Medieval Chinese Arming Sword? The LK Chen Grand Marshal Jian Review

Rune Slicer
2 followers
1 Video View·Feb 22, 2025
Looking at the Ming Dynasty jian, here replicated in the form of the Grand Marshal by LK Chen
So what kind of swords did generals carry in medieval China? Well, let's have a look.
Hi folks, Matt Easton here, scholar gladiatorial. So what we've got here is the LK Chen Grand
Marshal Jian from the Ming dynasty. So it's modelled one to one on a surviving original Ming
dynasty sword of a type carried by generals and marshals, high-ranking officers essentially in
the Chinese military between the mid 14th century and all the way through to about the 17th century
actually. But this is fundamentally, by European standards anyway, a medieval sword. So often on
this channel we're looking at things like long swords and arming swords and Langmesser and
Faustians. This is the type of sword carried by, shall we call them high status individuals,
at the time of those swords in medieval Europe. Now one of the first things you'll notice is the
distinctive style of hilt which you may in fact recognise from more recent designs of Jian which
have a guard somewhat like that and a pommel somewhat like that. The grip lengths vary and
the details of the decoration may vary but fundamentally this style of guard and this
style of pommel are modelled after a certain type of mushroom and a certain type of gourd.
And now the mushroom, please forgive my Chinese pronunciation, but I think it's lingchi,
something like that, and the gourd we refer to. Now indeed sometimes, first of all the mushroom,
fungi, was believed to give certain kind of health benefits and still is in fact in Chinese medicine
and the gourd was sometimes used to contain artefacts and things in Taoist religion
that were supposed to bring good luck essentially. And we still see this to some degree in the modern
world as well and some belief systems still use amulets and stuff like that so it's very much part
of that kind of context. So to Western eyes often the shape of these pommels and guards look a
little bit odd but actually they became extremely, I won't say universal, but very very common
and carried on for centuries. Now this type of sword is different from the type of
Dao that was carried by a lot of troops at the time. Now this is in fact a later,
this is a 19th century style of Dao but it will give you the general idea. So there were various
types of single-edged, sometimes curved, sometimes straight, quite Falchion-like or Messer-like
swords that were carried by lots of soldiers including officers in this period in the Ming
dynasty. So by Western standards as I say what would be the medieval period so the 14th, 15th
centuries into the 16th century. However it does appear that the jian was carried by high-ranking
civilians, nobles, but additionally it was carried by those same people when they were operating in
military capacity. So if they were a general, field marshal equivalent, whatever. As is shown
in lots of art of the period, both paintings and statues and things like this, they often wore
these types of straight double-edged jian. Now you can see that the LK Chen version of the sword
here, which as I've mentioned is a one-to-one replica of an original surviving example,
has a wooden grip and scabbard, very very nice wood. You can find all of the details incidentally
linked below to their website where you can find there's different steel options for the blades,
we'll talk about the blade in a second, but it describes some degree of the manufacturer and the
materials that have gone into this. But it's very closely based on the original so you'll notice
that there are several brass or copper alloy fittings along the scabbard. The wooden scabbard
is a self-sustaining object in its own right but the metal fittings both add to the wearing of the
sword so it would attach to slings down here like that and held at that kind of angle usually,
slightly above horizontal. But additionally they also strengthen the scabbard so obviously the
shape at the end stops it getting damaged from being bashed against things or split or anything
like that. Equally if you're standing on the ground it prevents damp from penetrating the end
of the scabbard and then these fittings along here which are not dissimilar it has to be said
to the Japanese tachi mountings, assist in holding the two halves of the wooden scabbard together
and if it does split or whatever it keeps it together and keeps it as a functional scabbard.
