SpaceX's Big Solution to Solve NASA's New Space Plane Trouble Replace Boeing Starliner…

GREAT SPACEX
1K followers
449 Video Views·Sep 16, 2024
carrying Great Hopes from NASA the
Dreamchaser space plane has yet to take
flight unfortunately the primary
obstacle preventing its assent is the
launch vehicle itself NASA and Sierra
space are undoubtedly eager to resolve
this issue as the Dreamchaser holds
significant promise for the future
potentially serving as an ideal
replacement for what has become the
biggest disappointment of the moment
Boeing's Starliner in this challenging
situation they might need to turn to
SpaceX the longstanding savior of us
Aerospace efforts but why is SpaceX the
best option could this partnership
actually happen and what benefits could
this collaboration bring to NASA let's
explore these questions on today's
episode of great SpaceX the worst
spacecraft in history perhaps no other
vehicle is more deserving of this
humiliating title than the Starliner
over the past few years star luner has
consistently been a major disappointment
for NASA despite its $4.5 billion price
tag and more than half a decade of
development the spacecraft's first crude
Mission ended in Failure even after
finally launching it couldn't make the
return trip right now starlander remains
stranded at the ISS plagued by issues
such as helium leaks Thruster failures
and problems with its undocking software
this situation has led NASA to propose a
solution that that involves using
spacex's Dragon to rescue the mission if
Starliner cannot resolve its issues
within a month the two astronauts will
be returned to to Earth on spacex's crew
9 next year leaving Starliner to make
the trip back without any crew on board
for Boeing a long-standing company with
a reputation for engineering Excellence
this is nothing short of embarrassing
it's a mortifying failure for both the
company and the expensive crew vehicle
however this setback could create
opportunities for other spacecraft while
the role of spacex's dragon has already
been extensively analyzed this situation
presents a particularly significant
opportunity for Dreamchaser the space
plane poised to emerge as a viable
alternative for NASA Dreamchaser could
potentially support or even replace
Starliner in the future but why is this
the case compared to Starliner
Dreamchaser boasts several strengths
that set it apart originally envisioned
as the successor to NASA's Space Shuttle
dream Chas stands out due to its design
and unique Landing method as a space
plane unlike conventional spacecraft
while it's still too early to
definitively assess its reliability the
positive results from its test offer
more confidence than Starliner has
managed to inspire though Dreamchaser
has been slow in its testing phase this
deliberate Pace has allowed for thorough
evaluations helping to avoid the
pitfalls that have plagued Starliner in
contrast Starliner delays have not
yielded the same level of reliability
this careful approach by Dreamchaser
could prevent the types of issues that
have continuously hampered Starliner as
for Boeing's Starliner the best it can
do is to fulfill the tasks outlined in
its NASA contract however with its
history of countless problems and delays
even that seems uncertain there's no
guarantee that Starliner will be able to
perform as required making any further
delays or failures all to possible
moreover the possibility of the
Starliner project being cancelled is
growing NASA has recently shown a
willingness to cancel costly projects as
seen with the Chandra telescope and the
Viper lunar rover both of these projects
are arguably as important as Starliner
yet Starliner has been far more
disappointing even though NASA remains
committed to Starliner going as far as
to Grant it a crew launch certificate
despite its inability to safely return
astronauts there's still a chance it
could be cancelled in that event dream
Chaser would be a strong candidate to
step in although NASA could rely on
Dragon to take over Starliner duties
they likely wouldn't want to create a
monopoly or become overly dependent on
any single organization this makes
Dreamchaser an attractive alternative
allowing NASA to maintain competition
and flexibility in their crude space
missions however Dreamchaser is not
without its challenges despite
successfully completing testing and
being moved to the launch site at
Kennedy Space Center it has yet to take
flight this delay adds another layer of
complexity to NASA's options as they
consider the future of their commercial
crew program Dreamchaser was originally
set to be launched aboard ula's Vulcan
rocket during the c 2 mission however
due to the pressing need for government
payload certification Ula has opted to
launch a dummy payload on SE 2 pushing
the Dreamchaser mission to an
undetermined date it's undeniable that
dreamchaser's progress has been somewhat
slow after years of development its
first prototype was only completed at
the end of last year the month-long
testing process that followed led to a
scheduling conflict with its intended
launch vehicle the Ula Vulcan Centaur in
