Stuart Hameroff, MD, is a physician, Professor of Anesthesiology and Psychology, and Director of the Center for Consciousness Studies at the University of Arizona in Tucson. In medical school, Hameroff became interested in the intelligent behavior of microtubules—protein lattices within brain neurons and other living cells. He developed theories proposing that microtubules function as self-organizing molecular computers and later collaborated with Sir Roger Penrose on the controversial Penrose-Hameroff "Orch OR" model of consciousness.
Based on quantum computing in brain microtubules, Orch OR links brain activity to the most fundamental level of the universe—spacetime geometry at the Planck scale. At that level, Penrose has proposed that Platonic information may guide or influence conscious choices and perceptions. Orch OR can be viewed as offering a plausibility argument for non-locality and spirituality.
Hameroff is also involved in clinical trials using transcranial ultrasound (TUS) for mood and cognitive dysfunction and co-organizes the biennial interdisciplinary conference Toward a Science of Consciousness.
So you raised a lot of issues Deepak. So let me just go back a moment to say that
most scientists today, scientists and philosophers view consciousness,
how the brain produces consciousness as a form of computation among neurons. They look at the
brain as a hundred billion or so simple switches, neurons that either fire or don't fire. They
interact, they compute, and when that computation reaches a critical level of complexity, they say
consciousness emerges, kind of like pulling a rabbit out of the hat. Now I don't agree with
that, and Roger Penrose and I have developed a theory which says all that computation occurs,
but where consciousness comes from, where awareness, what philosophers call qualia,
flavors, tastes, touch, conscious perceptions, awareness, actually involves reaching down to
the basement level of the universe, which is what you would, in the Vedanta, is consciousness,
and what we would call pure consciousness. And we would say that pure consciousness is
included in fundamental space-time geometry, along with the precursors of spin, mass, or charge.
Everything that we see in our real world, all the beauty we see around us, actually stems from
patterns in the most fundamental level that percolate up to our level, which is many, many
orders of magnitude higher. So how does that happen? Well, Penrose and I developed this theory
that the microtubules inside neurons, that the neurons are already too high a level, but if you
go down inside neurons, you see these structures that are sort of like computers. They look like
computers, they act like computers, and they may be quantum computers in which the bits, or the ones
and zero, ones or zeros, can actually be in superposition of both one and zero. Now what does
that mean? That means if you're in a superposition, or something's in a superposition of being both
here and there, it means that the universe itself, at its most basic level, has separated, has
bifurcated, so that you have a curvature in this way and a curvature in that way. Now what happens
to that separation? In the multiple worlds theory, each separation branches off to form a whole new
universe. But Penrose came up with this idea that these separations are unstable, and after a
specific time, t will collapse to one or the other, with the choice being... Because of gravity?
Because of quantum gravity, because of the intrinsic nature of the universe and space-time
geometry, some kind of bounciness, or some kind of restorative nature to choose
one or the other. But the choices are not random, whether it chooses this curvature or that
curvature, whether this reality perceived is chosen versus that, depends on information
embedded in this geometry, in this Planck scale geometry, which Penrose calls platonic
values. So good, evil, aesthetic, ethical values can actually be embedded in and programmed into the
universe, or are embedded into the universe, from the Big Bang presumably, and those can influence
our choices and our conscious perceptions and choices if we're mindful and don't act rationally.
