Ranking Member Jerry Nadler delivers opening remarks

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
Mar 11, 2025
Hearing: Antitrust Law and the NCAA: Examining the Current Climate
Subcommittee on Administrative State, Regulatory Reform, and Antitrust
thank you Mr chairman Mr chairman the
business of college sports b a business
that generates billions of dollars a
year has seen dramatic changes in recent
years and the industry continues to
evolve rapidly College athletes are
being recognized and compensated for
their talents and contributions as never
before and new models of compensation
continue to develop through litigation
and other competitive pressures but now
the NCAA which generates nearly $1.3
billion a year in Revenue wants to stop
this progress dead in its tracks it
wants Congress to step in and protect
the NCAA its conferences and schools
from having to share a greater
percentage of the of the money they Reon
each year with with their unpaid
athletes without whom there would be no
Revenue in the first place unfortunately
instead of highlighting the need for
continued reforms to the college
athletic system to protect the rights of
its athletes today we are considering
whether a repeat Anti-Trust offender
should get a ba bailout and be allowed
to turn back many of these recent
changes while diminishing the voice of
college athletes in
perpetuity the NCAA has lobbied Congress
for years seeking exemptions from our
laws to preserve their Monopoly on
college sports for example in the wake
of title 99's passage ushering in
historic opportunities for women in
sports the then all male NCAA sought
exemptions from the law in ADV advance
of litigation with the potential to
disrupt their control over broadcast
rights the NCAA sought Congressional
Intervention when faced with lawsuits
that could bring an end to their
suppression of athletes ability to
capitalize on their personal publicity
rights also called name image and
likeness or nil the NCAA asked Congress
this that in and now the NCAA is back
asking us once again to take action on
their behalf to turn back the clock on
many recent changes to the collegiate
system and to render College athletes
voiceless and Powerless the only
professional sports that enjoys the
antitrust exemption the NCAA seeks is
baseball and for decades this exemption
suppressed professional baseball players
abilities to unionize make needed
reforms to their Sport and obtain
competitive
salaries but now many of the same
Republican lawmakers who have decried
Major League Baseball's antitrust
exemption want to Grant the same Safe
Harbor from our comp competition laws to
the
NCAA we have ample evidence that
antitrust exemptions generally suppress
wages block access to necessary health
and safety protections and undermine
competition there is no reason to
contemplate a bail off for the
NCA especially when it has demonstrated
little regard for our competition laws
while failing to protect athletes from
being
exploited while paying coaches and
executive and Executives exorbitant
salaries from the hundreds of millions
of dollars of revenue generated by
college athletes the NCAA insists in
need sell from Congress to suppress
players wages and rights to employment
status while looking the other way on
academic fraud the NCAA insists that the
current system is necessary to protect
quote student athletes close quote the
NCAA knows that athletes often miss
class and cannot pursue their major
choice because of practice and travel
schedules yet they hold out the academic
aspect of a College's athletes of a
college athletes experience as all
important while the NCAA insists it
needs a bailout to ensure the survival
of Olympic sports and to protect women
athletes it has failed to sufficiently
promote those Sports and has failed to
ensure its member schools follow Title 9
we should not reward the NCAA by placing
restrictions are necessary changes to
the Collegiate athletic system changes
which are notably benefiting the
athletes already and which the NCAA
continues to resist and
decry it is not just College athletes
who are concerned about the special
protections the NCAA is seeking the
players associations of all the major
professional sports have also waited in
a joint statement they wrote quote nil
legislation reporting to protect
athletes should not be used as a trojan
horse to nullify athletes legal uh legal
legal rights or status legislation that
is meant to protect College athletes
should under no circumstances eliminate
or diminish their rights under contract
T antitrust Andor labor laws close quote
similarly in response to proposed
legislation that would affirm that
college athletes are employees under the
National Labor Relations Act The Players
Association wrote quote collective
bargaining has immeasurably benefited
the workers we represent and
professional sports as a whole
athletes enjoy elevated health and
safety standards medical benefits Fair
compensation and other rights both on
and off the field leagues and teams can
negotiate roster construction player
reserve and other competitive
regulations and fans receive the most
compelling entertainment product in the
world the same result is achievable at
the co colleg level close quote Mr
chairman college sports have the power
to bring communities together and to
Electrify the nation the college
football playoffs brought heat to a cold
winter and this month the country will
be riveted by March Madness perhaps the
best way to fully appreciate College
athletes is to watch them perform at the
highest levels please play the video
clip for the inbounder looking the
bounce Garcia
[Music]
[Applause]
we are up Casey
O'Brien sent on net and Harvey once more
the Badgers will his first
touch and typical Aston jenty look at
him go you can't bring him down is he
yes he
will Thomas B oh
my the Superstar strikes for North
Carolina what a go the 1 oh in the air
left center field Ro on the Move won't
get
there Tennessee walks it
off she was an Unstoppable Force last
season against Iowa but was coming off
the bench for ohai from the
future as you can see NCAA college
sports are compelling they're exciting
they're electric and people want to see
them advertisers know this and that is
why the business of college sports is so
lucrative but people are tuning in to
see great athletes and it is only fair
that the athletes see a portion of the
revenue generated by their
performances college sports have also
brought many non-financial benefits to
its athletes from life lessons about
teamwork building a strong worth work
ethic and gaining leadership skills to
promoting health and wellness and for
some it also has has the potential to
set them on the path to professional
Glory but for too many athletes the
current system has failed them important
changes are underway that have begun to
level the playing field and more are
being considered we should not put our
thumb on the scale in favor of an
organization that too often has placed
its profits over the interests of its
athletes I thank our Witnesses for being
here today and I look forward to their
testimony I yield back gentleman yields
back
