Divine elegance, Simone Martini's The Annunciation

Classic Art
36 followers
63 Video Views·Feb 10, 2025
A conversation with Dr. Steven Zucker and Dr. Beth Harris in front of Simone Martini and Lippo Memmi, Annunciation with St. Margaret and St. Ansanus, 1333, tempera on wood, gold background, 184 x 168 cm (Uffizi, Florence)
We're in the Uffizi looking at a painting by Simone Martini
and Lippo Memmi of the Annunciation.
Now, art historians spend a lot of time
trying to figure out who painted what here.
And some art historians see the central scene
of the Annunciation painted by Simone Martini
and the two figures on either side by Memmi.
And that desire to ascribe the most important part
of the painting to the more famous artist
comes from the writing of Giorgio Vasari,
a 16th century chronicler of Italian painting.
And Simone Martini was favored
because he was one of the most prominent students
of the most famous Sienese artist
of the previous generation, Duccio.
So let's step back for a moment.
In the 14th century, Siena, just south of Florence,
was a very important city-state in Italy.
Italy was not a unified country.
And Duccio had created for the Cathedral of Siena
this double-sided altarpiece, the Maestà.
And this painting was seen as a tremendous triumph.
Siena saw its great success
as dependent on the favor of the Virgin Mary.
And Duccio's Maestà focused on the Virgin Mary
as the Queen of Heaven.
The city was incredibly prosperous at this moment
and planned on expanding the Cathedral dramatically.
In anticipation of this, the city commissioned
four additional altarpieces for the Cathedral.
And here we are standing in front
of one of the subsidiary altarpieces.
This one's showing an early story in Mary's life,
the Annunciation, with the Archangel Gabriel
announcing to the Virgin Mary
that she will bear the Son of God,
that she will bear Christ.
Coming out of the angel Gabriel's mouth,
we can see his words,
"'Hail, full of grace, the Lord is with thee.'"
And the surface of the painting
is literally built up likely with stucco
and then that stucco is gilded.
And so those words have a sense of physicality.
And Mary seems to react physically to them as well
as those words head in her direction
and she very gracefully and modestly
pulls back away from them.
It seems as if she's been interrupted reading a book,
presumably the Bible, showing her piety.
She is wonderfully elegant with long features,
that long nose, long fingers,
an attenuated, lengthened body,
all references to the older Byzantine style
that had been adopted by seeing these painters
during the late medieval period.
We have the Archangel Gabriel
who seems as if he's just landed.
His drapery is still a flutter.
Between Mary and the angel Gabriel,
we see a golden vase of lilies,
a symbol of Mary's purity.
Whereas Gabriel, for his part,
holds an olive branch, a symbol of peace.
And above the lilies, we see what looks like a sunburst
with a dove at the center.
This represents the Holy Spirit.
And if you look closely, you can see that it's got a halo
and out of its mouth come rays
which are aimed directly at Mary.
The dove is surrounded by seraphs.
These are a high rank of angels that have multiple wings.
And are commonly represented with heads but without bodies.
If our eye continues to move up above the dove,
we see an empty circle that likely held originally
an image of God the Father.
What really distinguishes this painting,
even from the earlier style of Simone Martini,
is its extraordinary elegance.
There's such a linear quality to this painting.
Look, for example, at the elegant turns of Gabriel's cloak,
of the attention to the individual feathers in his wings,
the delicacy with which the lilies are painted,
or the face of the Virgin.
Or these lovely curvilinear forms.
For example, that drapery that flutters
behind the angel Gabriel.
Or the hem of Mary's garment that weaves back and forth.
In addition to that sense of elegance,
there's a sense of sumptuousness, of richness.
Look at that fabric worn by the angel Gabriel.
This fabric is meant to mimic the extremely rich silks
that were being imported from the East.
The technique that the artist used here
is to apply a ground of gold, paint white over it,
and then scrape that white away
to reveal the gold underneath.
This is such detailed work.
So finely crafted.
And on either side of the angel Gabriel and Mary,
we have two saints on the left,
Saint Ansanus, who was an important patron saint of Siena.
And Ansanus is appropriately holding a flag
with the colors of Siena.
There are four additional rondels with painted busts.
These include Old Testament prophets.
You can tell they're Old Testament prophets
because they hold scrolls,
and are included here as a way of expressing
that the Old Testament, the Judaic tradition,
was a foundation upon which Christianity was built.
That the prophets of the Old Testament
foretold the coming of a savior,
and this is the moment when that savior arrives,
when God is made flesh.
The artist has allotted just a little bit of space
for the figures to exist in.
It's almost as if the figures are standing on a shelf.
There's almost no room in front of them,
and very little room behind them,
until you get to this wall of gold
that is really meant to represent
the spiritual light of heaven.
So imagine for just a moment,
seeing this painting in the Duomo of Siena,
the main church of Siena.
This is a church whose walls are made
of white and black stone,
creating a kind of dizzying effect.
Imagine the spiritual power of an image like this
in the dim light of the church with incense, with music.
And this painting, one of four,
surrounding Duccio's great masterpiece, the Maestà,
the celebration of the Virgin Mary,
the patron and protectress of Siena.