The underlying entity that gives rise to consciousness would be what we call
proto-consciousness. It's quantum information, it includes multiple coexisting possibilities,
and when it reaches this threshold for self-collapse, there's a moment of conscious
awareness. A hap. A hap, a whitehead occasion of experience, a buddhist moment, which correlate with
science in terms of gamma synchrony, EEG, 40 hertz oscillation, so roughly 40 times a second
there's a hap, there's a self-collapse, and a moment of conscious awareness. A happening. A happening,
and we have a perception. Famously, the monks that the Dalai Lama sent over to
University of Wisconsin had 80 to 100 moments of consciousness per clock time, per second,
and so their perceived reality would slow down, since they're having more conscious moments
per time. So they would see everything in slow motion. Correct, and great athletes, Michael
Jordan said that when he's playing well, the defense is in slow motion. People in a car
accident, when they're excited, the car's spinning, the outside world slows down, because they're
having more conscious moments per time than they would under normal circumstances. So consciousness,
I think, is a sequence of discrete events of moments, which are kind of like the self-collapses
arising out of the underlying, what you call pure consciousness, what I would call proto-consciousness,
and I make that distinction so that we can have a mechanism, and I think we need to have a
mechanism for how the brain works, and how the brain produces conscious experience. Now this activity,
which is occurring in the microtubules, is, and you say there are maybe 10 to the power of 27
computations per second, right? Well, yes, and most views of the brain, as I said, 100 billion neurons
switching roughly a thousand times a second, with a thousand synapses, come up with something like
10 to the 15th operations per second, and that's what the goalpost is for artificial intelligence,
for the singularity. When they reach that with their computers, they say that we'll have brain
equivalents. I don't think that's right, because if you look at each individual neuron, it's
incredibly complicated. It's not a single on-off switch, or if you look at a simple organism like
a paramecium that swims around, it finds food, it can learn, it finds a mate, it has sex, it
avoids obstacles, avoids predators. I'm not saying it's conscious, but it's intelligent. It uses its
microtubules, these structures that are both the skeleton, the bone-like structural support of the
cell, but also the cell's onboard computer, in real time, processing information, telling the
cell what to do. And the microtubules, we think, are the quantum computer in all animal cells,
in living systems, and particularly in the brain, due to specific circumstances, can have this
quantum computation, which reaches this collapse, and has a moment of conscious experience, and
connects us to this most fundamental level of the universe, which you would call pure consciousness.
Okay, so these quantum computers are basically the size of molecules, or even smaller, right?
Or about molecular size, right? Yeah, they're made up, microtubules are made up of individual
proteins. So a protein is a molecule, it's a peanut-shaped protein, and they self-assemble.
It's actually quite a miracle. If you have enough of them with the right pH, and salt balance, and
calcium, and so forth, they will self-assemble and form girders, which form the structural support of
the cell. It's like, you know, the Indian rope trick, you know, the guy throws the rope up, and then
climbs up the rope. Or imagine a building self-assembling from the ground up, brick by brick,
each brick just floating to the right place. That's how microtubules establish the
shape, and the structure, and the functionality of each of our cells. And of course, the genes are
the same in each cell, so it's a matter of differentiation to turn one into a nerve cell,
and one into something else. So even though we call them quantum computers, I think they are
even more fundamental than, say, a nanocomputer, because a nanocomputer is still operating,
if there ever was one, which there isn't. But if there ever was a nanocomputer, it's still
operating at the level of atoms. We're going way beyond that, right? 25 orders smaller in magnitude
than the atom. Well, a quantum computer, I mean, the material housing the quantum computer
may be macroscopic size. I mean, the whole point is that life, and biology, and our brains exist
right on the edge between the quantum and classical worlds, allowing quantum information coming from
this pure consciousness level that you described to have influence in our classical world,
to have causal efficacy in the material world. Okay, so now let's go a little further, because
our subject today is going to be immortality. This level, this proto-consciousness level,
this pure consciousness level that exists at this very fundamental level of space-time geometry,
Planck scale, as it is the fundamental, it is the fundamental level. This level is immortal,
because it's before space and time come into existence. Well, that depends on whether the
universe is immortal. We don't yet know whether the universe is going to continue to expand,
stay in steady state, or eventually have a big crunch. And if that happens, whether there'll
be another universe on the other side. But as far as... But the potential for the universe
has to be immortal. It came into existence from something, right? Well, nobody knows the answer
to that. I think the latest thinking from Penrose and others is that it's a cycle. There was a big
crunch, a collapse, which gave rise to this universe, and we're in that, and that'll eventually
perhaps crunch again and give rise to another. I don't think anybody knows for sure, but that's
the latest theory, that we're in a cycle of big bangs and big crunches. You know, I read recently
that another theory which says, instead of the crunch, because of the dark energy, the universe
is keeping on expanding, and at some point it will override all gravity, and instead of a big
crunch, there'll be a big rip, which is a huge explosion back into nothingness. But the question
is, whatever this nothingness is, from it, everything came, and to it, everything returns.
