►國務卿狠打臉左派記者, 捍衛萬斯慕尼黑演講◄

跟嚕嚕貓學英文 Learn English With LuLu Cat (正版嚕嚕貓)
1.7K followers
2.3K Video Views·Feb 18, 2025
All right, did you see this yesterday?
Secretary of State Marco Rubio came to J.D. Vance's defense
after a CBS host criticized his speech in Munich
and made this comparison to Nazi Germany.
I wanna ask you about what happened in Munich, Germany
at the security conference.
Vice President Vance gave a speech
and he told U.S. allies that the threat
he worries about the most is not Russia.
It is not China.
He called it the threat from within
and he lectured about what he described as censorship,
mainly focusing, though,
on including more views from the right.
He also met with the leader of a far-right party
known as the AFD, which, as you know,
is under investigation and monitoring
by German intelligence because of extremism.
What did all of this accomplish
other than irritating our allies?
Well, why would our allies or anybody be irritated
by free speech and by someone giving their opinion?
We are, after all, democracies.
The Munich Security Conference
is largely a conference of democracies
in which one of the things that we cherish and value
is the ability to speak freely and provide your opinions.
And so I think if anyone's angry about his word,
they don't have to agree with him,
but to be angry about it, I think, actually makes his point.
I thought it was actually a pretty historic speech,
whether you agree with him or not.
I think the valid points he's making to Europe
is we are concerned that the true values that we share,
the values that bind us together with Europe,
are things like free speech and democracy
and our shared history in winning two world wars
and defeating Soviet communism and the like.
These are the values that we shared in common.
And in that Cold War, we fought against things
like censorship and oppression and so forth.
And when you see backsliding and you raise that,
that's a very valid concern.
We can't tell them how to run their countries.
He simply expressed in a speech his view of it,
which a lot of people, frankly, share.
And I thought he said a lot of things in that speech
that needed to be said.
And honestly, I don't know why anybody
would be upset about it.
People are a lot, you know,
you don't have to agree with someone's speech.
I happen to agree with a lot of what he said,
but you don't have to agree with someone's speech
to at least appreciate the fact they have a right to say it
and that you should listen to it
and see whether those criticisms are valid.
I assure you, the United States
has come under withering criticism on many occasions
from many leaders in Europe,
and we don't go around throwing temper tantrums about it.
Well, he was standing in a country
where free speech was weaponized to conduct a genocide.
And he met with the head of a political party
that has far-right views
and some historic ties to extreme groups.
The context of that was changing the tone of it.
And you know that, that the censorship
was specifically about the right.
No, I have to disagree with you.
Free speech was not used to conduct a genocide.
The genocide was conducted by an authoritarian Nazi regime
that happened to also be genocidal
because they hated Jews and they hated minorities
and they hated those that they had a list of people
they hated, but primarily the Jews.
There was no free speech in Nazi Germany.
There was none.
There was also no opposition in Nazi Germany.
They were a sole and only party that governed that country.
So that's not an accurate reflection of history.
I also think it's wrong.
Again, I go back to the point of his speech.
The point of his speech was basically
that there is an erosion in free speech
and intolerance for opposing points of view within Europe.
And that's of concern because that is eroding.
That's not an erosion of your military capabilities.
That's not an erosion of your economic standing.
That's an erosion of the actual values
that bind us together in this transatlantic union
that everybody talks about.
And I think allies and friends and partners
that have worked together now for 80 years
should be able to speak frankly to one another
in open forums without being offended, insulted, or upset.
And I spoke to foreign ministers
from multiple countries throughout Europe.
Many of them probably didn't like the speech
or didn't agree with it,
but they were continuing to engage with us
on all sorts of issues that unite us.
So again, at the end of the day,
I think that people give all,
that is a forum in which you're supposed to be inviting
people to give speeches,
not basically a chorus where everyone
is saying the exact same thing.
That's not always gonna be the case
when it's a collection of democracies
where leaders have the right and the privilege
to speak their minds in forums such as these.
Mr. Secretary, I'm told that we are out of time.
A lot to get through with you.
We appreciate you making time today.
Yeah.
We'll be back in a minute.
Joe, what did you think about this exchange?
So let's get this straight.
Her argument is that the Holocaust happened
because of too much free speech.
It was weaponized to conduct a genocide.
Rubio, the Secretary of State, Marco Rubio,
who is as serious as a prison fight
and as sharp as anyone out there, period,
was not having it.
