Can you guess which topics elicit the most mockery? God, religion, and morality. In the absence of a rational argument, mockery takes it place. Dennis responds to those comments and asks whether science is able to offer answers to life's greatest questions: knowing right from wrong and good from evil. Enjoy!
0:00 Dennis’s Daily Radio Show 0:54 Sponsored by T.W. Lewis Foundation 2:18 Addressing Criticism On Last Fireside 3:17 The Most Mocked PragerU Subject 6:00 How Do You Know Murder Is Wrong? 7:48 Mockery Is Not Persuasive 8:33 Scientists Are Still Human 9:20 What Science Doesn’t Answer 12:20 Dennis Responds: Upset Comment 1 14:36 Dennis Responds: Upset Comment 2 16:53 Listen To Scientists About Science 18:15 Dropping The Atom Bomb 19:31 Dennis Responds: Upset Comment 3 20:25 The Result Of Poor Education 22:00 The American Divide 23:41 Secular Conservatives Must Know This 25:13 Importance Of Knowing History 28:50 How To Become Successful 29:38 Important Concepts To Be Heard
hi everybody i'm dennis prager this is
the fireside chat every week I come into
your life which right now is a different
life for all of us this is my home this
is my study my dog my fireplace and I've
been spending a lot of time here for the
last few weeks because there's really no
place you can go I do go to my radio
studio to do my daily radio show I feel
a very deep moral commitment to those
three hours and try to bring calm and
reason and encouragement that to
people's lives so if you ever do not if
you don't know and you're ever
interested it's easy to hear my radio
show either on a local station in the
United States or on the Internet in the
United States and abroad anyway I want
you to know this session of the fireside
chat is brought to you by a generous
donation from Tom Lewis who authored a
wonderful book one of the ideas that we
talk about a Prager you are in his book
the book is solid ground a foundation
for women in life and the the
interesting thing and the important
thing about this is when you're young in
particular you need you need a map in
life but you need more than a map a map
tells you where you are but you have to
figure out where you want to go that's
called wisdom this this book has wisdom
in it and it's the five characteristics
for long-term success goal-setting
helping others self-awareness personal
character hard work and the president of
Arizona State University said all lives
require roadmaps to move forward Tom
Lewis in his fantastic story solid
ground outlines a journey for life that
can inform us all that's the president
of Arizona State so I just wanted you to
know about this the this is a perfect
time to read by the way because the
not much else you can do you know except
watch all fireside chats binge on
fireside chats and Prager you videos so
I I have a few thoughts I want to share
with you where is that sheet of people
apparently it was the usual amount of
criticism and mockery of comments that I
made about science and scientists you
know virtually every preview video gets
a fair number of negative comments
people who don't like what we say no
matter how gentle and rational it is no
matter how credential the speaker there
would be no people who will attack us
there are whole websites that attack us
and that's a compliment because
obviously we're having a big impact and
so people who differ with us would would
like to take us down and I am I I fully
appreciate that fact that I understand
that I have that doesn't I don't lose
sleep over it but there's a very
interesting phenomenon that you probably
would not have guessed so you know we
have videos on on every subject except
as it happens Natural Sciences we're not
going to teach botany or chemistry or
biology certainly can't do it in five
minutes and that's not our intent we
want to give wisdom we're not we're not
there to to simply give data or
knowledge we are there to give knowledge
of history and we have videos on very
important figures in history which are
fascinating whether it's Walt Disney or
George Washington or whomever it might
be Booker T Washington it's one of my
favorite people so we don't we don't
have anything in the Natural Sciences or
math for example we understand that but
otherwise we talk about everything what
do you think it's the most hatred of all
the subjects I mean we've defended the
free market and capitalism and America
and and and taught all sorts of issues
with regard to morale
and a lot of personal issues a lot of
male/female issues you know what gets
the most not just hatred but mockery is
any time we put up a video defending the
existence of God or making the case the
four biblical values in other words
values rooted in the Bible the
judeo-christian value system and the
like that's what gets the most mockery
and again not just hatred but hatred and
mockery and I always wonder and I still
wonder why I'm not completely certain
why it is but I I think it's part of a
of a brainwash that has taken place that
has convinced a fair number of people in
America and in the West generally that
religion is for stupid people this is
truly what a lot of people have been
taught and believe that if you are
intelligent and rational you cannot be
religious that they are it's a sort of
mutually exclusive idea so therefore
when we present an idea as I do for
example in my Prager you videos on the
Ten Commandments the mockery especially
here's one how do you know that murder
is wrong if God did not say do not
murder now here's the irony I have
debated this at Oxford I've debated this
with with professors who are atheists
and they all agree if there is no they
agree that's the irony if there is no
God
you don't know murder is wrong you can
posit it as wrong you can believe it is
wrong you you can offer it as a great
value but you don't know it because it's
not knowable you can know that this is
paper paper has a fixed chemical
physical quality I can prove this is
paper I cannot prove murder is wrong you
can believe it is wrong and I serve
hope you do but it's a belief so I
