Student loan lawyer Stanley Tate joins us to tackle the big question we’re all asking: what’s actually happening with student loans right now? We’re exploring the latest legislative changes, what they mean for your repayment strategy, and why Parent PLUS borrowers are especially freaking out. We talk through everything from the COVID payment chaos we all lived through to the potential collapse of graduate programs and the emotional toll of student debt policy. What you’ll walk away with is information you can use, not just more anxiety. Whether you’re strategizing payments or just trying to stay sane, this episode helps you navigate what’s coming next.
Key moments: 00:00 Introduction 04:52 Future borrowers will see hard caps on how much they can borrow 09:11 Parent PLUS borrowers must get on an income-driven repayment plan by July 2026 13:55 Should SAVE borrowers hold on or switch? We share our strategies 25:47 Resources to manage student debt exist, but you have to choose action over ignoring the problem 31:47 Our predictions for what happens to graduate programs moving forward 39:20 Student loans aren't a "set it and forget it" type of debt
Hello, everybody.
Welcome to the Student Loan Planner Podcast and welcome a special guest,
Stanley Tate Esquire, attorney at law and
buddy of mine, friend of mine, student loan expert extraordinaire.
I thought it'd be kind of cool to hang out with Stanley
and just kind of talk through
just some stuff going on with the craziness of student loans right now.
What's up, Stanley?
Hey, what's going on? How's everything with you?
Good, good.
And we're going to be publishing this across both of our channels.
So did you want to give a shout out to your show, Stanley?
Yeah, you can just check us out on YouTube as Student Loan Lawyer
there, and I think the link will be down in the caption below.
So you can check that out there.
Yeah, yeah.
So Stanley and I actually I think we first met when we were both in St.
Louis at our home in St. Louis.
I didn't realize it at the time.
Was your partner then in residency or training or fellowship?
Yeah, she was. She was actually done.
She one of these kind of super geniuses that started med school at like 18,
which is like crazy.
Like I think about that, like, oh, my gosh, like she was in med school that young.
Oh, my gosh. So anyways, yeah, we were and we took our first job.
Her first job at a training was in St. Louis.
And so we started there and then we had to move during the pandemic, man.
The they kind of freaked out during covid and they're like, oh, my gosh, any
any elective surgeries, they're gone forever.
And then like they later off and like as soon as they later off,
like demand came roaring back, you know, everybody was sitting at home
and saying, oh, shoot, look at all these health problems.
I want to get them worked on, you know.
So that's that's how we ended up in North Carolina.
So, yeah, that's interesting because I was out there for my wife
at the time was doing her residency and fellowship at Wash U.
And we were both working out of Cortex without even realizing
we're talking about student loans in both of us out of St. Louis.
And both of us actually working out of Cortex,
but didn't even know each other until we like cross paths one day.
Yeah. Yeah. I mean, those were those were different times, right?
Different times where student loans were calm and I'm just kidding.
I feel like they've never been calm.
Like any time I talk to somebody that's a fellow like student expert,
like I'm talking to someone who I feel like I've, you know, served, served
in a conflict with or something like that, just because it's like it's been so,
you know, exhausting at times.
I mean, rewarding to help people. Right.
But like, gosh, what if we've seen quite a bit over just
the few years we've been in this? Right.
Yeah. I mean, starting from, you know, I got into this in 2014,
which was a more static time in comparison to today,
which is like the most dynamic time in student loans bar none.
But I don't know that it's ever been like a problem
that you fully had your arms wrapped around at all times
just because there's so much complexity to it.
I always tell people this is the most complex consumer loan product bar none.
To try to figure out.
So it's really hard to just get started in it and then to be an expert in it
and then actually have intelligent conversations with other people about it
just because it is so complex.
So it's always cool when I get to talk with someone like you.
Yeah, I mean, so we obviously just had this one big, beautiful bill act pass.
Oh, I always kind of three B's makes it harder for me to say.
Oh, B, B, B, A.
I mean, the bill, we'll just call it the bill
and or the GOP bill and today's show.
I mean, so could you kind of give people
sort of a 30,000 foot view as to what this bill does for student loans?
Well, I think what this bill does for student loans
with the kind of bifurcated out, separated out to what does it do
for current borrowers and what does it do for future borrowers?
And then there's like a weird hybrid of people who are current borrowers
who are also still planning to borrow moving forward,
which are typically like parent plus loans for that first group of existing
borrowers, it limits your repayment options moving forward.
And so while we had like this kind of diverse menu of options
that some say was overly complex, others say, no, it actually kind of worked
for me once you realize how it can work.
We're limiting down from getting rid of save, getting rid of pay as you earn
and then getting rid of income
contingent repayment and only having this one income
based repayment plan moving forward outside of that income based repayment.
There's two categories.
There's a 10% version of 15% version, depending on when you went to school.
So we're eliminating income driven repayment options
and just having one IBR with two parts inside it.
But then we also are introducing a new repayment plan
based on your income called the repayment assistance plan.
And that works similar to these income driven plans.
And that is based off of your income.
But it's also entirely different in some other ways.
Not to mention that it extends the forgiveness timeline for people
from 20 to 25 years to 30 years across the board.
No matter what loans you borrow, undergrad or grad.
And there is a third repayment option, the standard plan
that's being introduced that kind of tears up on the number of years
we had to pay back the loan based off of the amount borrowed.
So that's what we have for current bonds.
