How do particles get mass? Neil deGrasse Tyson and comedian Chuck Nice discover squarks, sneutrinos, the Higgs boson, and whether dark matter has a particle with theoretical physicist Brian Greene.
Can we finally get to the bottom of what happens when a quark falls into a black hole? Learn about the ultraviolet catastrophe, the start of quantum physics, and Max Planck quantizing packets of energy. We also discuss how Einstein won the Nobel prize for the discovery for which he is least famous.
We take a deep dive into the Higgs boson. Who’s Higgs? What’s a boson? Find out about how the Higgs field creates mass, the different quantum particles, and how quarks create protons and neutrons. Brian breaks down the theory of supersymmetry: does every particle have a counterpart? Learn about squarks, sneutrinos, and whether supersymmetry can give an answer to what dark matter is.
Is the fabric of spacetime woven by tiny wormholes? Discover the Casimir force, quantum fluctuations, and why you need so many dimensions in a string theory universe. We discuss whether the cosmological constant is, in fact, constant. Plus, find out about the biggest mismatch between theory and experiment in physics.
Timestamps: 00:00 - Introduction: Brian Greene 07:45 - When a Quark Falls Into a Black Hole 13:55 - The Beginning of Quantum Physics & Einstein’s Nobel Prize 18:01 - Discovering the Higgs Boson 21:52 - What is the Higgs Boson? 26:26 - How Do Particles in an Atom Get Mass? 30:30 - Is Dark Matter a Particle? 33:20 - Squarks, Sneutrinos, & Supersymmetry 40:16 - Fabric of Spacetime Woven by Wormholes 45:06 - Four Dimensions & String Theory 47:20 - Is Dark Matter Just Matter in Another Universe? 49:30 - Is the Cosmological Constant Constant? 56:16 - A Cosmic Perspective
I have not been the same since we had lunch.
You explained to me, and I've said it here,
the fabric of space-time might be woven by wormholes
that connect the virtual particle pairs
that come in and out of existence.
So it's like a little quantum net
holding the whole universe together.
Yes, exactly right.
We find mathematically, if we cut the threads
of quantum entanglement, space falls apart.
It discretizes into little tiny pieces
and then just disappears.
I gotta go.
This is StarTalk.
Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist.
I got Chuck Nice with me.
Chuck, baby.
What's up, Neil?
All right.
You know what we're going to talk about today?
I do not.
The only way to talk about physics
is to talk about physics with Brian Greene in the house.
That is true.
Thank you.
You gotta, you know, you can't.
It's empty.
Unless you have Brian Greene in the conversation.
Absolutely.
And he's just up the street up at Columbia.
You're a dual professor, professor of physics
and professor of mathematics.
That's right.
Wow.
You get paid twice for that.
But I go to no faculty meetings.
I'm always in the other department.
That's pretty cool.
I'm sorry, I can't.
I'm math today.
So you're author of several books
until the end of time.
Was that your more recent one?
That's my most recent, yes.
And that came out how long ago?
2020, right at the pandemic.
What a moment to have a book called
Until the End of Time, right?
And the one I think most people know,
if they know you at all,
The Elegant Universe.
There's another one, The Fabric of the Cosmos.
Yeah, absolutely.
That was the next one.
And Hidden Reality.
Yeah, that was about multiple universes.
Right.
Man, so he's all up in it.
I believe The Fabric of the Universe is a tweet.
A tweet.
A satin weave.
So welcome back to the show.
Thank you.
You're more than a three-peat,
I think, at this point.
Yeah.
Oh, God.
And you're involved in a lot of things.
You're writing the book.
Other than being a professor,
you're writing the books.
And are we in the 15th year
of your World Science Festival?
How many years have you been doing this?
That's right.
We started in 2008.
So if you just subtract,
it's even a little bit more,
but the pandemic changed things a little bit.
Pandemic, yeah.
But yeah, we're coming up to
probably the 15th live event.
Congratulations on that.
Thank you.
Although it's a little audacious
to hold it in New York
and call it the World Science Festival.
But we don't only have it in New York.
We also have it in Australia.
And we've had events in Amsterdam,
in Moscow.
Look at that.
I got nothing.
I can't.
In Italy, in Spain.
I know.
I try to.
And by the way,
New York is the world.
Yeah.
Let's be honest.
I mean,
for anybody out there listening,
I'm sorry.
You go to Paris,
you find Parisians.
You go to England,
you find the Brits.
But you come to New York,
you find everybody.
Audacious would have been
like the cosmic science festival.
Yeah.
You know,
then you would have had a point.
Well,
congratulations on bringing it
to the world.
Thank you.
Or taking it to the world.
And what I enjoyed most about
the several that I've attended
is the effort to bring the arts
into it in a meaningful way.
Oh.
There's,
you know,
there are many artists
who I would later learn
are not rare
who are inspired by science
and the universe
and discoveries.
And they will compose dance
and music.
And you have a mixture
of these sessions.
We do.
I mean,
the goal is to have science
feel connected to everything
that matters to us.
And of course,
culture is a big part of that.
Culture and arts matter to everybody.
In fact,
now with AI,
we're doing a program
on the arts in the age
of artificial intelligence.
So how is AI changing
how artists approach
their work
and how scientists
think about art?
There will be more
unemployed artists.
Yeah, well.
Yeah, but it's a funny thing.
People say that.
Just not paid.
They won't be unemployed.
They just won't be paid.
Yeah, but whenever new
technology comes along,
like the camera,
people are like,
okay,
now you don't need
artists anymore
because anyone can just
click.
But there are artists
who use the camera
to create things
that mere mortals can't.
And there are painters
who actually take a picture
and then they actually
paint the picture
as opposed to
having someone
sit for a portrait.
But that wasn't the biggest
issue,
the biggest thing.
The biggest force
operating was
you no longer needed
the artist
to portray reality
because, of course,
the camera captured that.
Freed him up.
Freed the artist
to portray
impressionistic scenes.
Beyond reality.
Exactly.
It's not what the scene
looks like.
It's what the scene
feels like.
It's the interpretation.
That matters.
It's huge.
I mean,
that's what is the magic
in so much expression.
It's what we do with it
as opposed to
just literally depicting
what's out there.
So,
there are many people
who project that
AI is going to create
a new kind of art.
Yeah.
Just the way the camera does.
It still has to shake out.
You still need to see.
I think AI will
just accelerate creativity.
It doesn't replace it
because what happens is
you have associations
that are being made
at a level that
you as a human being
would maybe eventually
over a course of years
you might make
those associations.
But the computer
can do it
almost instantaneously.
And then you take that
and you say,
hmm,
what does that mean to me?
