"SpaceX New Big Contract on Dragon Humiliated Boeing Starliner... === #techmap#techmaps#elonmusk#starshipspacex#boeingstarliner === Intro:0:00 Contract: 0:19 Dragon:3:28 Starliner: 6:56 Outro: 14:56 === 1) SOURCES OF THUMBNAIL 2) SOURCES OF IMAGES AND VIDEOS Everyday Astronaut: https://twitter.com/Erdayastronaut https://www.youtube.com/c/EverydayAstronaut === SpaceX New Big Contract on Dragon Humiliated Boeing Starliner... Dragon, America's only spacecraft reliable enough to carry astronauts into space since the space shuttle, is about to embark on a major new mission. What milestone will SpaceX's ship reach this time? And, will Starliner ever catch up? Watch until the end to find out. On December 19, Vast announced on their X account a deal with SpaceX to launch two astronauts to the International Space Station. SpaceX's Falcon 9 rocket is set to launch up to two Dragon missions to the ISS to assist Vast's upcoming bid for NASA's private astronaut missions or (PAM). SpaceX New Big Contract on Dragon Humiliated Boeing Starliner... NASA's PAM strategy, introduced in 2019, aims to boost the LEO space economy and demonstrate the potential of commercial destinations. It provides industry partners with key insights into LEO mission costs, operations, crew selection, training, planning, management, cargo integration, and crew health protocols. So far, the agency has awarded four PAM opportunities, all to Axiom Space, with little to no competition from other providers. For Vast, getting NASA to approve these two missions was extremely important. The company plans to use additional ISS missions with NASA to tap into the agency's expertise, collaborate with private and international partners through NASA's PAM program, and strengthen existing relationships. This is a key step as Vast prepares to compete with its Haven-2 design in NASA's upcoming CLD Phase II program, aimed at selecting a successor to the ISS. SpaceX New Big Contract on Dragon Humiliated Boeing Starliner... Max Haot, the Chief Executive Officer of Vast, stated:” Enabling payload and crewed missions to the ISS is a key part of Vast’s strategy, allowing us to further our collaboration with NASA and global space agencies. These missions not only strengthen our expertise in human spaceflight operations and collaboration with NASA but also position Vast as a leading contender to deliver the next-generation successor to the ISS, advancing the future of human space exploration,""
Dragon, America's only spacecraft reliable enough to carry astronauts into space since
the Space Shuttle, is about to embark on a major new mission.
What milestone will SpaceX's ship reach this time?
And will Starliner ever catch up?
Watch until the end to find out.
On December 19, Vast announced on their X account a deal with SpaceX to launch two astronauts
to the International Space Station.
SpaceX's Falcon 9 rocket is set to launch up to two Dragon missions to the ISS to assist
Vast's upcoming bid for NASA's Private Astronaut Missions, or PAM.
NASA's PAM strategy, introduced in 2019, aims to boost the LEO space economy and demonstrate
the potential of commercial destinations.
It provides industry partners with key insights into LEO mission costs, operations, crew
selection, training, planning, management, cargo integration, and crew health protocols.
So far, the agency has awarded four PAM opportunities, all to Axiom Space, with little to no competition
from other providers.
For Vast, getting NASA to approve these two missions was extremely important.
The company plans to use additional ISS missions with NASA to tap into the agency's expertise,
collaborate with private and international partners through NASA's PAM program, and strengthen
existing relationships.
This is a key step as Vast prepares to compete with its Haven 2 design in NASA's upcoming
CLD Phase 2 program, aimed at selecting a successor to the ISS.
Max Hayut, the chief executive officer of Vast, stated,
Enabling payload and crewed missions to the ISS is a key part of Vast's strategy, allowing
us to further our collaboration with NASA and global space agencies.
These missions not only strengthen our expertise in human spaceflight operations and collaboration
with NASA, but also position Vast as a leading contender to deliver the next-generation successor
to the ISS, advancing the future of human space exploration.
Using SpaceX's Falcon 9 and Dragon human spaceflight system, the Vast PAM mission is poised to
accomplish several NASA objectives.