Then we have for people who are looking to borrow in the future,
that is going to limit the amount they can borrow moving forward for school.
Overall, it's going to put these hard caps in there at different amounts
and in grad school is going to be capped as well.
And so previously, people can borrow as much as they needed
to pay for their graduate program.
Now there's going to be more thoughtfulness that goes into your entire
federal student loan borrowing from undergrad to grad school.
And how am I going to be able to afford this with federal student loans?
And then we have a third category of those people who are current borrowers
who are also still borrowing in the future, where for the most part,
the things you need to worry about are that if you're still borrowing today,
then you're good for the next three years under the old rules.
But then if you borrow beyond those three years,
you put yourself in a position where you face caps moving forward.
Also, inside of there, there's you could lose access
to income driven repayment plans if you're, say, a PAM Plus home borrower
who borrows loans after July 1st, 2026.
And so I'm trying to give you a 30,000 foot view,
but then you get drug down in the details to where you actually got to get into it
to really explain it.
But I think the key takeaway is current borrowers are losing some repayment
options, but keeping income based repayment.
And they're going to get access to this new RAP plan.
Future borrowers are going to have a hard cap on the borrowing moving forward.
And then this small category of borrowers who have existing loans
and are still borrowing have to be very mindful about what that means
in terms of their ability to fund education moving forward.
And also, what does it mean for the current repayment options
moving forward as well?
You know, bro, this is the attorney, you know, level explanation, right?
Of the 30,000 foot view. I'm just kidding.
I mean, so, yeah, I think like so we were talking kind of before
the recording about some of the big problems that people are going to face
from this.
I mean, so technically, if you borrow after July 2026,
you might be able to continue borrowing.
But if you borrow after 2026, you're kind of stuck with RAP, right?
The RAP plan, right?
And on the standing is that if you borrow new loans after 2026,
then you lose access to income driven repayment, income based repayment
totally, and you're forced into RAP.
But then if you have Parent Plus on borrower, you lose access
to both income based repayment and RAP all together.
You're just trying to pay it back over time.
Yeah. So really, we got to get the message out there.
Parent Plus folks need to make plans to not borrow, right?
Not borrow after July 2026.
I think they're the category borrow most worried about moving forward
because they typically carry higher amounts of debts than other borrowers.
They're also at their peak earning potential
or they're in their retirement off a fixed income.
The retirees are less of a problem so long as they're properly managing
into an income driven repayment plan.
But those people who may have five years,
10 years left to go before their income changes,
if they don't get things right, they could be hammered here
with their monthly payments.
Yeah, I mean, I mean, like we were dealing with kind of.
An apocalyptic scenario briefly with that Senate bill, right,
where they were going to just take away everything from Parent Plus folks
immediately with no warning.
And, you know, luckily, that Senate parliamentarian kind of came in
and slowed things down a little bit, where we at least have, you know,
until 2026 of July to get, you know, people with Parent Plus consolidated.
Right, because that that was a wonderful sigh of relief for me
when they at least put that in about, you know, you can avoid
that accepted consolidation loan status if you're able to just get
that loan consolidated by July 2026.
Right. That would that would have been.
And there's no describing how bad that would have been
had that bill had passed as it was designed,
because there was even confusion about what it meant if you were
a borrower who was in, say, save or IBR with Parent Plus loans
and did double consolidation.
Did that mean you need to switch to ICR?
So your borrower is rushing out to switch into ICR
to take the most conservative view.
Thankfully, that didn't pass.
And so now we have a situation where there is time to get things done.
But there's still a hard deadline of when you need to get things done.
As a parent plus loan borrower, you need to be consolidated
and into an income driven repayment plan as of July 1st, 2026.
Or else you lose access to everything.
That messed up my vacation, man.
I was in vacation in Spain, you know, Crimea River, right?
But I was with my wife.
We're having this great trip without the kids.
And then, like, I see this freaking Senate bill.
And I'm like, oh, bleep.
Like, I know what this means.
We got to get everybody with Parent Plus onto ICR immediately
because that's what the bill says.
And I don't know that this at the time,
I didn't know the Senate parliamentarian was going to come in and say, save people.
You know, so no one did like you can.
I was looking at kind of bird rule impact and like you become this
quote unquote expert on some other thing that you had no clue about
in order to just kind of play out the scenarios.
But then you have to gamble, right?
But then even if you wanted to switch to ICR plans,
it was ridiculously hard to do so for some people
just because of the backlog of processing delays across the board.
Now, thankfully, some people were able to get in.
But then now you have a situation where people were in, say,
switched over to ICR in anticipation of it.
Now they have a higher payment and they're trying to figure out, OK,
does that mean I should switch back at this point? What should I do?
And it's just a mess that we are trying to clean up moving forward.
But I think the big takeaway is if you are a parent with Parent Plus loans,
you need to make sure you're an income driven repayment plan
as of July 1st, 2026.
Yeah, I mean, like the other thing I was thinking about was
and trying to figure out how to give advice during that time was like,
you know, if I don't tell people to do this, what is the downside?
Well, the downside was people's retirements would have been wrecked.
Right. Because you would have had no ability to pay based on your income.
And if you have like a 200 K plus parent plus balance, right,
that would have meant, you know, 2000 a month, 1500 a month.
And like the extended type of plan payments or default knows
they were going to be the only two options that that bill had passed as is.
So it's like, oh, crud, man.
Like there's you know, so I'm glad that that was spared for us.
I'm also glad that the new IBR, you know, plan survived
because that's something that affects a really broad group of people. Right.
