"Teaching Military History: Why and How? A History Institute for Teachers Walling presenting Thucydides"

History TV Epic
4 followers
5 Video Views·Jan 12, 2025
In the world of international politics, much has been made of the concept called the Thucydides Trap. Thucydides's Trap postulates that catastrophic war is a forgone conclusion when there is a new power rising that threatens the domination of an established power. Sadly, this reflexive concept has been idea-laundered throughout international think tanks for years, resulting in policies that demand the disintegration and weakening of the United States and the capitulation to the Communist Chinese Party. Today we will examine the trap of looking at the Thucydides Trap as an inevitable event as opposed to a situation that can be easily avoided through diplomacy and open discussion
This is The Causes of Things, and I'm your host, Michael O'Fallon.
It was 2,400 years ago that the Greek historian Thucydides said the following in his historical
record of the Peloponnesian War. It was the rise of Athens and the fear that this inspired in Sparta
that made war inevitable. This phrase that originated from Thucydides is used both wrongly
and rightly to explain the likelihood of conflict between a rising power and a currently dominant
one. It's called Thucydides' Trap. It is applied today to describe the global situation between
the establishment-dominant nation of the United States and the rise of communist China. And never
before has a nation risen so far, so fast, on so many different dimensions as has China.
The challenge is the impact and how China has risen. The discombobulation this will cause the
United States and the international order, of which the United States has been the principal
architect and guardian. And as a matter of fact, without the United States and their assistance,
China would not have the rise that it currently has, which is something we need to get into a
little bit more in a future episode. But the past 100 years has been what historians now call
the American Century. And if you are in the United States, you've heard the term
American Exceptionalism. Well, American Exceptionalism was a dirty and terrible
phrase in some of the circles that I have been in over the past 12 years.
What I heard from a number of my Chinese friends and clients over the past 12 years was the phrase
Chinese Exceptionalism, or Asian Exceptionalism, which as I learned later, would have potentially
disastrous implications on the entire world. And when I say this, I mean for the Chinese people
and Asian people as well. And we want all Asians to prosper, all Chinese to prosper.
We do. We want all men and women to have the equal opportunity to prosper and turn their toil
into dreams with unlimited potentiality. But what is the disastrous part? The truly frightening part
is the totalitarian mercantilist nations that are wanting literal world domination.
And the ideas that govern their rise bring death, draconian control, and the loss of
individual autonomy wherever these ideas govern the masses. But let's step back in time and put
into context this concept of Thucydides' Trap. Roughly 2,400 years ago, Thucydides expressed
a view that resonates in strategic thinking to this day. And once again, Thucydides argued that
the real cause of the Peloponnesian War and the rapid increase in the power of Athens,
and the fear that this aroused in Sparta, which had dominated Greece thus far, is what led to
this conflict. Thucydides focused his writings and analysis on the structural tensions caused by a
sharp change in the balance of power between the rivals of Athens and Sparta. He pointed to two
main factors that contribute to this change. The aspiring power's growing need for validation,
and its demand, rather implicit or explicit, for a greater voice and strategic place in multilateral
relations. And the current power's fear and determination to defend the status quo.
In the 5th century BC, Athens emerged as a powerful force that in mere decades had become a
possessing financial resources and wealth, but also reaching primacy in the Greek world in the
fields of philosophy, history, literature, art, architecture, and even beyond that. So in many
ways, this would identify what most would consider a hegemony. In Thucydides' historical record,
human emotion made conflict inevitable. And at several points where peace was possible,
emotion unfortunately propelled it forward. In the beginning, there is a set of speeches in Sparta,
debating the possibility of going to war with Athens. Archidamus, the Spartan king,
tells the Spartan people not to underestimate the power of Athens and urged that Sparta
must not be hurried into deciding in a day's brief space a question which concerns many
lives and fortunes in many cities and in which honor is deeply involved. But we must decide
calmly. Now, even though Archidamus, the Spartan king, said this, the Spartan ethor advocated,
quote, vote therefore Spartans for war as the honor of Sparta demands, end quote. The Spartans
followed the ethor, which led to a war of honor and fear against the Athenians. Thucydides argued
that Athens' behavior was understandable. With its rising power, its confidence also increased,
as did its awareness of past injustices and determination to right the wrongs
that were committed against it in the past by Sparta. But equally natural, according to Thucydides,
was the behavior of Sparta, which interpreted Athens' behavior as ungrateful and a threat to
the system that Sparta had created and under which Athens was able to emerge as a great power.
