Eternal Life is Like What? | Episode 312 | Closer To Truth

Truth exists
11 followers
I cannot imagine going to sleep and never waking up.
Death surrounds me.
And although I surely know better,
I somehow feel immune.
I'm not alone.
Eternal life.
Almost all religions promise it.
In one form or another, the message goes forth.
Death is not final.
The end of my body shall not be the end of me.
I feel no temptation to prove life after death,
chasing down this story or that.
The anecdotal evidence is unscientific.
And the scientific evidence is nil.
But I am compelled to find visions of eternal life,
however hazy, blurred, or opaque.
If there is eternal life, what would it be like?
The answer should make some kind of sense.
If not, I doubt it were real.
I'm Robert Lawrence Kuhn,
and Closer to Truth is my journey to find out.
I start at Oxford with Richard Swinburne,
one of the world's leading philosophers of religion.
Deeply analytical, Richard believes in eternal life.
I'd like to know how he sees it.
Richard, the promise of God is immortality, eternal life.
Can we even begin to appreciate what this can mean?
I think we can begin to appreciate it,
but that's about all.
Eternal can be used in two senses.
It can mean either outside time or everlasting.
But the tradition has been pretty unanimous
that eternal life for humans means after this life
and everlasting life after this life.
But of course your main question is what would we be doing?
What would we be doing? That's right.
First of all, of course, we'd be happy.
But happiness is not just a sensation.
Happiness consists in doing what you want to do.
But the normal doctrine about heaven
is that it's not just happiness.
It's what Aquinas called beatitudo, blessedness.
And blessedness is doing what you want
where what you want to is supremely worthwhile.
And what is supremely worthwhile?
Well, of course we don't know.
But the last book of the Christian Bible,
the book of Revelation, does give some picture of it
which we can grasp.
And there seem to me two elements
that are mentioned there.
The first is worship, worship of God.
And there's a lot of talk about dances and hymns and such like.
Now, anyone with aesthetic sensitivities
will recognize that music, art, poetry,
these are enormously valuable things in themselves.
But their value in part is a matter of what they are
depicting or representing.
And if God is omnipotent, omniscient, and perfectly good,
then he firstly deserves infinite reverence.
And secondly, he has an infinite amount of things
to tell us and reveal about ourselves.
However worthwhile and enjoyable and beatific it can be,
speaking personally, after a while,
I don't know how long a while is,
the passivity of just worship would seem to me in my state now
to become rather boring.
Worship is essentially an active thing.
It's doing, it's playing the instruments and doing the dances.
But my point is there are, if God is as depicted,
infinitely many different new aspects to him
which we can respond to with infinitely many new
and growingly sensitive kinds of worship.
How do you see our substance, our body, our spirit?
The New Testament talks about a new body, a resurrected body.
Christian religion, unlike Eastern religions,
has always emphasized the resurrection of the body.
Although when we die, soul and body come apart, as it were,
and nevertheless, soul and body are finally reunited.
And what goes to heaven is the whole person, body and soul.
Not necessarily a body with all the limitations of our bodies,
but a body.
What makes it a body?
Well, a body is a public object.
It's something where other people can get hold of you
and you can get hold of other people.
And what is maintained by the body is your public presence
and your availability to other people.
You have a place, and if people want you,
they can get you at this place.
And they can interact with you at this place.
So it means a public expression,
and it means that heaven is a community of individuals.
There is also much talk, it's always been emphasized,
saints have work to do.
There's a saying of Jesus with respect to his apostles,
that they will be judging the 12 tribes of Israel.
But judging really means ruling over.
They will have work to do in helping people
into being good people who will naturally express themselves
in worship.
Happiness, blessedness, worship, body and soul,
a community of individuals with work to do.
Sounds pretty good, but I'd hoped for more.
Maybe I shouldn't feel this way.
Is there more?
J.P. Moreland is a Christian philosopher who believes
the Bible to be the literal word of God.
Does his vision of eternal life have more?
J.P., I'd like to try to explore what eternal life
experience would be like.
When you have your new body in the resurrection,
as you see it, this new body is not a material body.
Material is corruptible and disintegrate,
and this is forever, right?
No, it's a regular physical body.
By saying it's a spiritual body, it means it won't cease,
it doesn't decay, it doesn't mean it's not material.
So, it's a new kind of material?
No, I don't know the answer to the kind of material it is.
I do know that it's not limited like our physical body is now.
And I also think that in the eternal life
when we're embodied, we will have powers over matter.
Jesus, for example, I think was an archetype.
He was able to command a tree and it withered.