There's a lot of people that borrow their first loan after after July 2014
that now get to pay, you know, for 20 years on that plan.
If they don't borrow after July 2026, they would have had to pay,
you know, 15% of income instead of 10 and for 25 years instead of 20.
So that's I mean, that's a huge difference in payments that, you know,
I mean, I was joking, like, you know, the Senate parliamentarian
can't accept any gifts, probably.
But, you know, student borrowers should send that parliamentarian flowers
or something because, man, she saved everybody.
Thank you for listening to this show.
If you are not already getting our weekly newsletter every Thursday,
you are missing out.
We break down student loan news updates, money tips, all in one helpful newsletter.
Sign up for free at studentloanplanner.com slash newsletter.
If you're not already getting these important weekly updates on every Thursday.
Yeah, I mean, I guess she saved everybody for now. Right.
For now.
Well, you don't know what the world is going to look like three, four, five,
eight years from now.
And that I think that's always like the important thing to keep in mind
with these plans, because they are so long in nature
that time is going to change things with these plans as they are.
And which makes sense because we have a relatively young federal student
loan lending program that has adjusted over the years
to kind of meet the world where it's at.
And so I imagine we may see more changes moving forward.
But where we are at today, it is super thankful
that they preserve IBR 10 percent for people because it comes
with that shorter forgiveness timeline and a cheaper monthly payment,
while also keeping IBR 15 percent and credibly opening it up
to a larger category of borrowers than the other would otherwise qualify for.
Namely, those parent plus loan borrowers who didn't double consolidate.
They're going to instead be stuck.
Instead of stuck with ICR at a higher monthly payment,
they're going to be pushed into IBR and end up with a cheaper payment
than it otherwise would have been eligible for.
So that's a good thing at base.
But then they'll save plan borrowers who are going to see their payments
three X, four X in some cases.
That's going to be tough.
And we're going to have to deal with what that looks like
for that category of borrowers as well. Right.
Well, I mean, like if you took out your first loan before October 2007,
then you went from a 225 percent of the poverty line deduction, right?
With, you know, 10 percent of income above that to old IBR is 15 percent,
you know, with 150 percent deduction, right?
So like you were saying, people don't realize.
And the other big whammy that I call out to Stanley is like,
I see IBR recertifications.
They've been pushed off so many years that a lot of people,
not only are they paying on a lower percentage of the larger deduction,
but they're paying on a really, really, really old tax return. Right.
And, you know, and so like, you know, those some of those
IBR recertifications got pushed into 2026.
Who knows if we can trust that? Right.
I personally kind of don't trust Department of Ed saying, oh, yeah,
we pushed out some of these recertification dates. Right.
Because who knows?
I mean, they could just undo that with very little notice, I think.
Yeah, I think that's
I think that's what is the larger kind of prominence
underneath all of this is that there's a loss of trust
in the administration itself and that your word is your bond
that what you say is what's going to happen.
And so there is going to be some kind of picking and rebuilding
that relationship back up,
especially when you're in a long term relationship
with someone 20, 25, 30 years in some cases.
But I did actually want to ask you a question.
I have to take over your interview.
You know, I know you should.
We're doing this on both of our shows.
So, you know, you should interview me with some stuff that's on your mind.
I guess. But we're on that same plan.
Barra, I want to double tap there.
How are you with interest resuming on August 1st, presumably?
How are you thinking about what say plan bar should do?
Should they take this diamond hands approach
and just hold on to say for as long as possible?
Or like I guess I was trying to think through
just the decision framework there for someone.
So how have you been thinking about that?
That's a great question.
I mean, the way I look at it is,
are you in a place of financial abundance or not? Right.
So for the borrowers who are in a place of financial security,
financial abundance, my question is with anything with student loans,
does this help you or does this not help you write as a borrower? Right.
And if I have somebody who's getting
zero percent interest with P.L.
Slough buyback eligibility for a forbearance period less than a year,
then it's pretty reasonable to say, hey, stay in the safe forbearance
because you can do a buyback with the lower the two payments before or after.
Because it's a forbearance less than a year.
And then, you know, zero percent interest if you're paying your loans back.
So the only person, you know, before this announcement
that the safe forbearance was not a good idea for was somebody pursuing,
you know, 20 or 25 year forgiveness in the private sector
because they're obviously not getting any credit,
you know, towards forgiveness.
You know, I mean, theoretically, there was going to be a, you know,
a buyback for, you know, those folks.
But, you know, we don't think that's going to happen. Right.
So so kind of my thought process before this ending was, well,
pretty much people that are slam dunk, you know, 20, 25 year
forgiveness cases might want to consider getting out of it.
But everybody else just hang out, chill in the safe forbearance until further notice.
Now, with this change, with the zero percent ending,
I'm thinking about it really from two directions.
Like one is the PSLF buyback rules are pretty clear that once it's past,
you know, the 120 or the past a year for the forbearance,
they're allowed to just ask your tax returns, right?
It's like to get that buyback number.
So PSLF borrowers now know that it's been past a year.
It's not really much benefit in staying in the safe forbearance.
And then, you know, the other thought is, well, if you have no more zero percent
interest, what are the chances this administration reinstates
some sort of interest freeze during the duration of the administration?
I think pretty much nil.
So the way I look at it is get out of the safe plan forbearance
unless you've got, you know, high interest credit card debt,
high interest personal loans.
You don't have an emergency fund.