Okay,
so it pushes you along.
Pushes you along.
Yeah,
but the flip side of that
is if you have a computer
creating so much
there's a lot of
chaff,
you know,
that you have to separate out.
It's so true.
So, yeah.
There's chaff
even when people do it.
No, it's true.
You're born and raised
in New York City.
Yeah,
right across the street
from where we are
sitting right now.
You went to
Stuyvesant High School,
which is a selective
high school that
specialized in science
in the way the
Bronx High School of Science
specialized.
In fact, they're rivals.
That's right.
Intellectual rivals.
Why do you think
that we've wrestled
each other now and then?
I always lose them.
You would not like a book
if it didn't have equations
in it.
That's true.
This is weird.
Yeah,
that has changed,
I should say.
That's funny.
So you read a novel.
That's right now and then.
That meant you thought
more deeply about math
than you thought about words.
Yeah,
but the one change
I would make
to that statement was
it was when it came to books
for a science class.
If the book was
chock full of words,
I'd feel like,
oh no,
there's a lot of interpretation
that's going to go into
this particular science class.
But if it was
chock full of equations,
I was like,
nah,
this is rigorous.
This is going to be specific
and it's going to be something
that I can nail
because I don't have
to interpret.
I can just really
engage with the equations.
Wow,
so in a history class
or a literature class,
you would have been in tears
for the task required of you.
It was mostly just for science,
but you're absolutely right.
There is a different mindset
that you bring to a history class
or an English class,
which I did not have
a full appreciation for
when I was younger.
That's absolutely true.
And as I got older,
and especially there's a moment
when I graduated college
and I said to myself,
I think I just got
a technical education
as opposed to learning
about the world
and life and humanity.
And I went into
kind of a tailspin
for a little while
because I was like,
what did I do?
And that really then
changed it all for me
and words have become vital
to the way I engage
with the world.
You think?
I mean,
you know,
there's four bestselling books.
Yeah,
but words matter.
If you want to talk
to other people
who are not physicists.
And if you want to really
get the essence
of what someone's about
as opposed to quantifying
some quality of abstract
or objective reality.
Okay.
All right.
I think that's a,
that's an enlightened posture.
Yeah.
I've gotten there.
It took me a while.
So,
what I want to do is follow up.
There was a question
to our cosmic queries
that I didn't have an answer to.
Oh, no.
Here we go.
Okay.
And I said,
you know,
I don't know.
We're going to have
to get Brian Greene in here.
We've got to get
the big guns in here.
All right.
If I remember the question,
it was,
what happens
if a quark
falls into a black hole?
You have a quark pair.
Yes.
And we've only ever found them
in quark pairs.
Yeah.
Okay.
And in a normal lab,
if you take them
and pull them apart,
the force that wants
to bring them together grows,
which sounds weird
when you're used to gravity
and other things
where distance
makes something weaker.
But they're like
really creepy identical twins.
No.
I can't remember
when you meet identical twins
that are like super creepy.
Where they sort of talk together.
Where they kind of talk together
and walk together.
They got their own language.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Yeah.
Okay.
Right.
So,
but it's kind of like a rubber band.
Yeah.
As you stretch the rubber band,
the force is greater.
Yeah.
The gluonic force between them.
The gluonic force
is held together by gluons.
So now,
as I pull it apart,
there will be a point
where it snaps.
As I understand
my nuclear physics,
it snaps with the exact amount
of energy you put in
so that out of that energy
creates two other quarks.
Yeah.
So now I have four quarks.
Quark-anti-quark pair is produced.
Pairs.
Thank you.
Yeah.
Okay.
Pairs.
Okay.
So now.
So you want to see what happens.
Now you send a pair of quarks
down the black hole.
It gets split.
We make two other quarks.
Yeah.
Thank you.
That was very good.
And you keep doing this
and they,
so wouldn't the quarks
eat
the entire gravitational field
of the black hole?
Yeah.
And then you wouldn't have
a black hole left.
You just have a ball of quarks.
You have to realize,
number one,
that we still don't know
the physics of the singularity
of a black hole well enough.
Why else did I invite you
into this office now?
So,
well,
I wish one day,
one day I pray
that I'll sit here
and tell you what happens
at the singularity
Bring the person who knows
next time.
But here's the thing.
There is nobody on planet Earth
who knows the answer,
unfortunately, yet.
Okay.
When we follow the mathematics
to the actual singularity
of a black hole.
Using Einstein's
general relativity.
Using Einstein's
general relativity
and even some of the
modifications that have come
from more recent thinking,
we're still not there yet
to truly understand
what happens.
And I should say
there are ideas.
There are ideas of things,
I don't know if you've heard
of them,
called fuzz balls,
where there isn't
actually a singularity
and the black hole
is actually a more fuzzy
collection of matter.
So there are ideas
that people put forward.
That makes your math
come out okay.
Makes the math come out okay,
but we're not sure
that it's right.
And when they say
the black hole is where
the singularity at the
center of a black hole
is where God is dividing
by zero.
Yeah, that's a
Stephen Hawking quip
or something.
Did he say that?
I think it is, you know.
So you remember why
if you divide by zero,
it blows up.
And it's actually,
in a sense,
it's literal
because if you calculate
what's known as
a scalar curvature,
which is a number
that characterizes
how warped
a region of space is,
it does go to infinity
as you go to
the center of a black hole.
Just like when you
divide by zero,
it goes to infinity.
In fact, it goes to infinity
as the sixth power
of your distance.
So we know very well
how badly behaved
the center of a black hole is.
So it goes to infinity fast.
It goes to infinity fast.
That's crazy.
Yeah.
And so if you ask
what really happens
if something is just
being crushed at the center,
we can't really answer yet.
So is it possible
that as a quark-anticorporate
pair goes,
that the tidal forces
will create additional
quark-anticorporate?
Sure.
And then you'd have
the proliferation of quarks
making me some sounds.
So there may be a cloud,
and there may be
some sort of cloud
that forms just before it hits.
Ultimately, we believe
it hits the singularity,
whatever that means,
because we don't really know
what the singularity is yet.
If it's a fuzzball,
you can have a fuzzball
or quarks, possibly.
Or the fuzzball
may have a slightly
different impact
on the quark-anticorporate pair.
Maybe before...
Influence on it.
Yeah, yeah.
Impact.
Yeah, that's right.
Exactly.
So it's a really good question,
but it will have to fully await
a full understanding
of what truly happened
in the center.
Okay, so me not being able
to answer it wasn't
just my personal ignorance,
it's a total ignorance
of all humans on Earth.
Yeah, and there are...
So I don't feel so bad.
And I should say,
there are many, many questions
like that that we're
still struggling with.