And again, coming back to my tradition, it says, when we experience samadhi, you know, when we go
into this experience where observer, observed, and process become one, you are actually at ground
state. And the ground state of the self, of you as an organism, is also the ground state of the
universe. How could it not be? Because, you know, there's only one ground state. This ground state
is immortal, and therefore, there's a part of me, which connects to that ground state, which is
immortal. And embedded in this, is the potential, or you might say, the superposition of memories,
desires, imagination, platonic values, that exist in a superposition of possibilities,
and that when I die, I probably go into this ground state, which is part of a matrix of perhaps
other individuals or beings, and we're all entangled there, while maintaining some kind
of individuality, at least in as potential, and that this has the possibility of recycling, what
spiritual traditions may call reincarnation. Does your model, which you know, is a model that's
being talked about, and I think we should mention that your colleague, Sir Roger Penrose,
was also the thesis advisor of Stephen Hawking. So, we're talking, you know, about scientists
such as yourself, and Sir Roger Penrose, are you saying that your model could possibly lend itself
to the survival of consciousness after death, or as proto-consciousness, or as some quantum
entangled information in space-time geometry, which could then recycle, which would be
basically reincarnation? Well, I would say that. I should say first that Roger, who's well known on
his own right for many, many things, wouldn't necessarily agree with what I'm going to say.
He tends to shy away from anything in the spiritual or religious realm. So, but based on our theory,
I would say, yes, it's possible, because, and the context is, for example, in a near-death
experience. I'm an anesthesiologist. I work in an operating room. I put people to sleep and
wake them up. I've been doing it for 35 years. Now, we have occasionally cardiac arrests,
and patients are revived, and there have been a number of studies that show that at least 17% of
these people report that during the resuscitation, when their heart was stopped and there was no
blood flowing to the brain, they report this NDE, or near-death experience, with common features.
For example, a white light, being in a tunnel, perhaps visiting with deceased relatives,
usually a sense of calm, serenity, and in some cases, floating above their body, looking down
on the resuscitation. So, when these studies were done, the BBC did a show called The Day I Died,
and they asked the doctors who did the study, how can you explain this? And they said,
we don't know. Ask Penrose and Hameroff, because they have this crazy theory.
So, here's what I said for the BBC, and I'll stand by this, although it's been controversial.
Normally, even right now, our consciousness is happening in our brains, in the neurons,
presumably in the microtubules, but due to changes in fundamental space-time geometry,
because it's between our ears also. It's everywhere. It's happening at this most…
the continuum of the whole universe, right? Right. But normally, generally speaking,
I think it's mostly constrained between our ears because of the isolation mechanisms that
prevent decoherence, although certainly it can extend with ESP and telepathy and other things.
But when the blood stops flowing and the energy stops being delivered to the tissues, to the
neurons, to the microtubules, the quantum information embedded in Planck scale geometry,
this most basic fundamental level in the brain, can kind of leak out or dissipate to the universe
at large, but remain as one entity by quantum entanglement. Part of the matrix. Part of the
matrix, but staying together as a soul, as that person's consciousness, including their memories,
and can exist outside the body in the hologram of the universe, non-local, repeating its scale.
And then if the patient is revived, can go back inside the brain and the patient is revived and
says, I had this near-death experience. I was floating above my body. Now, if the patient
does not survive, unfortunately dies, then it's possible that this quantum entangled
information in the universe, in the matrix, can persist indefinitely and perhaps even
go back into a zygote or an embryo, in which case we have reincarnation. So I'm not saying that I
can prove that or that definitely exists, but given all the history we have and the lore that
suggests it's possible, I would say it's scientifically feasible and plausible for that to occur.
What is the explanation for the fact that a person who is no longer having brain activity
can see the room, can see the operating room, can hear sounds, can report? What would be the
explanation for that? The brain is dead. Most scientists would say that consciousness
is a high energy process that emerges from the top at a high level of complex processing,
which requires energy. However, if consciousness is actually a quantum effect, quantum requires
very little, almost no energy. Ambient heat from room temperature can drive it rather than destroy
it. So it could be that in patients who are at the end of life or whose heart has stopped and
blood stops flowing, that their outward behavior, the non-conscious processes,
the axonal firings that require energy to drive it, they cease and the patient appears dead or
moribund, but yet the quantum information can stay entangled for a longer time in the brain,
and then when finally the energy is completely gone, can leak out or dissipate to the universe
at large. It's because it's the lowest energy process. But yet there is seemingly some kind
of perception, right? It's an out-of-body perception. Yes, it's consciousness very much
like what would occur inside our body, except it's disembodied. Disembodied perception,
which would kind of fit in with the whole idea of astral bodies and astral planes and, you know,
perception in these planes, the lokas of ancient lore. The universe is a hologram. A hologram,
you know, is a three-dimensional image that's projected from two dimensions. And you record it
typically in a photographic plate. That's the old-fashioned way of doing it. And all the
information for the image in 3D is stored in this plate. And then when you re-illuminate it,
you get a three-dimensional image. But if you take the plate and smash it into a million pieces,
take one little piece of the plate and re-illuminate it, you don't get one little
piece of the image. You get the entire image. All the information is in every little location.