And just the actual benefit of the nonpayment existing
is pretty critical for your finances.
So that's that's the way that I think about it.
And I think it's interesting because
the way I hear you coming at it is from,
I think it also is biased towards the audience that you serve,
which is primarily like higher income, higher debt of PSLF, higher income people.
So and when I look at it, there's this
other approach where I'm thinking about you have borrowers
who just want to hold on to say because they have this hope
that somehow save is going to be preserved and they'll be that lucky few
that stuck around long enough and actually get to benefit from the lower payment.
So there'll be that preserved category.
And there's nothing you can really do with that
because psychologically, they're holding on to a different
kind of factor there that you can't really account for.
Right. I'm going to say, yes.
And what is that person losing?
They're just losing credit toward forgiveness, towards
ADR forgiveness during that capacity.
And then with interest accruing,
I don't know that they're actually losing anything either in that standpoint,
because interest is going to accrue no matter what plan you're in.
And maybe by greater pressure, because you are somehow you're like,
oh, I want to hold on to because I think the benefit of it is going to weigh out
for me, but I'm really worried about the interest ballooning my balance
and what that may do for taxes.
So you start entertaining all these downstream considerations.
But I think that person, if that's what they want to do,
they should probably just stay there because they're holding out hope
for this thing that I don't think is realistic.
But I understand why they hold on to it.
But then you point out that for people who are actually
marching towards forgiveness as soon as possible
under that 20 or 25 year rule.
The only reason why you should stay and say
is because you really can't afford the payments today
under the new IBR plan that you're in, and you need to adjust
your budget to account for it. Right. And that makes sense.
Or maybe you realize that you're looking around the corner,
your income is going to change because maybe you're going on FMLA
or maybe you're going to have job loss here shortly.
And so you'd rather time it more strategically to switch
so you can get that lower payment for that a year,
because you're perversely incentivized if you're working towards
forgiveness to pay as little as possible towards your student loans.
And this I've been thinking about, like this, say, Planned Borrowing,
because you hear all these people like, oh, man, what do I do?
What I do? This interest is interest.
And I don't know that the interest to me is actually a driver of a decision here.
But I guess I wanted to make sure I wasn't missing anything.
I thought of it because I didn't see it as a driver.
I see it as a psychological driver,
but not an actual like real decision making drive.
Well, I mean, I the way I think about it is like
people that keep the clock running.
Have good outcomes, like people that keep that clock moving forward
in terms of building up that forgiveness credit, right?
I see him all the time on our Facebook groups and, you know, email inboxes
where people are like, just got 600,000 forgiven, baby.
Heck, yeah. Going out to celebrate with the with the spouse tonight,
you know, like and the thing is, is, you know, they they had that happen
just because, yeah, a lot of them were in the safe plan for parents,
but they like they submitted buyback in some cases.
They, you know, made sure their employment certifications
were on time and submitted regularly, right?
Like they're staying on top of stuff.
And, you know, I think that, you know, the what do people call like
the like hopium or something like that, like a lot of podcasts
talk about hopium, right?
It's a drug and people want to believe in it, but it's it's bad for you.
I mean, I think that like I mean, I feel I feel what you're saying, though,
because, you know, initially I recorded a video
before we knew a little bit more of the details about the safe
for parents ending where I was assuming that they were people
going to have bills do as well at the same time.
And I ended up being mistaken in that.
And I made a correction video.
But when I when I said that we were expecting that
they could also issue bills to people,
there was a lot of anger in the comments section on my on that video.
A lot of people were, you know, even kind of getting a little bit,
you know, throwing out like,
you know, at this guy, you know, screw him.
You know, he's he's all about, you know, profiteering off of us,
you know, whatever it's like.
It's like, bro, like if I do this for 10 years, you know, yeah, yeah, I've made,
you know, more than I should make from doing something like this.
But at the same time, it's like, dude, like, I mean, find me something else.
I'm just kidding.
But like but anyways, like people, people were just really angry in the comments.
And I think what that is is hurt.
People are hurting right now, right?
People are really upset and in denial that we had the election that we had
that's going to have these consequences for borrowers.
You know what I mean?
I think that's a little bit of it is like the psychology of like
this thing was promised to me and these guys are going to break the promise
about offering this plan that was given that was offered to me.
And, you know, and and they're going to not continue,
you know, almost I mean, basically almost six years of no interest at all.
Right. Like if you think about debt at zero percent, people,
people are not bothered by that.
And so you've had since 2020, you know, basically with that same plan,
you know, they had the zero percent interest until the end of the pause
and then save allowed a lot of people to not have to recertify
and keep their low payments, which gave them zero interest.
And then the same plan for Barrett's continued on with zero percent.
So, you know, you've got like five years worth of, hey,
you don't have to really make a payment if you don't want to.
Interest is zero.
And then suddenly that's starting to come to an end.
And people, a lot of people have, you know, taken that money
and pledged it to other things in their lives, too, just to be honest.
Right. People are not made of money.
Most people are not.
And so people have spent it on daycare.
They spent it on, you know, buying a home.
They spent it on, you know, having a reliable vehicle for their family.
And like suddenly this thing is coming back
and it's coming back with a vengeance and people are like, oh, oh, bleep.
You know, so I don't know that's.
And so I think, you know, what I'm trying to say is, well, some people
took advantage of that opportunity to build savings,
build wealth, build financial security.
And those people, you know, can go down this path.
