Why Terrifying Student Loan Payment Notices Are Going Out and Why You Shouldn't Panic

Loan Solutions
2 followers
9 Video Views·Mar 11, 2025
There's a very specific regulation that explains why millions of borrowers are seeing payment notices from their servicers demanding payments that are in some cases more than 50% of their income. Here's what your rights are and why you shouldn't panic.
00:00 Introduction
00:31 Student loan regulations
04:30 Consolidation loan regulations
06:15 Partial financial hardship for IBR
07:20 IBR eligibility and distinctions
08:22 How student loan borrowers can prepare for changes
Borrowers are freaking out right now
because they are getting terrifying notices in the mail
showing payments that they cannot afford.
We're hearing rumors of people getting payments
that are like 50% of their income,
and folks just don't know what to do right now.
And so I'm gonna show you in this video regulations
that you've probably never seen before
to explain why these notices are going out.
I'm gonna explain also why you don't need to panic
and what you can do to make sure that your payments
are affordable on your student loans no matter what.
So let's dive into these regulations
and explain what all of this means.
All right, so let's look at the actual regulations
of the standard tenure plan,
which is the plan that you default to
if you do not get onto an IDR plan
or you're late on recertifying
or you don't send in your documentation.
That's the plan that they default you to,
and that's the plan that they'll project on your loan bill
if you don't sign up for IBR, right?
And let's look at what the definition actually says.
So the standard repayment plan
for all subsidized, unsubsidized, plus loan borrowers,
regardless of when they entered repayment,
and for direct loan consolidations
who entered repayment before 2006.
So the first part of this
is all loans that are non-consolidated, right?
So under this plan, a borrower must, must, not may,
must repay a loan within full
within 10 years from the date the loan entered repayment
by making fixed monthly payments.
So a borrower has to make
at least a certain amount of payments,
and this talks about the amount may be adjusted
to affect variable interest rates.
That's really only effective with these loans before 2006.
So what this is saying is the standard plan,
read what this says, right?
It must repay a loan within full
within 10 years from the date the loan entered repayment.
So what happened during COVID?
Everybody that was signed up for IDR
got credit for repayment.
They were in repayment, right?
Which means that basically everybody's got three
or four years of repayment credit
unless you graduated during COVID or after.
So what that means is let's say that all you did
was sign up for IDR in 2020,
and let's say you had almost four years of COVID forbearance
and let's say your total repayment plus COVID forbearance
credit and repayment is four years so far.
So that is four years of the 10 years
from which you must pay the loan in full
under the standard plan.
So what happens is they tell you,
hey, you got to recertify your income.
If you don't recertify your income by a certain date,
then the standard repayment amount for an unconsolidated loan
is going to be something that is amortized
for a 10 year repayment schedule
minus the length of time you've already been in repayment.
So that means if you have a standard person
that's got four years of repayment credit during COVID,
they're going to amortize that standard 10 year plan
under a six year repayment schedule.
So if your repayment amount is like,
you see I have the $200,000 loan
with a 2000 a month standard 10 year plan,
all things with presuming you have zero repayment credit,
then if you had four years of payment credit during COVID,
which basically everybody did that had loans before 2020,
that means your standard 10 year plan
is actually gonna be a standard six year plan.
And let's say you are a brand new attending position
with seven or eight years of credit,
then theoretically your standard 10 year plan
would be 10 years minus those seven or eight years
you already have.
So that standard 10 year plan would actually be amortized
to something like a crazy two or three year standard plan,
which could be like a huge amount of your balance.
Like on a $200,000 loan,
it could be seven or $8,000 a month.
So this regulation I feel like
has always been kind of ignored by the servicers.
I actually don't remember them implementing it this way.
Before 2020, I've done this for nine years.
So this is pretty interesting to see them,
you know, using this regulation by the letter of the law
and essentially frightening people when they send out that
you gotta recertify your income notice.
They show you the standard repayment plan if you don't do it
and that standard repayment plan due to
the way the COVID paused and how long it lasted
has created this perfect storm
where borrowers are getting these, you know,
bills that are like half of their income.
And that's why, because the standard repayment plan
is amortized over the remaining length of time
to have the loan paid off in full
within 10 years of the date that it started repayment,
which starting repayment does count for like IVR and pay
that is considered repayment, right?
Now, I do wanna show you a little bit of a distinction
for consolidation loans, if I can find it here.
Here we go.
Standard repayment plan for direct consolidation
loan borrowers entering repayment on or after 2006.