He also asked back,
why would our allies or anyone be irritated by free speech?
And to his point, the genocide was committed
by an authoritarian Nazi regime.
I mean, who would have faced the nation?
What's moderated by like actual journalists
like Bob Schieffer had morphed into the view,
but that's where we're at at this point.
And Rubio handled it beautifully and he's correct.
And again, Margaret Brennan, who remember,
she hosted, moderated, co-moderated
that vice presidential debate with J.D. Vance
when she tried to fact-check Vance.
Vance fact-checked her back and then she cut off his mic.
They're proving to be no different than MSNBC
at this point, it's bizarre.
Yeah.
During VP Vance's comments, you could hear a pin drop
and afterwards, all you could hear were tears.
I mean, I know these are smart people,
but they keep pushing back and they just keep rejecting
everything that seems obvious.
Sure, look, I mean, what you're seeing
is the European version of what happened in America
as Trump and MAGA gradually began to break up
the old order and the old establishment.
The European elites have controlled the continent.
They basically built a huge welfare state.
They opened their borders to millions of immigrants
who are unassimilated, don't share their values.
Just two days before the Munich conference,
you had somebody drive a vehicle
and kill two people, wounded, I think, 36.
Again, nobody in Europe, in the elites,
want to talk about it.
And I think J.D. Vance's speech,
plus his speech in Paris earlier,
those two speeches are the most important wake-up call
to Europe, maybe in my lifetime.
Because he's just telling them the truth.
If you don't change, if you don't modernize,
if you don't become competitive, you're gone.
You will cease to exist as a civilization.
And that's a fact.
You know, in fact, the first sentence, the second sentence,
he actually talked about that attack that you referenced.
And he talked about how horrific it is.
And of course, he's there with his family.
And I think he was trying to make that connection,
like, I'm with you, I'm here to help you,
I'm here to help wake you up.
And it's even arguable if they can even turn it around
at this point.
And of course, you referenced the MAGA movement.
Here in America, we still have a lot of resistance.
So yesterday on Face the Nation, host Margaret Brennan
tried to take Vance to task.
Many say that Rubio took it easy on her.
Your thoughts?
Well, I mean, first of all, the American left-wing elites
are utterly, totally ignorant of history.
They make up fantasies, they believe in the fantasies,
and then reality hits them, and they're shocked.
But here's what's going on.
What J.D. Vance, and I think President Trump,
and frankly, Secretary Hegseth in another speech,
what they're trying to do is the equivalent
of having an intervention if your neighbor's
a total alcoholic, and you're trying to sit down
and say to them, you have to change your life.
We're trying to say to the European elites,
you're not gonna compete with artificial intelligence,
you're not gonna compete militarily,
you're not gonna be able to modernize your society,
you're not gonna be able to compete economically
unless you have profound changes.
And of course, the elites are fine, they're doing great.
The country may be lousy, but they're doing great.
So they don't wanna change, and they're frankly angry at us
for telling them the truth about their problem.
Yeah, they go around every six months
to some palatial place, they have five-star restaurants,
eat the greatest food in the world,
and have these great discussions,
and then agree to meet again in six more months,
and everyone else suffers.
You know, two weeks ago, you were at the White House,
and I was reading where you wrote that you left,
when you left that visit, you were as hopeful
as ever, so tell us, this groundswell of hope,
why it's different now?
Because you have in President Trump,
the most consequential president, I think,
since Abraham Lincoln.
You have somebody who's willing to look at the facts,
offer totally new and unusual outside-the-box solutions,
be very, very practical, negotiate with everybody,
and both here at home and overseas,
he's like a gigantic breath of fresh air.
This is the closest we've come to being able to replace
the 90-year-old Rooseveltian coalition,
and it is the necessary intervention
to help our European allies understand
that they have to change,
if in fact they're gonna survive.
So, the level of courage that President Trump,
Vice President Vance, and their entire team is showing,
I think is historic and remarkable,
and look, they're gonna make mistakes.
You can't move at this speed,
decide on things this big,
and not have some things go wrong.
But on balance,
this is the most consequential presidency, I think,
since Lincoln.
Now, they've still gotta pass a giant tax bill
by May or June.
They've still gotta win the House elections next year.
A lot of steps between here and history,
but they're certainly off in the first month
to an amazing start.
They really are.
And I gotta tell you, the roots of all of this go deep.
Part of them touched you when you were speaker,
so I really appreciate you, Newt.
Thank you very much for coming on.
Thank you.
