We Test 3 Ways To Set A Fence Post (1 Winner)

Full House
57 followers
1 Video View·Mar 15, 2025
Hey there you snuck up on me. You caught me doing two of my least favorite things.
Digging holes and we're getting ready to pour some concrete and see how that compares to wet
versus dry versus post foam only this time we're going to do it with wood post. So we've dug these
holes about three feet deep. We use a 12 inch auger but we never want to leave any loose soil
in the bottom of the hole. If you disturb it it comes out of the hole. To give you an idea
the depth of these holes this mark is 42 we're right about here. It should be right at about
36 inches deep. So at the end of this what we're going to do is we're going to dig these posts up
we're going to pull them out and see if there's any difference. Now we're probably going to wait
about a week and allow that concrete to cure and we're going to see what the dry concrete does
after a week. Now it's really important to notice that this soil has some moisture but very very
little. Like it's got just enough if I squeeze it together it'll kind of stick together in a
dirt clod. This is fairly dry ground we haven't had a lot of moisture and we don't get a lot of
moisture. This doesn't get irrigated or anything so it's always dry. The last time we did the post
foam and the dry pack was in the spring and so there was a lot of runoff a lot of water snow
and things like that to help. So we're going to see if it makes any difference this time not having
anything other than natural rain which is we're starting to come into our dry season to help cure
that concrete. All right what do you say? Well let's start mixing. My least favorite thing to
do in the whole wide world and just stab your point right into it without stabbing me. Come on
get in there. We're going to take two more bags of this. These are 60 pound bags. The stiffer it is
the harder it is to mix and the wetter it is the poorer the quality of the concrete.
We're just vibrating this really good. That last batch is probably a little drier than
maybe you want it. It'll be fine though. What you will notice we use a 12 inch auger but what we
have is on these corners if we use a really small auger let's say we use an eight inch auger we're
going to have no strength right here on the corner because it's only going to come to right about
there and then that's where this will break out. So if we had a small hole we would have almost
no strength right here in the corners. So that's why we use a 12 inch auger. The other thing you
want to take into account for is if your auger moves when you're drilling these holes. If it
moves even a little bit with a really small tight hole you're never going to get that post in the
right spot. So we'd rather buy a little bit of extra concrete for making sure we have good footings
if we're going to use this method versus saving a little bit of money on the concrete and then
having to spend a bunch of time and labor moving holes later on after we've hit really rocky ground
and it moves. Awesome you can just set those right there by that hole. Okay today we're going to do a
bonus because I have a very special post that we've set up for that fourth hole because we're
going to have wet concrete, dry concrete, post foam and you're probably thinking what's that one for?
Well it's for our special post and we'll talk about that here in a minute. Okay next you can
start off with your big end but if you're going to dry pack eventually we're going to use this end
and that'll give us a lot better compaction. If we're going to throw it in there dry it's got to
be compact. If you don't pack it you will make very very weak concrete not to mention this post
will want to move all over the place for quite some time probably in this dry climate. So once
we get the bottom pack you want to check the level then we'll just go around we'll stab this end and
that helps recompact it even better. Okay epic. We'll cover all these with dirt.
Oh we didn't check this post. Is it plumb? Nope. Okay if you take nothing away from this video at
all please take this away. This is your bonus tip. Now this post is not plumb here just so you can see
we're way over the line. We need to move this post this way a lot to get it plumb.
Now what I see everybody doing in all these videos with these DIYers doing their own fence
the next thing they're going to do is they're going to go over here and they're going to get
their 2x4s and they're going to put 2x4s all the way around this post. They're going to stake it off
and get this thing all nice and plumb and then they're going to wait for the concrete to cure
right here. Well let me just show you why that's not necessary. So we need to get this post plumb.
We just barely poured it. We're out of plumb as we've shown you. I'm going to push on this post
as hard as I possibly can right now and I'm still not even plumb right now. So I got to go some more
tamp that with your big end. Okay that's good. So we're plumb both ways right now and you saw how
much work I had to put in to get that post to move. Trust me whatever wind you have is not moving that
post. It takes a lot of pressure and as dry as this mix is unless you mix it as soup it's very
very quickly going to set up because it has very fine aggregate. So we've got this thing plumbed
up and when we come back to pull this we'll see if it's still straight because I guarantee you I
am not using any 2x4s to brace this. We have done 40 foot tall fences and never braced a single post.
Stop doing that if you're doing that or considering doing that. If you see your contractor using
bracing like that that is your first sign that you hired somebody that doesn't have a clue what
they're doing and you should be worried and really watch what they're doing from that point forward.