Like, we believe that
when any information
falls into a black hole,
we believe that information
does not get destroyed.
But for a while,
Stephen Hawking thought,
no, any information
ultimately hits the singularity
and leaves our universe.
He changed his mind
later in life,
which just goes to show...
Was that his famous bet
with Kip Thorne?
Yes, that's right.
So they bet, I think,
an encyclopedia,
you know, the source of information
that we humans have created.
So there...
Kip Thorne was one
of the executive producers
on Interstellar.
Interstellar, right.
And he sort of spearheaded
the effort, among others,
but he was the exponent
to build the laser interferometry
gravitational wave observatory,
LIGO,
the detected colliding black holes.
And he won the Nobel Prize for that.
So he's significant in our field,
and I have at least a few books
by him on my shelves.
And he was clearly
on a level of geekdom
where he bets encyclopedias.
Yeah.
But in terms of his book,
he wrote an encyclopedic book
on gravity and black holes,
which is about, you know,
1,200 pages,
just filled with equations.
Therefore, I loved it
when I was a kid.
The Misner-Thorne-Wheeler.
Yes.
I have two copies of that
in my office.
Two copies?
Yes.
Do you want to cross-reference
or something?
One of those is mine,
and the other one
belonged to my wife
who has a PhD
in mathematical physics.
Wow, that's so cool.
We met in relativity class.
Really?
Taught by John Wheeler.
Really?
Yes.
You took relativity from Wheeler?
Yes, I did.
That is amazing.
Nice.
Yeah, so John Wheeler
is one of the authors
of this Misner-Thorne-Wheeler.
And Misner taught physics
at University of Maryland.
Charles Misner.
Charles Misner, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Okay, so I want to think of it
as a quark catastrophe
that would happen
in the center of the black hole.
The trouble with quarks,
they're like triples.
By the way,
there's a previous,
if we're physics geeking out here,
there's a previous time.
Was it 100 years,
110 years ago?
There's something called
the ultraviolet catastrophe.
Yeah.
Do you remember that?
I remember it well.
I wasn't there,
but I've learned about it.
Yeah, this is the start
of quantum physics.
Yeah, it had to predate 1900.
It predated Planck, Max Planck.
Oh, okay.
Because there was an equation
that would show how much energy
would come from glowing objects.
Okay.
And how much energy
of a certain wavelength of light
and then another wavelength.
And so there'd be the spectrum
of what it gives you.
Okay.
And if you follow that equation
to higher and higher energies,
it blows up.
And it was called
the ultraviolet catastrophe.
Nice.
Now, we knew that's not happening
in the actual universe.
Right.
But we had no theoretical understanding
of why the actual universe
was not doing what our equation said.
So we knew something was missing.
Okay.
And Max Planck comes along,
finished the story.
Yes, and Max Planck comes along,
and he suggests an idea
that he never fully believed.
This is interesting.
He suggests that maybe the energy
only comes in packets
of certain quantized sizes,
and therefore your calculation
of the amount of energy
was biased by assuming
that energy could come
in arbitrarily large or small amounts.
If you assume it only comes
in packets of a minimum size,
then the total energy
inside that cavity is finite.
It actually converges and drops off.
And it agrees with experiments.
Right.
But the weird thing is...
And he got an equation.
The equation is like,
holy shit,
that would come out of someone's head
to make this happen.
It's got an exponential,
and an exponential has
interesting properties
where it goes up
and then it comes down again
if it's a negative exponent.
I mean, there's a fun math in there.
And was it just a fitting function,
or did he actually have
deep physics insight?
He had a model in mind.
He really quantized the energy.
He broke it up into little bits
and redid the calculation,
and that's what came out.
But then later on,
he never fully believed
that energy in light,
in photons, as we now call it,
did come in little packets.
Right.
He said, sure,
the math seems to describe it,
but I'm not willing to go
to that next step
of ascribing a full reality to it.
And so it's really Einstein
who came along
and came up with the idea
of photons more particularly
with the photoelectric effect.
And that's how he wins
the Nobel Prize.
Many people think he won
the prize for special relativity
or general relativity.
No.
My boy Kushner could have had
eight Nobel Prizes.
His Nobel Prizes are for
what he's least famous for.
Right.
Yeah.
But perhaps most impactful.
That just means you're a gangster.
That's straight up.
But in terms of impact.
Right, exactly.
There are people winning
Nobel Prizes for discovering
things that he predicted.
Right.
So if you add everything
he predicted to the
Nobel Prize count,
plus what everything,
if they gave out Nobel Prizes
for everything you did,
I give him eight Nobel Prizes.
What would you give him?
Well, certainly gravitational waves,
although again,
he didn't fully believe it,
but it comes right out
of his 1916 and 1918 paper.
I'm saying if you give him
a Nobel Prize for everything
people discovered based on his stuff.
Well then,
it's kind of everything,
I think.
Yeah.
Persons on the Nobel Prize
receiving, writing,
nope, you're taken.
Right.
It's like that Bugs Bunny,
first base, Bugs Bunny,
second base, Bugs Bunny,
third base, Bugs Bunny.
Yeah, every Nobel Prize
is Albert Einstein.
That's the answer right there.
Yeah.
And so, of course,
since if energy is quite
quantized,
thus is born
the branch of physics
called quantum physics.
Quantum mechanics.
And that probably has had
the greatest impact
on life as we know it.
And that was the year 1900.
Yeah.
Well, 1905 is when Einstein
writes his paper
on the idea of photons,
but Max Planck,
you're right, was 1900.
Max Planck was clean 1900,
starting a new century.
Yeah.
Before they even had calculators.
Oh, was that, really?
Was it that far back?
Yeah.
As you may know,
we recently posted a video
in response to Terence Howard's
appearance on Joe Rogan's podcast
where he discussed
his interpretation of maths.
And key points to take away
from that are,
one, we should critically analyse
all the information we come across,
and two, be open to our views
being challenged.
Like this new study on dark matter
being debunked, for example.
It suggests the universe's expansion
is not driven by dark energy
but by weakening forces of nature.
Now, when it comes to new theories
that challenge
our accepted understanding of space,
it's important to see
how different scientific sources
are interpreting these new findings
to fully understand it.
Luckily, ground news
makes this much easier to do.
With the Vantage Plan,
you get access to original research,
plus every article covering it
and even insight on each news publication's
political bias and credibility.
Their founder and former NASA engineer
also designed their Blindspot feed,
which uses patented technology
to help us easily step out
of our echo chambers
and see important news stories
we might have otherwise missed.
Exposing yourself to diverse perspectives
helps ensure that you don't just know
enough about an issue
to think you're right,
but you actually know enough
to recognise when you might be wrong.
