when SpaceX first mentioned they would
try to catch Vehicles out of the sky a
few years back it seemed ridiculous but
now it has become a reality as SpaceX
has successfully caught the super heavy
booster three times in the most recent
Starship launches and is gradually
moving toward catching both stages of
the world's largest rocket however this
plan hasn't gone as smoothly as we
thought Starship flight 8 lost its
second stage after 8 minutes of flight
leading to a complete change in the
catching objectives for the upcoming
launch so how has spacex's plan changed
after flight 8 how did Elon Musk react
let's find out on today's episode of
alphatech the sight of a rocket
explosion over the Texas sky was far
from the outcome SpaceX had hoped for
with Starship flight 8 their fully
stacked test vehicle beyond the
technical flaws that now require
fine-tuning this failure has also
disrupted the timeline for starship's
ambitious 2025 program before the launch
of Starship flight 8 FCC filings had
already confirmed that the license for
flight 9 specified that both the first
stage booster and the second stage
Starship would either return to the
launch site or execute a controlled
landing on water had flight 8
successfully caught the booster with
mechazilla and safely landed the second
stage in the ocean flight 9 would have
marked the next major step catching both
stages upon return the plan was for the
second stage to return to pad B and land
using the newly constructed Tower Paving
the way for continuous testing of
starship's operational capabilities and
the supporting launch infrastructure
however the unexpected failure of flight
8 has has forced SpaceX to reassess its
development timeline no one can predict
exactly what will happen next but one
thing is clear the road to making
Starship fully operational just became
more challenging Elon Musk has
reaffirmed that the catch system will be
perfected this year and will become a
routine procedure by next year stating
good chance of catching a ship this year
should become normal next year this
suggests that in 2025 SpaceX might be on
the verge of a significant Milestone
perhaps consistently catching a super
heavy booster or achieving the First
Catch of the Starship upper stage after
re-entry however catching is not yet
routine as ongoing challenges such as
the explosion of Starship V 2 and flight
8 continue to highlight the difficulties
involved as a result the plan for flight
9 will not follow the previously
expected attempt to catch Starship
instead it is widely anticipated to
prioritize stability and performance
data over risky recovery operations
setting the stage for a catch attempt in
a subsequent Mission SpaceX is expected
to deploy ship 35 paired with booster
14-2 a combination that marks a notable
milestone in the program the first
reflight of a super heavy booster
booster 14-2 having presumably flown
successfully on a prior Mission will
provide Engineers with crucial insights
into the durability and refurbishment
processes required for Rapid booster
reuse an essential component of spacex's
cost reduction strategy ship 35
meanwhile will be the latest test bed
for the upper stage thermal protection
system propulsion reliability and
orbital capabilities the lessons learned
from ship 34's failure in flight 8 will
undoubtedly inform modifications to ship
35 though SpaceX has yet to publicly
disclose the specifics of those
adjustments this decision to delay the
attempt to catch Starship reflects a
pragmatic shift in priorities following
the outcome of flight 8 flight 9 is
expected to focus on Gathering Telemetry
data and validating fixes rather than
attempting a high-risk recovery
this iterative approach exemplifies
spacex's test fail learn repeat
philosophy a method that is driven the
Starship program forward despite
occasional
setbacks looking ahead flight 9 promises
to build upon both the successes and
failures of its predecessors offering a
clearer picture of the block two designs
Readiness for operational missions
whether it achieves a stable orbit
conducts a controlled re-entry or simply
provides more data for the next
iteration this Mission will be a
critical stepping stone toward spacex's
ultimate Vision a fully reusable
spacecraft capable of carrying crew and
cargo to the Moon Mars and Beyond as the
company continues analyzing the
anomalies of flight 8 and prepares for
the next launch the global space
Community watches with anticipation
eager to see how flight 9 will shape
Humanity's path to the
Stars this is truly a launch filled with
hope and promise for the future of
Starship it's exciting to think about
what comes next
but why is catching Starship so much
more challenging compared to catching
super heavy catching the Starship upper
stage is significantly more challenging
than catching the super heavy booster
due to a combination of technical
environmental and operational factors
spacex's Innovative mechazilla Tower
with its Chopstick arms has successfully
caught three super heavy boosters as
demonstrated in Flight 5 flight 7 with
booster 12 booster 14 and flight 8 with
booster 15 improving the feasibility of
the concept however extending this
capability to the Starship upper stage
introduces additional layers of
complexity that make it a far tougher
engineering problem to solve the flight
profiles and trajectories of the two
vehicles differ dramatically the super
heavy booster separates from Starship
early in the flight typically at an
altitude of around 60 to 70 km and
returns to the launch site shortly
afterward via a suborbital path it
performs a boost back burn to redirect
itself toward the mechazilla tower
followed by a controlled descent using
its grid fins and engines making its
trajectory predictable and manageable in
contrast Starship is designed to reach
orbit or a high altitude suborbital
trajectory traveling much farther and
faster after completing its Mission it
must re-enter Earth's atmosphere from
space decelerate and navigate back to
the launch site a far more complex and
variable Journey atmospheric re-entry
introduces another major hurdle for
Starship the super heavy booster avoids
the extreme conditions of orbital
re-entry ascending and descending
through the lower atmosphere at
suborbital velocities typically less
than 2 to 3