Does any of this sound a little bit familiar? This combination of factors resulted in structural
tensions and subsequently a war that completely devastated all of Greece. In addition to the
objective shift in the balance of power, Thucydides drew attention to Spartan and Athens' leaders'
perception of the situation, which then led to an attempt to increase their own power through
alliances with other countries in the hope of gaining a strategic advantage over their rivals.
The lesson that Thucydides taught us, however, is that alliances are a double-edged sword. When a
local conflict between Corfu and Corinth broke out, Sparta felt that to maintain the balance it needed
to help its vassal, Corinth. The Peloponnesian War began when Athens came to Corfu's defense,
and Corfu leaders convinced the Athenians that a de facto war with Sparta was already underway.
Corinth also convinced the Spartans that if they did not attack Attica, they would be attacked by
Athens themselves. Corinth then accused the Spartans of misunderstanding the gravity of the
threat of maintaining a favorable balance of power in Greece. And although Sparta ultimately
won the Peloponnesian War, both Athens and Sparta came out of the 30-year conflict in ruins.
So with what Thucydides had brought us in terms of his understanding of the Peloponnesian War
into today's world, what many are trying to do is trying to take the conflict that happened
then between Sparta and Athens and apply it directly to what's happening between the United
States and China. But I think that this is improper. But in the United States over the past
50 years, the story of the rise of the conflict between Sparta and Athens has been wrongly applied
by several of the power brokers in the international globalist movement. First and foremost would be
former U.S. Secretary of State Henry Kissinger. And on the other side of the Pacific,
Xi Jinping, the communist Chinese leader who has put his nationalistic ambitions above honesty and
goodwill negotiations, stated, quote, we all need to work together to avoid the Thucydides trap,
destructive tensions between an emerging power and established powers. Our aim is to foster
a new model of majority country relations. Keep that in mind in the next few podcasts because that
relates back to the Belt Road Initiative as well as their continuing discussions with the World
Economic Forum. Another voice in the conversation surrounding Thucydides trap would be the
President Emeritus of the Asia Society, member of the Council on Foreign Relations, and Hang Lung
CEO, Ronnie Chan. And full disclosure is necessary here. I have known Ronnie Chan and his brother
Gerald very well over the past 12 years and served them in different capacities. But I believe that
the story of Thucydides trap is misapplied and forced in this situation to try to describe the
rise of China and as well the relationship with the United States. And in all the studies that
pertain to Thucydides trap, especially when it's being used as a reflexive theory, the main idea
is that the new power, and in this case China, the challenger, is going to compete to the death
to displace the old, the current dominant nation or rule, which in this case would be the United
States. But again, there seems to be a forced narrative that is trying to reflexively take
Thucydides trap over the past 50 years and make sure that everyone is talking about this as if
it is something that is inevitable that must happen. And the specific discussion has been
recently reanimated because of military and political developments at the international
and domestic arenas. And the narrative in regards to the debt diplomacy driven,
neo-colonizing nation of China is that somehow we must achieve detente by gradualistic decline
of the United States. It's as if this is a foregone conclusion by the international community
along with China. So to avoid war, to avoid any kind of conflict that could result in World War
3, the powers of the world must cooperate to create that gradualistic decline of the United
States. They must have some of those within the United States as well precipitate that decline
so that China may rightfully rise along with other partners, which I believe we're up to,
I think around 136 partners in the Belt Road Initiative right now, to rise with these other
partners together for a great reset, a great move forward, a great leap, if you will, into
the fourth industrial revolution. But there's a few things that are getting in the way.
And one of those things that's getting in the way is that old-fashioned American
insistence on rugged individualism, privacy, self-reliance, democracy, and entrepreneurial
spirit. Mix in, of course, national pride, constitutional law, and autonomous rights,
and you have a problem in achieving your great global reset. You see, because giving up personal
privacy and guaranteed rights is not something that the vast majority of Americans are really
willing to do. So if the entire rest of the globe participates in the creation of what will be called
a circular economy, that is Davos-speak, by the way, for a Keynesian socialist economy,
then either the United States will be embargoed by the world and forced into a difficult, almost
no-win situation. America will have the leverage of the weight of China and the rest of the nations
participating in the supranational scheme applied against its neck. And we got here
over the past 50 years by proclaiming the need for global participation to avoid
the catastrophic consequences of Thucydides' trap. And of course,
this is all nonsense. It didn't have to happen like this. We didn't need to have the rest of
the globe partnering with a nation that is literally committing genocide against its
Muslim population in western China to come to this. We didn't need to have the rest of the
globe trying to avoid the horror of a possible third world war by partnering with the monstrous
totalitarian state that tramples over treaties and crushes the rights of Hong Kong and Taiwan.