So, avoid the Dunning-Kruger effect,
get ground news,
and critically analyse
the information you consume,
all for $5 a month
if you use our link or scan the QR code.
You're saving 40%
on the same Unlimited Access Vantage Plan
you use with the discount.
We really can't recommend ground news
and their commitment to rigorous analysis
and combating misinformation enough.
Having said all of that,
let's get straight back to the show.
We're old enough to remember
when the United States lost
the most powerful collider in the world,
the superconducting supercollider,
which they already,
there was money allocated,
they started digging a hole,
it was a 200-mile circumference,
there was something huge,
and superconducting,
it was going to use superconducting magnets,
which had very powerful magnetic fields,
and because that was coming of age at the time,
it was going to push the frontier.
My analysis,
if you read the report,
well, there were cost overruns,
and we have too many other priorities here,
so we're going to zero the budget
for the superconducting supercollider.
And you read the report and say,
well, we have other priorities,
plus this was going to be built in Texas,
and if we're going to build the space station,
which is based in Houston,
Texas was already getting a chunk of change.
You know when all this happened?
Between 1989 and 1992,
when the debates,
and then they zeroed the budget.
What else was happening over those years?
Let me think.
Oh my gosh,
peace broke out in Europe.
No longer do we need the physicists
to protect us from the evil,
godless communists.
That's what I think was the subtext of that story.
Damn you, Harmony.
Because no other particle accelerator
was ever canceled for any reason
that was designed, conceived,
and built in the 20th century.
So if you grant me one conspiracy theory,
grant me that.
But then you think they kept the space station
because that was the place
where the new battles might be waged?
Possibly, yeah.
It's what we're looking at right now
when you think about it.
Yeah, with the space force and everything else.
So that's where I am on that,
but I say this only to note that
once that got canceled,
the center of mass of particle physics
went across the pond to Europe.
And then CERN,
the European Center for Nuclear Research?
Somewhere in there, yes.
It's a French acronym
when the words are in the French order or something.
That's it.
It goes there.
And I think our lawmakers
don't really understand
that if we don't do the physics,
someone else can and will.
We don't own all access
to future discoveries of science.
And so now Europe does it.
And so they went ahead,
built a large hadron collider,
and they successfully found the Higgs boson,
the big holy grail.
July 4th, 2012.
Look at that.
Was it July 4th?
That's sticking it to us.
Wow, that really was.
And you know they really found it on June 28th.
You know they found it on June 28th,
and they were like,
But there are a lot of Americans involved
in the large hadron collider.
But yes, exactly right.
Peter Higgs, is he American?
Peter Higgs is Scottish, I would think.
I think he's from Edinburgh.
Although I think he was Edinburgh,
but I don't think he was Scottish.
Maybe he was English.
I don't 100% know.
But yeah, he predicted its existence,
and then it was discovered,
and at the announcement,
saw tears welling in this man's eyes
who'd been waiting decades for this idea
that at first nobody believed,
ultimately was accepted theoretically,
but it was proven experimentally finally in 2012.
And what is the Higgs boson?
Exactly.
Of the particle categories,
one of them is bosons.
Right.
And bosons are force-mitigating particles.
Okay.
So when we think of a force action at a distance,
there's a way to think about that
in terms of the particle
that in the category of particles is a boson.
One of the bosons is this Higgs boson,
which has what properties?
Was I right?
Yes, very good.
Thank you.
He said I was very good.
Hey, can I answer?
Take it, Brian.
Please.
It's what endows other particles,
even itself actually, with mass.
Interesting.
Now where does that come from?
Well, just to take Neil's idea,
it starts with the idea of a field.
That's how you get rid of this idea of action at a distance.
You imagine that space is filled with stuff.
You don't invent the fields?
I really don't.
Michael Faraday.
Oh, really?
Well, that makes sense.
He was the first to think about it.
And think what a leap that is.
It's huge.
It's an insane leap.
You take it for granted,
there's nothing there.
You're looking at nothing,
you're seeing nothing.
And yet you're positing that there is something there,
and that's an amazing thing.
But he was talking electric and magnetic field.
Right.
What Higgs is talking about is a new field called
the Higgs field,
which he didn't call it that,
but that's what we call it.
So it's this field that fills space,
and as particles that otherwise would be massless,
as they try to go through space,
they have to burrow through the Higgs field.
And that creates a kind of drag force on them,
which is what imparts the mass that they have.
Okay.
And that's the field.
Now what's the particle?
Well, if you have this field,
in principle,
if you hit it hard enough,
like hitting the surface of water,
you can cause little particles of the field to spray out.
Right.
And that's what the Large Hadron Collider did.
It slammed proton against proton,
and that way jostled the Higgs field
and caused a little droplet of it to break free,
and that's the Higgs particle.
And then we got the, oh my God,
so you're seeing an actual piece of the field.
Yes.
Oh my God.
So the Higgs field generated via equals MC squared,
its own particle of its own.
That's amazing.
That's right.
Its own DNA.
Or you can say it's a quanta,
to go back to the other language,
it's a quanta of the Higgs field,
like the photon is the quanta of the electromagnetic field.
All right.
That's amazing.
That's some stuff.
So.
Okay.
Okay, now I get it.
So it's not the particle that you're actually seeing.
It's not the particle that is imbued with mass itself.
It is the thing on which the particle is traveling,
the field, the medium itself.
Boom.
It kind of splashes apart for a quick second,
and then that itself becomes a particle and has mass.
Holy.
Wait.
That's amazing.
That is amazing.
Chuck just blew a gasket.
Oh my God, that's crazy.
Dude, that is insane.
Call the doctors.
This is the first time I've actually really understood.
Call the doctors.
Because.
Oh my God, that's so freaking crazy.
Oh my God.
A week later, he's there in bed still.
Eyes this big.
That is fantastic.
So my favorite analog to this.
Yeah.
Is when I explain the Higgs field to people,
I say it's like a Hollywood party.
Okay.
So there are people in the party.
Right.
All right.
And the bar is at the back of the wall.
Okay.
And if no one knows you and you walk into this party.
Okay, that's my experience.
You have near zero resistance to movement through that party.
True.
So you have a very low, if not zero, party mass.
Exactly.
Okay.
Because you have no.
You get into the bar right away.
You get in the bar right away.
Right.
So your inertia, it knows no resistance there.
Exactly.
Whereas Beyonce walks in, everybody will crowd around here.
She can only make very small steps towards the bar.
She has a very high party mass.
Is that fair?
That's awesome.
That's the party field.
The party field.
And then if you slap all those party goers,
you can slap off one of them.
That's the party particle.
Somebody from the beehive pops out.
