China's All-Terrain Vehicles Hit the Battlefield | TDTV

China Insider TV
242 followers
46 Video Views·Jan 21, 2025
The Financial Times reported on December 3 that Russia has purchased over 2,000 all-terrain
vehicles from China.
The first batch has already been deployed for battlefield use.
The all-terrain vehicle is called ATV, which stands for all-terrain vehicle, meaning a
vehicle that can travel in various terrains.
Chinese people are accustomed to calling this type of vehicle a beach car, meaning it can
navigate through soft sandy beaches where regular vehicles would struggle.
The manufacturers selling these vehicles to Russia is Odessa Industrial in Shandong, China,
and the model is the Desert Rover 1000-3.
This vehicle weighs 1,600 kg, is relatively lightweight, with a payload capacity of 550
kg.
It can accommodate three infantrymen, and behind the driver's seat, there is a compartment
that can carry 220 kg of cargo.
It can perform tasks such as reconnaissance, search and rescue, patrol, and transportation
in complex terrains.
Actually, before the Financial Times report, there were already videos circulating.
In early November, there was footage showing Chinese-made vehicles during Putin's inspection
of the Southern Military District.
The fact that Russia has acquired these Chinese vehicles for use in warfare is not breaking
news.
The breaking news is the disclosure of the details of the transaction.
In November, Russia received the basic model of this vehicle, a total of 507 units, all
deployed to the front lines.
Additional 500 units are expected to arrive before the end of this year, and in the first
quarter of next year, 1090 units will be delivered to Russia.
So, in the last quarter of this year and the first quarter of next year, a total of more
than 2,100 of these vehicles will be delivered to Russia.
This is currently the largest and most concrete arms deal disclosed by the Chinese Communist
Party to Russia.
Regarding the use of these vehicles on the front lines, there is now very conclusive
evidence.
Just a day ago, a video was uploaded on YouTube, showing two Chinese-made all-terrain vehicles
being destroyed and abandoned on the battlefield.
In this footage, there are also photos of Russian soldiers posing with these vehicles
and segments of these vehicles driving on muddy Ukrainian terrain in the autumn and
winter.
In short, the widespread appearance of these vehicles on the Russia-Ukraine battlefield
is an undeniable fact.
As many military enthusiasts may wonder when seeing Chinese-made vehicles being destroyed
and abandoned, the first thought is, is there a quality issue?
Are these inferior products?
The vehicles seen being destroyed in the video are the basic models of the first batch, meaning
they do not have additional armor.
From the video, it can be seen that the part frozen through is the compartment behind the
driver's seat, where there is a large hole, resembling damage caused by an RPG, rocket-propelled
grenade.
The destructive power of RPG and similar weapons depends on the type of warhead they use.
The effectiveness varies significantly depending on the type of warhead, some of which have
armor-piercing capabilities, while others do not.
Based on the low resolution of the video and only two destroyed vehicles as evidence, it
is not possible to judge the quality of these Chinese-made vehicles.
This includes the Bradley Infantry Fighting Vehicle made in the United States, which has
a good reputation, including the American-made Bradley Infantry Fighting Vehicle, which has
a good reputation, but in the first two weeks of Ukraine's counteroffensive in June of this
year, losses exceeded 15%.
There is also the Leopard 2 Main Battle Tank, which is a world-class main battle tank made
in Germany.
By the end of August this year, Ukraine had received a total of 71 such tanks, of which
five were completely scrapped, and more than 10 were severely damaged, requiring extensive
repairs before they could return to the battlefield.
In another case, a 57-story high-rise building in Chonshak County, Hunan, was constructed
in just 12 days, sparking discussions both domestically and internationally.
The swift progress raised concerns about construction quality, especially as the construction company,
Yuanda China Holdings Ltd., had previously faced scrutiny for the world's tallest building
SkyCity project.
The practice of rushing construction schedules and large-scale Chinese projects has been
perplexing.
In a talk show on June 24, 2011, commentator Xu Zidong expressed confusion about the haste
in completing construction projects.
The hosts emphasized the importance of prioritizing safety over rushing construction timelines.
They cited examples such as the Shenzhen Bay Bridge and Hong Kong's New Airport, where
expedited construction led to operational issues and safety concerns.