He was able to produce loaves and fish from a small number.
I think we're going to be able to engage in all kinds
of artistic creativity.
So, we'll be able to say, for example, to a hillside,
I want you to turn purple and look like this.
So, I think we're going to engage in all kinds of
learning, all kinds of play, all kinds of artistic creativity.
It won't be boring, it will be exciting and invigorating.
We'll always be finite so there will always be new things to
learn. And here's the important thing, we'll be able to do that
with those we love and with God.
And it will be a co-exploration.
There will be deep rich community, times of deep
interaction where there is not going to be hiddenness.
We'll have a material body.
We'll have a physical body.
We'll be able to eat.
Physical body means made of the same kinds of atoms?
Yeah, it'll occupy space.
You'll be able to see it.
It'll have a shape.
Yeah, of course.
But it'll never change.
Well, if by change, I mean you can move your arms and you can
color your wrist green if you wanted to.
But if by change you mean decay, no, it won't decay.
Ever.
Ever, that's right.
And will all kinds of physical functions,
will there be sexuality?
I don't think there will be sexuality and we won't miss it.
That won't be something that will be needed.
Why is food needed?
I don't know why.
I mean that's why did God create worms green?
It'll be a source of pleasure that will be something that
will be conducive to our nature.
Whereas our sexuality won't be as essential to our flourishing.
And I put it like this, will there be pets in the after
life? My answer to that is...
My answer is that God is about the task of making us something
that's going to be unbelievably exhilarating and thrilling.
And there will be whatever is needed for you to flourish as a
unique human person.
And God, there isn't one size fits all.
There are going to be things there for specific individuals
that's going to make Heaven a place for them that will allow
them to flourish maximally.
Whereas another person might not need that kind of thing.
Is Heaven a place?
It isn't now.
Heaven is real but it's not a spatial location.
It is a different mode of existence.
But when we receive resurrected bodies there's going to be a new
Heaven and Earth and we will be on Earth.
We won't be somewhere else but Earth will be very different.
Will we always be bound to Earth?
No.
That's why in Jesus' resurrected body as an archetype he was
capable of appearing and it appears that the laws of
physics did not control his resurrected body.
So, we're going to be capable of exploring.
This is one of the reasons why I think the universe is so big.
I think there are going to be opportunities for us to explore
and have an absolute blast.
So, everything you've got except sex.
Oh, and a lot that you can't imagine.
I mean, that's what...
Science fiction is really the only way you can get a hold of
this because the imagination needs to run wild to understand
what this is going to be.
It isn't going to be a bunch of little ladies singing boring
hymns in some wooden building that's half empty.
It's going to be a celebration.
An eternal life of extraordinary richness,
complexity and creativity.
To believe it all would take a long leap of faith.
But at least it sounds worthwhile.
What about other religions?
Christians have no monopoly on claims of eternal life.
For Islam's views, I turn to Sayyid Hussain Nasser,
a distinguished Islamic philosopher.
Hussain, what is eternal life like in Islam?
You know, Robert, this is an aspect of Islamic teachings
which is very much misunderstood in the West.
Because the Quran uses a very sensuous language
to describe paradise.
For example, there are animals and plants
in the Islamic paradise.
And in fact, the English word for paradise comes from
the old Persian word, pardis, which means garden.
And then there's the question of sexuality.
That is the presence of huris, which has entered
into the English language, of maidens and also men for women
and all kinds of things like that.
Which were then considered in the Middle Ages as proving
that Islam was not spiritual and it was very sensuous.
Now, of course, after the...
I don't mind, by the way.
After the sexual revolution of the 20th century,
lesser Christians made of that.
But let's take this description.
Sexuality, sexual union, is the most powerful experience
that we have on the external sense level in this world.
There's no doubt about it.
Eating, nothing compares to it.
But it's limited.
It is limited, first of all, by all the legal elements,
by our own physical capabilities,
by emotional relations, and 1,001 things
that we all know about.
Now, take all those limitations away.
The heart of the experience of sexual union
is a paradisal experience.
That's why everybody's after it.
It's a kind of seeking after the lost paradise.
Now, these descriptions of paradise,
which involve what's called ma'idah,
that is the feast, the paradisal feast of fruit,
paradisal fruit, and so forth and so on.
And then, as I said, the sensual, sexual descriptions
are not meant to simply lower the value of paradise,
but to elevate it and to show that everything
that is pleasurable in this world,
everything that we enjoy is really a reflection
of a paradisal experience.
And even within paradise, there are levels.
The highest paradise is called the paradise of the gardener
and not the garden, paradise of the essence,
in which every single concept and idea
and limited form of existence is transcendent.