Oh my God, look at Beyonce.
Oh, there it is.
All right, so I have learned, not from you,
and I'm disappointed because I thought you would have told me the whole story.
Yes.
I come to you for these frontier conversations,
that the Higgs mass that a particle would have is only for free particles.
If a particle is in an atom, it's not getting its mass from the big field.
I have told you this in the past, though.
I absolutely have.
But you're absolutely right.
I'm a fat proton in a nucleus.
I'm not getting my mass from the Higgs field.
No, and that's why it's a really misleading notion that many people have.
They think that all mass comes from the Higgs field.
It is just the fundamental particles.
And here's the thing.
If you were to go up into your particle data book,
which I know you have a few copies lying around in here.
It's very good.
If you look up the masses of the quarks,
the up quark and the down quark,
that make up a proton up, up, and down, add up their masses.
He said that quickly.
Up, up, and down.
The nucleons have three quarks.
Right.
And they're all bound together, making up the proton and the neutron.
But they're different combinations of three quarks.
This is good.
Tell them.
So quarks have charges, fractional charges.
Yes.
So watch this.
Okay, go ahead.
Proton has a charge of plus one.
All right.
How do you get that from three quarks?
Yeah, how do you do that?
So give it to me.
You got to have a two-thirds and a two-thirds and a minus one-third.
Two-thirds, two-thirds, minus one-third.
So two-thirds plus two-thirds is one and a third,
and then a minus charge to bring it down to one.
Now, neutrons have charged quarks inside of them,
but they don't have any charge.
So how do you get them?
How do you get them?
Let's hear it.
Oh, it must be up two-thirds, down one-third, down one-third.
Yeah, so if you have an up and then a down and down-down,
then you got a two-thirds, minus one-third, minus one-third.
Cancelling out, and so it's a neutral thing.
Even though what's inside of it has charges.
Right, but here's the thing.
The point I want to make, though,
is if you add up the masses of those quarks,
they're much less than the mass of the protons.
So what's going on here?
They make up the proton,
and yet the proton's much heavier than its ingredients.
Answer is there's another contribution to the mass,
which has nothing to do with the Higgs field,
which is the thing we were talking about before,
the energy in the glue holding the quarks together.
Oh, the gluonic force.
The gluonic force.
Energy holding them together equals mc2.
There's mass associated with that energy,
and most of the mass of the proton
is coming from the glue that's holding the quarks together.
That's insane.
So let's take a neutron,
which has a half-life in minutes,
like 15 minutes, if memory serves,
and after that amount of time,
half the neutrons will have decayed into a proton,
let's say if it's a regular proton,
and then an electron.
An antineutrino.
If you add up the masses of those,
don't you recover the mass of the proton?
As long as you're taking kinetic energy into account.
Yes, of course.
Because they fly away.
They fly away.
But yes, but yes.
So the energy budget is all there.
It's all there.
Okay.
Look at that.
So everything is conserved.
All the time.
And in fact, the way the neutrino was predicted
was from looking at these particle decays
and finding that the energy budget was not adding up.
And so the idea was maybe there's an invisible particle
that's carrying away some additional energy.
Was this Enrico Fermi?
Yes.
So what I like about this is he's like,
look, folks, I can't explain this.
Let's make some shit up.
Yes.
But geniuses make up shit that's right.
There's a quote.
That's a quote.
That's a bumper sticker right there.
That's it.
I'm getting a T-shirt.
That's awesome.
That's great.
That's what Carl Sagan was famous for saying.
They laughed at Einstein.
They laughed at, you know, all these people with these great ideas.
And he said, they also laughed at Bozo the Clown.
So just because people laughed doesn't mean they're going to be wrong.
He makes it up, and then everyone starts looking for it,
and it's this highly elusive particle that has no charge,
because we knew all the charges had already balanced in the lab.
It's got no charge, but it's carrying away energy
and no one has detected it.
And he was Italian, right?
So neutrino is like little neutral.
Little neutral.
Little neutral one, I think.
Oh, that may be right.
Little neutral.
Little neutral one.
And so that's the only thing that allows me to,
okay, I'm not going to get in your way.
When people say dark matter,
it's some elusive particle that we can't detect
that's accounting for the extra gravity,
and we haven't found the particle yet.
And I'm thinking that's intellectually lazy,
but it's no different than neutrino.
So that's why I cut it some slack, more slack than I otherwise would.
Now, we still need to find it.
We still haven't found it.
If it's a particle, we haven't found it.
Yeah, right.
So are you a betting man?
Is it a particle or is it something else?
Look, I'm relatively conservative when it comes to these things,
so I think that it's likely to be a particle.
Just because we've been down that road before.
We've been down that road before.
It fits in so well to our theoretical framework.
It doesn't require—
Do you have a slot for a dark matter particle?
Well, the amazing thing is,
and here's where you're going to come back at me and say
this should undercut my confidence.
When you look at a theory called supersymmetry
that I've spent a long time working on.
Okay.
Within this theory,
which goes beyond what we know about particle physics
for reasons that are well-motivated.
Because that's ordinary symmetry.
That's right.
It takes the symmetries that we have,
and it takes them one step further,
and it's the only step further that you could possibly go.
So of course nature must make use of this final symmetry principle.
Why else would it exist?
That's the thinking that we've had.
Wait, just let me back up for a minute.
So as I was learning particle physics,
I was intrigued to recognize that you have your electron,
you have your photon,
you have your neutrino,
and these other sort of basic particles.
And they exist in our world that we live, we experience.
Okay.
If you up the energy knob,
other particles manifest.
There's a version of the electron
that manifests only in these higher energy levels,
and it's called a muon.
Right.
Okay.
And so there's a whole layer of particles
sitting above the ones that are in our world.
Right.
So there's three of these layers.
And tell me the three electrons.
You get the electron, the muon, and the tau.
The tau.
Yeah.
Okay.
And there's an electron neutrino,
there's a muon neutrino,
there's a tau neutrino.
Right.
So now I have three layers here,
and you have access to them in your particle accelerators,
because it takes a lot of energy,
and you can get there.
Yeah.
Okay.
Now what does supersymmetry do with this package?
Supersymmetry says that...
This package is...
Beautiful and confirmed.
And tell me the three force carriers.
We have a photon.
You have the photon,
then you got the gluons,
you have W and Z bosons,
or the weak nuclear force.
Okay.
And those are the three forces.
Discovered by Bozo.
Right.
Bozo.
Actually, Bose.
Bose is an Indian physicist.
Yes, absolutely.
And then for the quarks,
you got the up and the down that we spoke about.
You got the charm, the strange,
you got the top and the bottom.
Right.