hindsight Sierra space might regret not
considering more carefully before
partnering with Ula a company currently
undergoing significant changes as Ula
phases out its older rockets and focuses
on developing the new Vulcan Centaur it
is under pressure to secure National
Security launch service ification this
urgency doesn't align well with
Dreamchasers Pace additionally Vulcan is
neither quickly produced nor launched
and it lacks reusability limiting
Dreamchasers deployment flexibility this
could result in yet another year passing
without a Dreamchaser launch which would
be a significant disappointment for
Sierra space NASA and the broader
Aerospace industry beyond the current
scheduling conflict Vulcan may not be a
suitable long-term partner for
Dreamchaser as ula's older Rockets
retire Vulcan will become its primary
vehicle for launching National Security
payloads however due to delays Vulcan
has accumulated a backlog of missions
that will take years to complete with
its recent selection for phase three of
the National Security space launch
contract running from 2025 to 2029
Dreamchasers launch plans could be
further affected so who can save
Dreamchaser Sierra space and NASA at
this critical time the answer is none
other than SpaceX Vehicles if you agree
with my opinion please respond with yes
in the comment section down below don't
forget to like share the video and
subscribe to our channel to keep
following spacex's development Journey
NASA would likely be thrilled with this
combination as it offers numerous
benefits compared to Ula SpaceX vehicles
have several advantages firstly SpaceX
boasts the highest launch frequency in
the world Falon 9 in particular has
reached over 360 missions becoming the
most frequently launched vehicle in
recent years Falcon 9 can currently
handle launches every 2 to 3 days
sometimes even within hours offering
unmatched flexibility to all customers
including Sierra space additionally
Falcon heavy though launched less
frequently maintains stability and is
ready to step in for Falcon 9 in
challenging situations the reliability
of Falcon Rockets is also a significant
Advantage with a success rate of over
99% from 2015 to July of 2024 Falcon
Rockets experienced no major incidents
and even when they encountered problems
with the second stage SpaceX quickly
addressed the issue and made a strong
comeback this level of reliability is
unmatched by any other rocket or
organization one of spacex's most
significant competitive advantages is
the reusability of its Falcon system
this feature allows SpaceX to save on
production costs which in turn reduces
launch costs a benefit every customer
appreciates reusability also enables
SpaceX to increase its launch rate over
time their launch rate has consistently
risen each year with a goal of reaching
148 flights this year therefore SpaceX
is undoubtedly the best option to help
Dreamchaser at this time with frequent
launches flexible scheduling affordable
costs and unlimited future potential
SpaceX offers everything Sierra space
needs to get Dreamchaser off the ground
with spacex's support Dreamchaser could
definitely launched this year provided
it's ready not only will the cooperation
between SpaceX and Dreamchaser benefit
NASA in the near future but it also
holds immense potential for long-term
gains Beyond Dreamchaser Sierra space is
developing another promising project the
inflatable life module currently part of
the orbital Reef initiative with blue
origin given its potential Sierra space
could eventually create its own space
station system which will be crucial for
NASA once the International Space
station retires in this future scenario
Dreamchaser and SpaceX Rockets would
continue to play Vital roles in
supporting NASA's space activities while
some might assume that Dreamchaser would
launch on Vulcan or new Glenn as part of
orbital Reef it's clear that these
vehicles lack the reliability that
SpaceX Rockets consistently deliver
building and operating a new space
station involves numerous challenges
including maintaining schedules and
ensuring stable operation for vehicles
that are slow to manufacture and launch
meeting these demands may not be
feasible SpaceX with its rapid launch
capability and proven reliability is
undoubtedly the best option to meet
these stringent requirements the
prospect of Dreamchaser launching on
SpaceX Vehicles is a glimpse into the
future of the Aerospace industry this
partnership would bring together the
world's most reliable launch vehicles
and one of the most promising spacecraft
in the coming years and now that moment
is approaching these two giants will
join forces to soar into space and
Achieve remarkable Milestones so I ask
of you are you ready to witness this
historic collaboration for me if there's
one thing I know to be constant it's
that excitement is guaranteed cancelling
Starliner is becoming an increasingly
real possibility and it may not be NASA
making the decision Boeing itself could
step away from the program but why would
Boeing cancel Starliner and how easy
would it be for them to withdraw what
would this mean for NASA and the