believe God said it is wrong you believe
you said it is wrong or your society has
said it is wrong
by any notion of logic it is obvious
that if there is if I'm admitting if if
there is a God who said murder is wrong
that's a lot more of an objective
reality than I believe murder is wrong
this should be completely
non-controversial as atheists have
acknowledged this ever since they
started debating the issue now they'll
say well look but you know there is no
God so I'm stuck I got to figure out how
but now to get people not to murder
that's an honorable position I respect
that but but you can't deny that God
saying do not murder is a lot more
powerful than society says do not murder
or the cops say do not murder or my
conscience says do not murder okay so
that that's just mocked all over the
Internet as you can see what was the one
name of that woman the the comedian yes
I met Samantha B mock that right yeah
okay but that's all C but whenever
people mock and that's all they do I
know they don't know how to deal with it
intellectually it's a because if you can
if you can demolish an argument
intellectually why would you use mockery
mockery make make you feel good but it
is not persuasive you you have not used
reason you have used insult and the like
but it is it is not it is not an
argument so apparently I spoke about I
don't remember exactly what I said but I
know what I think so I assume this is
fairly accurate where I mentioned that
the science is science and scientists
are scientists apparently this was too
complex a thought for a fair number of
people who thought I was deriving
science
when I was saying that scientists are
humans like everybody else scientists as
I said run the gamut of brilliant and
wise to stupid and foolish just like
plumbers and chiropractors and dentists
and uber drivers and any other group
scientists are not one whit wiser than
than electricians but we think they are
because people believe in science not
just in science in its facts h2o is
water but in science as the answer to
life's questions science does not answer
life's questions it answers questions
such as why does a cancer cell
metastasize what is the gravitational
pull of the Sun on the planets that
science and only science can answer I
don't look to the Bible to figure out
the gravitational pull of the Sun or how
to deal with metastasizing cancer cells
I don't know one religious person who
does so it's it's it's a non-issue
science as I say even said last time men
of science women of science have saved
my life I would be paralyzed and perhaps
dead if it were not for surgeons all
right this arm was getting paralyzed and
I had a seven-hour surgery and this
great great surgeon saved saved my left
arm because of what was happening in my
back congenitally okay my gratitude to
doctors is as scientists if you will is
enormous but I don't assume that any of
my surgeons have a better take on
capital punishment or the the size of
government then than anybody else and if
that's not a knock on them why would
they I don't go to a surgeon for wisdom
about Society I go to a surgeon
or knowledge about how to correct a
nerve problem in my spine I don't know
why this is why why why all the mockery
because I said that science is a
substitute religion for many people it
is so they say well that's ridiculous
science is fact-based and religion is
faith based the moment you say science
tells you anything other though other
than facts it's a religion if you say if
I say to you what do you believe in on
your answer with science then science is
functioning as a religion science
doesn't tell you not to murder science
doesn't tell you not to steal science
doesn't tell you not not not to do
anything bad it doesn't tell you to do
anything good science has nothing moral
to teach us that's not a knock on
science if I study geology do I know
good and evil if I study chemistry do I
know good and evil the mitochondria tell
me the honor my parents but all of this
is new to so many secular people who've
gone to college this is all new so
instead of dealing with what I say they
muck it there's a classic Dennis Prager
makes conservatives look
see that's a that's a deep thought now
you know it's interesting you could say
a lot of things about me but I very
rarely have been accused of being stupid
just for the record wrong right wing the
whole litany of stuff but I'm not
particularly stupid I actually have been
blessed by God or nature with a good
mind and a good brain if you wish to
deal with me in a debate if you wish to
say you know what Prager is wrong when
he says X Y or Z because of the
following reasons ABC that's an argument
but Prager makes conservatives look
is not an argument it's it's
it's sort of forgive me a masturbatory
thing you feel good in saying it and it
brings you pleasure but it doesn't
achieve anything except giving you
pleasure should I be more inclined this
shows you
how this person has never thought that
anything that I have said through never
these is all brand-new should I be more
inclined to believe peer review test
data or a 2000 year old book written by
sheep herders but there is not one
religious person who believes that you
you you learn peer review test data from
the Bible that shows you how foolish
this comment this is a person who has
never thought this through okay so do
you learn thou shalt not murder thou
shalt honor your parents thou shalt not
steal love thy neighbor as thyself
from peer review test data of course not
you learn nothing about good and evil
which is the most important question on
earth from text data from peer review
test data but this is this is the
ignorance that pervades the secular
world so often not always so often the
Bible is a source of wisdom not a source
of peer and reviewed test data that's
why the comment is a non sequitur okay
next this is infuriating science is not
a religion it's a method to use
empirical evidence to answer a question
you're right and for people for whom
that is all Sciences it is not a
religion I didn't say it's a religion to