We didn't need the fertile fallacy of Thucydides' trap. This is all alchemy. Thucydides' trap is
another example of what I call Pygmalionism. And if you recall, in the ancient Greek fable of Ovid's
Metamorphoses, Pygmalion was a Cypriot sculptor who carved a woman out of ivory. According to Ovid,
after seeing other women prostituting themselves, Pygmalion declared that he was
not interested in women, but then found his statue was so beautiful and so realistic
that he fell in love with it. In time, Aphrodite's festival day came,
and Pygmalion made offerings at the altar of Aphrodite. There, too scared to admit his desire,
he quietly wished for a bride who would be the living likeness of my ivory girl.
When he returned home, he kissed his ivory statue and found that the lips felt warm.
He kissed the statue again and found that the ivory had lost its hardness. Aphrodite had granted
Pygmalion's wish. Pygmalion married the ivory sculpture, which changed to a woman, under
Aphrodite's blessing. So in Pygmalionism, also what we can refer to as reflexivity,
you avoid the objective issues in order to achieve the end you wish to create,
with subjective insistence that some potential catastrophic end must be avoided. In other words,
whatever you wish to make true, you make true by continuing to talk about it, by continuing to
think about it. And what was a non-reality, you make into a reality. That's Pygmalionism.
That's also the answer to Thucydides' Trap, not unlike the global climate scare tactics
of Extinction Rebellion. Thucydides' Trap will create a global World War III if we don't find
a way to create managed decline in the United States now. So Graham Allison writes a book about
Thucydides' Trap. Thucydides' Trap is constantly discussed in our military circles within the
United States. Thucydides' Trap is talked about as almost an inevitable conclusion of what will
happen with the relationship of the United States and China within the halls of Congress. And the
Asia Society, and Ronnie Chan, then of course have to have conferences with Graham Allison
discussing Thucydides' Trap ad nauseum, non-stop. Because now you have invested in trying to stop
Thucydides' Trap, which is a non-event. It's only a possibility. And in conversations in the circles
that I have been running in over the past 12 years in Washington DC, London, China, New York,
Los Angeles, I have had to endure hours and hours of lectures and discussions on Thucydides' Trap,
the Pygmalion reflexive wheel in full effect. So if the entirety of the political, governmental,
military, and corporate world believes that everything must be done to avoid Thucydides'
Trap, it will lead nations to do the unthinkable. To join hands with the Communist Chinese Party.
To place all their bets on the rise of China and the slow deconstruction of the United States.
To avoid a war that would never happen. To deconstruct and weaken the United States for
the purposes of avoiding a global war with China. Handing the keys of the United States
over to a supranational entity and joining in peace and prosperity in the fourth industrial
revolution with China. So how do ideas like Thucydides' Trap become instant doctrine, instant
dogma within our military circles, our political circles, our geopolitical think tanks? How do
these things become almost permanent fixtures that everyone must direct policy on, direct their
conversations on, direct their future plans on, direct their investments upon? How does this happen?
Well, it's through a process called idea laundering. And what is idea laundering?
And how idea laundering has been essential forwarding the reflexive response to the theory
of Thucydides' Trap? Well, idea laundering is essential in creating a fertile fallacy that
we've talked about many times before. That is shared and shared over and over again. That is
fallacious information referred to as science or knowledge. But instead of science that is being
derived through the scientific method, it's being derived by what someone wants to do operationally
in the future. To be able to create. Hence the Pygmalion effect. It is a part of the process
moving away from political science and into the idea laundered realm of political alchemy.
So once again, I'd better define alchemy again for everyone who hasn't heard our past programs.
So alchemy is not the science that you and I have understood that seeks objective provable truth.
So where the scientific method seeks to understand things as they are and are provable,
alchemy seeks to bring about a desired state of affairs. Or it just wants to make something
happen and needs to create research, even false research, to achieve its end objectives or goals.
So to put it another way, the primary objective of science is truth. Alchemy's goal is
operational success. So this brings us to a method known as idea laundering and also the
false idea of Thucydides trap. And the Thucydides trap champions, which are politically engaged
global politicians and elites, have been developing concepts like these for more than 30 years.
And all that time they've been percolating. Only recently within the last six to seven years have
they begun to emerge in mainstream policymaking. But these politicians have idea laundered
Thucydides trap by passing off their ideas as knowledge. That is, as if these terms describe
facts about the world of political reality around them. And while some concepts within
these ideas may contain bits of truth, they aren't scientific. By and large,
they're the musings of ideologues that wish to accomplish their specific goals
of reordering the political landscape. And in this case, it's creating a feedback loop centered
around preventing the supposedly inevitable catastrophe brought about by Thucydides trap.