So under the standard plan for consolidation loans,
a borrower must repay a loan in full
by making fixed monthly payments over a repayment period
that varies with the total loan amount
of the borrower's student loans
described in paragraph J of the subsection.
So this is the schedule for the standard plan
if you consolidate.
So you can see that if you have a $60,000 loan,
the standard repayment plan
is actually a 30 year repayment plan.
Instead of this definition of the standard plan
that's based off of having to pay the loan off in full
within 10 years of the date the loan restarted repayment.
So in other words, this standard plan is a ginormous payment.
The one for consolidation loans down here
is a very, very low payment.
And because the standard repayment plan
for 60K plus consolidation loans is a 30 year schedule,
it doesn't count for PSLF because that payment
is lower than the standard 10 year repayment plan.
So in other words, this standard repayment plan
is too low to qualify for PSLF and IDR forgiveness.
This standard repayment plan is too insanely high
to likely qualify for IDR forgiveness.
And this is what's trapping people right now
because people are either on the safe forbearance
or recently getting kicked off the safe forbearance
and they need to recertify their incomes.
But when you can't do that or when you're confused
and you just see stuff coming in the mail
and you see a bill with no context
that says it's $10,000 a month,
it's just terrorizing people and freaking them out.
And so let me explain how to have relief from this.
So if you look at IBR regulations,
you have to have a partial financial hardship to sign up,
which a partial financial hardship means
that your IBR payment has to be lower
than what your payment would be
under the standard 10 year repayment plan.
Okay, and the standard 10 year repayment plan in this case
really is a standard 10 year plan
versus this super weird amortization in the other regulation.
So that's based, the standard 10 year plan here
is based on the greater of the balances
of the borrower's loans when they entered their payment
or the amount that the borrower owed
when they signed up for IBR repay.
So that's to account for, you know,
people sometimes have tons of interest
that is accrued and capitalized
when they sign up for IBR repay, right?
So you have to have a partial financial hardship
to sign up for IBR.
And, you know, partial financial hardship
is not what it sounds like.
It is very specific in the definition.
It is dependent upon, you know,
you having a IBR or pay payment
that is lower than the standard 10 year payment amount,
you know, literally based off of the size of your loans.
And if I look at the IBR plan in here,
so there you go.
So for new borrowers under IBR,
this is an important distinction.
Your new borrower, if you took out for IBR purposes,
if you took out your first loan after July 2014,
and if that's you, you pay 10% of your income for IBR.
If you took out loans before 2014,
then you pay 15% of your income under IBR.
So this is the statutory plan
that the courts can't eliminate
without Congress voting it out and changing it.
And the GOP position has been to preserve IBR
for existing borrowers.
So this is the safe, protective,
affordable repayment plan that you can't access.
Now think about this.
In terms of IBR and accessing it,
you know, the freeze on IBR recertifications
is not going to last super long, okay?
It has to end fairly soon
because of just the chaos that it's causing.
So probably by the time this video comes out,
very shortly after I release this,
that freeze is gonna be gone.
So if the solution to getting a terrifying amount
of money per month as a bill in the mail
is a couple things.
You know, first, know that your student loans
are not actually late until about 90 days
after it's due.
So turn off auto pay if you need to,
like ask for forbearance, right?
And you probably will be able to access IBR
if your income is lower than the size of your debt.
So if you're truly struggling,
if this payment amount under the standard plan
truly would be horrific,
the IBR plan should be available to you.
And you can get to that by going to studentaid.gov
slash I-D-R.
And if that application for some reason is not showing,
then you should be able to find the paper application
of the I-D-R application online,
the one that's from the Wayback Machine,
which is the internet archive.
It's floating around Reddit, for example.
It's got a 2027 expiration date on it.
You can take that paper application, fill it out,
throw on your tax return on there,
upload it to your servicer portal,
so that you'll be the first in line
when I-D-R applications resume again.
So do not panic if you see a standard repayment plan
that is like $5,000 a month,
they send you in the mail.
There's alternatives to panicking.
It's called just knowing your rights.
So in the regulations here,
you can see as clear as day here
why the standard plan bills are going out,
why they're so terrifying,
and why so few people understand
why those bills are so terrifying,
just because of the regulations.
They just haven't been looked at and dusted off in years,
since the COVID pandemic, really.
And if you have any questions,
I'd love for you to put this in our video here,
just to ask away.
And thank you so much for watching
and following Student Loan Planner.