Now let's dispense with the scabbard, just before I do I just want to mention that the scabbard does
fit into the guard so you'll notice that when that guard seats around the top of the scabbard it is
watertight at least from rain, maybe not if you actually submerge it but from an upwards angle
there is no real practical way that rain and moisture can enter into that scabbard because
the top of the guard actually seats like a cup fully around the scabbard and the scabbard goes
in there so you've kind of got a guard and a rain guard all built into one which is quite a nice
unit. Now let's have a little look at the blade and here we go so it's a rather attractive blade
straight double edged and you'll notice that it doesn't have an awful lot of taper to it,
the edges are almost parallel in fact it has a very slight amount of taper, let's just put the
scabbard down here for a second and it has some degree of distal taper in fact quite notable
it's really quite a thick blade very very thick up here it might look like it's going to be a
particularly light sword but it's not especially light and we'll talk about the stats in a second
it's very very thick to about there and then it slims down here and doesn't ever get really super
thin towards the point so it is a relatively, again I'm being careful with this because it
is sharp, it is a relatively thick and rigid blade strong blade and you'll notice that when
I flex it due to the distal taper it stays pretty much totally straight to about there
it starts to flex here and then most of the flex is in the last third of the blade there we go but
I can tell you if we smack the pommel there you can see it does have some degree of vibration
it's got a vibrational node around there near to the center of percussion and it is nevertheless a
rigid blade it's not hugely wide but it is quite thick and you can just feel the way it tracks in
the air it has authority to it it moves very nicely and it's nimble but equally you can tell
that once it's moving it's got a good amount of inertia in it and bear in mind this is a type of
that was used on the battlefield as a battlefield sword some people see the
jian as a civilian sword in this area but actually it was carried by high-ranking
generals now were they expected to fight well probably often not but nevertheless
I have no doubt that this could function on the battlefield as a fully um you know as a fully
robust and respectable weapon on the battlefield yes you can use it against halberds and spears
that were used at the time yes you can use it against a dhow for example and this blade is
thicker than most dhow are and weighs about the same so it has a different format it might not cut
as well as a dhow um but it has some other advantages now one of the things you'll be
wondering I'm almost certain most of you who watch this channel at this point will be like
Matt what happened to the point um now this is one of the interesting things if we look at Ming
dynasty um so by medieval by European standards kind of medieval era um jian some of them don't
have points some of them are rounded like this now I won't say it's blunt uh it's rounded now
we do find parallels to this actually if we go back into uh certain iron age swords and in fact
if we look at the Viking era I won't say that Viking era swords are fully rounded quite like
this but some of them are are almost blunt on or blunt from that point of view but I should point
out that this edge essentially can continue around the tip so I wouldn't really want to be stabbed
by that per se certainly not out of um armor or out of protective clothing um so whilst that is
from your point of view a rounded tip it's still quite a thin edged object now the question is
ah and I should also mention many of these are pointed and do have points in the end now
I can't unfortunately give you the answer of why were some rounded and why were some pointed
we just don't know and I have spoken to the people at LK Chen about this and they have sent me
lots of pictorial examples of originals where some are rounded and some are pointed um we just
don't know why now I do find it interesting I mean it's very interesting why were they rounded
instead of pointed but then you've also got to ask well if there was some reason to have them
rounded why were some of them pointed now this is a point at which you can uh throw in your
your hats into the ring what what do you think do you have any theories about this as far as
I'm aware there is no written source material from Chinese history explaining why that might
be the case um equally there's nothing from Chinese martial arts I don't believe that explain I mean
there might be some theories but I don't know that there's anything that really fixed explains why
that might be the case from a purely mechanical point of view um I could think that perhaps if
you're cutting at the with the real tip and you're really focusing on using this as a cutting
weapon rather than a thrusting weapon then a rounded tip as we've seen with things like falchions
and indeed viking era swords a rounder fatter tip means you can cut with the very tip of the weapon
which means that you can hit from further away that being said it comes at quite a great cost
of course because when you come to thrust there there is a as you can see I can push that into
my hand and it does start to hurt a bit but the simple fact is that if if anyone's wearing
anything like lamellar padded armor silk even aside from things like a mail or anything like
that but if they're wearing even any degree of layers there's a good chance that that point won't
penetrate through there um so why why would you rob yourself of the point I don't know the answer
to that but some of these were pointed and indeed if you like this sword and you wanted it to be
pointed you could quite easily in I would imagine an hour or two with um a file turn that into a
pointed blade um now the blade itself is very nicely edged it has a single bevel um no secondary
