The Investing Secret That Created A Billionaire

Coin Crunch
8 followers
24 Video Views·Oct 17, 2025
The Investing Secret That Created A Billionaire
Warren Buffett's net worth skyrocketed
from a few million to over a billion
after he drastically changed his investing strategy,
a strategy he learned from an investor
that most people have never even heard of.
In the early 60s, Warren Buffett took a flight
to San Francisco and met that very investor.
His name was Philip Arthur Fisher.
I met Phil Fisher just once, and it was great.
I enjoyed it, I loved it.
They were such good writers,
and their thoughts were so clear.
It's proved to be an obviously good idea,
yet 98% of the investing world doesn't follow it.
Phil Fisher has one of the greatest
investing track records of all time,
and his teachings reached Buffett
at exactly the moment he needed them,
principles that guided investments in American Express
and The Washington Post,
and, well, practically every stock pick since then.
The stories from this part of Buffett's career
are fascinating,
and they're sprinkled with investing lessons
for those trying to find success in the stock market.
Plus, I'm going to show you some tools
that make it easier than ever
to apply them in your own portfolio.
This video was made in partnership with Stockopedia.
More on them later in the video.
The shift in Warren Buffett's stock picking strategy
wasn't really a choice, but rather came out of necessity.
Ben Graham's cigar butt strategy
had made Buffett a millionaire by age 30.
However, it didn't scale very well
and was undermining his reputation.
Graham's approach was simple.
Buy businesses so cheap,
you're effectively paying less than the cash,
inventory, or liquidation value on the balance sheet.
Graham called them net nets
in his book, The Intelligent Investor,
but Buffett likened them to cigar butts
you find on the sidewalk.
You get one free puff and then move on to the next stock.
Do this over and over again,
and you'll make a tidy profit.
Early on, Buffett would scour all corners of the market
to find these tiny companies being ignored by Wall Street.
Today, you could pull up every stock in the world
that fits the formula in about two seconds on Stockopedia,
but back in the 1950s, this meant going one by one
using a physical Moody's manual.
In 1950, at the age of 20,
he invested in the Commonwealth Trust Company.
The bank had $125 per share in assets,
but was trading for just $50 per share.
Less than a year later, he sold the stock for a 50% gain.
But as Buffett's wealth grew,
these cigar butt puffs weren't big enough.
He needed to invest bigger amounts of money
without buying so much of the company
that he would cause the price to move.
So to make the strategy work,
he sometimes had to take control of the company.
That's where the reputational problems started to creep in.
In the late 50s, Buffett's investment partnership
took control of Dempster Mill Manufacturing Company.
To prevent its bankruptcy and make a profit,
he swapped out the manager and cut costs aggressively
by laying off around 100 employees.
From his perspective, he had just saved a dying company,
but the townspeople of Beatrice saw him as a ruthless owner
who just came in and gutted it.
But there's another disastrous cigar butt investment
that became the foundation for an entirely new strategy.
Berkshire Hathaway.
We know it today as Buffett's empire
of American companies and stocks.
But in the early 1960s,
it was just a struggling textile business.
With some historical data shared by Stockopedia,
we can see that while Berkshire was profitable in 1960,
they began bleeding cash and it was only getting worse.
Buffett didn't care about this.
The value he saw was in the assets.
The cash, inventories, the land, buildings and mills
were worth about $19 per share
after paying the company's debts.
And yet the stock price was just $7.50.
So the Buffett partnership bought about 5% of the shares
between 1962 and 1964.
His idea was that Berkshire would buy back his shares
for a profit as they shut down and liquidated plants.
Berkshire's CEO initially agreed to pay $11.50 per share.
But when the tender offer came in, it was slightly less.
A trivial difference, but Buffett felt disrespected.
So instead of selling, he bought every share he could
until he owned a controlling interest.
The good news was that he'd paid slightly less
than the per share value of the company's net assets.
The bad news, however, was he now had his capital
trapped inside a dying business.
To make matters worse, the stock market was booming.
So the cigar, but ultra cheap stock opportunities
were drying up.
Fortunately, two very important things
happened around this time.
Firstly, back in 1959, he met Charlie Munger.