Furthermore, they discussed China's high-speed rail projects and urged a focus on safety
rather than meeting political deadlines.
They cautioned against treating construction as a task, emphasizing the need for the utmost
safety and security.
Ironically, within a month of this broadcast, China's high-speed rail system experienced
a major accident.
The discussion also touched upon the Wenzhou train collision in July 2011, questioning
whether the high-speed rail accident was a natural disaster or a result of human error.
They pondered the role of Chinese media as either a mouthpiece for the people or a tool
of the government and the implications of accidents on China's pursuit of rapid GDP
growth.
In 2016, the New York Times reported that China witnessed a high number of work-related
accidents annually, occurring in coal mines, factories, construction sites, and on roads,
resulting in tens of thousands of deaths.
Official statistics for the first half of 2016 showed that 14,136 people died in work-related
accidents, a 5.3% decrease compared to the same period the previous year.
Fast forward to 2022, and according to the Chinese government statistics, a total of
20,963 people died in various production safety accidents throughout the year.
The number of deaths in work-related accidents per 100,000 employees in mining, commerce,
and industry increased by 22.7% from the previous year, leaving a grim impression of the situation.
To know, the lowest selling price, even in the United States, is over $20,000.
The prices of these vehicles that can be driven off the regular road surface, um, starting
prices are over $50,000.
If it's a military-grade vehicle, the price can be higher, even up to over a million dollars.
So, compared to this, the basic model of this all-terrain vehicle produced in China, its
equivalent price is just over $17,000, which is even less than the price of similar civilian
vehicles in the United States.
That basic model is one-third of the price, um, with such a low price, it is indeed difficult
to expect the quality to be good.
The Financial Times said that the price of the upgraded model, which is to be delivered
later, will be 2.1 million rubles.
According to the current exchange rate, this 2.1 million rubles is equivalent to just $23,000,
just catching up with the price of a Toyota Corolla in North America.
You say the quality has improved, but its price is still there, and it hasn't increased
much.
Now, it is still unknown where the upgrades of the subsequent models will be.
Are they armored and protected?
Of course, all the above information comes from the internet.
If there are any inaccuracies, please let the audience and netizens, especially experts,
correct them in the comments.
So, what we want to talk about today is what?
It is the focus on the batch of vehicles that Chinese companies are selling to Russia.
Currently, it is not about the quality, it is likely that there is a quality issue, but
we need to wait for more information to come out, and then we can discuss this issue in
detail.
Today's focus is on the fact that the Russian side has disclosed it themselves, and there
is very solid video evidence indicating that these vehicles have already appeared in large
numbers on the Russia-Ukraine battlefield.
Since this news has already been announced, then if China continues to deliver more, you
can't say you don't know, it's being used in war, right?
You can't deny that it is military equipment, right?
So, when facing the upgraded U.S. sanctions, there is actually no excuse.
That's the significance.
Some friends might say, wait, didn't we hear earlier that a large number of Chinese-made
shells had flowed into the hands of the Russian military?
That's even more direct military supplies.
Why can China still deflect blame?
These two situations are different because arms and ammunition have their own circulation
market.
Chinese-made arms and ammunition can flow into the hands of the Russian military through
underground channels, the black market, or even through third countries.
This is entirely possible in reality.
Not only Chinese-made military shells but also Western military aid to Ukraine could
potentially reach the Russian military through such underground channels.
So, Beijing can easily deflect blame by saying, as long as we didn't sell directly to Russia,
it's not our fault if others resold it.
So, they can deflect blame in this way, and it makes sense.
However, in the case we are talking about today, this specific product, the all-terrain
vehicle, ATV, does not have such a circulation channel.
When it appears in large quantities unilaterally on the Russian-Ukraine battlefield and is
used for military purposes by the Russian military, then the Chinese side completely
loses the excuse to deflect blame.
Therefore, it is like making it clear that they are challenging the United States.
This has caused confusion about Xi Jinping's policies.
What exactly are you trying to do?
When these all-terrain vehicles appeared in large quantities on the Russian-Ukraine battlefield,
which was in early November, it was the time when Xi Jinping was preparing to meet with
Biden in San Francisco.