It's just more blurry or less focused. So it turns out that consciousness and memory in the brain
are arranged as a hologram. And even more astounding, the universe is a hologram.
We were talking about that discovery recently with gravity waves, looking at gravity waves
emanating from the Planck scale. And they found noise in these detectors, which at first they
thought were some kind of artifact. But they found that the noise, the same information pattern
repeated roughly every three orders of magnitude going up from the Planck scale up to the level of
biology. So the universe is a hologram. And this repeating noise, the scale-free dynamics scaling
up, gets to the level of the brain or to the level of biology. Now, on the other side of the coin...
So let me stop you there because this is mind-boggling. You and I are having a conversation.
We're in this place in New York City, which is part of the planet. And all this is being
orchestrated from a two-dimensional surface somewhere on the edge of the new universe
in a black hole. Well, not necessarily. I think emanating from a singularity or black hole would
be that it came from the Big Bang, perhaps. So I don't know about some other black holes.
Okay, from the Big Bang. But the other side of the coin is that neuroscientists, for example,
Marcus Rakel, has shown that if you look at the brain waves at different frequencies in the brain,
you can go from fairly slow, like roughly 10 seconds, which is roughly the order of a given
train of thought, down to hundreds of cycles per second, down even to nanoseconds. So it's
roughly every three orders of magnitude. So there's a gap between that and what we know
coming up from the universe. And that's where the microtubules step in, because they have
resonant frequencies in the kilohertz, in the megahertz. The actual microtubules vibrate in the
megahertz and also in the gigahertz, the water inside the microtubule core. So if you go from
the brain to the neuron to the microtubules, you connect it to the universe. And we're one big,
we're several steps on this hierarchical level from the Planck scale on up. So when you meditate,
and if you reach an altered state, you might go from having, say, 40 or 80 cycles,
thoughts per second, skipping to, say, 8,000, or to 800,000, or millions, and every three orders
of magnitude. And as you go down in scale, you increase frequency, you increase the intensity,
you increase the vastness, and the vividness of the information. So that could be your locus in
Vedanta, your astral planes, even, that can exist at these smaller levels scale-wise,
but vaster levels in terms of information processing. Well, you know, the word loka
in Sanskrit is related to the English word location. So location in space-time as a
projection of this space-time geometry, depending on the frequency domain in which it is manifesting.
So, you know, there's a great story in the Vedanta of Ram, the incarnation of God,
okay, and he's born into a royal family, and his father sends him to the great sage, the Rishi,
whose name is Vasishta, and as is the custom in India, the king, the incarnation of God,
bows down and touches the feet of this great sage, and the sage says, hey, stop it, you know,
what are you doing that for, you're God, and Ram says, I might be God, but I've forgotten,
so can you please tell me how to remember who I am, and so the lessons begin, and the first lesson,
or one of the first lessons is, there are infinite universes, infinite worlds, they come and go in
the vast expanse of consciousness, they're like motes of dust, dancing in a beam of light,
shining through that hole in my roof, and then he starts to explain that these lokas, or these
locations, are actually projections of this fundamental proto-consciousness, what you call
proto-consciousness, what we call pure consciousness, and that there are actually an infinity
of them, because the superposition of possibilities is infinite, literally, and therefore, I'm now
going to teach you how to travel in these different domains of consciousness, and that is
the body of the work, called Yoga Vasishta, we actually, at our place, we teach a course called
Secrets of Enlightenment, where we actually use some of these techniques to give people at least
some experience, without drugs, without anything, into experiencing these more unmanifest domains of
this consciousness, so this world that we're experiencing now, is the gross world, or you
might say, the manifest order of space-time causality in its most, you know, in its most
solid form, material state, but prior to this, and deeper to this, there are more expanded levels of
manifestation, they're relatively less material, so we have a gross body, a subtle body, and then
what they call the causal body, from where all this is happening, which would be the proto-consciousness.
