Alain Corbani of Montbleu Finance recaps gold's 2024 performance and looks forward to 2025. He has a price target of US$3,000 per ounce for the year ahead, and in his view, the direction of interest rates in the US will be the most important factor to watch.
He also shared his thoughts on the performance of the gold stocks, explaining why they aren't rising across the board.
"The sector has not performed in a homogenous way — it hasn't. It only performs in a homogenous way at the end — at the peak of a cycle," Corbani explained during the conversation. "For those who don't know where we stand, I can tell them already that we are not at the peak of the cycle — we are far from the peak of the cycle."
❓ Will the gold price reach US$3,000 in 2025? Tell us in the comments!
I'm Charlotte McLeod with InvestingNews.com, and here to be with me is Alain Corbani.
He is Head of Mining at Monbleu Finance and Manager of the Global Golden Precious Fund.
Thank you so much for being here.
Always great to have you.
Thank you, Charlotte.
It's always a pleasure to be with you.
Yes, I always enjoy our catch-ups.
And since we are very nearly at the end of 2024, of course, we're going to spend some
time looking forward at the new year.
But before we go there, I wondered if we could take a quick look back at gold in 2024.
Any themes that stood out to you, surprises, takeaways that you have?
So 2020, when we had this interview, the same interview a year ago, we strongly believed
that gold would hit the $2,500 level.
And for the fundamental reasons that we explained, and that we are going again to update the
viewers today.
But basically, the scenario is unchanged.
And we think that there is more room for gold to hit $3,000 in 2025.
But backward, 2024 was a very good year for billion, for physical gold.
It was a very good year for silver, physical silver, less so for platinum and palladium.
But this is a very different topic.
And we're going to focus, unless you ask me other questions, but we're going to focus
on gold and mainly gold and maybe on the side silver.
So silver and gold had a great year.
The disappointment came from the gold miners.
And when gold, what year to date, were up 25-26%, the gold miners are up, if I look
at the major gold miner indices, they are up 10%, 14%, 15%, 16% for the silver miners.
So they underperformed the underlying commodity.
And this is a disappointment.
But this is year to date.
But if we had stopped counting two months ago, this class of assets had outperformed
billion.
And the main reason is the inversion of the perception in October, October, November,
of the direction of interest rates.
With our new U.S. president coming into office in January and the statistics showing that
he had significant chances to be elected president, to win those elections, the market's starting
to shift.
And they're starting to discount what they call the Trump, the Trump trade.
And the Trump trade was about more growth, more inflation, and that induced a less dovish
monetary policy.
And this is exactly what the market has been playing over the last two months.
So we are in that honeymoon phase that for us is not going to last very long.
And even though the Federal Reserve has been, they were in December, very, very sure about
their dot plots and the fact that rates would move slightly lower, but not much.
And the inflation would be around two and a half percent.
And the growth rate for 2025 of the economy, U.S. economy, would be around 2.1%.
Well, if that's the case, and we don't believe it's going to be the case, but if that's the
case, rates should stabilize at these levels.
And this is why we had this consolidation in the price of gold and a consolidation in
gold miners.
OK, I think that's a really good look back at 2024, and it gives us a lot of different
paths to go down.
I want to ask you a little bit more about the Fed in 2025, because when we had, as you
said, the same conversation last year, we talked a lot about the Fed.
And I remember what you had told us is when the Fed pauses, this is when we have the gold
price go up.
And of course, we had that pause and now we have the Fed going down.
So maybe we can hear a little bit more about what you think is coming from the Fed in 2025
and what that could mean for gold.
So we should we should always listen to what the Fed says and try to put those words in
a context of fundamental data.
So in December, let's let's look at what the chairman of the Fed, Jerome Powell, said in
December. He said basically that we are closer to the neutral rate.
And to say that we are closer to the neutral rate means implies that he is not going to
lower rates much more from the current levels.
And this is what the market is playing.