And then the people who, you know, for whatever reason,
we're not able to do that.
Yeah, I'm on board with people continuing in the same plan for parents.
But but only as a as an opportunity for a wake up call, like, hey,
I got to change some stuff because like I want to be in that financial
abundance category of a borrower and not the I'm strapped
and praying for a miracle category of borrower.
But I guess, you know, that's where it's tough at, too,
because it depends on the audience that you're working with regularly, because.
Absolutely. Yeah.
I have borrowers who they need a miracle.
And I think about this one teacher I met in client of mine on California.
She lives in Oakland.
She single mom, three kids, no child whatsoever.
She makes one hundred thousand dollars, which sounds great on paper, but she's.
But it's but it's California.
So three kids. Yeah.
In one of the high cost living places.
And her payment under IBR is going to be unaffordable.
She's going to break her no matter what.
Now, those are always these edge cases like across the board.
But I think about that person and what opportunity
was there really for her to ever do more than build up an emergency savings?
Right. There was an opportunity to pay down the debt during COVID.
There may not have been opportunity to put that money
towards a high yield savings account.
So they have flexibility moving forward.
And so there's always going to be like this tension of have a have nots.
And oh, has it like you could do this and then other have nots like, well,
show me how I was supposed to do that.
And then so excited at 43 million bars.
We just have all these different stories.
Well, and I'm sorry.
And well, it's OK.
And I'm just thinking my wheels are turning, listening to the story,
because I guess what I would what I would say to a borrower like that
and the hard thing is, you know, obviously,
I've got to be able to pay people enough wages
where they're willing to take student loan consults.
That's a constraint that I have. Right.
And so, you know, so I cannot charge, in some cases, a low enough price
where someone like that would maybe be able to afford our services.
I like to think that people could, but not everybody can.
And so like so.
So but if a borrower like that was able to to pay for services
like what I would jump into right away is, OK, you know, family, three kids,
family size of four.
All right. We probably got maybe a 50, 60 K, you know, deduction.
Right. One hundred fifty percent of the poverty line.
And then, you know, we've got a lot of not good choices.
What what is the least bad choice? Right.
And, you know, I think I would I would ask her, I guess.
Like, I guess my saying, I think, you know, my my thinking is just like
kind of aligned with like the thinking of like a financial planner
versus coming at it from like a different angle. Right.
Like maybe how maybe how somebody else would think about it.
But I guess I would say, like, OK, you know, if she's a single mom,
she's a teacher.
Hopefully she's got a good pension on the way at some point. Right.
And so maybe it's OK to have a lower savings rate
knowing that that pension is coming at some point.
And, you know, maybe there are some things to do strategically,
depending on her debt amount, like maybe maximizing that, say, plan for parents
or maybe doing, you know, nine months out of the 24 months of forbearance
like during her higher income years or, you know, maybe, you know,
maybe you pause, you know, the student loans, build up enough savings to buy.
Like I don't know if she has like a new car payment or a used car payment. Right.
But if there's a way to get out of a car payment and get like, you know,
five, six thousand dollar car, that's not quite a beater Honda. Right.
But it's something that's reliable enough around town
and then put that money into, you know, a 401k to lower her AGI to pay even less
given her tax rates.
Yeah, that brain power that just went into like that.
Oh, yeah. Yeah.
Trying to take a limited pool of resources and say,
how do we split this up in such a way
that you're able to do all things adequately for yourself
and that they're going to be certain tradeoffs, whether that be a forbearance,
whether that be decreasing savings temporarily, whatever,
that you're going to have to survive because you can't survive.
And I agree you can.
But then the mental load that it takes on top of all the other things
you have to do.
Yeah, it's almost impossible to keep up with
without a rigorous support system there.
And unfortunately, our system doesn't come from your servicer.
And it damn for sure can't come from your friends and family
because they don't fully understand the load that you're under.
And so we have from advocates like us and assistants like us.
But then it comes at a cost, which is why I love doing these videos,
because like, dude, if you can't afford to consult,
I still want to be able to help you with our resources and videos like these,
where we have these conversations and say, right, can we do it?
But yeah, well, that's it. Yeah.
But but that's but that's the thing is, you know, hopefully she knows
she's not alone.
Hopefully she knows that, you know, there's there's no
you know, if you don't have it in the budget to hire a lawyer or hire
a financial plan or something, that's OK.
There's there is, you know, stuff like these free YouTube.
And then it comes down to, like, is this something you want to tackle
or is this something that, you know, you want to choose to ignore? Right.
And, you know, we can't we can't
make someone come to the well and drink, right?
They've got to be wanting to take to say, you know, hey, this is a bad situation.
This is screwed up.
This is so messed up for borrowers, but it is what it is.
And the only thing I can do is try to make a good, you know,
the best of this situation
or or bury my head in the sand.
Those are those are kind of the choices, right?
So, I mean, at least at least in terms of I don't know that cynical or something.
But I guess I guess the way I look at it is as it shouldn't be like this,
but it is kind of like cancer or something like that.
Right. Like cancer shouldn't exist, but it does.
Yeah. Right.
Like it just is what I tell people all the time.
Like, yes, you're in this relationship with the government.
And at times it's been an abusive relationship
or what felt like an abusive relationship.
And the only way to opt out of that relationship is for you
to get rid of the loan somehow, whether that be aggressive payoff,
whether that be discharged through bankruptcy or some forgiveness program.
But the reality is forgiveness.