Yeah, you mentioned that there were seven lokas, supposedly, and I think there, if you go
every three orders of magnitude, be about seven stages between our biological scale, and getting
down to the, near the Planck scale, so we should investigate that further. But let's, let's talk a
little bit about the heart problem, and I want to actually see if we can give people an understanding
of, of it, so here I'm holding something, and we say this is a pink, it's a rose, I think, I think so,
pink rose, and this is green, and, and all these beautiful colors, and this lovely arrangement,
what's coming from here to my eyes, the photons that are coming from here to my eyes, have no pink
in them, everything but pink, everything but pink, right, okay, and everything but green, but even so,
they are at a fundamental level, we're talking about frequencies of electromagnetic waves that
are colorless, right, otherwise we'd see something here, but you know, there's some colorless
electromagnetic frequency coming to my eyes, which is causing, through a series of processes,
an electrical current to go to my brain, where there are synaptic firings, so there's no green
from here, to here, to there, and yet I'm experiencing green, which we call a qualia,
right, a subjective experience of green, where is that green? Well, that depends on whom you ask,
most neuroscientists would say, that you say, just as you said, it's not, it's kind of an illusion
created in the brain, what I would say, is that the essential, let's take the pinkness of the rose,
the essence, the essence of that pinkness, the smell, are a particular configuration of
Planck scale geometry, at the universe, spreading out over that, the space that the rose is occupying,
and those particular patterns are reproduced in our brain, because the quantum information from
the rose entering our eyes, it's not only the photons that register in the back of the retina,
and the wavelength is determined, or the intensity is determined, but also there's
quantum information going between the inner and outer segments of the rods and cones,
through the ciliary stock, that can extract quantum information, more than what's visible even,
and that can be reproduced in our brain, so that we are capturing the fundamental essence
of the rose, by reproducing the Planck scale geometry configurations of the rose in our brains.
So every time I look at the rose, I'm recreating it?
I think, I think it's likely that the redness and the essence, the essential features of the rose,
the qualia of the rose, are being recreated in your brain, or being transmitted to your brain,
I mean, there's really no, the idea that there's a separation, is an illusion of the material world,
and in the quantum world, there's actually a connection, but sticking to the material
explanation, yeah, you could say it's being recreated in your brain, the essential qualities,
the qualia of the rose, due to the space-time geometry configurations,
are being reproduced in your brain. So you remind me of a poem by Rumi,
he says, let the waters settle, and you will see stars and moon mirrored in your being.
Yeah, I like that. We are, we are co-creating this rose with
whatever exists at that fundamental level. I think so, I think the essence of it is,
is happening in here. So this is frequently referred to as the hard problem, right?
Explain the hard problem. Well, the hard problem refers to the question of why we have experience,
why we have qualia, why we have redness, pain, joy, sorrow. It could have been that the world was,
could have, could be populated by entities that look and act like us, that have complex behavior,
but have no inner life, have no inner awareness. Zombies.
Zombies, they're called. Philosophers came up with a term called zombies, which would be somebody
who looked or acted like us, but had no inner experience. They could be an…
Couldn't fall in love.
Couldn't fall in love. They could, you know, pretend to fall in love to, to, to, to mimic
behavior. But, you know, android, in the movies, androids, robots, the kid in AI who didn't,
supposedly didn't have any actual inner feelings or consciousness. These would be zombies. So the
question is, are zombies possible? Is there something that is missing, that could be missing
from our brain in which we would still behave and outwardly look, look like we're conscious,
but not have it? And David Chalmers, the philosopher David Chalmers, Australian philosopher,
coined the term the hard problem. He said, you know, look, there's all these problems of memory,
of reportability, of perception, of behavior, of learning, and so forth, which can be non-conscious.
