Global Trade is Facing a Crisis – And No One is Ready For It

Global Finance News
11 followers
Mar 10, 2025 #finance #financial
#finance
#financial
Hot on the heels of the big drop in employment, global trade soared at the absolute wrong time and for all the wrong reasons. Both point to the same huge loss of economic momentum, now seen coming from places all over the world. China, Canada...even the USA.
New data shows that there's been a big impact, something big is happening in the global trade
market. We've seen imports absolutely surge, which sounds like a strong and resilient economy,
when it's actually an indication of how things might go in 2025. And this is something we've
seen all over the place, including China, which suggests that the payback period that we're
talking about may have already started. And that payback period is exactly what the stock market
is worried about, given the fact that stocks are only ever sold when it encounters the traditional
recession signals. When it looks like the economy here, as well as the rest of the world,
starts to behave like it did in, say, 2007 or 2000, 2001, everybody heads for the exit.
That's what we saw last summer, when the U.S. economy was confronting the possibility of
encountering traditional recession signals, leading to Japan-induced selling in shares.
But now we have different reasons for stocks to go down here in 2025, including, as I just said,
the fact that we're going to have a tremendous payback, giveback period after the artificial
high, the tariff-beating activities all over the world that reach these proportions. We got all
this data coming in on the size and scale of the artificial distortion, all of this front-loading
of activity and demand. And it stands to reason that if the front-loading was this big, then the
payback is going to be at least as big. And then you throw on top of it the weakness in the economy,
the tremendous loss in momentum of which this is a part. Maybe the payback is even bigger than it
seems otherwise, just from what we have on the upside. So we've got this staring us across the
entire global goods economy on top of all these other things. No wonder the stock market's getting
sold, because everybody can see that there's a tremendous amount of, at the very least,
risks that are piling up, very real risks that are now piling up and becoming more and more visible.
And as they become more and more visible, the last thing you want to do is sit there and wait to see
if you can get to the exit before everybody else does. So there's a lot of stuff that makes sense
once you step outside the idea the economy is just fine and it's heading in the right direction.
So Mr. Van Meter, Steve, we got a whole bunch of global trade statistics, starting with the U.S.
imports that absolutely soared in the month of January. We had a massive increase in imports,
and that wasn't because suddenly consumers and businesses said we're going to buy everything
and anything. That was exactly the opposite of that. Well, Jeff, businesses want to buy everything
and it makes perfect sense they want to buy it because they now have a built-in excuse to raise
prices and they've been desperate. A lot of businesses have been wanting to raise prices
because we've looked at the retail sales data and we can go back over the past three years
and when you inflation adjusted, it's been largely negative. So for a lot of businesses,
this is not a good thing. They've had higher employment costs, they've had higher other costs,
rent and expenses, but they've been unable to pass it along to the consumer. So they've been
eating at the margin. So yeah, they want to buy everything they can because they want to buy it
at yesterday's price because when the tariff hits, they're going to go right down to the store and
they're going to raise all their prices and say, see, it's not my fault. The tariffs came,
we had to raise our prices, but we have this old inventory that we bought before the tariffs hit
and now we can fatten our margin. They're super desperate for it. But the problem is,
as we've seen from retailers like Ross today, they said, hey, you know what? We've been
discounting trying to entice people to come in and buy, but for some strange reason,
foot traffic continues to fall. So what this is setting up for, Jeff, is a lot of businesses
stocking up as much inventory as they can get, and they're hoping to sell it through.
Problem's going to happen is they can't sell it through.
Yeah, it's a very dangerous, great game, right, Steve? Because you're basically betting that
Jay Powell was correct about the soft landing. So he's saying, I'm going to load up as much
inventory as I can while it's still cheap, and then I sell it off at a higher price for me
and hope that the increased profit and margin helps to claw back some of the lost profits
down the road. But if the economy doesn't hold up, and it was already weak to begin with. We
talked about this during the fall. Retailers have been warning, they warned about the Christmas
season. While the Christmas season wasn't horrific, it certainly wasn't what everybody
had hoped it had been. So there were already weakness heading into the early part of this year.