Aerospace industry after nearly 3 months
stationed at the International Space
Station Boeing's Starliner capsule
finally returned to Earth without its
crew on board despite Boeing and NASA
labeling the return as a success it's
difficult to ignore the reality leaving
astronauts stranded in orbit is a
glaring failure this event further
erodes public and Industry confidence in
Boeing Starliner program which has
already been plagued by delays technical
issues and significant setbacks worse
yet Boeing itself appears increasingly
frustrated with the Starliner system all
signs suggest that the project May soon
come to an embarrassing and premature
end with Boeing potentially deciding to
cancel the Starliner program altogether
Boeing's growing dissatisfaction with
Starliner was made clear following the
recent Landing in what should have been
a routine press conference with NASA no
Boeing officials attended a highly
uncharacteristic move press briefings
are standard practice after significant
missions providing an opportunity to
update the public clarify results and
demonstrate accountability Boeing's
absence has raised questions were they
preoccupied with postm Mission
complications were they still upset over
previous decisions by NASA or more
simply were they too embarrassed by the
mission's outcome to face public
scrutiny whatever the reasoning their
decision not to appear at the Press
event sent a strong message of
frustration and Poss possibly
embarrassment the financial burden
Starliner has placed on Boeing further
complicates the situation the company
has suffered enormous losses due to the
years of delays and Technical failures
in 2022 alone Boeing reported a
staggering $1.47 billion in losses
primarily from issues related to the
Starliner program these losses continued
into 2023 with the second quarter seeing
a 257 million doll hit due to problems
with flammable wiring and parachutes
pushing the crew flight test or for
cft-1 mission to 2024 most recently
Boeing's Financial reports show an
additional $125 million loss still tied
to delays before the cft1 mission
bringing the total loss for Starliner to
a whopping 1.6 billion these Financial
setbacks combined with technical
challenges have delayed Boeing's
Starliner One mission to the second half
of 2025 The Continuous need for repairs
and adjustments to ensure SA safety will
undoubtedly consume more time and
resources potentially increasing
Boeing's losses even further moreover
with Boeing's current trajectory it's
becoming increasingly doubtful that they
will be able to meet NASA's requirement
to complete six crude flights as part of
the commercial crew program contract
Boeing has spent nearly a decade just
trying to successfully complete the crew
test mission with little to show for it
Beyond mounting losses and repeated
delays time is running out and the
prospect of Boeing in completing One
mission per year to fulfill the contract
seems increasingly unrealistic When
comparing Boeing's progress to spacex's
achievements under the same CCP contract
the difference is Stark SpaceX which
also received funding under the program
has successfully launched nine crew
missions for NASA including the crew
test mission and they are preparing to
launch their 10th Mission this month on
top of that SpaceX has conducted
numerous private missions including the
high-profile Polaris Dawn Mission which
featured a commercial spacewalk it's
clear that while SpaceX has excelled in
developing and deploying its Dragon
spacecraft Boeing's Starliner has
struggled to keep up the implications of
Starliner failure extend far beyond
NASA's commercial crew program the
ongoing delays and issues have tarnished
Starliner reputation making it unlikely
that organizations will opt to use the
spacecraft for future missions spacex's
dragon has become the Preferred Choice
with proven reliability and cost
Effectiveness while Starliner faces a
dwindling market and a grim future
Boeing once a leading name in Aerospace
now finds itself grappling with a
spacecraft that lacks public trust and
Industry support without those critical
factors the viability of the Starliner
project is severely compromised for
Boeing the cancellation of Starliner
could relieve them of a significant
burden the company has poured years of
effort and billions of dollars into a
project that has yet to yield successful
results pulling the plug might seem like
the best option especially as Financial
losses continue to amount however the
decision to cancel Starliner would not
be without significant consequences
firstly cancelling Starliner would
irreparably damage Boeing's reputation
for decades Boeing has been a
Cornerstone of the US Aerospace industry
contributing to countless missions and
projects across various sectors to end
the Starliner program in such a
humiliating way would not only reflect
poorly on the company but could also
tarnish the image of American space
exploration as a whole secondly Boeing
received substantial financial support
from NASA to the tune of $4.5 billion
this funding came from taxpayers and
Boeing would face immense public and
