easily and get into an oscillation
with a thermostat unless you damp that
by constraining What's called the
integral term and applying a dissipative
term a derivative term to correct for
the oscillation so that you get a nice
stable Solution that's controllable
that's predictable and this is called
tuning the PID circuit which is
something Alysa spent a lot of her time
doing lab view which is a nice gooey
graphical user interface programming
term which is very common in
instructional Laboratories so if you
come here to UC San Diego or you go to
humal State University you'll get great
experience doing control over Servo
Motors and heaters and resistors and
thermometers and doing everything
digitally acquiring and sampling an
analog signal temperature length Etc and
then converting that to a digital signal
and then correcting and compensating
applying compensatory signals to make a
very stable active control system and
this type of technique is using
everything from these tabletop type
gravity experiments all the way up to
the Lio experiment that we've talked
about many times including with the two
of the three leaders Nobel Prize winners
Barry beish and with Ray Weiss on this
very channel so here's a recording
measurement where Alyssa is showing her
data from the laboratory tuning to get
not an overall small value of the Tilt
although that would be nice but to get
smaller and smaller variations and
oscillations in the amount of tilt over
time and you see the very first runs
that's shown at the top with no
components of proportional integral
derivative included and then the final
term which has the lowest variation the
lowest oscillatory Behavior over 1.2
days worth of data and that shows the
best behavior and you see little
interruptions that look like hash in the
data those could be from people coming
in the building going out of the
building there's some periodic things it
could be from everything from
interference from Wi-Fi to other effects
that can be filtered out but the goal
has been achieved with just two terms
this proportional term and the
derivative term damping out the
oscillations but also correcting so that
when it's too big a tilt you correct you
heat or you control the length of the
apparatus keeping it stable and its
overall magnitude as small as possible
so they're still working on this they're
still trying to improve the tilt over
time the smaller they can get it the
more accurate they can measure both
Alpha and Lambda so they want to have
Tighter and Tighter feedback control but
you can't overcontrol you can risk
sending the system into an oscillation
that also is unstable and doesn't
improve your measurement whatsoever and
they want to understand characterize
their instrument much better and you can
read more about the results and The
Cutting Edge nature of the field in
these papers and there's a paper in
progress that Alysa herself has been
working on so stay tuned for that look
at the work of Professor Doyle
at humble State and stay tuned for great
results from both the etvos team and the
Hsu team and stay tuned for more work
from Alysa Johnson a rising star who
we're lucky enough to have here at the
UC San Diego system where she's studying
gravity in the laboratory if you think
of the entire Cosmos as our laboratory
she's working on Simon's Observatory
measurements of primordial gravitational
wave
radiation so if you like this
measurement like to learn more about
experimental searches for Gravity click
here this video about ligo and I'll see
you in the next video
[Music]