#finance #financial In this video, Colin Exelby, CFP® breaks down Elon Musk’s shocking claim about 20 million active Social Security numbers belonging to people over 100 years old. Is this a lie? If he is correct, it could be a huge deal for the solvency of the Social Security System. Join me and uncover whether this is a massive fraud, if there are millions of payments to 150 year old people and if there is truly a government data error.
Elon Musk just exposed what could be the biggest fraud in history—claiming that over 20 million active Social Security numbers belong to people over 100 years old, far exceeding the actual centenarian population, raising serious questions about whether this is a massive government oversight, an outdated COBOL system glitch, or something more sinister; with $72 billion in improper payments from 2015-2022, is taxpayer money being diverted to fund these potentially fraudulent accounts, and should the government invest $10M to fix the system and restore trust
In this video, I'm diving into the explosive story that is rocking the world of social
security, personal finance, and the nation at large. Elon Musk said in a post on X that
the Department of Government Efficiency, or DOGE, may have discovered the biggest fraud in history.
Potentially over 20 million social security numbers listed as active in the social security
systems who are over 100 years old. So one X user pointed out that 2023 data showed the US
population of around 334.9 million people. But Musk's post, which shows 394 million people
broken down by age who are listed as not dead, Musk responded, yes, there are far more eligible
social security numbers than there are citizens in the USA. Of course, it's possible that some
of the people live that long, but the enormous size of that number, 20 million people,
raises some red flags, or at least some yellow ones, and people across the country are in a
frenzy over this discovery. It's kind of crazy listening and seeing all of the stuff in the
media related to this story. Well, it turns out that just by doing a little bit of digging,
the Office of the Inspector General looked into this back in 2023 in a report titled
As of September 2015, social security stopped making any payments to people who are listed
as older than 115 years in the database. Looks like social security already corrected the issue.
Maybe Musk's post is out of touch. Maybe this is just a minor glitch that just needs to be patched.
Roughly 67% of American citizens rely on social security to provide over half the
retirement income. The major concern is that legitimate social security contributions from
American citizens are being used to fund these potentially fake accounts, further amplifying the
shortfall within social security and the chance that benefits are reduced by 2035.
I explain the problems about this if you want to check them out in this video. I'll provide a link
to it down in the description. So is this merely a clerical error because the COBOL software used
by the government is old and outdated and needs updating? All the retirement paperwork is manual
on paper. It's manually calculated and written down on a piece of paper. Then it goes down a
like yeah there's a limestone mine where we store all the retirement paperwork because it was
started in 1955. Or is it something more nefarious? The job of DOGE is to find fraud and waste. Do
they just uncover something huge? Well for decades we've heard about dead people receiving social
security benefits, but we've always been told it's an extremely small problem compared to the size
of the social security budget. It's often cited that the potential fraudulent payments are less
than one percent of the total payments made to social security recipients. But is that true? This
pending analysis by DOGE could unearth some massive fraud like this. As we know there's a massive
amount of fraud in this country. You have for example foreign fraud rings. These are foreign
nationals who come into the United States. They use fake social security numbers. They use fake
identities to steal billions in taxpayer benefits. There's no way to know until DOGE gains full
access exactly how much money we're talking about. But over a 10-year normal budget window you could
be talking about saving over a trillion dollars by clamping down on massive fraud in our tax and
entitlement systems. Including again those carried out by organized fraud and theft rings. So are
there bad foreign actors who've been stealing identities and receiving benefits? I bet there
are. But how many? And how large is the fraud? Is it small as previous reports suggest or is it much
larger? The concern is that taxpayer money is being used to fund these potentially fake accounts.
Some people might just say this is a conspiracy theory or a data entry error and it's definitely
possible. More on that in a moment. But in my opinion it's important to ask questions and get
answers. If there isn't any fraud the answer should be easy and we can move on. According to
the Pew Research Center 101,000 Americans are living who are over the age of 100. I'd be
interested to know how many people of the 20 million active numbers over 100 are actually
receiving payments. That is the potential for fraud according to Musk. Turns out social security has
been on top of this to some degree and we already have a lot of this data. In the recent inspectors
general report the social security administration believes that it made nearly 72 billion dollars in
improper payments from fiscal years 2015 through 2022. While this sounds like a huge amount of waste
it is less than one percent of the massive number of total benefits paid out during the period.