The man Buffett credits for pushing him away
from cheap garbage stocks
and towards a completely new strategy
and who would join Buffett at Berkshire
two decades later in 1978.
But secondly, he came across a book called
Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits
by a man named Philip A. Fisher.
Well, actually it was fellow investor Bill Ruan
who introduced him to the book in the late 50s.
It detailed Phil Fisher's investing approach,
including his now famous scuttlebutt method
for identifying stocks with enormous growth potential
in front of them.
The approach was markedly different
from the strict value focus Buffett had been used to,
but the teachings were crystal clear and made perfect sense.
He delved deeper into Fisher's history.
He'd attended Stanford Business School,
including a field study course
that involved visiting local companies.
Fisher drove his professor every day
to get extra one-on-one time to talk business.
Phil would later recall that the mentoring
and the real life experiences
ultimately planted the seeds for his strategy.
His Wall Street career had started just a year
before the 1929 stock market crash
and he vowed to avoid the mistakes
that many people had made.
Three years into the Great Depression,
he started Fisher & Co,
where he advised the general public
on a concentrated basket of growth stocks he had analyzed
After a three-year hiatus to serve in World War II,
he resumed providing investment advice,
now focusing on just a handful of clients.
By scaling back to less than 15 clients,
he was able to use performance-based fee contracts.
His clients stayed with him for years
because his method was delivering them huge profits.
Then in 1958, after beating the market for years,
he wrote the first of four investing books.
The book laid out a 15-point criteria for picking stocks.
Each characteristic can be partially assessed
through the company's financial statements,
but the true picture would come
from interviewing suppliers and customers,
talking with management or even ex-employees
and its competitors.
For example, 0.7 on the checklist
is outstanding labor and personnel relations.
Fisher had found that great companies
often had low turnover and a motivated workforce.
So he favors companies that offered fair compensation,
advancement opportunities, and a culture of loyalty.
To assess this point,
you could compare compensation between similar businesses,
but you would learn far more
by talking directly with employees.
Companies love to boast
their superior workplace cultures in marketing materials,
but what is it actually like in practice?
Fisher called this investigative groundwork
the scuttlebutt method.
A scuttlebutt was a water tank on sailing ships,
so basically the equivalent of the water cooler in an office,
the place to hear gossip
about the true nature of the business.
This method was one that Fisher used
throughout his entire career.
There was a company called Food Machinery,
whose stock price fell from $21.50 in 1929
to just $4 by 1932.
It was a pretty small company at the time,
doing about 5 million in sales a year,
which is about 100 million in today's dollars.
Despite the pessimism from Wall Street,
it met many of his 15 key points.
It had sizable market potential
with the demand for canned food
likely to surge when the Great Depression ended.
It was developing new products
by diversifying into chemicals,
and it had top-notch management and engineers,
which Fisher was able to test
by meeting with the company's leadership,
particularly John D. Crummey,
who was the president and the founder's son-in-law.
Fisher concluded that the firm's intrinsic value
far exceeded its current modest earnings,
and so he invested.
Just two years later, in 1935,
the stock was trading at $30 a share.
Another two years later, it was up to $50 a share.
90 years later, the company does $4 billion a year in sales,
almost 1,000 times more than when Fisher was buying.
Buffett visited Fisher at his office
in San Mateo, California.
I met Phil Fisher just once, and it was great.
I enjoyed it, I loved it.
He was nice to me.
But because Fisher was such a good writer,
everything he learned was straight out of his literature,
and in 1963, Buffett first began applying this new strategy
in a big way.
That year, American Express saw its stock price
fall almost 50% because of the salad oil scandal.
If a bank wanted to lend money to a small business,
American Express would go out to the business's warehouses
and verify how much inventory they had.
That inventory would then be the collateral
against the loan in case the business failed.
Well, in the early 60s, a guy named Anthony DeAngelis
lied about how much oil he had in warehouse tanks
in order to get loans.
He filled the tanks with water instead of oil,
and the Amex auditors didn't pick up on this.
When the fraud was exposed, American Express
was on the hook for about $60 million,
which is about $600 million in today's dollars.
