"The Gun" (1976) – Part 1: Flintlock to Percussion

Battlefield Firearms
3 followers
Mar 17, 2025
This is 1 of 8, in an excellent series of 15 minute documentaries detailing the development of guns from the flintlock to modern military arms and is definitely one for the connoisseur. Note, there are some tape damage parts. I recorded this series with my first VHS machine in the early eighties and when the tapes started deteriorating, I transferred them to DVD, using an old player to clean the corrosion off and a new player and tape cleaner, used about every 10 minutes to clean the heads. Took about 3 weeks. then when I couldn't find this series on YouTube, I decided to converted them to Mp4 using Sony Vegas, for upload, as I wanted to make sure this documentary, in great BBC style, stayed alive.
The Armourers is the last in a series of individual competitions which together make up
the aggregate for the Match Rifle Championship at Bisley. This is the moment when people know
whether they're in their national team or whether they've just failed to make it.
When in these very difficult conditions they try to stay on the target to get somewhere in the
prize list, so it's particularly appropriate in this very tough competition that the prize is
this handsome silver medal commemorating Alexander John Forsyth, the greatest benefactor
in the history of the development of firearms.
The Reverend Forsyth, Minister of Bellhelby in Scotland, was a keen wildfowler and therefore
particularly conscious of the exasperating consequences of the slowness of the ignition
of the flintlock. It was so slow, he wrote, that the duck had time on seeing the flash in the pan
to dive to safety underwater before the shot reached them.
Whatever you're thinking, the ignition delays with the flintlock were so considerable
that one shot only at sitting birds. The art of shooting flying was a long way away in time yet.
But that wasn't the worst or the only one of the Reverend Alexander Forsyth's difficulties.
You've seen the problem with the flint. The leading edge wears away
and one has to change it. In fact, 10 or 12 shots is the absolute limit for one flint.
But you've also a problem with the steel. This face which is being struck by the flint
gets chipped away and every so often they had to have this refaced.
The vulnerability of the flintlock to rain or scotch mist conditions
was another source of frustration to a keen wildfowler.
There was no way of preventing water dripping into the pan between the inner lip of the pan
cover and the barrel and it needed very little moisture in the powder to put the sportsman
completely out of action. Unloading the soaked charge and reloading was in itself quite an
operation. With a double barrel shotgun, there was the real danger of blowing your head off
as you reloaded one barrel when the other was still charged. It was very easy to forget to
lower the cock on the loaded barrel to make it safe. A slight flaw in the engagement of the sear
in the lock, quite a frequent fault in fact, and the jar of ramming could fire the other barrel.
When the gun missed fire, the sportsman's first instinct was not to draw the charge,
a tedious business of screwing the rammer tip into the successive layers of the charge
and drawing out each separately, but to prick some more fine grain powder through the vent
so that if you were lucky, it would transmit the flame from the powder in the pan
to the powder of the charge. But you weren't always lucky. Even in this most perfect form
of the flintlock, with a roller to reduce friction and speed the lock's action, with a v-pan like this
to prevent the water going in, with a platinum bouche to reduce corrosion, with a patent breech
to improve the speed of the whole action, you had to watch such things as the flint becoming loose
and not packing the powder down so that it caked and wouldn't ignite. In fact the flintlock in its
most perfect form, and expensive form too, was far short of what the sportsman really required under
all conditions. The Reverend Forsyth was not only a clergyman and a sportsman, but a keen amateur
student of chemistry and engineering. Forsyth was determined to improve the performance of the gun
under sporting conditions. To start with, he thought that the solution might be found in
improving the strength of the gunpowder. He thought by taking out the potassium nitrate
and putting in fulminates, he'd achieve his object. But he was still using spark ignition,
and then the idea struck him that really all that he needed to do to ignite the gun was to use
percussion to strike the powder. And he designed a lock in which this was possible, and this is it.
This is the scent bottle lock, or roller magazine lock. It's very simple indeed. This scent bottle
contains the powder, and it simply rotates on an axis so that at this position, 180 degrees round,
by gravity the powder is dropping into a little anvil inside. It was then rotated back so that
the striker at the top is in position over the powder, and it's ready to fire.
It needed a safety device, and there's a blowout plug at the bottom, so that if by any chance
it's a little slack on the pivot and the powder went up, it blew out safely without damaging the
fire. But such a lock required very fine workmanship, and it was expensive. It was
an excellent solution for the wealthy sportsman. Unfortunately, it was not a solution for the
soldier. It is still, of course, a lock applied to a muzzle-loading weapon which has to be loaded
with powder, wad and ball in the usual manner. But the speed with which the lock could be primed and
made ready was impressive. More impressive still, however, was the speed of ignition,
virtually simultaneous with the fall of the hammer. No duck could dive that fast.