Social security believes it has a 99 success rate of people receiving what's deserved. It doesn't
mean that we shouldn't work harder to reduce that number even further but most private companies
would take a 99 success rate. But it's still 72 billion dollars and if we can capture that money
we should. The key question is whether that's really accurate. You know what is accurate? That you
should stay up to date by subscribing to the number one personal finance channel on YouTube.
This one, See the Forest Through the Trees. It helps the channel reach more people and you will know
whenever I release a new video. All right so is the 72 billion dollars in improper payments accurate
or is it actually more? Well part of the confusion comes from social security's software system
based on the COBOL programming language from the 1960s. This antiquated software which most younger
engineers have never even worked with has some odd protocols which were originally outlined in a 2015
report by the inspectors general. Some with knowledge of COBOL say that if you leave a date
field blank it defaults to May 20th 1875 resulting in an age of 150. Okay well that might explain some
of it but others say that that's not true and maybe social security creates its own default date
for numbers where there isn't a date of death. Either way that explains about 1.4 million incorrect
ages of the 20 million. The real question is are we paying these people with taxpayer money?
And the answer is no. As of September 2015 social security automatically stopped payments to people
who are older than 115 years old. According to Musk's tweet there are little over 12 million
numbers above the age of 120. Well that is a relief. No one above that age is receiving any
benefits. But who actually knew that until Musk shined a light on the data? I know that I didn't.
Well according to that social security administration's inspector general report in 2023
there are actually 18.4 million number holders age 100 or older who are not receiving social
security benefits and have not had any earnings reported since the 1970s. That would indicate that
they are most likely dead. It's believed they died decades ago before the use of electronic
death reporting and that is why they show up in the report. As of 2015 the social security
administration's inspector's general report stated that there were 6.5 million social security numbers
of people older than 112 without proper death information on file. Most of these people had an
entry code type L which the administration defines as a life claim filed before 1972.
According to social security these are social security numbers that were issued to people who
had never before been issued one when they filed the claim. Then the social security would verify
eligibility and submit it for processing. 48,746 number holders had the code D which the
administration defines as a death claim filed before 1972. These are created typically when
family members file death benefit claims on someone who has never issued a social security number.
Social security would then verify these claims using deceased individuals private information
like date of birth address or other identifying information to confirm the claim but they never
recorded the date of death in the system. In this report they found social security was issuing
payments to 266 number holders whose records contained a date of birth before June 16, 1901.
However in only 13 cases was it likely that the beneficiary was actually age 112 or older. The
others were errors in the birth date or failure to confirm the information. So let's dive a little
deeper. The 2023 update report stated that the social security administration had added death
information to the records of approximately 1.5 million of that 6.5 million number holders
age 112 or older from the 2015 report. Well that's a good start to cleaning up the data but there is
a long way to go. For tax years 2016 through 2020 the administration received reports that
individuals using 66,920 social security numbers had approximately 8.5 billion dollars in wages
tips and self-employment income using 139,211 social security numbers assigned to people age 100
or older. In fact one social security number appeared on 405 different suspended wage reports
and 210 numbers appeared at least 50 times on wage reports received during the five-year period.
These are the waste and fraud numbers that we should be focused on but these numbers are far
far less than what was initially reported by Elon Musk and Doge. Now the recommendations from
the report to the social security administration were four items and these four recommendations
were made in 2015 to clean up the system. Two were accepted and two were not. Number one add death
information to that 48,746 death claim records that did not already contain a death entry.
Number two record dates of death to the records of 1.4 million non-beneficiary number holders.
Number three determine whether it can efficiently correct the approximately 5 million remaining
records identified by the audit. And number four review and take appropriate action to resolve
discrepancies in 219 cases where multiple individuals appeared on the same record.