All the programs take time except for total and permanent disability
or bar defense to repayment, even though that takes forever as well.
We're seeing really hard, even with the relaxed standards,
really hard to get rid of it.
So if you want to end that relationship, you have to aggressively pay off the debt.
But then when we run the numbers, there's simply not enough room
in your budget to aggressively pay off the debt for a large category of borrowers.
And so now you are stuck with the cards that are dealt with.
And you have to exist in this relationship.
And you hope the relationship improves over time is the best you can do.
And for a while, things worked.
Income PSLF did never really work.
But your repayment and staying current did work
because we had flexible repayment plans that adjusted.
Say arguably went too far.
And now we are left without saying with our mind space,
and these rules that we're trying to figure it out.
And we have to figure it out because what is the alternative default?
Default can have huge consequences for borrowers.
So I don't recommend that one either.
Well, I mean, that's like that's an interesting point, right?
Because like, hey, if you're starting to think beyond your student loans,
check out our other show, Financially Free Era.
It's about what comes next.
Investing, building wealth and designing a life you actually want.
Just search for Financially Free Era wherever you listen to your favorite
podcasts.
There's some huge differences
between the Obama administration and the Biden administration
in terms of how they handle student loans, like Obama was in that.
President Obama was in that more like pragmatic,
like kind of honestly centrist lane on student loans.
Like he wanted to cap Parent Plus, right?
Like he was you know, he did repay, which took away married filing separate.
Like so it's like he was very much in the hey, you know, like, yeah,
we want to have some protections, some interest subsidies.
But like, you know, let's let's be realistic with this or something, you know?
And like, I think Biden kind of used the student loan angle as a way to,
you know, really kind of hold together that political support within his party
because he wasn't as, you know, popular of a figure. Right.
And so, yeah, I think that, you know, I guess if Biden had been a
I don't know who the most popular Democrat would be currently, but, you know,
like that, I don't remember a special person.
There maybe is a one.
But, you know, if you had I mean, if you had an Obama level figure
currently in the Democratic Party,
I don't think that they would have necessarily done this.
He or she would have done the same plan. Right.
Like, I think that that was kind of in some ways like a reaction to
I've got to show I'm leading on an issue in a very progressive way.
And student loans was just sort of became this.
I don't know this this thing where he was able to try to connect
with younger voters who he struggled with. Right.
So I don't know.
I mean, that's that's kind of like just doesn't really help the situation
at this point.
I guess I wonder, like in the future, will the Democratic Party
try to return to cancel student debt?
Let's have the save plan come back.
Or will they be a little bit more, you know, a little bit more nuanced
in their approach?
I don't know. I don't know the answer to that.
I mean, none of us do, but I think it's forgiveness itself
is kind of a losing issue across the board.
But there I was thinking about, like,
what is an ideal kind of fix here look like?
Because there is no perfect fix to any of this.
And even if we treated higher education
like the public utility, it is and we fully subsidized it.
Then that leads to other problems as well, where other schools won't exist
because now we have to closely monitor kind of choices
and kind of cap the spending we have there.
And I don't know what a fix looks like is.
And one of the things I was thinking about it would be really cool
if we had like an amnesty day where like you say, start over two years from now.
Every borrower will be able to pay back what they originally borrowed
without the interest in capitalization.
You have two years to get to that point.
Now, that rewards those people who have the finances
to be able to pull that out of your window.
But then maybe we come up with some type of scaling provision where it's like,
OK, for those of you who over the last five years,
you've averaged less than, say, $80,000 household income.
You get to pay a tiered portion of that back and then we can move on
because no matter what we do, we're going to try to fix it moving forward.
But then we have 43 million borrowers who are on this long tail
that are going to be grossly affected by the changes that we make going forward.
I just didn't have a perfect solution.
But I was like, amnesty day sounds really cool to me because for the most part,
it is rare that I meet someone who doesn't want to pay back their fair share.
Now, what the fair share means to somebody?
He changes the video. Right. Yeah.
But a lot of people are just like, dude, is there a way for me
just to pay back what I borrowed and maybe a little bit of interest,
but not this grossly inflated amount.
It's not uncommon for me to meet someone who borrowed loans in the early 90s.
They borrowed 24,000.
They now owe $200,000 through a combination of capitalization.
They defaulted collection fee percentages, et cetera.
And that's absurd.
It's also a consequence of their decision.
So I don't want to take that away from them.
They made some decisions.
Sometimes life just happened to them, whatever.
But we need a fix.
And I don't even know what a fix looks like.
But amnesty day sounds really cool to me.
Well, I mean, let's talk about the next crisis, if that's all right.
So, I mean, you know, we've been talking,
we're talking about what we think is going to happen
to the number of graduate programs before we started recording. Right.
And Grab Plus came around 2006.
We're looking at this graph of pharmacy schools
where the number of pharmacy schools went from like 45 to like 83
in like three years after Grab Plus came out.
And now it's at like 133 pharmacy schools.
And, you know, I guess my prediction was it's going to fall like by 50 percent
the number of schools in the first three years of this new bill
once it goes fully into effect,
because you can only get that three year borrowing, you know, in place
if you start before July 1st, 2026.
So like next fall, people are going to be going to grad school
with 50 K per year limits and aggregate 200 K limits.
And so just thinking about the professional schools
that have been having people borrow, you know, 300, 400 K.
There's a lot of them out there.
I mean, what do you think happens next?
Because these are also not inflation adjusted limits.
