This Sculpture Was BURIED for 1,400 Years

Classic Art
36 followers
#GJWart #OnlineArtGallery #ArtHistory #art #classicart #fineart #history #oldart #oldpainting #oldpaintings
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores the history and mysteries surrounding the *Laocoön*, a masterpiece sculpture in the Vatican depicting a Trojan priest and his sons being killed by sea serpents. From its rediscovery in 1506 to debates over its anatomy, aesthetic meaning, and authenticity, the work remains one of the most contested objects in art history.
There is a sculpture in the Vatican of a man being killed by sea serpents.
He is bearded, his body twisted. The marble captures the precise instant before he and
his two young sons die. The man's mouth is open in what should be a scream,
but if you look closely you will notice that he is not. The question of why he is not screaming
has divided art historians for nearly three centuries, and the question of who really
carved this masterpiece makes this the most mysterious sculpture in human history.
In the year 77, the Roman writer Pliny the Elder described a single sculpture in the
palace of the Emperor Titus as a work to be preferred to all other paintings and statues.
He named the three Greek sculptors from the island of Rhodes who carved it,
He described the composition, a Trojan priest and his two sons being killed by sea serpents,
the bodies twisting in marble. Then, the sculpture disappeared. For more than 1400 years,
no one knew where it was, what it looked like, or whether it had survived at all.
The only thing anyone had was Pliny's description, and the conviction that somewhere in the ruins
of Rome the greatest sculpture of antiquity might still exist. On the 14th of January 1506,
a man named Felice de Freiris was digging foundations for a building on his vineyard
on the Esquiline Hill in Rome. What he uncovered, nearly intact, was a marble group of a bearded man
and two boys entangled in the coils of two enormous snakes. Pope Julius II was informed
within hours. He sent the architect Giuliano da Sangallo to the site. Sangallo brought a
30-year-old sculptor with him, who was at that moment working on the early phases of the Sistine
Chapel and the tomb of Julius II. His name was Michelangelo Buonarroti. Sangallo and Michelangelo
stood in the pit, looked at the marble emerging from the soil, and identified it within minutes.
This, they said, was the Laocoön Pliny had described. Within a month the Pope had purchased
it and installed it in the Belvedere Courtyard of the Vatican, where it has remained in one
form or another for nearly five centuries. The sculpture depicts a moment from the fall
of Troy. According to the myth, Laocoön was a priest in the city who warned his fellow Trojans
against accepting the wooden horse the Greeks had left outside the gates. He suspected correctly
that it concealed Greek soldiers. He was right. He was also doomed. Athena and Poseidon, who were
favouring the Greeks in the war, sent two enormous sea serpents to silence him before he could be
believed. The serpents wrapped around Laocoön and his two sons, Antiphantes and Thimbraeus,
and crushed them. The Trojans, taking the deaths as a sign that Laocoön had been speaking against
the will of the gods, brought the horse inside the walls. Troy fell that night.
For Romans, this was not abstract Greek mythology. Their own founding myth held that Aeneas,
a Trojan prince, had escaped the burning city and led the survivors to Italy,
where his descendants founded Rome. In some traditions of the story, Aeneas was Laocoön's
own brother. The serpents that killed Laocoön were therefore the moment that made Aeneas'
escape possible, and the moment that made the Roman Empire possible. When Emperor Titus displayed
the sculpture in his palace, he was not collecting Greek art. He was displaying the foundation moment
of his own civilization, carved in stone. The sculpture captures the precise instant of the
attack. Laocoön at the center, his body twisting, his face locked in an open-mouthed cry. His sons
on either side of him, one already collapsing and the other still struggling. The serpents winding
through the composition, binding the three figures together into a single unified knot of suffering.
Now, there is one detail in Pliny's account that has never been reconciled with the sculpture
itself. He wrote specifically that the work was carved from a single block of marble.
The Latin phrase he used, ex uno lapide, was part of what made the achievement so extraordinary in
Roman eyes. A figure of this complexity, with three bodies and two coiling serpents,
and all the empty space between them, executed from one stone.
In the 20th century, modern restoration techniques were applied to the sculpture
in the Belvedere courtyard. Conservators discovered that the marble was actually
composed of at least seven separate blocks, joined together with such precision that the
seams had been concealed for centuries. Either Pliny was mistaken about something he saw in
person, or what he described and what the Vatican has are not the same sculpture.
But when the sculpture came out of the ground, it was incomplete. The right arm of Laocoön himself
was missing, along with the right hand of one son and the right arm of the other,
and sections of the snakes. The Vatican had to decide how to complete the work.
Now consider the argument that broke out. Most of the sculptors brought in to advise,
believed Laocoön's missing arm had been extended outward,
raised heroically into the air in a grand gesture of defiance against the serpents.
Michelangelo disagreed. He argued from anatomy. The muscles of the back and shoulder, he said,
indicated that the arm could not have been extended. It had to be bent backward,
with the hand reaching over the shoulder, the priest seizing the serpent as it bit him.