The market is positioning for very limited interest rates cuts in 2025.
Actually, if you look at the statistics of the future, what the futures are telling us
is that basically they think that we will have only one 25 basis point cut in 2025.
So what I'm saying to those who believe in that scenario, and there are many, many of
them believing in that scenario, is that we are in an environment where you have leading
indicators who are showing a weakened economy, a weakening economy, an inverted yield
curve that is un-inverted and now is in positive territory.
Inflation, everybody's focusing on the last couple of months, the numbers of the last
couple of months. But the reality is that remember that inflation was at 4.5 percent not
long ago, less than two years ago.
We're at 4.5 percent.
We're down to 2 percent now, to 2.5 percent.
And suddenly everybody's expecting a resurgence of inflation.
There is a resilient economy, there is a resilient inflation, but it doesn't mean that the
economy is not going to weaken.
There are too many indications, too many indications that are showing, and to start with
the labor market, that are showing that demand is going to weaken.
And if demand weakens, therefore growth will weaken.
And if growth weakens, we will have, the Fed will have to intervene and lower rates much
more aggressively than what we're discounting today.
OK, really interesting to go into that.
And if we take a look a little bit closer at the U.S.
economy, are you somebody who thinks that we're heading toward a recession or what do you
see coming in that regard?
Well, there are some, the Fed has has been really focusing a lot on the labor market
lately and rightfully so.
And if you look at the job openings in the U.S., those numbers keep, keep slowing down.
And I remind you that in 2022, that number was at 12 million, 12 million job openings in
2022, and we're down to 7 million today.
The 7 million, to put them in context, is back to pre-COVID numbers, statistics.
And back before COVID, we were trying desperately to have a growth rate above 2
percent and we had no inflation, hardly any inflation.
And we believe that we're going back to that normal, old normal, which was 2 percent
growth and probably some inflation, but not much more.
And we'll need lower rates because today the nominal rates are at very restrictive
levels. And this is what very few people understand.
You cannot have a 2 percent growth rate and have a restrictive monetary policy.
And this is where humbly, very humbly, I find it very strange that we can have nominal
rates, the Fed Fund rates at 4.5 percent, 4.25 percent, and inflation at 2 percent or
2.5 percent, and expect these levels to remain at this level without impacting
negatively the economy.
This has never been the case before.
We don't think in new paradigms that will allow you to evolve with 4 percent, north of
4 percent. The 10-year, US 10-year notes are trading at 4.6 percent and very limited
growth. Mind you, some growth, but very limited.
So to be a little more concise, I will say that we won't call the recession, but we
definitely are calling for a weaker economy because when the labor market weakens, demand
weakens. And if demand weakens, the economy will weaken.
This is as simple as that.
And that implies lower rates going down in the next few months, at least in 2025, and
definitely not, we're definitely not in the cap of those who think that rates will
stabilize at this level, we don't.
OK, OK, I definitely see what you mean there.
And looking a little bit closer at inflation, if you had to put a number on where
inflation is going in 2025, what would you say?
Because it feels like we're in an interesting scenario.
You mentioned the Fed is focusing less on inflation right now, more employment.
We're not at the 2 percent target just yet.
People are definitely feeling inflation, I think, in their everyday lives.
And we have Trump coming in.
Lots of questions about if his policies will be inflationary.
So what are your thoughts there?
So let's let's spend two seconds on Donald Trump and the animal spirit that that he
represents. He was elected.
The main the main concern of the American people was and the reason why they voted for
Donald Trump, the main one was inflation.
It wasn't immigration.
It was inflation.
Can you imagine a second that this animal spirit will not try to accomplish what he
promised on that front?
I am I'm one of those who truly believe that he's got this in mind and this president
and and the House and Congress will will try will try to to fight inflation.
Now, the actions or the promises of the actions are tend to demonstrate that those
actions could be could trigger more inflation, which which implies that maybe those
actions will not be put into into practice.
So from wordings to action, there's a huge gap.