So like every year that borrowing limit kind of goes down by inflation, too,
with the way they wrote it.
So it sort of feels like a ticking time bomb. Yeah.
I think over time, you're going to see the scaling back of programs
and institutions as well.
Like there are going to be HBCUs that simply can't exist
without parent plus loans.
That's just reality without some type of government intervention.
You're it was interesting about that stat.
Like we were looking at the table, the pharmacy schools are that
we nearly 4X the number of pharmacy programs,
but we did not 3X or 2X the number of applicants.
We just increased the amount of people that were admitted. Right.
That almost doubled, like almost tripled over time.
Yeah. 34% acceptance rate to like 87% acceptance rate. Right.
So I think you're going to see a culling back of programs.
You're going to see a culling of institutions.
And if you're an ran, you know, type person, you'll say,
good, this is what the market says.
If you'll survive, you're supposed to survive.
And I could work with that.
But then you're going to have people and people are weird in that
we're not going to do the smart thing financially.
We're going to do the thing that feels good emotionally.
And we're going to find a way
to fund our child's education outside of federal student loans.
And so that's going to be a step up in private loan borrowing.
And right now, there's going to be tighter limits on borrowing
because they're going to focus on prime borrowers with creditworthiness.
And they're going to move beyond creditworthiness and start looking at
what is the actual return on investment that you can expect for your degree
itself. And at the school that you're at,
you're going to see these kind of sophisticated models
continue to evolve because they already exist.
But then at some point, they're going to run out of prime borrowers
and people are going to borrow separate loans.
And you'll see people with 14, 15, 16, 17 percent interest rates
on private student loans that they're taking out,
not because it is a smart financial decision, but because it is
I need to do this as a parent for my child
to give them what I could not have myself,
which I don't know how we account for that.
And I don't know that you can turn this Titanic around quick enough
to like get rid of that behavior, because you're going to have people
that are unfortunately are stuck because they're starting school.
They already started school this year.
They have to pay for year four and instead of withdraw.
Right. Like or change schools.
Like and why why do I need to change schools?
My your my oldest kid, your oldest daughter, she got to go to hell.
She wanted to know, why can't I do the same thing?
So it's going to be all these internal pressures that you can't account for,
but that are going to exist.
And I think that's going to be a really sad situation
that the number of borrowers who are going to take out loans,
that they really can't afford to pay back comfortably
and are going to end up in a worse financial position.
They're going to have to leverage their retirement, et cetera,
or they're going to have to look to bankruptcy as a solution.
Yeah. I mean, like what what do you tell?
I mean, like also, I've been getting stories from borrowers saying
like they're asking their financial aid officers about this
and the financial aid officers are like, oh, there's nothing to worry about.
It'll be fine. Don't don't don't worry.
You know, I mean, like, oh, they told us back in ninety six,
ninety seven, ninety eight when we're in undergrad.
They're like, oh, take out the loans.
You'll find a way to pay it back.
You'll figure it out.
Like I mean, like I think that is there any accountability, right?
To where if that statement is false, is there any legal remedies you have
or, you know, and the answer is no.
So it's sort of like, you know, or at least most cases, I guess, like
there may be like where these states have developed these consumer rights laws
that didn't exist at the time that, you know, for me, I went to undergrad
in ninety eight, ninety nine ish era, and those consumer rights hadn't developed.
And there may be individual claims that need to be pursued at that point.
But those are also far downstream.
I think I just worry about like, OK, where are we at today?
Which is good thing.
Current bars have options.
Yeah. Future borrowers have less options.
They have to be more circumspect with the institution they're paying for.
But then also accounted for just humans
and humans are not going to do the best financial thing.
They are going to do the best emotional thing at times, often.
And how do we protect those people?
That is my concern.
I hope that the next administration
prioritizes fix this moving forward,
not just in a way that calls things.
And I think that's where we're at.
We're getting one of cat programs, bro.
But like the way that we're doing it is like really harsh.
Well, yeah, I mean, I mean, I'm thinking about,
you know, people that are going to go to school that need to borrow
for the three years, whatever they have to borrow for the fourth year.
Like there's a lot of people in dental school
right now that are going to be borrowing for those three years
and then the year four comes along and you've got to borrow
one hundred fifty to two hundred thousand dollars for that final year.
So living expenses has got to pay for matching.
Why do you have to pay for your travel matching,
which is already funded by private loans?
But it just increases the load overall.
Right. But I'm just thinking like, OK, so you take out the hundred fifty K
to finish your four.
And that is a fifteen hundred dollar payment a month
when you end on top of whatever the IBR payment is.
And so people are going to come out making, OK, you're making one hundred fifty.
But after taxes, this is going towards student loans.
Yeah. But after taxes, you're making one hundred thousand
because student loans are not tax deductible. Right.
And so you're OK, so you're making eighty five hundred a month.
And of that three grand a month is going to be going to student loans.
And so like there's this, you know, you could say there is
a supply demand shock to the market that's coming to.
And I think that this is definitely on the way where I think we're going to see
is if you have half the schools closed down, there's going to be a half
of the new entrance into the labor market that there were before, too.
And so if you get, you know, fewer people entering the labor market,
employers have no choice in that, you know, supply demand equation.
But to pay higher wages, presumably. Right.
I mean, so I think that you will see wages for existing providers
in these sectors, I think, go up over time.
But it's good. That's not going to happen right away.
I think it's going to happen a very long term.
And, you know, only if this sort of strict
loan system survives, which I actually don't think it will.