So again,
they come in three pairs of two.
Oh, okay.
Supersymmetry says take all of those particles
and double them.
Another shadow version of all of those particles.
So shadow governance.
For the electron...
We are the puppets.
This is the deep state.
They are the puppet masters.
The quantum deep state.
Wait, wait, wait.
So I didn't know this.
The entire set of particles
would have a counterpart
in this supersymmetric place.
So for the electron,
you have the supersymmetric electron.
For the quarks, you have squarks.
For neutrinos, you have neutrinos.
People just making shit up.
You run out of names after a while.
Look at the latest cartoon.
But here's the thing.
This is all mathematically motivated
by a completely compelling rationale.
So this is not pulled out of thin air.
We have our universe three ways.
A three-layer cake.
And there's a whole other cake.
Where does that live?
With us.
But we believe they're more massive,
which is why we wanted to build
the superconducting supercollider
to try to find them.
Now, we've looked for these
at the Large Hadron Collider.
If they're so massive,
why aren't they right here
in front of our faces?
They typically have short lifetimes,
so they'll decay into lighter particles.
But the lightest
of the supersymmetric particles
would not decay,
and therefore, it should be all around us.
Tell them why the lightest one
would not decay.
If it's the lightest one,
when it decays,
the decay products have to be
lighter than it.
Okay.
And so if it's the lightest one,
subject to a certain conservation law...
There's no place for it to go.
It's the same reason why
you can have an energy field
of any kind,
and you will not make particles
out of that.
Right.
Unless the energy available
is higher than the E equals MC squared
of two electrons.
Right.
Because it has to make them in pairs.
Okay.
To keep the charge conserved.
To keep the charge,
because it's a plus and a minus.
Right.
An electron is the lightest
physical particle.
Right.
So nothing's happening.
Lightest charged particle.
That's why it's not happening
around us right now.
Yeah, it's the lightest
charged particle,
so it has to talk
the electromagnetic field.
There it is.
That's why light coming
from lights
is not just making particles.
It doesn't have enough energy.
If it did?
If x-rays started coming out of there,
x-rays, high energy x-rays,
you can pop electrons
into existence.
Right.
Because they're stepping down,
so they leave something.
The energy of the field
is big enough
to create the electron
and anti-electron,
and so it will pair produce them.
In fact,
That's so wild.
electron microscopes
are enabled by x-rays
creating them,
and the wavelength of x-rays
is so tiny
that you can see tiny detail.
It's tinier than the detail.
You can't have resolution
higher than the wavelength
of light that you're using
to see it.
Right.
Now, back to dark matter,
just to finish this point.
So this is a whole massive
other layer cake,
and you're telling me
that is the mass
of the dark matter.
Well, the lightest
supersymmetric particle
would be stable,
should be around us.
So maybe it's filling space.
Right.
And here's the beautiful thing.
This will blow your mind.
My mind's already blown.
When you do the calculation
of how much of this
lightest supersymmetric particle
should be left over
since the Big Bang,
it exactly matches
what you need
to be the dark matter.
It comes in the right abundance.
Dang.
And yet we've not found it,
and it may be the wrong answer.
So sometimes things
that just seem so deeply compelling
are wrong,
but we don't know yet.
Wow.
So do you know enough
in the theory
of these particles
to predict
how you should detect it?
Yes.
Now, they can vary
which is the lightest
supersymmetric particle
on the flavor
of the supersymmetric theory
you're looking at.
But in any given version, yes,
you know exactly
how the particle interacts.
Okay, so now you have
everybody's favorite flavor,
the theorists,
come out with their
competing models,
but still,
they've got to have
one of these particles.
Okay.
So now I'm an experimentalist,
and it's how many tests
for this one?
I don't find it.
Let me test for that one.
I don't find it.
So it's not looking good.
Yeah, I agree.
Okay.
I agree.
Okay.
Wow.
I agree.
But yet,
when I was a student,
it was almost
a foregone conclusion
that you just had
to look for it,
you'd find it,
this is the dark matter,
because supersymmetry
also solves other problems,
the so-called hierarchy problem
that solved the dark matter problem.
It's a beautiful idea
that seems perhaps
not to be right now.
It's not fully ruled out yet,
but that may be
where we're going.
Who's the one that said
the great tragedy in science,
a beautiful theory,
slain by some facts?
Yeah.
Somebody said that,
I forgot,
400 years ago.
I think that's exactly
what it may be.
Hey, StarTalk fans,
I don't know if you know this,
but the audio version
of the podcast
actually posts a week in advance
of the video version,
and you can get that
in Spotify,
Apple Podcasts,
and most other podcast outlets
that are out there.
Multiple ways to ingest
all that is cosmic on StarTalk.
I have not been the same
since we had lunch months ago,
and you explained to me,
and I've said it here,
that there are ideas percolating
that the fabric of space-time
might be woven by wormholes
that connect the virtual particle pairs
that come in and out of existence,
and that if they're connected
by wormholes,
rather than just some field,
then the wormhole
is an actual structural texture
of the universe.
Yeah.
In fact, the other way-
I'm sorry.
First of all,
I need some weed.
To even deal with this.
Because I'm trying to figure out
what you just said
because it's so frickin-
I mean, it really is just crazy.
Well, let's back up.
The vacuum of space
is not a vacuum
because quantum physics requires what?
There's all sorts of uncertainty,
and that uncertainty means
that there's fluctuations,
and therefore there are
particle-antiparticle pairs.
There's energy fluctuations.
There's field fluctuations.
Right.
It's a roiling mess
out there in space.
So there's no nothing.
There is no such thing as nothing.
That violates uncertainty.
There's truly nothing.
Right, there's truly nothing.
We couldn't have uncertainty.
So the uncertainty is, you know,
gives us the fact that
we do have virtual particles.
Yes.
We know that they popped
in and out of existence.
Well, what you're trying to tell me-
I think-
It's not that we know they're there.
How do we know?
No one denies it
because it's completely consistent.
Well, the Casimir force,
where you actually put
two metal plates
in otherwise empty space,
they should simply sit there.
They're drawn together,
and our best explanation is
it's the virtual pairs of particles.
It's the fluctuating field.
Did you know about the Casimir force?
I did not.
I feel like I have fallen into
a Star Trek nightmare.
So you take two
exactly parallel plates.
Okay.
Okay, and evacuate
what's in between.
In between them.
That makes sense.
The best vacuum you can muster.
Right.
Then you slowly move them together.
Right.
There is a point
within which
a whole other force kicks in.
That's right.
And it's not the gravitational force.
It's not electromagnetic force.
Rather, it's a force
that comes from
the Casimir field,
which is basically...