It was here in this manse at Bell Helvey that Forsyth lived for 75 years, and it was in these
grounds that he had his workshop, the Minister's Smiddy, a garden house where he produced his
experimental locks, and no doubt went on for years with improved designs. It was not from here,
however, but from Number 10 Piccadilly that his weapon was made available to the public.
He'd been helped in its patent in 1807 by the celebrated James Watt and by James Purdy,
and from Piccadilly the public were able to buy first the scent bottle lock and then later an
improved version. His improved lock still used loose percussion priming powder, which had to
be treated with considerable respect. In fact, only a few grains were put in the magazine,
so the amount needed per shot was only one eighth of a grain.
Priming could not be simpler. Ignition was so fast that in future attention to speed the action
of the gun still further would be directed only to shortening the distance travelled by the hammer
or striker. Logically, the next step forward in the development of the design of the perfect firearm
was to have cartridges containing their own ignition loaded at the breech.
This was exactly what these cartridges are, and they were invented by Jean-Samuel Paulet
to be used in this epoch-making weapon, which was also of his design. These cartridges sealed
or obturated the breech perfectly. Brass expands momentarily with the explosion of the charge to
seal the breech, and then contracts sufficiently for the cartridges to be extracted after firing.
Paulet cased his guns with all the necessary tools and other items,
so that the owner could load and reload his cases as necessary.
It was a gun very difficult to criticise, unless grossly misused.
These small brass cartridge ends may look rather strange to the modern eye,
but they did the job extremely well. In fact, Paulet also covered the long brass case,
which totally sealed the breech. In every particular, this gun is a modern breech-loading
weapon, and yet it failed. Paulet, a Swiss, worked in Paris from 1808 to 1814,
and he failed, unfortunately, to get his invention accepted. Then he came to Britain,
but he was so little successful in getting the populace to accept his views, that when he died
about 1828, it was in total obscurity. The man who, next to Forsyth, perhaps did the most
for the development of firearms, died completely unknown. Until 1821, Forsyth's patent ran on,
preventing others in Britain from challenging him seriously, but at the same time encouraging
others, including Wesley Richards, to try every kind of alternative means of harnessing the
percussion principle. As possible vehicles for the fulminate, tubes, patches, pills, pellets,
caps, and many other forms were tried by many makers, and even magazine loading of pellets
was employed. One of the most successful forms of percussion detonator was the tube. A simple
copper tube, lightly crimped at the ends, was held in a kind of clamp, so that the detonating flash
passed through the vent to the charge. The tube lock was widely adopted on the continent, but was
also seen in such versions as that of Joseph Manton on the sporting field in England. In some areas,
it remained common for almost as long as percussion muzzle loaders survived. It was the percussion
cap, however, which in the end gained by far the widest following. Who first thought of using a
small symbol of copper this way will probably never be known. There were many claimants for
the honour. Colonel Peter Hawker, the great sportsman, was one of them, but so too were the great gun makers
Haig and Purdy. Caps shared with pellets the important property of being easily magazine loaded.
It is one of the curious facts of history, that though they could so easily be mechanically
seated on the nipple, they never were in any British army weapon. By the 1840s, the percussion
cap was dominant. Forsyth's invention was triumphant. Only the sailors in the Royal Navy,
as their bare feet trod on spent copper caps, had mixed feelings, and their complaint was not
against Forsyth himself. After 250 years of use, the flintlock was finally eclipsed.
When they laid the Reverend Alexander Forsyth to rest here in Bellhelvey in June 1843,
all he had received from a grateful government for his epoch-making invention was 200 pounds.
He'd had his expenses, but 200 pounds was all he'd received. In fact, a little after his death,
a further thousand pounds was paid to his relatives as a result of a parliamentary petition launched
for him. Even so, 1,200 pounds, and Joshua Shaw in America got 4,000 pounds for the invention of
a percussion cap, and he probably didn't in fact invent it. Forsyth is reputed to have turned down
20,000 pounds for the French government in the Napoleonic Wars, but as a good patriot,
he refused it. All that Forsyth had in fact for this outstanding invention was a doctorate.
The opportunity was lost by the British government in 1806, for Thys spent a whole year in the tower
working on the invention under the Master General of Ordens, but with the change of Master Generals,
the British government sent him packing with all his rubbish.
It was one of the great lost opportunities in history.