I mean, that's that's the other prediction I've got.
Stanley is like, you know, I've been doing this long enough
to see so many iterations of things come and go that like
the second you have unified democratic control of D.C.,
I think that the student loan system gets rewritten again.
I don't think that this current system is is is going to last
maybe more than my prediction would be a few years,
and then it'll be changed again.
I agree with you on that, because as we get ready to draw to a close here,
I think a lot about that, too, with
what we're trying to solve for right now is right now,
next year and maybe the year after.
Unfortunately, student loans are this unique debt
that has long term implications, but doesn't come with like this
set in and forget it mindset.
It's actually a very active involvement in it,
unlike your mortgage or your cardinal, where you just pay it
and you don't think about it.
But to student loans, you have to manage it based on those rules.
And I do think we'll see a change because that's just consistent
with how we handle other areas of law.
Like the code gets too verbose and we have to trim it
and we have to totally overhaul it.
We've done it with the Internal Revenue Code.
We've done it with the bankruptcy code.
We have not done it with the Higher Education Act the same way.
We've made these iterative changes.
ICR was an iterative change.
IBR was an iterative change.
IBR 10 percent.
Pay as you earn.
Repay. Save was arguably an iterative change.
Also like kind of a nuclear bomb to it with the early forgiveness timelines.
A little bit overdrawn, but whatever.
So we're going to see a change there.
I don't know what that change looks like for future borrowers
in terms of not only their repayment options, but their borrowing limits.
Because I do believe we need some type of control on it.
Parent PLUS loans.
Yeah, they're unlimited.
And we did that because we shifted how we paid for school.
It used to be states involved.
And they come along, say, you know what, just put it on the backs of parents.
And then we make these ridiculous loans that are not tied to creditworthiness
whatsoever, because we need lower income families
to also be able to pay for their children to go to school.
And if we put credit limits, they're not going to be able to afford it.
And I hope to see a change in the future
that gets things right, whatever right looks like.
But I'm not even sure what that means,
because arguably higher education is a public utility.
And I think we should treat it as such because our population does much better.
But educated society, does that mean we need to increase taxes in order to do it?
I don't know.
But I think we need to be real with ourselves about what higher education
means to the value of our GDP.
Well, I mean, one one idea that I thought was actually
kind of smart, the way the Biden administration tried to structure
the structure, the cancellation was giving people who got Pell Grants
an extra 10 K of cancellation like that kind of in a lot of ways
kind of is a way to, you know, imperfect way.
But it's a way to kind of identify who needs a little bit more help.
Right. And who's coming from families that do not have generational wealth.
Right. So I'm just sort of thinking about like, man,
if they had just made this new law that anybody who got a Pell Grant
in undergrad for grad school, they can get an extra 25 K borrowing limit.
You know what I mean?
I mean, that would have made a big difference
because then somebody would have been able to borrow, you know,
300 K over four years of medical school instead of 200.
And you would have eliminated a lot of the private loans for that
for that subprime market.
It's going to be paying 14 percent or something.
Yeah, dude, it's a we have yet to reckon with our original sin.
And so, you know, we're programs where we need.
We do need to account for the inequities in just long term finances
and that people just don't have the same amount of resources to pay for things.
And the change that we have in place don't account for that.
They're just like this hash of job done.
I do agree something needed to change.
I don't know that the way that we're changing it makes the most sense
for the whole of society.
And, you know, it's who can go to school
in a way that is not financially ruinous moving forward.
Well, I mean, and you know, I think that the issue of student loans
going forward, too, is going to be just frankly way more partisan
than it was in the past, right?
Like if you go back to the Romney sort of Republican era,
like there was a lot of lot of people graduate degrees in the suburbs.
Those people were basically all Republican or not all Republicans,
but, you know, disproportionately Republicans. Right.
And then come fast forward to now, you have this big education gap
between the parties that didn't used to really be there in the way
that it is now. Right.
And and so you have, you know, with the Republican Party,
a lot more of a working class type of coalition.
There's a lot less interested in the fate of student loan borrowers
than they would have been 10 years ago.
You know, we're one issue voters, man, to talk to other sources
that made people one issue voters, immigration.
I'm all about that. Right.
Student loans. I don't care about that.
I got no student loans.
But I think, you know, that's where we look bigger picture about
what does this mean for our overall society, who we aspire to be as individuals?
I hope that is one that we are empathetic towards one another.
But they don't seem that way.
Thank you so much for being in the show, Stanley.
And check out Stanley Tate wherever you listen to anything with student loans.
Check out student loan planner as well.
A lot of chaos, and even with this bill passing in the coming months,
so we will keep our eyes on the chaos for you so you don't have to.
And thank you so much for listening to the student loan planner podcast.
And thank you so much for listening to Stanley and me just chat about
just what's going on in the crazy world of student loans.
Have a great rest of your week.
Are you on the free student loan planner email list?
If yes, you could upgrade your experience and discover student loan loopholes
so good they might get repealed if I talk about them publicly.
Find out my very best thought leadership
that I really just can't be super open about anymore, unfortunately.
If you want to get our very best tips, not just the ones that I can share for free,
then go to studentloanplanner.com slash insider
to get a special discount for your year membership.
That's studentloanplanner.com slash insider
and get our very best dozens of bonus content and tips
that's going to save you money and get you out of student debt faster.
And if you're already an SLP insider,
please reply back to those emails and let me know how I can make it even more valuable.