That got a Nobel Prize?
The Casimir?
Well, 1948
is when it was discovered.
Okay.
It got one in my book.
But it should have.
You just gave it one.
I just gave it one.
It definitely deserved one.
That's insane.
But it's an imbalance
between the fluctuations
of uncertainty
within the plates
and the fluctuations
of uncertainty
outside of the plates.
And it's that imbalance
creates a force
that puts them together.
Yeah.
Okay.
So that's how we get
the particles
in the vacuum of space.
Okay, so now...
Unbelievable.
So now,
why a...
What compels you
to say wormhole
rather than just a field?
Well, because
it really comes from
the idea of quantum entanglement.
Oh, yes.
What we find is
that entanglement,
which normally
we think of
as particle pairs,
but now we're finding
that the vacuum of space
may be stitched together
by the threads
of quantum entanglement itself.
So deep down
within the substrate
of reality,
it may all be stitched together
by quantum entanglement.
And then,
other work shows us
that quantum entanglement
connecting two particles
is just like a wormhole
going from one to the other.
Because what happens in one
happens to the other instantly.
Yes.
And that means they're touching
each other in that instant.
They're connected
in some weird way.
And entanglement
is one language,
but we believe
wormholes may be
the general relativistic version
of that quantum language.
So it's like
a little quantum net
holding the whole universe
together.
Exactly right.
Because we find,
we find mathematically,
if we cut the threads
of quantum entanglement,
which we can do mathematically,
space falls apart.
It discretizes
into little tiny pieces
and it just disappears.
I gotta go.
No, Chuck.
I need you to the end of this.
Chuck, don't leave me.
Don't leave me, Chuck.
Oh my God.
That's insane.
It's not just that
there's a field there.
It's the fact that
they were quantum entangled
that makes the wormhole
model compelling.
Yeah, but I would say
you don't even need
the particle pairs.
It's as if the entanglement
is entangling regions of space.
So space itself
has a fundamental substrate
woven by these threads
of quantum connection.
Now look, it's mathematical,
but it comes out
of our cutting edge ideas.
It all makes sense.
It just makes sense.
He's not pulling it out of his ass.
He's saying the math gave it to him.
The math works.
And he started out saying
my boy loves the math.
Now, last thing.
Yeah.
Explain why you need
more than four dimensions
for your string theory universe.
Well, it's a very
concrete explanation.
When we look at the equations
of string theory,
there's a consistency equation
where something must equal zero
or the math doesn't work.
That something is a product
of two things.
One term is really complicated.
It's never zero.
The other term is
the number of dimensions minus 10.
The only way to get it
to be equal to zero
is for D to be equal to 10.
That's it.
I am not joking.
This is where the constraint
of extra dimensions comes from
in string theory.
The math is forcing our hands.
Forces your hand.
And then you say,
well, let me take this math here.
One thing you could say is,
well, if it's not D equals four,
three space and one time,
throw the theory away.
Others of us will say,
hey, let's consider the possibility.
Don't sell the universe short.
Yeah, exactly.
So why should these
three dimensions of space
be the only ones?
Right.
We only are aware of them
because they're big enough
that we can be directly aware
of them with these really
faulty sensors that we have.
If it's only your sensors
that limit that awareness,
Yeah.
why not in principle
can we build something
that can gain access
to these higher dimensions?
Yeah.
So there are experiments
on the table.
Some have been carried out,
but more precise ones
may be done
where you study
Newton's law of gravity.
Why does Newton's law
go like one over R squared?
Why do we teach our kids
GMM over R squared?
It's a geometric
Geometric sphere
in three dimensions of space.
Yes.
Look at that sphere
in four or five or six dimensions
and the two in Newton's law
won't be a two.
No.
It'll be a bigger number.
The fall off will be differently.
And so look at
the gravitational force
on very small distances.
Look for a deviation
from the one over R squared
that Isaac Newton
told us about
in the late 1600s.
Okay, because that's only
in our dimensional measurement of it.
Yes.
Okay, because I'd ask you,
again, over that same lunch.
Yeah.
Why do we have lunch?
I forgot.
We were hungry.
No, no, no.
We were just catching up.
You know, it's my annual fix.
My annual Brian Greene infusion.
It was could dark matter
be ordinary matter
with ordinary gravity
in a parallel universe?
Because for reasons
I don't understand the math of,
the field theory equations of,
you were telling me
that electromagnetic energy
cannot escape our space-time,
but gravity can.
In a certain model
called the brain universe,
where our universe...
B-R-A-N-E.
It comes out as a membrane.
Yeah, it's a membrane.
So our universe is like
a four-dimensional membrane
floating in a higher
dimensional universe
that might have other membranes.
Higher dimensional membranes.
Yes, and those other membranes
are parallel to us,
like two slices of bread
in a big loaf of bread.
I like it.
So one slice of bread
is some other
membranial universe.
Ours is this one,
but it's one multi-brain.
Okay, and so gravity
could leak out of one
into the other.
Or it could just be the...
Yeah, that's right.
So the gravitational pull.
That's what I'm getting.
So if the other universe
has six times...
See, this is where
you corrected me,
because I was thinking,
because we have six times
as much force of gravity
operating in the universe
as matter and energy
can account for it.
Okay.
It's a factor of six.
Right.
So I'm saying,
why isn't it just
a parallel universe
that has six times the mass,
and it's leakage
into our universe,
and we're trying
to feel the elephant,
trying to figure out
what it is,
but it's just regular matter
in another universe
whose gravity leaked.
But then you said,
if it's in another membrane,
it's going to be
dropping off faster
than one over r-squared.
Yeah.
Like one over r-cubed,
or some higher dimension.
Yeah.
And if that's the case,
it has to be way more
than six times.
But you could imagine
rigging it so that
it would have
the right amount.
Yes.
And people have studied this,
and it's hard to make
these theories work
in detail.
And be all self-persistent.
it's an idea that's
absolutely worthy
of investigating,
because that's one way
to make it invisible.
Just put it in another membrane.
Yeah, just stick it
somewhere else.
Yeah, exactly.
And then we can still
calculate with it.
It's not a problem.
Yeah.
Right.
Yeah.
That's crazy.
Man.
Oh, man.
All right.
I don't know what to believe
about anything.
Nothing is real.
Nothing is real, man.
Dark energy.
I'm curious about this,
because it was a natural
arithmetic element
of Einstein's equations.
It's like an integration constant,
as I understood it.
You're talking about
the cosmological constant?
The cosmological constant
in his equations
that enabled Le Maitre
to calculate that
the universe is either
expanding or...
But the universe is not static.
And so there's a term there.
And if you've had calculus,
you might remember
there's a constant of integration.