bevel and that of course is correct for a lot of historical swords from around the world so there
is no there's not even a micro bevel as far as I can see it is absolutely just a single bevel to
the edge in terms of the um hilt I find these quite interesting now from again from a western
point of view you might look at a long hilt and think well was this occasionally used two-handed
now I have to be honest and say I don't know um I think it's entirely possible that occasionally
these were used two-handed however predominantly as far as all the art is concerned and the martial
arts the treatises that survive and so on so forth and the systems that survive um these do
seem to have been predominantly one-handed swords now they are not completely unique in having a
longer grip than you need on a one-handed sword because we can find comparisons with the Langmesser
you can find comparison with the Burmese Da, the katana when it's used one-handed and indeed
the Wakasashi sometimes although Wakasashi grips vary in length so there are plenty of other you
know the the Krabby for example from Thailand there are other comparisons for swords that have
a longer grip than you need for a one-handed sword why might that be well balance is one
obvious main reason so by having that extension at the back end here and bear in mind this pommel
is not solid this is hollow so we've got a hollow pommel and you've got a hollow guard
that's not an especially heavy pommel and so having this extension of the back means that
you have a really nice sort of balance and heft to the to the weapon and you can move it very
nimbly around additionally and this is I think a less important part if we look at for example
European or German specifically Langmesser sources when you have an extension of grip
out the back if you're coming in close you can indeed use this for hooking actions so if you've
grabbed someone's wrist for example you can hook the blade out of the person's hand or you can
hook over their arm in order to do grappling actions additionally if you're using shields
and bear in mind that shields were definitely used in China at this time quite extensively
but if shields are in the equation then having this extension on the back if you're trying to
get around someone's shield then you can hook the top of your sorry the bottom of your hilt
over the top of their shield to open them up in order to get over the top of the shield and get
in at them so absolutely there are lots of things you can do with this extension at the back of the
sword now you'll also notice that coming back to the heft and the balance one of the things is that
this sword really moves all around really really nicely now I have practiced kung fu for a couple
of years of my life but I never did weapons I only did unarmed stuff so I have no authority
on the use of Chinese swords certainly not from the Ming dynasty however there are better channels
for that like the scholar general for example shout out there but my impression is this is a
which despite it's it's not a lightweight sword it is it moves it feels lighter than it is it
moves incredibly well but once it is moving it feels like it has a lot of momentum to it
it feels like it's going to hit with authority does not particularly feel like a civilian dueling sword
it does feel like a battle sword now in terms of the stats on this particular sword
it weighs just over 1100 grams I've just weighed it and the blade should be as far as I recall
around 29 inches yes 29 and a half inches which is 74 and a half centimeters for those of you who
want metric so it's not a particularly long sword it's not a particularly short sword it's a quite
very very comparable actually to medieval arming swords of a similar period and some of you might
say well Matt fundamentally is this like a Chinese arming sword it kind of is yes but the big
difference is you have to remember that in China during the Ming dynasty the standard sword of most
soldiers was a dao of various types and these straight jian by this point were really only
carried by very high ranking people and indeed by court officials as well so it was really the
the noble sword of this period whereas arming swords in Europe of course were carried by
everyone obviously of different qualities and and decoration and stuff like this but
there is a big difference in China compared to Europe at this time we also have to remember of
course that in the Ming dynasty there was quite a lot of quite famously conflict between China
and various other people around including the Mongols or Tatars as they were sometimes known
in Europe and who were using forms of dao predominantly they weren't using straight
swords like this and equally if we look at Japan for example that were doing quite a lot of
sea-bound competitiveness piracy essentially at this time this is a completely different sword
to anything really being used in Japan at that time the Japanese by this point were
using the tachi and then transitioning through the uchi katana into the what we now know as the
katana but this is a completely different sword to that but you might say oh but Matt they they
used to have a sword like that in Japan that's very very true they did have types of jian
and they are not hugely different to this so if you see sometimes there are temple swords in Japan
and they do look a bit like this Ming dynasty jian but what they actually are is an earlier
version there was an earlier you know 9th 10th century type of jian which indeed was used in
Japan and that was the Chinese jian of that period this is a later descendant this is the
14th to 16th century 14th to 17th century descendant of that type of jian and it's not
functionally hugely different it is pretty much the same and there were types of jian being produced
and used all the way through to the 20th I was going to say the 19th but in fact the 20th century
and indeed for anyone who practices tai chi you will notice some similarity between what you
