Major SCOTUS Ruling WEAKENS Administrative State: Supreme Court Winner | Facts Matter

Facts Matter
2.9K followers
513 Video Views·Mar 13, 2025
🇺🇸 Try the Epoch Times here: https://ept.ms/RomanSale
🟡 Claim your free Gold from American Hartford Gold: https://ept.ms/3biH9MN
⭕️ Sign up for our NEWSLETTER and stay in touch 👉 https://ept.ms/FactsMatterNewsletter
© All Rights Reserved.
All right, Mark, thank you so much for joining us.
Glad to be here, Roman.
Can you please introduce yourself and your organization?
Sure, Mark Chenoweth,
President of the New Civil Liberties Alliance.
We sue the administrative state
to defend people's civil liberties
from overreaching government.
So this past year you had,
I would say not even a relatively big victory,
it's a huge victory.
Your case was among the two cases
consolidated into one decision
that overturned the doctrine of Chevron deference.
That's right.
Huge.
Could you start by outlining to the audience
what the doctrine of Chevron deference was?
Sure, so Chevron deference
came from a 1984 Supreme Court decision.
And what it said is that if a statute is either ambiguous
or if there's a gap in the statute
so that the meaning isn't entirely clear,
that if an administrative agency comes in
and it makes an interpretation of that ambiguity or gap
that the court considers reasonable,
then the court has to defer
to that agency's interpretation of the statute.
So essentially you're taking the independent judgment away
from the judiciary,
and you're instead telling those
Article III lifetime appointed judges,
just listen to whatever the administrative agency says.
Right.
Well, I can imagine just hearing that definition,
the way I imagine it would work
in a benevolent society
where you take it sort of at face value
that it was totally intended for a good purpose,
is like if a statute says,
water has to not have a dangerous amount
of benzene in it, drinking water,
and then the relevant agency has to determine,
okay, what's the level of benzene
that would be allowed in drinking water
to not make a contaminated parts per trillion
or something like that, right?
So that's like the law,
and then the agency interprets that law
in actually executing.
So that's the positive, I guess,
side of the Doctrine of Chevron Deference.
Yeah.
What were some of the negatives
that came out over the past several decades?
Well, let me stick with your example for a second.
So imagine that Congress has specified that
about benzene and the agency looks at that,
but then the agency says, you know what?
We need to look at some other substances as well.
Let's take a look at, pick your favorite, say lead.
We need to look at the level of lead as well.
Congress didn't say that,
but that's just because it's a silence in the statute.
It's a gap in the statute.
Well, it could be that Congress had very good reason
why they didn't want that particular thing regulated.
Maybe they didn't want that agency to do it.
Maybe they didn't view it as enough of a problem yet
to command sufficient resources,
whatever the case may be.
But if the agency then takes it upon themselves,
you have the growth of the regulatory state
that we have seen.
When you ask about some examples,
so the particular example in the Relentless case
and the Loper Bright case, which was the companion case,
it's the same underlying statutory issue.
It's kind of a fun one.
It's from the Magnuson-Stevens Act,
which is not one that maybe people heard about a lot,
but it governs fisheries in the Atlantic and Pacific
and in the Gulf of America there as well.
So the question was, the law says that you can have
these government appointed agents on your boat
and you have to provide them a berth on the boat
and you have to feed them and take care of their safety
and so forth.
And they're there to make sure that you're obeying the law,
to look at the bycatch, things that you're catching
that you didn't intend to catch,
checking on fish stocks.
They have these different jobs.
Okay, fine.
There may be a role for the government
to try to keep the fisheries sustainable.
But then the OSHA fisheries,
which was the regulatory agency in question here,
they said, you know what?
Congress has not given us enough money
to do what we wanna do with these agents.
And we don't have enough to hire as many of them
as we wanna hire.
So what we're gonna do is we're gonna charge
the boat captains or charge the boat companies
for the cost of the salaries of these onboard monitors
is what they're called.
And the boat company said, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait.
Congress never said that.
How much were these salaries?
They were costing about $700 a day
to put one of these people on your boat,
which oftentimes was more than the profits
that were being made from the herring catch.
It's $700 per day, just every day?
Every day.
Or is it like a period of time for inspection?
Well, every day the one was on the boat.
And there's some, so there's some complexities
in the underlying fact pattern.
So some boats would go out for a day or two.
And if you were only out for a little while,
you were allowed to have your dockside inspection.
But our boats were larger.
They could go out to sea for 10, 12, 14 days.
They could freeze their catch on the ship.
And so they had to have an onboard monitor.
At all times?
Not at all times, but it worked out to about half the time.
Half the time the government forces you
to pay an employee of the government $700
to be on your boat.