Often it's just zero
and you can ignore it.
But when we were
in graduate school,
I'm a little older than you,
when we were in graduate school,
we always recognized,
we paid homage to that constant,
but said,
let's assume it's zero.
If this term existed,
it would mean
there was a force
operating in the universe
opposite that of gravity.
Depending on the sign
of the cosmological constant,
but yes.
Because it could have either sign.
It would either work
with gravity or against it.
But if we had a static universe,
it would be something
just holding up the universe
against the collapse of gravity.
Which is why Einstein...
And we didn't have any reason
to think it...
So it could be zero,
but we always had to go
through that portal.
We say, here it is,
we set it to zero and move on.
Exactly.
Okay.
Then it gets discovered.
Okay, dark energy gets discovered
in 1998,
gets the Nobel Prize,
using quantum physics,
which is done so well by us,
perhaps the most successful theory
ever about anything,
fails in its attempt
to predict the amount
of dark energy in the universe.
Yeah.
And it fails badly
by a factor...
What's up with that, Brian?
...of a googol.
Wow, by a factor of...
Bigger than a googol.
10 to the...
It's like 10 to 123 or something.
Googol is 10 to the 100th?
Yeah.
It gets the wrong answer
by the biggest amount ever
in a mismatch between theory
and observation.
Yeah.
Where are we
with the dark energy theorists?
Well, look,
what this is showing us
is that quantum mechanics
is incredibly successful
when you apply it
to the electromagnetic force,
to the weak nuclear force,
to the strong nuclear force.
But we've long known
that when you apply it to gravity,
something goes wrong,
something changes.
This is the motivation
for string theory,
and this is the motivation
for trying to go beyond
conventional approaches.
And so you're absolutely right.
This is the clearest signal
that something is wrong.
Now, here's...
Well, that's not something's wrong.
That's actually a good thing.
Well, it's an opportunity.
Opportunity.
That's the word.
Yeah, it's a huge opportunity.
Yeah, the press always says,
oh, scientists are angry or this.
No, we're delighted.
Right.
If something breaks, oh, my gosh,
it's a new thing.
Exactly.
That's right.
And so I would say
my guess where we're going is,
and many of my colleagues
agree with me,
that you can't quantize gravity
the way you had to quantize
Faraday and Maxwell's
electromagnetism,
or the way you had to quantize
the weak or strong nuclear forces.
It may be that gravity
and quantum mechanics
are already so intimately connected
that it's a completely different
mindset when you approach them.
You don't take the rules
of quantum mechanics
and slap them onto gravity.
That gets you the wrong answer.
That's the wrong approach.
In fact, this idea of entanglement
in wormholes suggests that
gravity and quantum mechanics,
they're already in there.
They're already there.
That makes sense.
They already have the shotgun wedding.
It just was an attempt.
Exactly.
So you just need to understand
that melding better,
and when you do,
perhaps you'll be able to do
a calculation of the
cosmological constant
and get the right answer.
Right.
Yeah.
Now, another answer might be
maybe the cosmological constant
is not a constant, right?
There's recent data.
They're working on that now.
Yeah.
Maybe it's changing over time,
and so you don't actually
calculate the number.
You just need to understand
the dynamical process.
However, doesn't the math
in general relativity
require that it be constant?
No.
That's how it came out
of the integral.
There can be a constant,
but it doesn't have to be
the only contribution
that looks like that constant,
and the other contribution
can change over time.
It can be a constant,
but it doesn't have to look like
and then...
No, it's not the only contribution
to that term.
So you can have a field
that slowly varies over time,
and that field may dominate
its contribution.
So that field is meta
to that equation.
Yes.
Look at that.
It is meta to that equation.
Oh, my gosh.
Absolutely.
So Einstein did not talk
about that field.
No, he didn't.
No, he wasn't there yet.
And you're right,
and he did talk about the constant
because you're right,
it's just an integration constant.
It's an integration constant.
It's right there.
It's a constant.
So if, in fact,
it needs to modify,
because that's how
they reconcile this tension
in the age of the universe.
Yes.
Because the age of the universe,
there's...
In my day,
we didn't know it
by a factor of two.
Now people are...
I mean, it's not...
There's a 10% difference.
So it's more than 6,000 years.
Is what you're saying.
Yes, that's exactly
what I'm saying.
Yes, yes, yes.
When Noah's flood took place.
So to relieve the tension,
as we describe it,
this was a 10%,
some single-digit percent.
Uncertainty in the age of the universe.
Actually, not uncertainty.
These two methods
have very small, tight uncertainties
that do not overlap.
That's why everyone is freaking out.
And as I learned recently,
you can resolve that
by allowing the cosmological constant
to vary in some way,
but that's a meta variation
on top of...
Yes, yeah.
No, this Hubble tension
that people are struggling with today
is exactly something
that also may point toward
a dynamical value.
So we'll see.
Right, right.
But yes,
the true test of a version of gravity
that you fully understand
with quantum mechanics included
would be a calculation
of the cosmological constant
and get a number.
Are you and your people
smart enough to get this figured out?
I don't think so.
And that's our show.
Good answer.
Because you know,
I've dragged you over the corner
about that.
We have come full circle.
Because I told him,
I said, look,
you know,
Einstein came up with
general relativity
in 10 years
by himself.
You strength theorists,
dozens of you
have been working on this
for decades.
Either you're all wrong,
or you're all just too stupid
to figure it out.
And it's probably a combination.
Love you, man.
Brian, thanks for coming back.
My pleasure, thank you.
Always good, Chuck.
So great.
Chuck, we'll find you
in the hospital.
Bless you.
I'm completely fried right now.
I'm fried.
Just to take us out,
let me remind us all,
we are in my office
at the Hayden Planetarium
of the American Museum
of Natural History.
The Cosmic Crib.
And after this conversation
we just had,
I delight in realizing
and celebrating
the fact that
just a few pounds
of organic matter
inside of our heads
can not only contemplate,
but figure out
how the universe
works.
And yes,
we still have a long way to go.
And we don't even know
how long a way to go
remains in front of us.
But the distance
we've come thus far
gives us everything
that we call civilization.
And it's the power of mind
over the mysteries
of the universe.
And that is a product
of the eternal curiosity
expressed by our species,
beginning in childhood,
continuing, for some,
into adulthood.
We call them scientists.
Those who never lost
that childhood curiosity.
Brian Greene, of course,
among them.
So I'd like to just
give a shout out
to our species
for all it has wondered
as we looked up at night.
All that we have discovered
and all that we have yet
to figure out.
That is a cosmic perspective.
I'm Neil deGrasse Tyson,
your personal astrophysicist.
Keep looking up.