At that time, the main theme was to ease Sino-U.S. relations.
Also, it was during that time that Putin inspected the southern military district of Russia and
revealed these vehicles.
This is obviously to pull Xi Jinping into trouble, to poison the atmosphere for the
Biden-Xi meeting.
It's like telling Biden, don't just listen to Xi Jinping's sweet talk there.
In fact, he has already sold things to me.
And Xi Jinping actually allowed these two things to happen at the same time.
So, what exactly is he thinking?
My speculation about Xi Jinping's thinking is roughly like this.
He thinks, if the United States can do this to me, then I can do the same.
You also sell arms to Taiwan, and I also sell military supplies to Russia.
These two things are not contradictory.
Xi Jinping wants to say, oh, you, the United States, can do it like this, then I can do
the same.
It seems that I am meeting with Biden to talk about easing tensions, but at the same time,
I am selling military supplies to Russia, and it doesn't seem contradictory.
Xi Jinping is imitating the U.S., but why does it feel wrong?
The problem here is that currently, the CCP is in greater need of the United States than
the other way around.
You can do this imitation thing, but the U.S. has follow-up moves to deal with you, such
as imposing sanctions on more Chinese companies and raising the threshold for investment and
technology transfer.
The problem now is not whether Xi Jinping can learn from the U.S., but that the U.S.
can completely bear the subsequent costs, while the CCP cannot.
If you do this, you are putting yourself in the position of an enemy to the United States,
making it clear that even though you are meeting with Biden, there is no sincerity in easing
relations, it's just changing your stance against the U.S.
So, the Biden-Xi meeting has become a pointless meeting.
Regarding a series of recent changes, including this news, the reaction of international capital
is, of course, very keen.
Therefore, let's talk about other important news in the past two days.
Moody's downgraded China's credit rating.
Moody's, the international credit rating agency, didn't just make a move, it's a combination
of punches.
Earlier this week, Moody's changed the outlook for China's sovereign credit rating from stable
to negative.
However, it kept the A1 rating for China's sovereign credit unchanged.
The so-called sovereign debt credit here refers to the credit of the Chinese Communist Party's
government borrowing.
What is the outlook for credit ratings?
This is the first adjustment Moody's has made to China's sovereign credit rating in the
six years since 2017.
The last adjustment six years ago downgraded China's credit rating from AA2 to AA3, but
at the same time, the outlook was changed from negative to stable.
In 2017, it was a period when China's social debt was rapidly increasing.
Here's a bit more explanation.
Moody's credit ratings are divided into 21 levels, from AAA, highest grade, to C, currently,
U.S. Treasury bonds are in this highest grade, AA, high grade, is also known as advanced.
Within this level, it is further divided into 1233 levels.
The credit rating for Japanese government bonds was downgraded from AA2 to AA3 in 2011,
but it still belongs to the high-grade category.
A single A, such as A1, is called mid-high grade and is also divided into 1233 levels.
Currently, China is in the A1 category.
Well-known rating agencies like Moody's are very cautious when adjusting the ratings of
countries with political and economic significance like China.
They are measured and do not make spring-like adjustments all at once.
They usually take a step back before taking a step forward, or they take a step back and
turn around.
For example, in the 2017 adjustment, China fell out of two AAA grades, which was a significant
rating change, but Moody's changed the outlook from negative to stable, offsetting some of
the shock.
This year, they changed the outlook from stable to negative, which also had a cushioning effect,
even though the sovereign credit rating for China, A1, remained unchanged.
But is the situation the same as in 2017?
Certainly not.
Moody's has other ways of expressing a more pessimistic outlook.
On Tuesday, Moody's adjusted the credit rating for China's sovereign credit, and on Wednesday,
it lowered the investment rating outlook for 40 Chinese companies from stable to negative.
Notably, 18 large non-financial enterprises need special attention, including 13 central
enterprises such as PetroChina, Sinopec, and CNOOC, as well as two local state-owned enterprises,
China National Railway Group and Dongfeng Motor Corporation.
It even includes large private companies like Tencent and Alibaba, lowering the outlook
for their credit ratings to negative.