Yes, that was what was happening.
And Congress never allowed it?
Never authorized that.
Congress never said that could happen.
But it was a gap or ambiguity in the statute,
or at least that's what OSHA Fisheries said.
We pointed out, look, it's not actually a gap
because Congress did say there are three circumstances
in which you could charge the boats for the onboard monitors.
One, if it's in the North Pacific.
Well, these guys weren't in the North Pacific.
They were in the North Atlantic.
And the Atlantic and the Pacific are different oceans,
as I'm sure everyone except OSHA Fisheries recognizes.
Secondly, if it's a foreign vessel.
Well, that makes sense.
If you have foreign vessels coming
into American waters to fish, we would
want there to be an onboard monitor,
make sure they're not stealing all the fish,
and we're going to make them pay for it.
Fine.
And then the third condition was one
that didn't apply to any of these boats,
and no one said that it did.
It wasn't really in controversy.
And so when Congress has specified three conditions
when you can fund the boats, that's not really
a gap in the statute.
It means that everyone, every normal person who reads that
says, well, then you can't charge them
in any of these other circumstances.
But that's not what OSHA Fisheries decided,
and that's how the case got all the way to the Supreme Court.
Wow.
I feel like that particular agency pushed the limit,
thinking they, is it because this doctrine of Chevron
deference, are there like many such cases
where it's like well beyond what the statute says?
Or was this particular agency really
going like a step beyond what all the agencies were doing?
Well, I'm sure they didn't make any friends
at the other agencies by getting Chevron deference overturned.
But no, I don't think it was that different than what
we've seen in other agencies.
Agencies, because they've had 40 years
of the almost reflexive deference
from the federal courts, they've gotten
used to pushing the limits, as you say.
And so they do it more and more and more every year.
And that's why it was so important for the Supreme
Court to step in and say, no, no, no, no.
It's the job of the courts.
And the Constitution says it's the job of the courts
to decide this question.
All right, just to pause here for a super quick moment,
listen, it's obvious that the financial system
is not looking too great.
After being pumped up with trillions
of virtually free government dollars
for many, many years now, well, the stock bubble
might actually burst in the near future.
And in that process, unfortunately,
it could take away the nest egg of anyone
who happens to be exposed to it.
And so consider taking this opportunity
to diversify into something which is beyond the grasp
of Washington, D.C. and Wall Street,
physical gold and silver.
And the best company to use, in my opinion,
is the sponsor of today's episode, American Hartford Gold,
who I should mention is also my own personal gold
and silver bullion dealer.
And besides myself, they have thousands
of five-star reviews from other Americans,
and they also have an A-plus rating
with the Better Business Bureau.
And working with them is rather simple.
They have a huge selection of coins, bars,
and rounds to choose from.
They have super friendly staff who you can call
and they can set up either gold delivery
directly to your doorstep, or they can even set you up
in a gold IRA.
And then lastly, best of all,
if you tell them that Roman sent you,
they will throw in a free gold coin
with your first qualifying purchase.
So give them a call.
The number is 866-242-2352.
That's 866-242-2352.
Or you can simply text Roman to 65532.
I'll also throw a link to their webpage.
They'll be down there in the description box below.
And in particular, Congress had decided in 1946,
in a law called the Administrative Procedure Act,
to give that responsibility to the courts,
that when it comes to a federal regulation,
that the job of determining what the law is
belongs to the courts, not the agencies.
Okay, last question.
Now that the case was successful,
the Supreme Court overturned this doctrine,
what does that mean for common Americans
throughout the whole country?
Like what specifically...
Well, can they expect to be different
in their everyday lives?
Well, I think one of the things it means
is that agencies are going to try,
they're not gonna be as apt to overreach.
They're not going to try to push the limits of the law,
because they recognize that if they try to do that,
that they're gonna get slapped down by a federal court.
I think it also means when they write the regulations
in the first place, they're gonna try to write regulations
that actually implement statutes that Congress passed,
and not just the wishes of the agency
that they think might fill a gap
or an ambiguity in the statute.
So it really, I think, puts the onus back on Congress
to be the one legislating,
and if it's going to be charging people for something
or taking away some liberty that people have,
Congress needs to vote on that, they can be accountable,
and it's not the faceless bureaucrats
making those decisions and getting away with it that way.
Well, listen, that victory was probably
one of the biggest blows to the administrative state, right?
I mean, literally, you took their ability
to create laws, essentially, out of their hands.
That's right.
Mark, thank you so much.
Yeah, absolutely, it was a pleasure, believe me.
Thank you for the interview,
and thank you as an American for what you did.
Absolutely, nclalegal.org.
