Is it possible that some of the galaxies out there are made of antimatter? How transparent is science research across the world? Which of the Lagrange points is my favourite? And in our free bonus question on Patreon, how big can of a moon can the Earth sustain? All this and more in this Q&A show.
00:00 Start 00:29 Can antimatter galaxies exist out there? 02:03 Can we use double gravitational lenses? 03:40 My favourite Earth's Lagrange point? 05:48 How transparent is space research across the world? 11:13 What if we find out where life started? 13:17 Are there frozen nitrogen asteroids?
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
is it possible that some of the galaxies
out there are made of antimatter how
transparent is science research across
the world which of the lrange points is
my favorite and our free bonus question
on patreon how big of a moon can the
Earth sustain all this more in this
question show it's time for the question
show your questions my answers as always
wherever you are across my channel if a
question Pops in your brain just write
it down I'll gather them up and I'll
answer them here all right let's get
into the questions mark begin is it
possible that some of the galaxies that
we see are composed of antimatter
wouldn't they look the same yeah in
theory if we could see a Galaxy and it
was made of antimatter and all of the
stars were made of antimatter and all of
the planets were made of antimatter and
everything was antimatter and there's no
matter in that Galaxy it would look the
same but the problem is that you know we
know that our galaxy is made of regular
matter and that if a Galaxy made of
matter collided with a Galaxy of
antimatter then you would get
Annihilation you get a release of gamma
radiation it would be very obvious in
fact we can detect the gamma radiation
coming from the annihilation of
antimatter in various places around the
universe and so if there was entire
galaxies made of antimatter there would
be this border between the ones that
were made of antimatter and the places
in the universe that were made of matter
and there is the
intergalactic medium where you've got
particles of hydrogen that are moving
through space there's rocks and dust
there's hypervelocity stars that are
moving from Galaxy to Galaxy and there
would be these places where the two
parts are mixing and exploding and it
would be the most obvious thing in the
universe there would be parts of the sky
where antimatter and matter Annihilation
was going on at a scale we can scarcely
comprehend and it would just be super
obvious and we don't see that what we
see as far as we can look in all
directions is regular matter hanging out
without interacting with antimatter
Known Unknown can we double
gravitational lens theoretically yes so
with a gravitational lens you've got
some background object like a Galaxy
it's emitted light and then that light
passes by a Galaxy cluster or something
that is in the way and the light from
that distant object follows sort a curve
path around the Galaxy cluster and then
converges on you as The View and so the
light rays that would have gone off and
away they get focused like a telescope
and you get to see this magnified
version it's allowed the Hubble Space
Telescope and James web to be able to
see things that it just wouldn't be able
to see with its raw capability um and so
the question is then if you had another
galaxy cluster that was even closer and
so then the second Galaxy cluster was
fine-tuning the light rays that were
that had been already lensed from the
first one uh would that work and and
absolutely uh you know we see multiple
lensed telescopes work just great here
on Earth that you know sometimes it
takes you a couple of lenses to get the
light rays going beautifully parallel
and into your eyehole but people have
never seen one and so there was actually
there was a couple of papers we reported
on on Universe today about searching for
a double gravitational lens so the
non-coplanar gravitation lens and the
communication Bridge so that's the paper
and here's our story on Universe today
Domingo Flav what is your favorite Earth
lrange point I I never get that question
what is my favorite Earth lrange so
let's think about the options so we've
got the Earth Sun lrange points and
we've got the Earth Moon lrange points
so Earth Sun L1 in between us and the
sun that'll allows you to observe the
sun it also allows you to just observe
the Earth that's where the NASA's
discover satellite is it gives us these
really cool images of the earth so L1 is
pretty cool L2 that's the place where
you've got James web and uclid and gion
it's this place where you can go and
hide the Sun the Earth and the Moon from
your observations and from their you
know their heat getting in the way of
your telescopes so that's also a very
cool place L3 on the far side of the sun
eh kind of boring no good use for that
so we can cross that went off L4 L5
those are the ones that are ahead and
behind the Earth in orbit uh they're
cool because they're gravitationally
stable and so you could put things into
those locations and they would just hang
out there like a telescope so that's
pretty cool but I think of of of those I
would say Earth Sun L2 is my
favorite Earth Moon same thing you've
got three right one on the far side of
the earth L3 boring we don't have to
worry about that one in between the
Earth and the moon L1 that's kind of
cool cuz you could have a space elevator
that is uh going from the Moon up into
space and you could use that that's
pretty cool uh the Earth Moon L2 point
that would be on The Far Side of the
Moon uh you could put communication
satellites back there to relay