These include expanding the number of PAM providers, broadly disseminating the knowledge
and experience gained from conducting PAM missions, and assisting NASA in further advancing
its goal of fostering a low-Earth-orbit LEO space economy.
Vast announced that its agreement with SpaceX for crewed Dragon missions to the ISS is supplementary
to a previous contract with the company to launch its Haven 1 module, and at least one
crewed Dragon mission to the module in 2025.
On SpaceX's side, Gwynne Shotwell, SpaceX's president and chief operating officer, stated,
I am excited to work with Vast as they build more opportunities and destinations for more
people to travel amongst the stars.
If Haven 2 becomes the successor to the ISS in the future, this mission will be known
as an important link and a turning point in the history of space exploration.
The contract with Vast demonstrates that SpaceX's Dragon spacecraft is again trusted to make
history.
Its modern and safe design is the key factor that makes crewed Dragons so reliable.
SpaceX, to significantly reduce space transportation costs, designed the Dragon spacecraft to be
reusable rather than discarded, as is common with most spacecraft.
It consists of a reusable capsule and a disposable trunk.
SpaceX and NASA initially certified the capsule for use in five missions.
As of March 2024, they are working on certifying it for up to 15 missions.
Crewed Dragon is capable of autonomous operation.
SpaceX and NASA state that it is capable of carrying seven astronauts, but in normal operations,
it carries two to four crew members.
The crewed Dragon features eight side-mounted SuperDraco engines as part of its emergency
escape system, removing the need for a traditional, disposable escape tower.
Additionally, instead of placing the essential and costly life support, thruster, and propellant
storage systems in a disposable service module, Dragon 2 integrates these components within
the capsule for reuse.
The trunk acts as an adapter between the capsule and the Falcon 9 rocket's second stage, and
also contains solar panels, a heat dissipation radiator, and fins for aerodynamic stability
during emergency aborts.
The spacecraft's nose cone protects the docking port and thrusters during ascent and reentry,
and pivots open for in-space operations.
Its propellant and helium pressurant are stored in composite carbon overwrapped titanium tanks
in the service section.
For aborts, eight SuperDraco engines provide 71 kilonewtons of thrust, while 16 smaller
Draco thrusters handle attitude control and orbital maneuvers.
During reentry, a PICA-3 heat shield protects the capsule.
Dragon 2 uses six parachutes, two drogues, and four mains for deceleration before splashdown.
SuperDraco thrusters are also available as a backup for parachute failure.
Since 2020, SpaceX has been the leader in launching crews to space for NASA.
These flights included many firsts, like Inspiration 4, the first fully commercial spaceflight,
and Axiom 1, the first fully commercial mission to the ISS.
As of December 2024, there have been 15 crewed orbital flights of a Crew Dragon spacecraft,
and this number is only likely to increase in the future.
In addition to the two PAM missions mentioned above, nine more Dragon flights are planned
in the coming years, including the Polaris 2 mission and the Haven 1 mission, which will
be operational in 2025 and carry four astronauts to the station.
Crew Dragon has consistently delivered reliable, cost-effective services, surpassing traditional
space programs and solidifying SpaceX's leadership in commercial space travel.
It is seen as a vital asset for NASA and other space agencies, contributing to the future
of human space exploration.
Meanwhile, the spacecraft known as Dragon's rival, Starliner, is having embarrassing performances.
Rewind to about 10 years ago when NASA awarded SpaceX a $2.6 billion contract to build a
crew vehicle.
Around the same time, Boeing received a contract for the same purpose, except this time NASA
gave Boeing a whopping $4.2 billion.
At the time, this made sense, as SpaceX was still a young private company, with no prior
experience building human-carrying spacecraft.
On the other side, Boeing is a multinational corporation that designs, manufactures and
sells airplanes, rotorcraft, rockets, satellites and missiles worldwide.
It's also among the largest global aerospace manufacturers.
They were supposed to beat SpaceX to space by a long shot due to their decades of experience
with the Shuttle and ISS.