Beneficiaries payment records reference the wrong number or date of birth discrepancies existed
between the beneficiaries payment and social security records. The administration agreed to
process three and four which are the easier items. The report was disappointed in not attempting to
fix one and two. The response was that no claims are being paid out to those people so it's basically
a waste of time. However what is not appreciated is that federal benefit paying entities, the
department of homeland security, the IRS, state and local government entities, and private corporations
who rely on the accuracy and completeness of the social security's death information
to detect unreported deaths and prevent fraud, they're not concerned with the deceased individual's
social security benefit status. Even though these identities are not being used to receive social
security benefits, they can surely be used to commit other fraud such as filing for benefits
from other federal agencies or states, opening bank accounts, credit cards, applying for loans, or even
jobs. Because death information is not filed in the database, none of these institutions will be
able to detect this fraud and this is really important. The 2023 report recommended that they
use the death information already in its records to input death information on 2.5 million number
holders records and they should use information on the deaths of people from the centers for
medicare and medicaid services and various state death data files to input death information on
approximately 498,000 records and they should develop a methodology to annotate death information
onto the records of the approximately 15.8 million remaining non-current payment status beneficiary
number holders that were identified by the audit. Well the social security administration, they
disagreed. They basically said that they are doing a much better job now of inputting the death
record data. There would be a significant risk of inputting incorrect death information and they
would have limited to no benefit to the administration and it would be costly to implement.
They suggested that other institutions relying on their data should just kind of do a better job.
Well the inspector general's report doesn't agree and neither do I. They don't believe there'd be a
significant risk to inputting death data onto these records. You're talking about millions of records of
people born in the 1800s who haven't worked or received benefits in over 50 years. This should be
easy. The administration estimates that it would cost five to ten million dollars to fix the errors
and that was too costly but these are valid social security numbers and not closing them out with a
The report references a man who opened several bank accounts using social security numbers
belonging to people born in the 1800s with no death information on file. Identity thieves are
getting smarter and smarter and can use this data to obtain loans, government benefits, or even
insurance. Why wouldn't we want to close this obviously open loophole for potential fraud?
The fact that Elon Musk has shined a light on the errors and the inaccuracies and the system
inefficiencies, it could really be beneficial in the long run. Now we can debate on how it was
initially brought up without any context and it shocked a lot of people but sometimes people need
to be shocked in order to wake up and understand the issues and get them fixed. Why couldn't we
just use some of the savings that Doge has uncovered in other departments like USAID
and fix the data in the social security reporting systems? If it only costs five to ten million
dollars to fix the potential problem and there were over 72 billion dollars of improper payments,
that seems like an incredible ROI for the government. So what does this mean for you?
Well depending upon how many fraudulent social security accounts there actually are,
and at this point the number does appear to be small, they could drain additional funds from a
Let's close that possibility by getting accurate data.
Second, leaving these social security numbers active could lead to increased identity theft
and fraud at other organizations and companies. The potential to create false identities in the
age of AI seems very real. There are already fake AI Instagram influencers and fake social media
AI impersonations of political figures. It won't be too long before AI can easily be used to create
fake identities. Why not close this loophole now before it really takes hold? And third and most
importantly, leaving these almost 20 million social security numbers with inaccurate data
just erodes public trust in one of the most vital government programs. When people lose faith in the
That's why so many people I talk to immediately say that they're going to take their benefits
as soon as possible because they're afraid they're not going to be there. It seems like there is
waste and fraud here, but it's probably roughly only one percent of total payments. But that's
still a large sum of money at around 72 billion dollars. Let's shine a light here and invest a
little bit of money to modernize the data reconciliation and fix the loophole. The ROI
and the investment is huge in my opinion because it would help increase trust in the government
while saving money at the same time. Social security is a very important program and it's
vital that it's protected from fraud. I hope this video will help to raise awareness of the issue
and that will lead to increased trust in the system. Man, that was a lot and there's been a
lot going on this past week regarding social security, Musk, the Trump administration and
what's going to happen. And it's going to be interesting to see what does happen next. Let
me know what you think down in the comments. Will the data get fixed in the next four years?
And do you own a business? Are you thinking about your financial planning? Then head over to
celestialwm.com. Click on the start here button and learn more about how to set up an appointment
with me. And if you're learning about your social security options, make sure you check
out my entire series on social security right here.