information about what's happening on
the far side of the moon but that's kind
of boring um L4 L5 again a heading
behind the moon in orbit around the
Earth that's where you could put your
giant rotating space stations the L4
Colony the L5 Colony so really it's
between Earth Moon L4 and Earth Sun L2
and if I had to pick I would probably
choose Earth Sun L2 that's my favorite
Earth LR Point jedward how available is
space research done by various countries
do any of them keep secrets like it
depends on the kind of research and the
kinds of secrets that they need to keep
so I'll give you an example of a country
that is that is largely transparent and
that's the US like most of the space
research is done under the offices of
NASA and so you've got all of the
different uh Rovers missions and in
general NASA makes all of the stuff
that's being gathered by those
spacecraft transparent like available
immediately you can go to the website
and you can download every single image
taken by the perseverance Rover since
the beginning of its operations 100
whatever 50,000 images from every single
camera every time the pictures are taken
you can just go and you can download
them if you want you can do all kinds of
analysis on them and discover whatever
you want in that data and so mostly NASA
stuff is done in in public now there are
various collaborations that NASA does
with other countries things like say the
Hub Space Telescope or James web where
things are held under an embargo so
whatever astronomers have requested time
on James web they get a year of
proprietary use of the data and then the
material is released widely to the rest
of the world but there is also uh space
research that is done under the offices
of the military and so you've got things
like say the X-37B which is the space
force reusable rocket plane where they
launch it on top of some rocket it
orbits the earth for a couple of years
and then comes back to Earth and it has
a collaboration of public and private
experiments on board so there was you
know with with a recent x37 there was uh
NASA experiments on board the x37 and we
learned quite a bit about about those
experiments but there were also secret
space force payloads um you know and
people wonder what that is and we don't
know what it was but you know we can
assume that it was some kind of you know
testing materials testing Electronics
trying to see how things operate in
space for long periods of time but the
results of that are kept as a military
secret and they will then use that to
build their spy satellites and things
like that what is the number of us spy
satellites we don't know what is the
nature of them what are their
capabilities we don't know so there's a
whole Space related military aspect
where secrets are being kept and then
you've got versions and flavors of that
among all the different nations so the
European Space Agency is a lot more into
the let's give an embargo let's give the
the people who propos the science and
EMB Argo to be able to get their work
together so in generally missions like
the Rosetta Mission we saw there was a a
multiple year embargo you know we can
assume that's going to happen with other
stuff like Ariel and the various
upcoming Plato things like that um and
then of course they have military
concerns as well and so there some of
that is going to be classified and now I
would say the worst is China um on some
hands uh they're very open and
transparent with what they're doing uh
they publish a lot of research papers on
the same kinds of journals archive
things that people are doing you know
astronomers get time on the fast
telescope they do a bunch of research
they publish the results the sensors in
China have a very light touch on on what
they do uh in other situations
collaboration so people from Europe or
us or whatever can go and work on the
fast telescope and be able to do their
results and and that's not necessarily
censored but then they've got their
missions you've got things like the
chonga missions the timway missions
what's happening on the Chinese space
station and you're seeing a filtered
version of that that is passing through
the sensors deciding which are the
things they want to make publicly
available and which things they want to
keep closer to their chest and as a
journalist that's incredibly frustrating
because I want to know everything right
I want to be able to just find out about
this kind of stuff and then you've got
to assume that there is a military layer
on top of that where they are hiding
their capability
um with you know military technology
with uh their ability to do earth
observation spy satellites things like
that so so you know there's always this
blend but generally scientific
information that's done to understand
the mechanisms on the moon or Mars
reaches the public fairly quickly From
Any Nation within a couple of years from
when it's taken or immediately if it's
NASA do you want even more questions and
answers well it's almost time for the
monthly Patron only question show I send
this out on the 15th of every month and
then me and my producer Anton go through
and answer the questions over what is
becoming a longer and longer show
sometimes more than three hours uh but
it's great I get a chance to do a little
bit more research ahead of time Anton
has a Physics degree and so we chat
about the answers to those questions and
you're guaranteed right now if you ask a
question there you will get an answer
now go to patreon.com universetoday and
I will put out the call on the 15th of
March so it's right around the corner
now I want to thank our new patrons
thanks to Craig fiser dwali Mark
lindville James Hill Millie Madison