everybody who believes in science it's
if you if you say what do you believe in
I believe in in my case I believe in God
and in Judaism and in the Bible or
Christianity obviously for a Christian
and that's that's my belief so what is
yours so if you say science then it is a
religion if you believe in science as
opposed to use science to find out
answers to empirical questions of course
you should so do i to create this
antagonistic relationship between
science and religion I don't have any
antagonistic relationship you've created
it whoever wrote this I don't have it
for one
one moment there is no antagonistic
relationship you feel there is because
you mocked presumably the Bible I don't
mock science I know how important
science is it saved my life and many of
the people I love that's pretty good but
it offers zero wisdom there was no
wisdom is how to live a life what is the
difference between right and wrong
we know the limitations of the Bible you
may not know the limitations of science
that's the difference we don't look to
the Bible for science you shouldn't look
to science for morality or wisdom that's
all I'm saying
but the moment you think science tells
you anything other than science then
it's a religion as regards scientists I
already said if you believe in science
scientists function if in the words of
Sciences our religion for you
that's as in other words that's all you
need in life which is what a lot of
people do believe just with science I
have the answers no you don't you only
have the answers to scientific questions
that's all so scientists in those case
that's why people say let's listen to
the scientists no let's listen to the
scientists only about science whether or
not the United States and the rest of
the world should destroy the world's
economy because of the coronavirus is
not only a scientific question science
tells me about the virus wisdom tells me
whether or not I should destroy tens of
millions of lives put people in the
street have more opioids use do you know
that spousal abuse is increased in
France by a third since the isolation
began there and and very similar figures
in the United States there are huge
repercussions for shutting down society
that's not a science question
that's a wisdom question science has
nothing to say about that question but
we looked scientists let the scientists
decide how long we're going to shut down
our society I have no interest in their
telling me how long we should shut down
Society I want to know their information
about the virus then I want wise people
to decide whether or not we do it for
example scientists made the atom bomb
scientists did not decide whether the
atom bomb would be dropped on Japan to
end World War two laypeople did people
who had no clue how an atom bomb is made
the scientists made the atom bomb they
did not decide whether to drop it see
our video on the morality of dropping
that bomb by the way which saved not
only a million at least a million lives
of Americans but probably saved a
million Japanese lives more Japanese
were killed and other bombs over in non
atomic bombs over Japan than in the than
the atomic bombs over Japan that's a
very important analogy we didn't ask
scientists should we drop the bomb the
President of the United States the
commander-in-chief who was not a
scientist or a military man decided name
was Harry Truman that's the way it works
in life you give me the information or
what I request from you then we will
decide what to do without your input
they did not ask the scientists whether
to drop it here we go again science is
based on test and religion is based on
faith so what that's correct
therefore what as I said science tell
you to honor your parents you know what
science you know you know what nature
tells you nature says the survival of
the fittest you know that the hospital
is the most unnatural thing in the
universe
because it's survival of the least fit
it's the opposite of nature the opposite
if you let nature guide you which that
science science is the survival of the
fittest should we apply it to human life
then close every Hospital this is sad
because I am raising issues that in your
lousy high school and lousy university
education were never raised it is it is
it is a tragedy that this is new to so
many of you watching this it is a
tragedy these are the issues that should
have been discussed in high school in
college but they're not so it's so new
to so many you mock instead of say wait
let me try to understand what he's
saying is there is there or is there a
rational flaw in what he's saying that
anybody here calling lis it's
not effective just isn't it's not a
rational response to a rational argument
where do you get good and evil from
science I do get that from the 10
commandments I do get that from love
your neighbor as yourself love the
stranger that's why we get and that's
why the Western world abolish slavery
before anybody else it had slaves which
was terrible but everyone had slaves so
the only moral question is why did
anybody abolish it not why did anybody
have it if an evil is universal the only
question to ask is why did it end not
why was it there okay what's our time
because I spent a lot here and this is
really important stuff 22 not much time
for Q&A but let's start at least with
the video question what this is like
magic reading a book on Houdini now so
it's on my mind hey guys my name is
Jackson come here I'm 18 notes and
from San Antonio Texas and a member of
Prague divorce my question is how can
Americans find common morality and a
time where to divide between religious
and secular is so prevalent Jackson
great question the the divide first of
all have a few answers for you Jackson
one is the divide in America is not
between the religious and the secular
it's between the left and the right
there are religious left-wing people and
there are secular right-wing people vast
number of my fellow conservatives are
not not religious just so with if that's
not the divide I have much more in