perceive to be a tai chi sword which is a form of jian and this indeed but I should reiterate
that this is a different beast in the hand to some of those jian some of those jian which are
really civilian dueling weapons and weapons of the nobility of scholars and such like
this is this feels more like a medieval arming sword with a long grip basically it is a substantial
and big sword 1100 grams so it's not crazy heavy my rapier for example is 1300 grams
but this is comparable to lot in mass alone to lots of medieval arming swords or indeed sort
of viking era swords as well so it is in my view a battlefield weapon but we still have to wonder
the tip what is that about why did they have rounded tips some of the time why did they have
pointed blades some of the time a very interesting thing now I'm very briefly
going to do a little bit of cutting with this and then we'll assess how it stands up
so I just got back in from testing this sword and I have to say I really like this and I'm
obviously familiar with the Ming Dynasty jian look and I'd seen these swords for many years
I've never owned one before and never a replica of one and I have to say that I didn't think they
were the most appealing swords in the world to me but actually owning one it's quite different
in the hand to how you expect it to be it's it's quite a beefy business-like weapon it feels it
feels very serious it feels very like an arming sword actually even if it doesn't particularly
look like one and I think for a lot of people particularly coming from a sort of medieval
point of view or a western point of view probably find these pommels and these guards somewhat odd
looking but once you get used to them I found they kind of grow on me and I particularly like
the details of the grip construction the way that you've got these sections big metal enclosed
sections at top and bottom holding everything in together and even the fitting of this for the
lanyard knot sword knot through the middle there which I didn't attach a sword knot to actually
because one didn't come with it so I just I just left it off but and you've got a secondary one up
here now I don't incidentally I don't know why there are two particular holes there perhaps
someone can chime in if you know why there are why there are two holes rather than one I don't know
I would imagine in terms of the construction that this is a hollow pin that goes through the tang
section incidentally but the the hilt construction method is is not evident from the outside but in
terms of how this performed really well this sword cuts really really nicely so it's got a
single bevel edge as mentioned which means it glides through the through the bottles it's not
super sharp you could certainly make the sharper it's what LK Chen calls sword sharp now I'm not
squeezing tightly and rubbing my hand along but I can as you see I can run my fingers along the
edge and not get cut but it feels fine so what this is is a very thin edge if not a particularly
bitey edge but it glides through water bottles and you know what it cut wood pretty well as
well now that hitting the wood is not really to test what the weapon does to the wood it's to
test what the wood does to the weapon and it's to test a couple of things first of all the blade
strength including the tang of course but also the hilt construction and I can tell you that nothing
has come loose or you know there's no movement in the guard there's nothing creaking rattling
anything like that so it's all still solid and tight as when I began there is absolutely no
damage to the edge that I can see although I do see some very fine little scratches where
probably where I was hitting the wood so I can see where I was hitting it but that would polish
out now I should also mention that these blades come in three different options LK Chen offer and
I'm not certain which one I've got so if you want to buy one of these feel free to message them and
ask which one I got if you want the same one but they do some different san mai and also essentially
pattern welded steel options different types of steel now I can see there's a very faint
pattern in this steel which suggests it's not a simple mono steel to me
sort of a crystalline type structure in the surface in the in the polish but it's beautiful
it's all just as straight as it started off looking up the bevels there is minimal rippling
it's very very smooth very flat the mid-rib is dead straight arrow straight very nicely done
so overall I'm a big fan of this sword as a user the only very slight thing when swinging it around
and hitting things that I found was that my hand does have a tendency to slide down this grip
it's one of the issues with having grips that are longer than they need to be to fit your hand in
so that is one thing to just mention the only thing I would say though is having that extra
long grip gives you a lot of versatility for how you gripped the sword you could absolutely
slide down to the pommel end like with a Viking era sword and hold it at the bottom and swing
if you wanted some extra reach equally if you really wanted to for whatever reason you could
put your thumb up the back maybe to get the point on line more easily or to do a snap cut
but it cuts great it seems to be super strong super durable it didn't come into any issues
whatsoever in the blade or the hilt encountering bottles or wood and so I can highly recommend
based on my testing so far I can highly recommend the Grand Marshal sword from LK Chen and hopefully
if you weren't familiar with these already this might open up another avenue of reading and
research for you Ming dynasty Chinese swords fascinating things used against numerous
different opponents in this period and contemporaries of the medieval arming sword and long sword
I hope this has been interesting for you thanks a lot for watching check out the links below to
LK Chen's website and see all of the other fantastic swords they've got on offer
and I will see you back on the channel really soon cheers folks