And so you're kind of betting that consumers are going to be there when you're ready to unload
this inventory on the rest of the economy. So you wait for the tariffs to hit and then say, okay,
the stuff that I have in the warehouse is 25%. The cost has gone up 25%. So I'm going to pass
that along to you. But if the consumer, the customer, balks at the price and says, okay,
I really want that, but 25%, I just can't afford it. Not only do you have the loss of sale, the
loss of volume, the loss of activity, you've got the inventory sitting in your warehouse that's
adding to your cost because you've got to pay for it to be there. Plus, you also see that if
the inventory is not moving out of the warehouse at the rate that you wanted it to, that means
you're going to have to start calling up the wholesalers and the importers and the manufacturers
and saying, we've got way too much as it is. And you knew we had way too much because we were
pulling forward demand. We've got to cut back even further than we were expecting before.
So yeah, like you said, Steve, it makes sense from the surface. It makes sense from the perspective
of Jay Powell's soft landing, but it's a dangerous game, assuming that a lot of things go in your
direction when all the science that we're getting here suggests it's not going that way.
Yeah, it's interesting, Jeff, because you pointed out, this is all going to back feed
up the supply chain because when we look at consumers, they've already been saying,
we can't afford prices now. And so businesses, again, excited that somehow they're going to
have to pay these higher prices so we can fatten our margins. So again, we'll load up the warehouse
in a big way, but what are we hearing from manufacturers now? This is where it's interesting
because probably the economy is slowing and consumers know the prices are going to go up,
and they're saying, look, it's not going to happen. I'm not going to come spend.
And yet manufacturing sector, we've heard about this little renaissance of,
hey, things are looking better. The outlook is going up and, man, things are turning here.
But then all of a sudden, we're now starting to hear from some of these regional Fed surveys,
the ISM, S&P Global, that, well, wait a minute, we're not going to be hiring as much as we
thought. In fact, we probably aren't going to be hiring anybody at all because suddenly we're not
sure about the outlook because maybe all this activity is front running the tariff. And sure
enough, that's exactly what we're seeing. And Jeff, you mentioned the payback period coming.
Well, based on what we're seeing in the economy and payrolls and in China,
it's telling us that the payback period may have already started, as you mentioned.
Yeah. So let's put the numbers on it. Let's get the proportions out there,
which is really the point here. When you see really the distortion in U.S. imports,
you get a sense of, OK, that's how big it was going up. So if there's symmetry here,
and there really should be, that's how much we got to come down. According to the Census Bureau
estimates for January, imports absolutely soared by 12.5 percent. Now, this is dollar value,
but 12.5 percent in January from December. And that had followed two months, November,
December, where imports were up 4 percent in each one. So you've got a three-month period
where imports have risen by about 20 percent. And the import values overall in the month of January
were 26 percent higher than the previous January. Now, a lot of that was, as many people have
pointed out, imports from Switzerland and in the UK, London, as far as gold, because gold,
everybody was afraid of, would be subject to tariffs as well. But even when you account for
the amount of gold, the likely amount of gold that was imported, at least officially, you still
see massive amounts of import growth outside of gold. It was something like 5 percent in January
alone, so maybe not 12.5 percent, but 5 percent. And it was still up about 18 percent year over
year. So massive artificial distortion in goods trade into the United States, trying to beat
tariffs. And all that stuff is not going off the shelf and into customer hands. That's stuff that's
being stored and inventoried with the intent, as Steve pointed out, to sell it off at higher prices
during the year. But you've already got to sell that stuff. And as consumer spending weakens,
there has to be a payback period. And we're already seeing, as Steve mentioned, where foreign
producers and domestic producers are saying, OK, we ran everything, we ran the factories as hot as
we could just to get this stuff made before the tariffs. Now what? We got all this stuff done.
We got to hope that there's new business coming in behind it. Otherwise, we've got nothing to do.
And that's really the story here that we're seeing. Steve, you mentioned some of the economic
debt, but I want the markets to talk about stocks, commodities, oil prices that slipped below.
One point last week, oil prices were as low as they had been in, I think it was going back to
August of 2021. So you're talking about three year low in oil prices. Why is that? Well, when you
make and transport and sell less stuff, you need less energy. So there's a component in almost
every way we look, whether it be the marketplace, macroeconomic data that already suggests
the payback period after this immense amount of artificial distortion is likely to be serious.