common with a conservative atheist than
I do with the left-wing Jew and I'm a
Jew just the way it is safer were
Christian conservative Christian has far
more in common with a conservative
atheist than with a left-wing Christian
that's just so the division is not
between the primary division in America
is not between secular and religious
it's between left and right now if that
doesn't that's the most important answer
but there's there's another answer to
your question and and that is that the
conservative secular individual at least
needs to respect the importance of God
and religion in American history and to
conservatism
the truth is conservatism will not
succeed if it remains godless for more
than a two generations it's just not
because God will punish you or any
nonsense like that but because America
is rooted in the notion that our rights
come from God it's in a declaration of
independence our rights don't come from
government that's the whole revolution
of the American Revolution rights don't
come from people rights come from
something higher than people
if a conservative cannot accept that I
understand that but it's a problem for
conservatism meaning conserving the
American value system which is I called
the American Trinity on every coin in
god we trust'
a player bassoon um from anyone and
liberty
the belief was that God wants us free
this is the greatness of the American
Revolution God wants us free that that
was remarkable and they got that idea
from the Torah from the third book of
the Bible leviticus which is on the
Liberty Bell
okie-dokie we still have time
cool Karina Brooklyn New York 18 years
old
hello Karina hi Dennis look at that she
responded love listening to your
fireside chats now it's that funny by
the way it's an interesting thing
this is video but she wrote I love
listening not watching it's a lot of
people listen on podcast but then they
don't see auto yeah all right that's
fair anyway so you're listening to the
fireside chat Thank You Korina they
bring a lot of insight into the topics
that are occurring in today's America as
a college student I was wondering what
subjects you would suggest to study to
become a good citizen and a successful
individual PS I chose architecture and
civil engineering as a major / minor and
I will be reading your rational Bible
soon smiley does the smiley mean not
really
all right just thought I'd add a smiley
to a nice thought okay so here we go
architecture and civil engineering which
are obviously related is a very it's a
wonderful a major / minor but you asked
what would I suggest the study to become
a good citizen and a successful
individual I I believe everybody should
major in history if you don't know what
happened you can't possibly know what's
happening it's not possible think about
it if you came
here's a bike I love the fact that these
analogies come to me because that's I
think an analogies all the time if you
came in to a movie in the last 15
minutes would you have a clue as to what
is going on you're in the last 15
minutes of history hours of history have
taken place before you you can't
possibly understand the movie if you
don't know what happened before the last
15 minutes it's as simple literally as
simple as that the ignorance is
astonishing I'll give you I mean one of
the most dramatic examples is how
utterly ignorant most people are about
the greatest mass murder machine in
human history communism sheer ignorance
most people know about the Nazis which
is a good thing although even that is
starting to fade and communism you know
I wonder how many of you watching in
high school or college can identify
Joseph Stalin let alone Leon Trotsky or
Vladimir Lenin if you can't
your education has been awful just awful
and it has been awful in most cases it's
true because their intent the intention
today is to indoctrinate not educate I'm
sure you know a great deal about carbon
emissions but if you know about carbon
emissions and not Stalin that is one
perverted form of Education
that's indoctrination not education so I
think history is critical then you
combine or in any all sorts of other
things successful individual well you
know that the the the way to become a
successful individual
is to study wisdom and that's certainly
not taught in our universities or high
schools by and large with the end of of
biblical teaching of teaching the Bible
what-what-what is the one of the wisdom
books that people learn by the way I
think there's other wisdom - I don't
think it's the only form of wisdom but
it was the big one for Americans and for
the West and there's less and less
wisdom as people have abandoned that
book Abraham Lincoln almost never went
to church but he read the Bible every
night I think we're good well this was a
passionate session really important by
the way this is an example of something
it might be worth watching or listening
to again because those concepts that I
offered they're really they're they're
basic and simple but they're new to most
of you and they they need to be heard
and then you go oh yeah that makes sense
that makes sense
so let me know your reactions and by the
way if you are curious about wisdom
which is the key to a better life please
do read my rational Bible it's a way to
ilex I'm explaining the greatest
thoughts of history and it's it's good
stuff and while you're stuck in your
home it's it's good greeting or good
listening and get it on on audible
anyway any you can get it in smoke
signals Braille large print it's called
the rational Bible anyway I wish you
well it's it's a difficult time this
that I that we're all going through
please know the the great great phrase
this too shall pass when good things
happen people think they'll go on
forever and that's a mistake but bad
things happen people think they'll go on
forever and that's a mistake this too
shall pass so good luck
look forward to seeing you next week
from my home I'm Dennis Prager thanks
for watching
thank you for watching if you'd like to
keep these fireside chats free please do
by donating to Prager you