Okay so now this is the special post. There's two different things about this post that make
it special. We decided that since we saw a video about the benefits of adding screws to the bottom
of our post in the concrete I would do the same. So I have added screws. I think maybe he only had
six or so in there. I'm thinking you know if six is good this many is better so you're welcome.
We're going to dry pack this and wet set it. I say we put it in there dry and see if the screws help
hold the concrete together better as it's dry. It's going to be very tough to dry pack though
because I'm going to be fighting these, the walls, this post hole is a lot smaller so we only used a
nine inch auger to drill this one and as you will see as we put this thing in here there's not a whole lot of room
and this is what I'm talking about on the corners we don't have a lot of concrete. Now
this may be acceptable this may turn out but we're going to go ahead and put this in here dry
which will also tell us whether or not compacting the concrete matters at all because guess what
I'm not going to compact it. I really can't without bending all my screws and I have such a tight hole
but you can see if my hole was off at all I would have a hard time getting that in line
because I've got no room especially with these screws in it just making it worse. Now mind you
this other post took five bags this one will probably only take two maybe two and a half
because we used a really small hole. Oh that sounds like plinko that really sounds like plinko
that brings me back to my Bob Barker days. So this hole smaller less concrete but we have screws
but we can't tamp it. It'll be really interesting to see how this one turns out. You can tamp the top
probably. The cool thing is we'll be digging these up so we can see exactly what it looked
like as it sat in its natural habitat that we made for it. So it's been a couple days and now
we have our our foam and what we're going to use today is the Sika Post Flex. This thing I think
they say someplace it replaces like two bags of concrete so I kind of expect we're going to have
to use two maybe even a part of a third to fill this hole all the way up. We will find out here
in just a second. Burst the seal. I think you roll it up. Caution caution caution step one.
Get your safety stuff yes check roll check. Now try and get all that good that goodness
from the bottom into the top. Then I think we're supposed to do this for 15 seconds.
That feels about right right? If we don't do it soon enough I guess it'll start boiling up in our
bag. I can tell you it does get warm. It is what they call an exothermic reaction. Now here's the
part I really don't particularly love. Until it starts setting up it's just all whoppity floppity.
This may be the only case you may have to use the uh the old bracing method that we showed you and
cursed about so many times. I don't want to move it too much as it's setting up. We want to try
and keep it fairly consistent. I would compare this to setting up hydraulic cement when we do
our core drill stuff. And we have some other methods so we don't actually screw it. What I
would do is I'd probably just take two truss rods and bend them so they come right over the top
because we just need a little bit of holding power here. It's already starting to get a little
stiffer than it was in the beginning. After we set this I'm going to show you something. Something
you might not believe but you'll see it with your own eyes for real. It's definitely expanding. It's
getting firmer but still not firm. Do another bag just because. Now I've done it once so I'm
really good at it. I know the rules. I know the whole situation. The other part is is you're gonna
have to have your post set to height or you're gonna have to cut them off. Trying to pull them
up and float them in the foam probably not something you'll be able to do like you can with
concrete. Not setting any records getting stiff at all. Like it's still wobbly. So while we wait
for this thing to set up I will tell you that we have used this exactly one time. One time we have
used post foam on a project. It was a project up on a mountain. Could not get concrete to it. Couldn't
get water to it. It was pack everything on whatever you can take on your back so we're not going to
pack yards and yards of concrete and that's when we went to the foam and it worked very well for
that particular situation. It wasn't a full fence. It was more of a cable barrier. They say at the
top here you just trim that off. I guess if you're going to do a bunch of this maybe having a hot
knife would be good because a hot knife would cut right through this. It's starting to firm up like
I can feel resistance but it's very very sticky. The good news is it does not take that long I guess.
What are we five minutes into this maybe? Yeah. I think we're pretty good. It can hold itself now.
We're gonna let it hold itself. Why don't you come over here and I'll show you something.
This is a power pole. This is not a fence post. They set this power pole about two years ago.
Maybe actually longer. It's probably been more like four years since they set that
and if you'll look right down here at what they used to set that. Post foam. I'm gonna just
let you know this post hasn't blown over and I can't push it over. All the ground is different.