Buffett saw an opportunity to invest in a great company
that was simply suffering from a one-time disaster.
He used the scuttlebutt method to see if the general public
had lost trust in the Amex brand.
To quote Fortune, Buffett concluded that while Wall Street
had punished Amex by battering the stock price,
Amex's reputation hadn't been tarnished on Main Street.
Buffett bought 5% of the company for about $20 million
and later built a 22% ownership stake
that's worth $50 billion today.
In 1966, Buffett invested $4 million
into The Walt Disney Company.
Before investing, he went to meet
with Walt Disney himself in person.
Another clear case of Buffett using Phil Fisher's principles,
only this time he made a mistake.
Buffett sold the investment for just a modest profit.
If he'd held onto that investment
like he did with American Express,
he would have turned $4 million into about 10 billion.
Even by the late 60s, Buffett's head was still primarily
in cigar butt deep value mode.
There's a quote from him in a 1969 Forbes piece
where he says, I'm about 15% Phil Fisher
and 85% Benjamin Graham.
He'd always keep some of Ben Graham's principles
like margin of safety, but as time went on,
Buffett lent more and more into Fisher's ideas.
That same year, Buffett dissolved the investment partnership
and rolled his personal wealth into Berkshire Hathaway.
The textile business was failing,
but he could use it as an investment vehicle.
In 1972, Berkshire acquired See's Candy
for about $25 million.
Its confectionery brands are so strong
that they've been able to raise prices for decades.
Another key principle of Fisher's,
look for pricing power.
The next year, Buffett set his eyes on the Washington Post.
The newspaper company had gone public in 1971 at $26 a share,
but starting in 1973, the stock market collapsed nearly 50%.
Interest rates were high, there was an OPEC oil embargo,
and of course, the Nixon Watergate scandal.
The Washington Post stock fell to about $20 by mid 1973,
despite the business remaining fundamentally sound.
Again, thanks to Stockopedia,
we can see that the Washington Post's profit margins
remained fairly stable, and so did the return on equity,
never dipping below 10%.
Buffett invested $10 million at a share price of about $20
at a time where he believed the stock
was worth at least $100 per share.
A decade later in 1985,
his stake was worth more than $200 million.
Buffett was now executing the best
of both Benjamin Graham and Phil Fisher's principles,
quality merchandise when it's marked down.
Now we get to the fun stuff.
How can we adopt some of these principles
in our own investment portfolios?
Well, thanks to the internet, it's relatively easy.
There's a ton of different stock screeners out there,
but the only one I use these days comes from Stockopedia,
and this is why.
I go to the Browse tab, pick an investing style,
and I can see the different stock screeners
based on the investing criteria of successful investors.
One of them, of course, is Phil Fisher,
and within a few seconds,
I've filtered more than 60,000 stocks
down to a few hundred that fit his investing style.
The American stocks in this particular basket
have returned about 230% in the past five years,
compared to about 90% from the index.
If I want to use this screener as a starting point,
I can copy it and add some of my own filters,
or just create one from scratch.
You can have a quick sneak peek
at the ultra conservative screener
that I use from time to time.
Each company has a Stockopedia stock rank
of quality, value, and momentum
that stems from the principles used by investment legends
like Buffett and Fisher,
and is grounded in decades of academic research.
A lot of the quantitative analysis from Fisher's checklist
can be done in Stockopedia too.
Profit margins, return on capital,
and valuation, for example.
And this forms the springboard
for you to do further qualitative analysis
per Fisher's Scuttlebutt method.
Reading reviews from customers and employees,
watching interviews from the company's leadership.
Even these Scuttlebutt strategies
can be done online nowadays.
I've really only just scratched the surface in this video,
but the team at Stockopedia has put together a free resource
that outlines Warren Buffett's investing blueprint
that combines the best of Benjamin Graham,
Charlie Munger, and Phil Fisher,
as well as 20 examples of high quality companies
that exemplify Buffett's principles today.
The link to this free resource
is down in the description below,
and there's also an exclusive offer
if you're interested in checking out Stockopedia,
including a 14-day free trial,
so you've got nothing to lose giving it a try.
Thanks for watching.