Fiona and Donnie Firefly Farm Mouse
destruction what happens if we find out
where life started do we put a museum
there I love this question um so I mean
obviously it's kind of astonishing to
think about the fact that we don't know
where life started that all life on
Earth shares a common ancestor that you
know we are we share a common ancestor
with chimpanzees and and we chimpanzees
share an a common ancestor with dolphins
and we dolphins and CH chimpanzees share
a common ancestor with rats and so on
and you go all the way back down the
tree of life and eventually you end up
with whatever was the first
organism and we don't know where it
started uh and we don't know how it
started so maybe it started in some
random puddle
on the surface of planet Earth it was
struck by lightning and just had the
right chemicals and and it created a
complex enough molecule that then was
able to continue evolving and then fall
under darwinian Evolution to continue on
from there natural selection or maybe it
life started at the bottom of the ocean
with these hydrothermal vents uh we just
don't know um and it could be that it
that it started multiple times and but
only the the family that we part of was
the one that was successful and all of
the others were outc competed by this
life or maybe it only started once maybe
it only started once in the entire
observable universe right here on this
one planet in that one puddle or under
that beside that one hydrothermal vent
we just don't know like if we could find
out that spot then we should erect the
finest Museum that Humanity has ever
created and this is one of the most
special places that could exist in the
entire observable universe this was the
place where life began that without that
spot without
that bunch of events happening then the
universe would be devoid of life um and
so you should go to that Museum and
definitely check out the exhibits and
definitely you know provide a donation
and get an annual pass David Wilson are
there Frozen nitrogen Asteroids for
example something that could be directed
to Mars to modify the atmosphere so
there are comets and you know they're
going to have some nitrogen on them but
they're going to have a lot of other
volatile elements they going to have
water mixed with dirt and regali and so
they would be the ideal things to smash
into Mars but you have the same problem
that if you smash a comet into Mars
you're going to make the place
remarkably worse already a bad place
you're going to make it a lot worse for
a long period of time and then you're
going to have a bunch of gases are going
to vaporize they're going to go into the
atmosphere and then the solar wind is
going to continue to act on Mars and
eventually over time start to blow those
gases away and and then you're sort of
back to to square one so the idea that
seems the most practical is that you
just block the solar wind if you can
somehow put up a sun shade at the Mars
Sun L1 the ground point then you know
some kind of structure it doesn't have
to be a sun shade but at least it can
block the solar wind then now the solar
wind is no longer uh tearing away the
atere of Mars and the various gases that
are escaping Mars the volcanic gases
that are already escaping Mars all the
time can actually start to build up in
the atmosphere over time and after a
while those gases build up the planet
warms up the the ice caps melt and you
actually get water on the surface of
Mars so really it's not about delivering
a lot of gases to the surface of Mars
it's about stopping the solar wind from
depleting the gases on Mars giving it a
chance to thicken its atmosphere did you
know you can watch the same video video
but with no ads and with one bonus
question all about how big a moon the
Earth can sustain now I'll put a link in
the show notes and in my comments so you
can go over and watch that right now for
free all right thanks for watching those
are all the questions that we had with
this episode now we record this show
live every Monday at 5:00 pm somewhere
in the world so if you want to go we'll
have a link to the next episode coming
up so just make sure you click subscribe
notifications Bell I'm sure there's a
way to remind you to go and watch the
episode when we go live it's two hours
long it's a lot of fun all right I'm
going to give you another thing from my
shelf but first I'd like to thank our
patrons thanks to Brian body Greg fely
Hudson Ward Sean Sergeant James Clark
barake gring David matz Jim Burke Steven
fer Munley Paul robach Dustin cable Vlad
shipin spiders swap. David Gilton and
Andre gross Jeremy M Abe Kingston
Michael Purcell Josh Schultz and Jordan
Young Who support us at the master of
the universe level and all our patrons
all your support me Universe to us so
here's something that's new from the
shelf and so what is this this is a
chunk of the James web space telescopes
sunshield uh and so what it is is it's a
bunch of layers so you can see we've got
the outer kind of gold layer and then
it's inside there's a whole bunch more
of this sort of reflective material but
also there's like this mesh that fits in
between and so there's ah 12 layers and
then it's built with this little mesh in
between that traps the Heat and sort of
minimizes or slows down how long it's
going to take for the heat to make it
through all of these different layers to
then become a source of infrared for the
James Webb Space Telescope and this was
leftover material uh that was done for
the construction and testing and my
co-host on astronomy cast Pamela gay uh
was given a bunch of them and she gave a
couple of them to me so I've got a piece
of the James web space telescopes sun
shield behind me all right we'll see you
next time