And we think that this administration, the future, the January administration will
definitely have in mind the fact that the American people want this administration to
fight inflation.
And and and we will and we will have this.
I think that this is only time will tell.
But my belief is that this administration is definitely the same as the Biden
administration. They know that inflation is a main, main hurdle, obstacle, and they they
have a target that they need to achieve.
Will they achieve it?
They will only achieve it through a weakening economy.
And we believe that we're going to have a weakening, weaker economy.
And let me remind you one thing.
When when if we look back to the 2016, 2020.
Trump mandate.
He is not the one who saved the economy from from the recession.
In 2019, it was Jerome Powell who saved the American economy from the recession by
lowering rates.
So, you know, same recipes will end up with the same results.
So we do not believe that those tariffs, those aggressive positions that that the new
administration will will put in place or will develop will end up in different results than
what we had early in the previous presidency.
So we we we look at the numbers.
The numbers show that Trump Trump's policy in from 2016 and 2020 without the
intervention of the Fed wouldn't have avoided the recession.
So we're back to the initial the core of the subject is what will the Fed do?
The Fed will lower rates.
I can tell you that already when the economy is going to weaken and the economy is about
weakened because there are too many indications that show that the labor market is
weakening, that the delinquencies, I mean, you name them.
There are 10 million Americans who are now delinquent on their student loans.
You have car loans, delinquencies, large hitting records that we haven't seen in 15
years. So the people is suffering.
The American people is suffering and it's suffering because of inflation, maybe, but
not inflation per se, but by higher prices.
And Charlotte, give me one second to explain what higher price and why higher prices are
different from inflation, because we had so much inflation that we had that prices have
reached levels that are destructive for for the demand.
It's not about going from a present level to a higher level.
Those levels are already very restrictive and conductive of pain for the consumers.
And this is exactly what what is happening.
It's not about inflation.
It's about prices that are too high, already too high for a lot of for most of the
American people. I think you can.
I think that's an important distinction to make.
And you can really see how all the different points that you're talking about come
together. So this is all important for gold in 2025.
Are there any other factors outside the U.S.
maybe that you're watching when it comes to gold in this coming year?
Well, everybody we do, but but again, we know and his because history is telling us
that the main main the key element that you have to to look at is the direction of
rates. Now, this being said, everybody will want to discuss about the behaviors of
central banks and how are they still buying and how much are they buying gold?
That's an element.
The second element is, of course, people will talk to you about geopolitical risks.
Are they being on the rise or not?
We never believed that the geopolitical risk was a key element to to forecast the
direction of the price of gold.
And you have, of course, the investment demand and the investment demand is basically
the the second most timely ingredient to to help forecast the direction of the price of
gold. And and if you look at those speculative positions, the long and the short in the
gold market, you realize that the shorts are non-existent.
So don't expect the support from the shorts for the price of gold in the short term
because they are non-existent.
And the long have been taking profits.
So technically speaking, you had already a 35 percent correction and ideally we could go
maybe to 50 percent.
But but this will take the price of gold to probably twenty five hundred, twenty five
fifty. But it won't go lower than that.
So not speculative positions, the future market, the central banks, investment demand
and and and the direction of rates, because remember one thing, the markets don't care
about politics.
They care about the economy.
So we can talk about politics as much as we want.
But I know for a fact that this is not a key element to that that will give us a
direction for the price of gold.
I think it really helps me when you put them ranking them in that order.
So I know that what is most important to you, I think that helps me understand a lot
more. So this is what we should be watching for gold next year.
I want to take a little bit of a closer look at the price.
So when we talked last year, you'd mentioned that twenty five hundred level.
And of course, we got past that.
And at the beginning of this conversation, you're talking about getting to the three
thousand level. So is that a 2025 story for you or how is it looking in terms of price?
Yes, for us, it's definitely a 2025 story.
We think that the long term neutral rate is not at these present levels.