However, the Starliner's journey is littered with stories of disappointment and sadness.
Originally planned to be operational in 2017, Starliner has been repeatedly delayed by problems
in management and engineering.
The first uncrewed orbital flight test, in December 2019, was deemed a partial failure,
leading to a second orbital flight test in May 2022.
During the crew flight test, launched in June 2024, the Starliner's thrusters malfunctioned
on approach to the ISS, and NASA concluded that it was too risky to return its astronauts
to Earth aboard the spacecraft, which landed uncrewed in September 2024.
You might think the problems Starliner has had, or the reason Starliner performed worse
than SpaceX's spacecraft, is because its design is less advanced than Dragon's.
In reality, it is the opposite.
The Starliner design is considered excellent on paper.
The spacecraft features a reusable capsule and expendable service module for low-Earth
orbit missions.
The capsule holds seven passengers or a mix of crew and cargo.
The Starliner capsule has a weld-less, spun-formed structure, and is reusable up to ten times
with a six-month turnaround.
Starliner features the NASA docking system.
Boeing modified its design before OFT-2, adding a hinged re-entry cover beneath the nose cone
to protect the docking port during atmospheric entry.
This was tested on OFT-2.
In contrast, SpaceX's reusable Dragon nose cone protects its docking port during launch
and re-entry.
The capsule uses the Boeing Lightweight Ablator for its heat shield, and is powered by 2.9
kilowatts of electricity from solar cells provided by Spectrolab, a Boeing subsidiary.
A 5.8-foot aeroskirt is integrated into the Atlas V launch vehicle adapter, providing
aerodynamic stability and reducing shockwaves from the rocket's front.
The spacecraft's propulsion system, built by Aerojet Rocketdyne, includes 64 engines,
12 MR-104J RCS thrusters on the capsule for re-entry orientation, 52 thrusters on the
service module for attitude control and orbital maneuvers, and four RS-88 engines for launch
escape capability, with thrusters grouped in four doghouses around the service module.
This overwhelming number of engines helps Starliner achieve high maneuverability during
docking with the ISS.
Boeing designed the capsule for ground landings, marking the first crewed capsule mission from
the U.S. after re-entry.
Three parachutes slow the capsule to about 4 miles per hour, followed by six airbags
to cushion the landing at one of four primary locations.
As you can see, the design of the Starliner is very sophisticated and complex.
However, because of this, small errors occur more often.
This complexity also makes it difficult for engineers to pinpoint the cause when problems
arise.
And we have all witnessed the consequences of it.
The Boeing Starliner capsule's first crewed mission launched on June 5, 2024, carrying
NASA astronauts Barry E. Wilmore and Sunita Williams from Cape Canaveral Space Force Station
to the International Space Station.
The mission was initially planned to last eight days, concluding with a landing in the
American Southwest on June 14.
However, as the spacecraft neared the ISS, a malfunction occurred with Starliner's thrusters.
After more than two months of investigation, NASA deemed it was too risky to return its
astronauts to Earth on board the Starliner.
Instead, the Boeing spacecraft returned uncrewed on July 7, 2024, and the astronauts will ride
down on the SpaceX Crew-9 spacecraft in March 2025.
This puts the vehicle's ability to achieve safety certification in question.
Before the propulsion issues with the crew flight test, the Boeing spacecraft's first
operational mission, Starliner 1, was scheduled for launch in 2020-2025.
NASA astronauts Scott Tingle and Mike Fincke, along with Canadian Space Agency astronaut
Joshua Kutryk, have been assigned to the Starliner 1 mission.
However, at the moment, even NASA is uncertain about the next flight schedule of this spacecraft.
NASA officials stated on October 15 that the timing of Starliner's next potential, crewed
mission to the International Space Station, ISS, in 2025 will be determined once a better
understanding of Boeing's path to system certification is established.
It's hard to understand why a veteran company with experience in two of NASA's most important
programs would perform so poorly, while a young company like SpaceX continues to achieve
great success.
Well, it turns out the answer has been right in front of us all along.