And that's added to an economy that wasn't in good shape to begin with.
Yeah, you're right, Jeff. I mean, we're talking about payback periods. Yes,
the market is suggesting that. But we know people are super bullish about stocks. So
that may not be the best barometer. But as you said, the energy market, talk about
probably the perfect metric to look at. We see energy prices coming down because
think about how this back feeds, right? So a retailer loads up with inventory and then
their warehouse gets full of inventory and they've got more stuff on the boat coming in.
And what are they saying? Hey, look, I'm not selling, I got too much. So as you already
mentioned, they're going to call the factory, the wholesaler and say, look, those orders I got,
you can cancel them all. Don't need them. Maybe some of the new stuff, but really,
I don't need much of that because I can't sell what I've got. And so as it flows back up into
the manufacturing sector, what happens? Hours get cut, jobs get cut. And next thing you know,
you get people on unemployment. You see the participation rate coming down because those
people that lose their job realize there are no other jobs. So they just sit at home and give up
and their spending power declines in a major way. And then you look at the energy markets and what
is it telling you? Well, if a manufacturer is not making new goods, they don't need it.
If those goods aren't going through the supply chain, well, the transportation sector is not
using it. People aren't going to work. They're not burning energy. You start to get the big
picture here. And that's why I like the energy markets. And I know you do too, Jeff, because
if you're not sure if everything you're looking at is telling you the economy is going in the
direction you think it's going, energy sector often gives you that validation. And right now,
I think it's giving it a very clear signal. Yeah. What it's saying is that the fax machine
has gone completely silent. The fax machine was running relatively decent. It wasn't ever great,
let's be honest. It wasn't all that great. But there was a relative, call it a renaissance if
you want, at least a transitory one at the end of last year. We saw it in a whole wide variety
of data. You brought up the payroll reports. You saw the payroll reports go up a little bit in
November and December. They come back down in January and then again in February. Even the
household survey, which I talked about in yesterday's video, the household survey was
down in October and November, made somewhat of a comeback in December and January, and then
plunged in February, suggesting, as Steve just said, that the payback may have already begun.
That's what we talked about with the full-time jobs. Full-time jobs absolutely plummeted by
1.2 million. And the household survey suggests that 600,000 of those were converted from full-time
to part-time jobs, but also on top of the 600,000 jobs that were lost, suggesting that there really
is a payback period here that may already be hitting the labor market in the United States,
and this is going to be a global phenomenon. So you look at some of these statistics like imports,
US imports that were so huge, and it's almost like you're staring into the abyss for the early
part of 2025 because you realize that was just temporary. Once the temporary factors dissipate,
we're back into not just the same economy left off with last summer, now you've got this payback
on top. And it looks, again, that's why energy prices, oil prices were down as low as they were.
You know, Jeff, we've had inventory recessions before, and a lot of people thought this one
wasn't going to be one when we looked at some of the other data that, yeah, inventories were
elevated, but not like we've seen in the past. And then with the tariffs coming along, all of a
And we look back to a lot of people saying like, look, there can't be deflation this time. Yeah,
there'll be some disinflation, but there's no way. But now when you start to factor this massive
inventory bill, and then based on what we're seeing in the household survey and what we're
hearing, you know, survey data telling us, yeah, we're going to have a massive inventory recession
on top of whatever other recession we were already likely to have, because these goods have to get
moved off shelves at some point. And if people can't afford them today, how are they going to
afford them at even higher prices? So again, we kind of look at what's going on here. And you say,
is the payback period here? It is here. It started. And I think that's what's really
scaring people is they were really hoping that this renaissance in the manufacturing sector
was going to backfeed into services and cause increasing demand. Instead, what do we see?
The services sector said, hey, whoops, hey, things really didn't go the way we thought,
so we're going to lay off. And the manufacturers came out and said, hey, we're relatively convinced
now this is just inventory building. So we're not going to be adding staff or expanding either.
And next thing you know, all of a sudden workers start to realize that that hope that they had,
all that debt they took on from the end of last year to front run tariffs. Well, now they've got
to pay the bill too. At the same time, they're looking at the labor market, watching people lose
their jobs and not finding another one saying, oh my, I could be next. I've got to cut my spending.