This is again very very rocky so you get down about 18 inches and then it's nothing but solid
sand and gravel all the way down. You know river cobble. If you look at our where we dug the post
holes and rocky ground there's a video right over here for that. This is right across the road from
that so very very rocky ground about two feet down. I think that they just decided that it would
be easier for them to backfill this giant hole because they usually get pretty big with foam
than it would be to try and tamp it because they know they can't get down in there. I think they
drill these about seven or eight feet. All their poles that they're setting out are done with the
foams. They're using five gallon buckets of it but likely made by one of these big suppliers
just like the stuff we're using in our post. So if you want a practical application not fencing
where foam is used right here and where we're doing this testing right there. It's very sticky
still. Still wobbly. We'll see if it gets a little harder. It's still very very sticky. I don't want
to put my finger in that. So we'll let this thing finish curing and then in a couple days when it's
actually seven days on all these posts then we will come back and dig them up and show you what
it looks like. Many days later at least seven yeah seven seven days later so this is at a seven day
cure time and luckily for us we did get a thunderstorm the other day that dropped a
bit of rain probably didn't make it all the way to the bottom of the hole but maybe we'll see a
difference in the top part of the concrete on the dry pack versus the bottom. I don't know we'll see
but before we do that I want to just kind of make sure they're in there tight. So I'm going to pull
this way but I mean it feels it feels solid. This one this one actually feels solid too like I feel
like I could snap the post off before the foam gave away. It's actually pretty pretty stout. This
one is dry packed as well. I don't I mean I'm seeing flecks in the post but I'm not really
seeing the ground move and I really don't have any concerns about wet set concrete working.
Hopefully we can all agree that works. Oh no this isn't good. This isn't good at all. This this is
the top. This is not dry pack. This is just throw it in there dry and let's see what happens. We did
not pack it. It doesn't look good. It doesn't look good. It felt solid. It did. I think it got hard-ish
but obviously we can't even push the post over without issues. I'm going to be a lot more careful
when I do the next one. We can see that some moisture got in there and made it kind of hard
but it's in our climate this probably needs more time. Even with the thunderstorm we got the other
day it's not enough water and without enough water those nails or screws didn't seem to do anything.
We might have to try that again later. Oh yeah there we go. That's it.
Hang on. Man I've been working out. I don't think it's going to break off. It was very well bonded
to the ground. I did not see any cracks anywhere around it. The dirt was molded. I mean you can
see it's still completely molded to this post. See zero issues with that whatsoever. So what I will
say about the post foam is the fact that it is expensive. Roughly $19 per bag so we used up $38
worth of post foam. Conversely on the post that we set in concrete we used up about four to five
bags and they're about four dollars a bag at our local store for a 60-pound bag and so that same
concrete cost us roughly $20 so roughly half the price but we didn't have to mix anything. We
didn't have to carry anything so much more expensive way to set posts. You're welcome.
Yeah I hate to say it. This stuff is not even remotely set up up top here. Yeah this isn't
going to work. That's with a rainstorm. But what I can tell you is we did pack this in here so this
is dry pack. The only thing we did is instead of using dirt we used concrete which cost us more
money. If we were just going to pack this in here and it stayed dry forever we're better off using
dirt or soil because it's not going to rot as fast. Man I don't know what to say about this
other than I mean it was in there solid. I'm sure it would set up over time it's just I have no idea
when it would set up. But it was solid I could pull on it and it felt just like all the rest of
them. In the last test we gave it probably a month and it was spring so we had a lot more moisture
in the ground and then we had a lot more moisture coming down. I guess that's just a warning if
you're going to try this in a sprinkled yard it's probably not going to be an issue but if you're
out in the middle of nowhere and you're in a dry climate like we are it's going to take a while to
set up. This is after seven days it's still powdery and you can see there's moisture in the ground
but it didn't suck any of that out. See it feels like right there there's some that hardened at
the very bottom of the hole maybe where there was more moisture I'm not sure. Don't worry this post
is good for another day. Okay last one hopefully this one's set up. I really feel like I'd snap
this post off if I tried too hard. Yeah it's cracking like it has no flexibility and that's
one of the advantages of the trident post is you have that flexibility. It may not seem like
it's stronger but believe me there's a huge advantages to it. So here's your bonus tip right
here you see how uniform the rest of the hole is and then we get to the top and it's all blown out
this is one of the reasons that we suggest that you leave your concrete down is because if you
live in a frost environment this is a huge lever for that frost to be forcing those posts out of
the ground when you get frosty. It's almost impossible to drill a hole and not have it
kind of conical at the very top. We prefer to leave the concrete down a little bit and help
alleviate some of that problem and then that frost locks that post in. So if you're an engineer
watching this and you're advocating for people doming concrete please stop it does no good.
This is the part where you want me to bust this concrete off huh? I don't really want to I'm not
gonna lie. I feel like this is how many licks to the center of a titsy pop kind of thing here only
the end will be way less satisfying. I mean I don't know what else you want to see it held up good
with more cure time this would get even stronger it probably hasn't reached its max cure time yet
28 day cure strength. So the one interesting thing that we noticed is that you're able to see
the line right here where we separated our two pours believe it or not I can see it right here
Plain as day. Did not bond together even though we poured it at the same time really.