That is, even we are beyond the paradisal state
in the ordinary sense.
Do we still keep our own personalities
or do we merge into some cosmic consciousness
which some religions teach?
First of all, it's not cosmic.
It's metacosmic.
Secondly, it's a kind of merging
without destruction of the individual.
There is a kind of swimming in the ocean of divinity
and therefore being drowned in that ocean,
but still retaining something of what we are.
Meister Eckhart formulated this beautiful expression,
fusion without confusion.
And therefore, we transcend what we usually identify as our I,
because by some great mystery,
which is not possible to understand
simply mentally and rationally,
we're given the power to be conscious
of our own nothingness in the divinity.
Islam's paradise is similar to the Christian heaven
in terms of God and bliss,
but wildly different in terms of its visions
and descriptive metaphors,
especially, well, with respect to sex.
I need to look beyond the Abrahamic religions.
What about Hinduism,
perhaps the world's oldest wisdom tradition?
I ask V.V. Raman,
a Hindu physicist and spiritual explorer.
V.V., I don't know whether this sounds silly,
but to me, the question of eternal life,
what it will be like,
is absolutely essential to my understanding of God.
How is the Hindu understanding of eternal life
reflected, differs from what we are normally seeing in the West?
The notion of eternal life implies,
from the Hindu perspective,
an existence that is without any change.
And here I should go to the key idea in Hinduism,
that that which changes is finite,
and that which does not change is eternal.
So, eternal life is the equivalent
of becoming part of the unchanging universe,
unchanging awareness,
which we call Brahman in the Hindu tradition.
Therefore, from that perspective,
eternal life is equivalent
to what one calls the merger with the infinite.
One sometimes makes an analogy
with water in different containers.
The pockets of water, whether in lakes or ponds or bottles,
have all come from the waters that have fallen as rain.
And the prayer says something like this,
that just as the waters from the oceans
come back and fall on the ground
and become these pockets of water,
ultimately go back to the same ocean.
It is in that way that ultimately we not only go back
to the ocean, we become one with it.
And once we are part of that from which we came,
we become eternal again.
So, eternal life is not as individuals,
but more as part of the whole.
If we started in this eternal state
and we went through this process,
perhaps different lives,
and wind up back in that state, what have we gained?
Every religious tradition has a particular world view
on these matters, which I think are ultimately
inscrutable and fathomable.
But we do have these particular pictures.
The Hindu tradition simply says that this entire experience
through which we go will ultimately end up in something
that is truly ecstatic, because that is what that merger
with Brahman is all about.
Hindu's vision of eternal life differs radically
from that of Christianity and Islam,
in that it is existence without change.
Individuality is subsumed by becoming one
with the great ocean of cosmic consciousness
from which we came.
But is there some common vision of eternal life
underlying all religions?
The person I ask is Houston Smith,
a great religious scholar who has personally practiced
Hinduism, Buddhism, and Sufism,
a mystical tradition of Islam,
while remaining a lifelong Christian.
What is the essence of eternal life?
The Indians have a useful phrase,
drop the body.
That's useful because it means there is something
that drops the body,
and that is what all the religions say.
Now, dropping the body occurs at the moment of death.
What will it be when we drop our body?
Well, what we can say is if consciousness
is the fundamental reality and it can't be destroyed,
consciousness will continue.
The light on the television screen
will never go out.
Now, what the images on that screen will be after death,
after we drop the body, we do not know.
That's the ultimate mystery.
But we know I'm Robert, and you'll know you're Houston,
and we'll have ourselves.
Like Ramakrishnan said, I want to taste sugar.
I don't want to be sugar.
So, the second view is being sugar,
that I will merge into the cosmic consciousness.
But we lose our personality, so we don't exist,
but we become part of the great existence.
Right.
That is often described as the dew drop
slips into the shining sea.
So much for the dew drop, but that analogy is wrong.
It should be the dew drop opens to admit
the entire sea into it.
Virtually every human culture has a tradition
of life after death.
But this counts for nothing in uncovering what's really true.
Each religion paints its own portrait of the hereafter.
Some visions are ethereal, in that we merge and meld
with the collective consciousness
and lose our personal identities.
Other visions are individual and even corporeal,
in that we get a new non-corruptible body
and retain our personal identities.
The ethereal visions are beatific and cosmic.
The individual visions are more like human life,
amplifying the good parts and excising the bad parts.
Which would I choose?
It matters not.
When it comes to eternal life, my desires mean nothing
for coming closer to truth.
For complete interviews and for further information,
please visit closertotruth.com.