km/s this results in manageable
aerodynamic forces and heat loads
simplifying its return Starships however
must withstand the intense heat and
dynamic pressures of re-entry from
speeds up to 7.8 km/s or higher its
thermal protection system TPS made of
thousands of ceramic tiles Shields it
from temperature exceeding 1, 1400° C
2550 de F but maintaining stability
during the belly flop maneuver where it
falls horizontally to maximize drag is
difficult any misalignment or TPS damage
as possibly seen in Flight 8's ship 34
anomaly could destabilize its descent
complicating a catch attempt precision
and timing further differentiate the two
tasks the booster's return happens
within a tight 6 to 8 minute window
after launch allowing SpaceX to
fine-tune its Landing with Thruster
firings and grid fin adjustments to
align with mechazilla its larger size
about 70 M tall and over 200 tons dry
also makes it a stable Target for the
tower's arms Starships return however
could take 20 to 60 Minutes depending on
its Mission and its smaller size and
higher descent speed demand exceptional
accuracy the transition from belly flop
to Vertical orientation using its Raptor
engines must be perfectly timed and even
slight deviations due to wind engine
performance or guidance could make it a
harder Target to catch control and
maneuverability also play a role the
super heavy booster with up to 33 rapor
engines has immense thrust and robust
control during descent aided by grid
fins for aerodynamic stability its
Landing burn refined through years of
Falcon 9 experience allows for a
controlled hover or soft touchdown
easing the cat process Starship with
only 3 to six Raptor engines and
aerodynamic flaps relies on a rapid flip
maneuver and precise engine ignition to
slow its fall this sequence is riskier
and less forgiving any delay or misfire
could lead to an uncontrolled descent
leaving little room for mechazilla to
adapt structural and design differences
add to the challenge the booster
cylindrical shape and robust build are
optimized for vertical landing and
catching with a wide base and attachment
points well suited for mechazilla grasp
Starships Sleek tapered design and heat
shield tiles while ideal for space
flight and reentry are less
accommodating for catching its catch
points likely near the top must align
perfectly with the Tower and the fragile
TPS tiles could be damaged by any
Collision or misalignment threatening
reusability finally the maturity of
testing highlights the Gap by March 10th
2025 SpaceX has successfully caught at
least one booster building on years of
Falcon 99 Landing expertise and proving
the booster catching process catching
Starship however remains untested with
its re-entry and descent profile still
being refined as evidenced by flight 8's
issues the shift to tower-based catching
introduces new variables that SpaceX is
still working to master in summary while
catching the super heavy booster is an
impressive achievement catching Starship
is a steeper challenge due to its
orbital trajectory re-entry stresses and
precise maneuvering requ requirements
mechazilla success with the booster lays
the groundwork but adapting it to snag a
spacecraft plummeting from space demands
further
Innovation flight 9 and future missions
will continue to tackle these hurdles
bringing SpaceX closer to its goal of
full reusability Starship reusability is
a GameChanger for Mars exploration
because it tackles the biggest hurdle in
space travel cost spacex's Starship
designed to be fully reusable slashes
the price of getting to orbit and Beyond
by allowing the same vehicle both the
super heavy booster and the Starship
itself to fly multiple missions
traditional Rockets like NASA's Saturn 5
or even the space shuttle which was only
partially reusable were mostly
Expendable meaning billions of dollars
went up in Flames or sank to the ocean
floor with each launch the approach of a
Starship is more like that of an
airplane launch land refuel and repeat
for Mars This matters immensely a
one-way trip is Impractical for
sustained exploration or colonization
spacex's endgame isn't just a flag and
Footprints Mission but a self-sustaining
human
presence reusability means you can send
not one but dozens or hundreds of
missions carrying cargo habitats and
people without bankrupting the effort
the numbers back this up SpaceX aims to
get launch costs down to a few million
dollar per flight compared to the $1.5
billion per launch of the space launch
system SLS which is Expendable that's
orders of magnitude cheaper making the
economics of a Mars base feasible the
technical side is just as critical
starship's stainless steel design and
Raptor engines are built for durability
and Rapid turnaround the super heavy
booster lands back on Earth minutes
after launch while Starship itself can
land on Mars refuel using insitu
resource utilization isru think methane
produced from Martian CO2 and water ice
and fly back this closed loop system
eliminates the need to build a new
rocket for every return trip without
reusability you'd need a whole new Fleet
for each wave of missions which is
logistically and financially a
non-starter Elon musk's timeline hinges
on this he's talked about uncrewed Mars
Landings in the late 2020s and crude
missions shortly after reusability is
the backbone of that ambition without it
the sheer volume of launches think 1,000
Starships for a million person Colony
would be impossible let's examine the
progress by March 2025 SpaceX had
successfully conducted multiple test
flights with the fifth seventh and eth
flights successfully catching the super
heavy booster midair using the
mechazilla tower each success validated
the concept and reduced the risk of Mars
missions becoming one-off high stakes
Endeavors the challenge reusability adds
another layer of complexity precisely
Landing a rocket refurbishing it and
ensuring it is safe for the next launch
is no easy task the early Falcon 9
Landings exploded spectacularly before
the system was perfected critics argue
that this could delay Mars plans if
reliability is compromised however
spacex's track record shows they iterate
rapidly and learn even faster Mars is
not just a destination it's a driving
force for perfecting technology that's
all for today's episode thank you so
much for watching and see you next time