It did what we thought it was going to do. You know we're all about bonus content so as promised
what I want to do now is I want to show you our absolute favorite way to put posts in the ground
using our absolute favorite post. We're going to use the Rhino MultiPro XA. Oh that thing is spicy
hot. XA means it has an extended anvil it sticks down in this slot and the slot is what's going to
Big benefits to doing this are number one it's incredibly strong we have videos all over the
internet for more information on that check out this video here where we use trident posts and
a airboat to simulate a hurricane and see how strong these things really are. The nice thing
again is is it's an engineered product they're always going to be perfect they're never going
to warp, crack, chip, rust. Okay well they could rust I mean let's be real but it's going to take
a very very long time and because of the galvanization it holds up good in all climates
especially our dry arid climate but we use these things all day every day in Florida as well and
have had great success. Oh you know what the other benefits there's no dirt mess in our lawn when
we're done so if there's no mess in my lawn it means I don't have to clean up the mess I don't
have to haul a mess I don't have to carry concrete I don't have to worry about whether or not I'm
going to do it dry or wet I don't have concrete dust that I'm breathing in huge plus. So that's
30 inches this must be a eight foot post so we have 30 inches in five and a half feet out and
it took us under two minutes to do that it's ready to go. I'm going to just leave it at 30 inches we
could go deeper we could go to 36 inches we go to 48 inches if we wanted probably here we're not
going to get 48 we can easily get 36 just because as mentioned we have all this rock underneath the
ground. You can also see I can do all this stuff by myself if I'm very thoughtful about the way I
go about it I don't need any other help I can do all this on my own that's a big benefit. Now we've
got a post that's in here nice and strong and I guarantee you I would bend this post over well
before the ground failed on me. As mentioned before the only reason we use concrete is because
we need a fill that's going to get hard and it needs to be just as hard as the ground around it
so if we don't disturb the soil and we keep the ground hard then we don't need to have that heavy
weighted concrete for the additional strength. The surface area of the post is enough to keep
that in place and we have so many years of testing on this it's not even funny. So before you write
your comment down below telling me how this doesn't work it absolutely does. Places it doesn't work
especially with this driver if you have a lot of rock. As you noticed we have quite a bit of rock
under the ground but the first couple feet is really good. If it was like that all the way down
we would probably skip this but we have that clay layer that two foot clay layer above it allows the
post to stay put while we drive it and then it kind of holds that post right where we want it
so it can bust through the rocks. Again if those rocks were at the top we'd have a very difficult
time and I probably would not try this. That's a place where digging and excavating the dirt
and refilling it with concrete is probably better. This post is very hot
very hot. You know to be fair we should probably try and pull this thing out.
So I'm going to guess that probably took about a thousand pounds 1,500 pounds of pull to get
that thing out of the ground. One of the things people don't understand is if I was to drive a
two and three eighths pipe into the ground and it's all smooth and it's all round that takes
a lot less friction but something like this you'll notice that you get all that compaction
down inside the post and we have all that friction on every single square inch of this post
allowing it to really grab into that ground. Not that we have reverse gravity. We don't have a
whole lot of forces pulling up on our fences. It's usually laterally that we're going to have forces
or in line with the fence but this just shows how hard those things go on the ground if you have
good solid clay. Obviously if you have softer ground you're going to want to go deeper. If you
have frost you may want to go deeper still to get below the frost layer although it is not as
critical to get below the frost layer as it is with concrete because there's less surface area
for that frost to grab onto and shove that post out. It is not as affected by frost as concrete is.
Now you might be asking yourself can I rent one of these drivers? Highly unlikely. We get that
question all the time but most people only have drivers that don't have that extended anvil we
talked about so they can't drive the channel post not to mention they're probably not going to have
the channel post adapter. Another thing people ask us is can I use your channel post adapter on some
other driver? No you cannot. They are very brand specific. You need to buy the right adapter for
the type of driver that you're renting. Some rhinos are available at the rental store but most those
don't have that channel post adapter and they don't have the ability to drive the channel post
because of that extended anvil so check around. You may find one at your local rental store but
there's no guarantees. If you're a professional looking for one we sell those and there's a link
right down here and if you're looking for the Trident posts those are also available in the
link down below and that link down below that's like in the description you need to click on the
video and then there will be a whole bunch of links down there you'll see it and click
on that and that'll take you to the site where you can purchase all this stuff.