governmental scrutiny if the project
were canel without delivering on its
promises NASA selected Boeing for this
critical role in the commercial crew
program placing significant trust and
expectations on the company a failure to
meet even the minimum requirements of
the contract would be a major blow
potentially leading to repercussions for
both Boeing and NASA lastly the impact
on the future of the ISS and US space
leadership would be substantial Boeing's
failure to deliver a reliable crew
transport vehicle could place additional
strain on NASA and other private
Partners to fill the Gap left by
Starliner Boeing would not only lose
face but also it's standing as a
reliable partner in future space
missions ultimately the question remains
will Boeing pull the plug on Starliner
or will they push forward despite the
mounting challenges with each delay and
technical issue the like likelihood of
cancellation grows and while Boeing May
benefit from walking away it's clear
that such a decision would come with
far-reaching consequences for the
company NASA and the future of us space
exploration what do you think will
Boeing cancel Starliner or will they
find a way to salvage the project let us
know in the comments down below and if
you agree with this analysis make sure
to like share the video and subscribe to
our channel to stay updated on spacex's
development Journey indeed the future of
star ler ultimately hinges on NASA's
decision as the agency originally
created the project and selected Boeing
despite the recent setbacks NASA appears
to maintain a level of support for
Boeing Steve Stitch the manager of
NASA's commercial crew program recently
remarked we had a crew on board the
spacecraft we would have flown the same
uh backway sequence from the space
station and the same deorbit burn and
executed the same entry and so it would
have been a safe successful Landing with
the crew on board yeah I think it's
always hard to have that retrospective
look you know we made the decision to
have an uncrewed flight based on what we
knew at the time and based on our
knowledge of the thrusters and based on
the modeling that we had and we you know
if we' have had a model that would have
predicted what we saw tonight perfectly
yeah it looks like an easy decision to
go say we could have had a crude flight
but we didn't have that this ongoing
support suggests that NASA might still
consider CER ifying Starliner for crude
missions despite the uncrewed return
however this statement raises questions
about the contradiction between NASA's
confidence in starliners safety and
their decision to return the spacecraft
uncrewed it's unclear whether NASA will
continue to support Starliner or if they
will push for more significant changes
for now both NASA and Boeing are likely
working to address the spacecraft's
issues and determine the next steps as
the situation evolves it will be
interesting to see how NASA's support
impacts starlander future what do you
think about NASA's stance share your
thoughts in the comments section down
below and Boeing's troubles extend
beyond the Starliner program notably
impacting the space launch system or SLS
project as well according to NASA's
office of Inspector General or oig
components of the SLS 1B core stage and
exploration upper stage or E slated for
Artemis 4 fail to meet quality standards
and post risks to Future missions Boeing
May face corrective actions and
potential penalties as a result these
issues could delay Boeing's delivery
schedule potentially pushing the e
delivery to April of 2027 with Artemis
Force scheduled for September of 2028
this delay coupled with the increased
costs associated with the eus which has
already reached 2.8 billion highlights a
pattern of expensive delayed and
inefficient performance the core stage
cost remains uncertain but is expected
to be substantial the similarities
between the problems with SLS and
Starliner both expensive and delayed
point to possible issues with outdated
technology and working practices this
raises concerns about further
disappointments once SLS is operational
Boeing could face being removed from the
project a scenario that would be as
humiliating as the potential
cancellation of Starliner and could
signal Boeing's exit from the Aerospace
Market however if NASA were to remove
Boeing from the SLS project finding a
replacement contractor could be
challenging and might lead to new delays
this brings up the possibility of NASA
cancelling the SLS altogether despite
its success in emis 1 the SLS faced
significant delays and cost overruns
which could make it advantageous for
NASA to focus on supporting SpaceX and
its Starship program which promises a
more efficient and costeffective
solution Boeing's future in the
Aerospace industry is uncertain and much
depends on the fate of Starliner and the
SLS the possibility of cancelling
Starliner is growing and decisions in
the coming months will be crucial in
determining Boeing's role moving forward
well folks that's about it for today's
episode thank you so much for tuning in
and as always this has been Kevin from
great SpaceX until next time keep
looking up