It is not. It's closer to two and a half percent.
And that implies that the Fed will be more aggressive cutting its rates.
This is what it implies.
And in the meantime, we will all be watching the data on the inflation front because
everybody wants to look at inflation to give us a direction, but also on the labor
market. And we truly believe that the labor market will be the leading indicator for
lower rates ahead of us.
And and we see that labor market weakening month after month on very different
fronts. And on the labor market front, one one more thing.
You have the government employees and you have the private sector employees.
And if you look at what happened to the job openings in the private sector, you see a
continuous decline quarter over quarter over quarter, whereas on the government side, you
had a more or less stable rate of of openings.
And this shows how the labor market would have been much weaker had the government, the
public sector not been helping those data in that significant manner.
So the economy is weaker than what we think.
If you look at the profitability of of them, this is really not or maybe out of subject.
But it's important for it for the viewers to understand that the S&P 500 is not the
American economy.
The American economy is the 5000 companies.
And if you look at the top, the bottom 3000 companies, more than 40 percent of them are
not profitable, more than 40 percent versus less than 10 percent for the S&P 500
company. So the economy is weaker than what we think.
The labor market would have been weaker without the help of the public sector.
And inflation is indeed a resilient number, but it's not because we have a little bit of
inflation. We're not talking about three, three and a half, four percent inflation.
It's not because we have a little bit of inflation, then that the economy cannot weaken
and it will probably weaken much more than what we think.
But for the time being, if we look at the statistics from the that everybody's looking
from the Federal Reserve of Atlanta, we're still at three percent for Q4 2024.
So we'll see.
Time will tell.
But we are on in the camp of those who think that too many numbers are showing a
weakening economy that will force the Fed to lower its rates.
And this will be the other, not the other, the only factor that will help gold reach
3000 in 2025.
And and it's it's a fairly clear picture for us.
We there are no there are no hurdles to to achieve this target.
It's just a question of of time.
And and and the picture would be probably much clearer for everybody further down, down
a few months down, down into 2025.
Yeah, it does feel like we're in a little bit of a waiting period right now.
And once we get through the next few months, it'll start to become clearer, just like you
said. So I'll throw in just a small question about silver since it came up a little bit
at the beginning of our conversation.
So we've got a pretty, pretty open pathway for gold to 3000.
Where do you see silver in 2025?
As you know, silver is is more volatile than gold, simply because the market is much
smaller than than gold and and with silver, you always have this industrial factor that
gold doesn't have.
But basically, they go hand in hand.
So if gold is going to 3000, silver will definitely do extremely well, regardless of the
demand that could be affected by a lower economy.
But the lower economy implies lower rates, lower rates imply a market turning very
positive for the head of us.
And and silver will do very well.
So we are extremely constructive on silver because because we are constructive on
gold, knowing that silver is much more volatile.
And something that has really attracted my attention yesterday was the jump in shorts
of the silver ETF.
So I mean, that the number of shares that were shorted in less than a month was that
number doubled in a month's time.
So we have a ratio covering ratio of more than two and a half, which is which is not
extreme, but it's violent and we don't like violent moves.
So expect more volatility, even more volatility with silver than than in the past
because of those short positionings that probably will have a hard time settling at
lower prices.
OK, OK, extra volatility for for silver in the next little bit.
So we'll keep an eye out for that.
And before I let you go, of course, we want to take a look at the gold stocks.
So at the beginning of the conversation here, you had mentioned there's some
disappointment in 2024.
And I remember last year we were talking about gold stocks and you mentioned we were
moving from phase one, which was about strengthening the balance sheets, focusing on
profitability into phase two, which was more about growth.
So how is that transition looking to you right now?
What are you seeing there in terms of that?
It's definitely in motion and has been in motion for the last two years.
But it's growth that is very, very well thought that is that is fundamentally logical.
And by that, I mean we are not growing for the sake of growing, we're growing in a
clever, in a clever way.