In the early stages after NASA awarded SpaceX and Boeing contracts to build crewed transportation
systems, they sent four astronauts to work with these two companies.
These are Sunita Williams, Robert Behnken, Eric Boe, and Douglas Hurley.
Doug Hurley said that when working with Boeing, their engineers were often overconfident and
worked in a non-urgent manner.
Not only that, it even seemed like management was not involved in the project.
It was all about managing dollars and cents from Boeing's perspective, he said.
Hurley also noticed a different treatment of astronauts by the two companies' engineers.
He said,
There was an arrogance with them that you certainly didn't see at SpaceX.
When the SpaceX engineers were available, they were enthusiastic to receive feedback
from the NASA astronauts, eager to collaborate with them, and attentive to their suggestions.
In contrast, Boeing engineers appeared uninterested in hearing from the four commercial crew astronauts.
The differences in SpaceX and Boeing's work attitudes are immediately evident in their
results.
SpaceX has always had an attitude of not being afraid of failure, being willing to accept
mistakes, and always accepting feedback.
Thanks to that spirit they have developed at a very fast pace and are always at the
forefront of innovation.
As for Boeing, it seems that they have lost something important, which is the spirit of
an engineer.
At present, SpaceX has embarrassed Boeing more than ever when its Dragon spacecraft
has become NASA's most reliable vehicle ever to shuttle astronauts to and from the
ISS.
They are even going to clean the mess caused by Calypso's first crew test flight in June
by rescuing two stranded NASA astronauts, who the Starliner wasn't supposed to bring
back.
By contrast, the Boeing-Calypso Starliner spacecraft looked like scrap metal.
Not only was it unsuccessful, but it was hemorrhaging cash at such a rapid rate that the company
decided to sell it.
Boeing's financial health is more fragile than ever, as total losses on Starliner are
towards $1.85 billion, even though Starliner is a relatively small portion of Boeing's
overall business.
This contributes to the second-worst quarterly result in its history, with a $6 billion loss
between July and September.
To be honest, the decision to sell Calypso was on the table before Kelly Ortberg took
over as CEO in August.
At that point, Boeing held discussions with Blue Origin about taking over some of the
NASA programs.
Of course, such discussions are still at an early stage and may not result in a deal.
However, we can totally believe that BO is truly a potential buyer.
The company has a couple of potential lines of business that could be a good match for
what Boeing is currently doing in space.
Boeing is already one of the partners backing Orbital Reef, a commercial space station project
led by Blue Origin.
The plan calls for Starliner, accompanied by Sierra Space's Dream Chaser space plane,
to transport crew and cargo to and from Orbital Reef.
If Blue takes over the Starliner program, it will save a significant amount of money
instead of hiring outsourcing.
Last year, the company also began a collaboration with NASA to explore the development of new
capabilities for crew transportation to and from low-Earth orbit.
Not sure if this is referring to New Shepard, if it is talking about New Glenn, or if this
means BO is working on getting Dream Chaser and Starliner compatible with New Glenn.
Interesting stuff regardless.
Furthermore, some speculate that the reason Jeff buys Starliner is to buy the contracts
for six operational missions to the ISS under NASA's Commercial Crew program.
It has a point because the ISS retirement is very likely to be pushed back beyond 2030.
NASA has said more than once this year that 2030 is no longer special and that there is
no deadline for de-orbiting the ISS.
It means Starliner will have more chances to complete the contract and get the full
$4.2 billion.
However, there are still some challenges here.
Starliner is basically an incompetent spacecraft.
It is still alive because of the lobby it has in politics.
Whoever buys it will not have support from anyone and will have to fight like a lone
wolf.
This is a big deal, especially when its rival, SpaceX Dragon, has been dominating the market.
Therefore, to enter the race, BO or Boeing would have to completely resolve the technical
troubles on the vehicle in advance, or it will just be a major financial albatross around
their proverbial neck.
Talking about this matter, some opinions raise the positive view that Starliner is a distressed
asset.
However, 95% of the vehicle is good.
It's just some issues with the thrusters.