Now, sometimes they're conscious, but they can, they can occur non-consciously. These are very,
very difficult questions, and laboratories around the world are spending eons of time and money
trying to solve them, but they're easy compared to the question of why we have qualia, why we have
experience, what distinguishes us from a creature or, or, or an android or a robot that doesn't,
that may behave in a complex manner, but doesn't have any inner experience. So that's,
that's the hard problem, and I look at it this way. Consciousness, the hard problem depends on
the quantum aspects that we've discussed, but the other aspects of the brain can go on without it,
and for example, when I put someone to sleep in anesthesiology, in anesthesia for surgery,
let's say for spine surgery, let's say we're going to have to operate on somebody's cervical spine,
we have the neurophysiologists come in, and they, they put electrodes and, and, and record from the
brain signals from the feet and the arms to make sure that the signals are getting through the,
through to the brain, that the spine's intact, the spinal cord is intact during the surgery,
and, and yet the patient's unconscious. The patient has no consciousness whatsoever,
but we're recording evoked potentials from the brain. We're recording signals from the
periphery going through the spinal cord to the brain, and the brain is working perfectly well.
It's kind of like, that's an, that's an easy problem. It's not that easy, and people who work
in this area get insulted when they hear it's easy, because it's not, but compared to why there's
awareness, why there's experience at all, they are the easy problems, and the hard problem is why we
have qualia, why we have a sense of awareness of conscious experience. And as far as science is
concerned, so far, there's not even a theory to explain this qualia, is there? No, a lot of people
kind of trivialize the question. They say, well, it emerges at a higher order of complexity,
just like wetness emerges from water, or, or various higher order properties emerge, but that's
just a guess, and there's no evidence for that. There's no testable predictions for that. You know,
our approach, this part of it is hard to come up with testable predictions, but, but our, our
solution to the hard problem is to say that it connects to the fundamental level of the universe,
which gets into, you know, your territory of pure consciousness. So, you know, people like Richard
Dawkins, who I had a run-in with, people like Michael Shermer, who heads a society for skeptics,
who I had to debate at Caltech, listening to me, they frequently said, you misuse science
to propagate your theories, and now that I'm having a conversation with a professor,
a scientist, an anesthesiologist, who puts people to sleep and wakes them up, wakes them up
afterwards, what would you say to these guys who say you're full of it? They're, they're full of it,
and they're saying you're full of it. Well, they're full of it, that's what I'm saying,
because their, their, their solution to the hard problem is to ignore it, or to say, well, it
emerges at a higher order of complexity, don't bother me with the details, that'll come along,
or to pretend it doesn't exist. Daniel Dennett wrote a book, Consciousness Explained, where he
just kind of explained away the problem. So, their approach is to look at the brain as a computer,
and pretend the problem of consciousness that we're discussing doesn't exist whatsoever. So,
they would think of themselves as zombies? No, they would, well, you'd have to ask them, but
they would say that there's not really a, they would, they would question whether a zombie is,
is possible. They would say, if you have the machinery to do what the brain does,
then you have consciousness along with it, and that could be true, if you, that is true,
if you include the quantum properties, but they're cutting it off at the level, not only at the level
of classical versus quantum, but at the level of neurons versus going inside neurons. So, they're,
I think they're missing the boat entirely, and there's so many questions they couldn't answer,
but they won't debate me. I've, they criticize me, and I've challenged them to debate me,
and they always chicken out. So, is the universe conscious?
I would say it's proto-conscious, proto-conscious, it's kind of, it's kind of dreaming,
it has this, this pure consciousness, perhaps, built into it, but without the snapshots of
awareness, that only happens when this particular type of self-collapse or objective reduction.
So, something is dreaming up the universe? Well, you could say that.
Or could we call it God? You know, I, I, I wouldn't have a problem
with that. I, I think, you know, when you talk about God and spirituality, I think of three
things. There's, there's interconnectedness among living beings, which you can explain
through quantum entanglement. There's the ability to access and be influenced by cosmic wisdom,
if you will, divine guidance, or, or following the way of the Tao, and, you know, Penrose put
these platonic values, or proposed that these platonic values, including mathematical truth,
aesthetic and ethical values, are built into the universe, the Planck scale as patterns,
and our conscious thoughts are influenced by the, these platonic values. So, it's conceivable that
we have influence by this cosmic wisdom, if you will. And the third thing would be, you know,
afterlife, that we've talked about, the possibility that consciousness can exist after, after the body
dies, at least, at least temporarily, and perhaps be recycled in reincarnation.
So, there's cosmic wisdom, there's cosmic immortality, and there's cosmic truth,
goodness, harmony, and evolution, and that's God?
Well, we hope so.
Okay.