We purchase assets that are accretive and we are buying growth that is going to be
accretive and we don't build debt at the expense of the balance sheet.
So it's it's it's very sensible and it's a slow.
It's in it's really in in the early days.
I said that it's the last two years.
Yes, but it's it's it's slowly and very slowly picking up.
So and and when you look at the those gold miners, what is important is is to see how
they behave in the sense that what price are they willing to pay to achieve that
objective? And and in their case, the price is very, very reasonable.
In essence, it's accretive.
So I haven't seen one M&A announcement that didn't make sense or couldn't be
explained to the shareholders in a in a constructive way.
So so far, so good, but it's slow, slow motion and and and still very, very shy.
They are still very shy and because they see their balance sheet growing up, but
they are still very confused about the strategy that needs to be implemented with
that cash that that is being built.
So because they remember very well what happened in the past and I can tell you
already that two years down the road, those emotions they have about what to do
with their cash will have disappeared completely.
But we're not there yet.
We're not that yet. It's it's really the infancy of the of the growth strategy that
is being that we see being implemented in the sector.
Yeah, I think you're going in the direction where people have a lot of questions
right about the gold stocks we've seen.
Of course, there's been some companies that have done well this past year, but
people are really waiting to see those across the board gains and the gold stocks
across their portfolio.
So not for you.
Is that going to happen 2025 or that's down the road?
It it is it is I think it's a it's definitely I mean, the the performance of
the majors put aside the Newmont and the Barrick because they each had their
very, very different profiles and which affected the performance of their of their
shares. But globally speaking, the performance of the gold miners has been
extremely eclectic, extremely.
And and a lot of explorers, a lot of developers have been really, really have
had poor performances and we had disasters.
Actually, many disasters announced many disappointments.
So so this the sector has not performed in a homogeneous way.
It hasn't. And it only performs in a homogeneous way at the end, at the peak of
the cycle. So for those who don't know where we stand, I can tell them already that
we are not at the peak of the cycle.
We are far from the peak of the cycle.
And another and maybe that number of people will better grasp it.
It's the profitability of the sector.
Usually the sector peaks when the readjusted net margin, the net profitable of the
operations is north of 20 percent.
And now we're turning around 15 percent, 14 percent.
So there and the only way to increase the profitability, the only way is for gold to
go higher.
We're not there yet.
So we need a higher gold price to reach a higher profitability.
That will be the peak of the cycle.
We haven't seen this frenzy in M&A activities.
Every growth strategy implemented is very reasonable.
All that shows that the sector is really preparing for a better years ahead of us.
But let's not say years.
Let's stick to 2025 and see where we get, when we get to the 3000 and how those players
behave, because it's all about their behavior.
Their behavior will tell us if we have reached the peak of the cycle or not.
I can tell you already that until we reach 3000, I don't see any reason to get out of
the sector.
OK, I think I've got one more question before I let you go.
And OK, so keeping in mind that we're not in this time yet when we have those homogenous
gains all the way across the sector, we've got to do our work still right now in terms
of gold.
Any advice you would share for investors who are approaching the sector in 2025?
I will tell them to diversify.
I will not give them, you know, very original advice.
If you are not a specialist, you diversify because even specialists can miss some
disappointments.
So let's be humble, first of all.
And the only way in a sector that has a 35 percent volatility, 35 percent, it's huge.
So for a non-professional, I would advise diversification.
That's the only way to reduce the volatility and to increase the expected return on your
investment.
OK, I think that's that's some really solid advice to end on heading into the new year.
So thank you so much for coming on to talk about gold markets.
A little bit of silver.
This was really good.
Always happy to have you here.
As usual, Charlotte, it's a pleasure.
Once again, I'm Charlotte McLeod with investamuse.com.
And this is Elaine Combrani with Bombolo Binance.
Thank you for watching.
If you like this video, make sure you hit the like button and subscribe to our channel.
We'd also love to hear your thoughts, so leave us a comment below.