The argument was not abstract. The Pope's architect Donato Bramante organized a competition
to design the replacement arm, with Raphael appointed as judge. Several sculptors submitted
versions. Michelangelo's bent arm theory was rejected. Jacopo Sansovino's extended arm won.
In 1532, a sculptor named Giovanni Antonio Montorsoli installed a final version,
with the arm raised even more dramatically into the air.
That is the arm Laocoön wore for the next 425 years.
In 1906, an Austro-Czech archaeologist and art dealer named Ludwig Pollock was walking
through a stonecutter's yard on the Oppian Hill, a few hundred meters from the site of the original
1506 discovery. He saw a fragment of a marble arm lying among the debris. The style, he
recognized immediately, matched the Laocoön. The arm was bent. He acquired the fragment,
presented it to the Vatican, and was told that the museum would take it for study.
The Vatican placed the arm in a storeroom and did nothing with it for half a century.
In 1957, the Vatican museums finally examined the arm. The drill holes in the broken end aligned
perfectly with the corresponding holes in the shoulder of the Laocoön. There was no doubt.
The arm was original. It had been part of the sculpture since antiquity. And it was bent
backward, exactly as Michelangelo had insisted 451 years earlier.
The arm controversy is one of two arguments about the Laocoön that shaped how the modern
world looks at all sculpture. In 1755, a German art historian named Johann Joachim published a
short book called Reflections on the Imitation of Greek Works in Painting and Sculpture.
He had spent years studying Roman copies of Greek sculpture, and the work he chose as his prime
example, the work he believed defined the entire character of Greek art, was the Laocoön.
His description gave us a phrase that founded the discipline of art history.
Greek art, he wrote, was characterized by noble simplicity and quiet grandeur.
Even in extreme physical agony, the Greek hero contained his suffering.
Look at Laocoön's mouth, Winckelmann argued. It is open in a cry, but the cry is restrained.
He is being killed by sea serpents, and he is not screaming.
This, Winckelmann said, was the moral superiority of Greek civilization, made visible in marble.
Eleven years later, in 1766, another German named Gotthold Ephraim published an entire book
disagreeing. The title was Laocoön, an essay on the limits of painting and poetry.
Lessing's argument was direct. Laocoön's mouth is not compressed because Greeks were noble.
It is compressed because the sculptor was working in marble. A wide-open,
screaming mouth in stone exposes the teeth, distorts the face, and produces something ugly.
The sculptor had no choice but to restrain the expression.
Lessing's book founded modern aesthetic theory. The entire question of what visual art can and
cannot do, compared to language, was built on a debate on what is happening inside Laocoön's
mouth. Two readings of the same face. Either it is the moral restraint of Greek civilization,
or it is the technical limit of marble. The most important argument in the history
of European art theory was waged over a sculpture that had been buried in a Roman vineyard for
1400 years. But the arguments about the arm and the mouth assume one fundamental thing about the
Laocoön. They assume it is what Pliny said it was. In 2005, the art historian Lynn Catterson,
then at Columbia University, published a paper in the journal Artibus et Historiae,
titled simply Michelangelo's Laocoön? Her argument was that the sculpture is not
an ancient work at all. It is a Renaissance forgery, carved by Michelangelo himself,
and planted in the Roman soil to be discovered. Her evidence was circumstantial but accumulated.
Michelangelo, in his late twenties, had a documented history of forging antiquities.
His Sleeping Cupid, sold around 1496, was deliberately buried to acquire a patina of
age before being passed off as a Roman work. He was, in other words, already a known counterfeiter
when the Laocoön was discovered. Catterson identified a pen study by Michelangelo from
around 1501, depicting the back of a male torso that she argued closely resembles the back of
Laocoön. She produced bank records from 1498 through 1501, showing Michelangelo purchasing
substantial quantities of marble that cannot be accounted for in his known commissions.
She noted that the sculpture had been unearthed almost too cleanly, well preserved for an object
supposedly buried for more than a millennium, in Michelangelo's presence, on land conveniently
being excavated at the right moment. She wrote that he had the motives and the means.
Other scholars pushed back hard. Richard Brilliant, an emeritus professor of classical
antiquities at Columbia, and the author of the book My Laocoön, called Catterson's argument
non-credible on every count. Most art historians continue to date the sculpture to the late
Hellenistic period, somewhere between 40 BC and 20 AD, based on stylistic comparison with other
works. But the question has not gone away. In 2025, the Italian classicist Francesco
Collafemina published a book expanding on Catterson's case with additional evidence,
and the debate reopened in the art press. So which sculpture are you looking at when you
stand in the Belvedere courtyard? The Vatican still calls it Hellenistic. The arm Michelangelo
predicted now hangs from its shoulder, and the question of whether the sculpture is
ancient Greek or Renaissance Italian has never been definitively closed.