A lot of the technology is fundamentally sound, given that Starliner seems to have working.
For the complex technological components like the Environmental Control Life Support System
and Pressure Vessel, they could import and build a new vehicle around that core.
So how about you?
Do you think Blue Origin buying Starliner is a good choice?
Let me know in the comments.
Putting Starliner for sale is an inauspicious end to Boeing's space business, but it fits
perfectly with the principle of Boeing's latest CEO, which is doing less and doing
better.
We're better off doing less and doing it better than doing more and not doing it well, Ortberg
said.
Clearly, our core of commercial airplanes and defense systems are going to stay with
the Boeing company for the long run, but there's probably some things on the fringe there that
we can be more efficient with, or that just distract us from our main goal here.
So a pretty loaded statement there is that Ortberg wants to take Boeing back to its core
sector by making it clear that Boeing is an airplane company.
This wise step sets him apart from the previous Wall Street-style managers of Boeing who can
do anything to save every penny.
SpaceX CEO Elon Musk also praised Kelly Ortberg for this, which has since raised hopes of
reviving the once-greatest American company.
The new Boeing CEO spends time in the factory and understands engineering, which are big
improvements.
Hopefully, he turns around a once-great company.
Frankly, Elon has often pointed out the root cause of Boeing's collapse.
In June, he posted a tweet, as quoted,
The CEO of an aircraft company should know how to design aircraft, not spreadsheets.
On May 7, after Boeing's first crewed launch attempt was cancelled, Elon chided Boeing
on X for employing too many non-technical managers.
Also, in 2022, Musk opined about non-technical managers,
I strongly believe that all managers in a technical area must be technically excellent.
Managers in software must write great software, or it's like being a cavalry captain who can't
ride a horse.
Back at Blue Origin, buying Starliner isn't the only Boeing deal the company has its eye on.
In February, there was a rumor that Jeff Bezos' space company was likely a buyer for United
Launch Alliance, a joint venture between Boeing and Lockheed Martin.
Everything started in 2023 when ULA announced that it was for sale.
In December 2023, it was announced that Jeff Bezos was looking at purchasing the company
to merge it with Blue Origin.
In early 2024, some sources said that Blue Origin was nearing the purchase of ULA.
During that time, a handful of senior officials at ULA are seeking new jobs.
In February, Jeff Bezos sold shares worth roughly $8.5 billion,
after the stock rallied 80% in 2023.
According to speculation in the launch industry, ULA may be sold for $2-3 billion
and could be as high as $4 billion, so it's safe to say that Jeff can totally purchase ULA.
After stepping down as chief executive of Amazon in summer 2021,
Jeff Bezos is now all-in on Blue Origin.
Although he essentially has no technical background to successfully run a rocket company,
he is a businessman, a billionaire, and very smart at taking advantage of disadvantages.
ULA offers great value to Blue Origin.
According to the payload, ULA's existing contract backlog provides immediate market
penetration and revenue. ULA's launch backlog, possibly over $7 billion,
far exceeds what Blue will pay for the acquisition.
Additionally, ULA and its chief Tory Bruno are not ordinary.
To be fair, in the past two decades, not a single ULA Atlas rocket has failed.
That contrasts with two failures suffered by the Falcon 9 favored by SpaceX,
one in 2015 and one last September. That gives ULA bragging rights when it comes to reliability.
ULA's chief executive, Tory Bruno, is not a dumb. Since taking over ULA in 2014,
he has slashed employee headcount and taken other steps to control costs,
such as closing infrequently used launch pads.
He has demonstrated the ability to run a launch company with an excellent record of success
and managed the development of a large new launch vehicle, the Vulcan rocket.
His mission was clear, make it competitive with SpaceX.
His engineering background could complement Blue Origin's newly appointed CEO, Dave Limp,
a former Amazon executive who has strong management experience.
In conclusion, buying ULA and even Starliner would enhance Blue Origin in the competitive
market in the race against Elon Musk's SpaceX. And that just about wraps it up for today's
episode. Thank you and we look forward to seeing you next time.