And that's where we're at now. I think payback period has begun.
Yeah, I think the Chinese agree too, because the statistics that came out this week from
China on trade for the January and February combined period, first of all, imports were
down 8.3% year over year in U.S. dollar terms. That's imports into China, which means
mostly raw materials. So if you're expecting that you're going to have to pay back for the
activity that was front loaded into last year, plus you've got weakness to contend with too,
and you're not expecting to pick up any other demand anywhere else in the interim,
you're going to say, OK, we don't need any more raw materials. Keep your iron ore. We don't need
that. We're not going to make as much steel. So Chinese imports that were surprisingly weak in
the January and February combined period, so the two months of the year already, down 8.3%. As you
said, Steve, that's a suggestion, a very strong one. The payback has already begun on the upper
ends of the supply chain, and it only filters down from there. Chinese exports, while they
increased in the January and February period by 2.3%, that's in U.S. dollar terms, so nominal
terms. In real terms, they're likely negative, suggesting, again, that the payback has started
even on the export side. So the material going into China, much weaker. The material coming out
of China, the manufactured and assembled goods and components, that is slowing down materially
from where it had been at the end of last year as well. And as you said, Steve, I think the big
picture here is that everybody can see all of these things happening at the same time.
We've been talking about the inventory recession for the last couple of years,
and it was similar on the way up. Remember, everybody was afraid of, they couldn't get
goods because of the supply snafu and the supply chain problems back in 21 and 22,
so you had a massive increase in inventory. But then the inventory recession which followed it
was relatively mild. It wasn't deflationary because nobody had to sell all at once,
and the reason it was relatively mild is because at that time, there was still a lot of upward
momentum in the U.S. economy and the global economy. So as the manufacturers and wholesalers
and retailers had more inventory, they could afford to sit on it for a longer period of time.
It just stopped growing, which is kind of different from the typical inventory recession.
But here in 2025, you have this massive buildup of inventory, especially from overseas,
but the economic circumstances, there is no momentum underlying the economy, so there is
no support for an inventory reverse cycle that ends up going in the same way, just a gentle
sort of stop growing. There has to be a bigger payback, which gets into what you said, Steve,
the possibility that businesses have to liquidate stuff at lower and lower prices because they can't
afford to just sit on it, and they were expecting that they would be able to sell it relatively
quickly, and as soon as they find out they can't, it's not just inventory that gets liquidated,
right? It's also positions and hours and workers. It's everything else that goes with it. So I think
that's really the big picture here, is that it's all of these things at the same time.
Yeah, I agree, Jeff. I think you nailed it perfectly because when we talk about China
and their imports, a lot of people might think it's like, well, I don't care about Chinese
consumers. Well, it's not about Chinese consumers. They're the world's largest exporter. It's about
China's factories. So if China's slowing down and their exports are slowing down, then that tells
us the global economy is going to follow. So you want to know how the cycle begins. It begins right
where it starts, and that's China. So you said, and very accurately, if imports are going down,
it means demand from the rest of the world is going down. The factories there don't need to
produce. A huge problem because that means, of course, they're going to lay people off as well,
and that's exactly what we're seeing in the Chinese economy. So that's a huge red flag
because if you said, hey, if you were to come out and mention that all of a sudden imports
in China are surging, well, that would tell us that something is shifting. In this case,
it's shifting in the wrong direction, and you're right. I think the payback is going to be massive,
far worse than anybody at this point believes. Yeah, so you think China, okay, too bad for them,
but that's the point. It's not just China. It's everywhere else. Like we said, we're already
seeing it in U.S. economic data as well. We get it in Europe. Europe's been incredibly weak all
along, but here we have the U.S. showing the same thing after the artificial high and distortion
last year, huge loss of momentum coming in from all sides here in the U.S., and it's backed up
by the financial market volatility in stocks, lower interest rates in the bond market, market
interest rates, as well as all of these commodity prices, not just energy, but also gasoline.
So you're right, Steve. If we're thinking about, okay, the upside was this big,
then the payback has to be pretty substantial, and that's what we're seeing everywhere.
Payback is going to be a bitch, and it has already begun.
