19 Video Views·Mar 12, 2025 #education #gender #biology Are sex categories—male and female—real, immutable, and binary? Or are they “social constructs”? Colin Wright, Ph.D. in evolutionary biology and fellow at the Manhattan Institute, has the answer.
Do you know the truth about transgender ideology and "gender-affirming care"? Take the quiz and sign the petition to protect kids from harmful ideology. 👉 https://l.prageru.com/3s9t12U
This video was made possible by a generous donation from Joseph U. Oswald.
Script:
Asked to define the word “woman” during her Supreme Court confirmation hearings in 2022, Judge Ketanji Jackson famously demurred, saying “I’m not a biologist.”
Well, I am a biologist, and I’m here to help.
To that end, let me rephrase the question to Judge Jackson: are sex categories in humans—male and female—real, immutable, and binary, or are they merely “social constructs”?
Answer: real (that’s just the way it is and we all know it), immutable (it can’t be changed), and binary (there are only two sexes, not three or four or fifty-seven).
This is true throughout the plant and animal kingdoms. An organism’s sex is defined by the type of gamete (sperm or ova) it can or would produce. Males have the function of producing sperm, or small gametes; and females, ova, or large ones. There is no third gamete type. There are only two.
Therefore, sex is binary. This shouldn’t be controversial. It’s just basic biology.
Every one of us is the result of a male and female (our biological mom and dad) successfully reproducing. Sorry to make you think about that. Without the existence of males and females, I wouldn’t be here right now, and neither would you. Our species would have gone extinct long ago.
Many “gender” activists, however, falsely assert that sex cannot be binary and must be viewed as a “spectrum” because a very small number of people have genitalia that appear ambiguous or mixed, phenomena known as intersex conditions. These idealogues claim the existence of such conditions renders the categories “male” and “female” meaningless.
But intersex conditions don’t undermine the sex binary at all because sex ambiguity is not a third sex. The existence of very rare borderline cases no more raises questions about everyone else’s sex than the existence of dawn and dusk casts doubt on the existence of day and night.
Our society isn’t experiencing a sudden dramatic surge in people born with ambiguous genitalia. We are experiencing a dramatic surge in people who are unambiguously one sex claiming to “identify” as the opposite sex or as something other than male or female altogether.
Gender ideology seeks to portray sex as so incomprehensibly complex and multivariable that our traditional practice of classifying people as either male or female is grossly outdated and should be abandoned for a revolutionary concept of “gender identity.”
View Full Script: https://l.prageru.com/3EJPNSi
#education #gender #biology
asked to define the word woman during
her Supreme Court confirmation hearings
in 2022 judge katangi Jackson famously
demurred saying I'm not a biologist well
I am a biologist and I'm here to help to
that end let me rephrase the question to
judge Jackson are sex categories in
humans male and female real immutable
and binary or are they merely social
constructs answer real that's just the
way it is and we all know it immutable
it can't be changed and binary there are
only two Sexes not three or four or
57 this is true throughout the plant and
animal kingdoms an organism sex is
defined by the type of gamt sperm or OVA
it can or would produce males have the
function of producing sperm or small
gametes and females OVA or large ones
there is no third gamt type there are
only two therefore sex is binary this
shouldn't be controversial it's just
basic
biology every one of us is the result of
a male and a female our biological mom
and dad successfully reproducing sorry
to make you think about that without the
existence of males and females I
wouldn't be here right now and neither
would you our species would have gone
extinct long
ago many gender activists however
falsely assert that sex cannot be binary
and must be viewed as a spectrum because
a very small number of people have
genitalia that appear ambiguous or mixed
phenomena known as intersex conditions
these ideologues claim the existence of
such conditions renders the categories
male and female meaningless but intersex
conditions don't undermine the sex
binary at all because sex ambiguity is
not a third sex the existence of very
rare borderline cases no more rais
questions about everyone else's sex than
the existence of Dawn and dusk cast
doubt onto the existence of day and
night our society isn't experiencing a
sudden dramatic surge in people born
with ambiguous genitalia we're experienc
a dramatic surge in people who are
unambiguously one seex claiming to
identify as the opposite sex or as
something other than male or female
altogether gender ideology seeks to
portray sex as so incomprehensibly
complex and multivariable that our
traditional practice of classifying
people as either male or female is
grossly outdated and should be abandoned
for a revolutionary concept of gender
identity this new system holds that
males shouldn't be barred from female
sports women's prisons or other spaces
previously segregated so long as they
identify as female but interex and
transgender mean entirely different
things interex people have extremely
rare conditions that result in a parent
sex ambiguity transgender people however
aren't sexually ambiguous at all but
merely claim to identify as something
other than their biological sex once
you're conscious of this distinction
you'll begin to notice that gender
activists attempt to steer discussions
away from for example whether men who
identify as women should be allowed to
compete in female sports and toward
prominent intersex athletes like South
African runner cast cinia why because so
long as they've got you on your heels
making difficult judgment calls on
individuals with medically complicated
intersex conditions they've succeeded in
drawing your attention away from making
easy calls on unquestionably male
athletes like 2022 NCAA division 1
women's swimming and Diving Champion
Leah Thomas they shift the focus to
intersects to distract from
transgender but the existence of a tiny
handful of interex cases is completely
irrelevant to the issue of of allowing
males in female sports prisons and
restrooms crafting policy to exclude
males who identify as women or trans
women from female only spaces isn't
complicated that's because trans women
are unambiguously male and so the
chances that a doctor incorrectly
recorded their sex of birth are
essentially zero therefore any
transgender policy designed to protect
female spaces need only specify that
participants must have been recorded
female on their original birth
certificates or if no birth certificate
listing sex is available biology not an
individual's feelings will determine
whether the participant would be allowed
to compete as a male or a
female crafting effective interex
policies is more complicated but a much
less pressing issue for protecting the
Integrity of women's sports individual
organizations can decide for themselves
which criteria should be used to keep
female spaces safe and in the context of
sport
safe and fair it is imperative however
that such policies be rooted in
properties of the body and not one's
identity because identity is not gerine
to issues of fairness and safety you can
identify as anything you like but your
identity does not determine biological
reality and the reality is that sex in
humans is immutable and binary no amount
of activist hysteria is ever going to
change that I'm Colin Wright PhD in
evolutionary biology and fellow at the
Manhattan Institute for Prager
University thank you for watching this
video to keep Prager you vide is free
please consider making a tax deductible
donation