You should know that these companies are considered the flagship enterprises of the mighty nation
in the eyes of the public and are symbols of China's rise as a great power.
However, they cover everything from central SOE to local state-owned enterprises and even
large private enterprises, all of whom had their credit ratings downgraded.
What does this mean?
It reflects Moody's more profound and essential pessimistic view of the Chinese economy.
They only made adjustments to the investment credit ratings of individual companies, right?
You can't say they are pessimistic about the entire Chinese economy, can you?
How to interpret it is everyone's own business.
So, this is how major institutions operate.
They won't say some things directly, and they won't reveal everything at once.
Moody's credit rating adjustment can be considered a belated one.
What are their reasons?
In their report, they gave two main reasons.
One is that there is increasing evidence that the government and public sector will need
to provide more financial support to local governments and state-owned enterprises, posing
downside risks to China's finances and economy.
There is increasing evidence that the government and public sector will need to provide more
financial support to local governments and state-owned enterprises, posing downside risks
to China's finances and economy.
What does this mean?
It's essentially saying that the debt of local governments and state-owned enterprises
in China is continuously increasing, they keep borrowing and this poses significant
risks.
Why does the rising debt pose risks to China's finances and economy?
In fact, we discussed the reasons in a recent episode about U.S. debt.
Although the national situations are different, the principles are the same.
By the way, I'm planning to transition the content of the program a bit, creating more
refined, vivid, and slightly less current affairs-related episodes, similar to Evergreen's
Evergreen-type content.
Back to the topic, the direct consequence of increasing debt is that eventually, you
have to pay back.
Even if the government can keep issuing new bonds and rolling over old ones, you still
have to pay interest.
As the debt size increases, the government's interest payments increase, right?
Whether it's the central government or local governments, how do you pay the interest?
Ultimately, you can only do it through increased taxes.
If you raise taxes, where does the money for investment and consumption come from?
This affects economic growth, leading to the risk of an economic downturn.
However, if the government doesn't raise taxes, it will have a hard time repaying maturing
debts, leading to fiscal risks.
So, increasing debt brings these two risks.
Now, the debt of central and local state-owned enterprises is essentially guaranteed by the
government, so their risks ultimately become government risks, and they are considered
in the same category.
As mentioned earlier, issuing new bonds to repay old ones can work if the conditions
are right.
In reality, though, it's not sustainable because you have to assume that by issuing
But if your debt is already harming the economy, and even the current prosperity is not stimulating,
people are tightening their wallets, and everyone just wants to lie flat.
What do they use to buy when you issue new debt in the future?
When new debt subscriptions fall short, and you can't even achieve the goal of replacing
old debt, it inevitably leads to the government's inability to repay maturing debt, and that's
a burst.
The government has no way to repay the principal and interest on maturing debts.
China is currently rapidly heading down this path.
Recent articles and programs I've seen, as long as they can speak freely, financial influencers
all have a consensus, China's local government debt, in the end, can only be diluted through
a round of inflation, besides printing more money.
This is the first reason Moody's gave for lowering China's sovereign credit rating.
They also gave another reason, stating that China's structural and sustained low-medium-term
economic growth, as well as the increasing risk of continued contraction in the real
estate industry.
This sentence is a bit tricky.
What does continuous contraction in the real estate industry mean?
It means real estate companies are collapsing one after another, right?
If many companies go bankrupt, the overall size of the industry decreases.
So, you see, these major institutions speak in an interesting way.
They won't say that China's real estate industry is experiencing a wave of bankruptcies, instead,
they say the industry's size is continuously shrinking.
For the Chinese government, it indeed plays the role of dismantling the stage.
So, domestically, public opinion immediately counterattacks.
The Chinese government quickly organizes a group of writers, claiming that Moody's has
made three major misjudgments about China, and so on.
However, these writers have low influence and low credentials.
If Moody's is a massive pillar, they can't even be considered toothpicks.
When the building is about to collapse, a single piece of wood is difficult to support,
let alone toothpicks.
Moody has joined the chorus of those pessimistic about China, acting like a big tuning fork
in the symphony.
So, it will undoubtedly have a series of related consequences.
We'll discuss more as subsequent news unfolds.