Now, I think it's possible to say that idea laundering is analogous to money laundering.
And here's how it works. First, various politicians or elite global players have
strong objectives that they would like to accomplish. For example, they would like to
accomplish creating a worldwide socialistic circular economy. And they need to inspire
folks at the decision-making level to support the concept of encouraging the gradual decline
of, let's say, the United States, both from the top, legislatively, and the bottom,
from the general populace, to fuel their goals of displacing the United States
as the dominant world power to spread the power around. So they create a fertile fallacy
about the need to stop an almost certain global war with China that targets the United States
as the primary villain. You create the idea by wrongly taking one phrase from Thucydides' entire
history of the Peloponnesian War, base all of your game theory of what will happen in the inevitable
future, and insist that from now on and that everything must change because of Thucydides'
trap. And in this particular case, that the U.S. must be weakened to prevent this horrific tragedy.
It's a story that exists within a social power dynamic that unjustly ascribes authority
to weakly supported theoretical knowledge. That's what idea laundering does. Students
or politicians leave the academy believing that they know things that they do not know.
They bring this knowledge of Thucydides' trap to other institutions where, over time, laundered
ideas and the terminology that accompanies them become normative. They become doctrine or dogma,
giving them even more unearned legitimacy. And this all started from one spark, one false spark.
So the Thucydides' trap idea laundered concept has been laundered through the peer-reviewed
literature by activist scholars, think tanks, and politicians then widely taught for years
before being brought into the full understanding of the world at TED Talks and books. And if you
doubt their false hypothesis, even just a little bit of it to maybe say that there should be some
testing or maybe some doubting, I mean, this hypothesis seems pretty far-fetched,
you are dismissed from the inner circle of knowledge and influence. We tend to think,
you know, of propaganda as something generated by the state, but it's from everywhere.
Because the state is becoming the private, and the private is becoming the state. So this idea
laundering is a prime example of something coming from ideologues within think tanks that have
objectives and making its way into the public via sympathizers in the mass media. Eventually,
these lies or theories become de facto truths, either because people really do believe in them
because everybody else believes in them. And if they believe them and I don't, then I'm on the
then the cost of questioning them becomes too great. So people conform.
So I'm really hoping you get this. There are no facts. It's all narrative. One historian's
account is as good as another. Facts become whatever is useful to the ideological or
political crusade. This bad idea, along with these highly biased and unreliable claims about Thucydides
trap and US and China relations, has now been laundered so thoroughly that some of the most
powerful organizations in the world use it as authority and reach to further legitimize it
and spread the lies to the masses and especially to political bodies, deliberative councils.
And so the idea laundering begins with paper after paper, book after book, conference after
conference, using the same fallacious idea of the inevitable Thucydides trap as the certainty
that must be avoided. So if the entirety of the political, governmental, military,
and corporate world believes that everything must be done to avoid Thucydides trap,
as said before, it will lead nations to do the unthinkable. It will lead even corporations to
do the unthinkable. To join hands with the communist Chinese party. To place all their
bets on the rise of China and the disintegration of the United States. To try to avoid a mythical war
that quite possibly would never have happened. And the primary Thucydides trap evangelists who
are pushing the inevitability of this proposed catastrophic event are trumpeting the Thucydides
trap hypothesis with the same ferocity and the same frequency as an apocalypse focused
doomsayer prophet that stands on street corners waving the warning signs that the end is near.
And who is the primary antichrist in their political scenarios now? Well, of course,
it's President Donald Trump. And as the pro-China Thucydides trap cultist can be heard repeating
over and over again in TED talks and in Asia society meetings, he didn't cause the downfall,
but he certainly pushed it into the abyss. And thus, even within the United States,
the recruitment of folks at the state department level, in the military, in large international
corporations, in internationally followed sports teams such as the NBA who are convinced that the
future is China because of the Thucydides trap cult have all bet on China. And China has had
their proxy provocateur for the last several decades who would saber rattle as soon as the
United States would show some momentum of gaining strength in Asia and some influence in Asia. And
that has been North Korea. And North Korea would threaten South Korea and Japan whenever it was
time for China to flex its diplomatic muscle. So what did Donald Trump do that was different
than the past administrations? Well, he befriended North Korea's ruler, imperfect and brutal as he is.
And for a season, this took some amount of leverage away from China. See, because North
Korea was their sock puppet, disrupting some of the key components necessary to the mythology around
Thucydides trap. Now, others have bet on the international go-betweens. You know, the referees
of the international political world with the folks, let's say, at the World Economic Forum,
believing that the Great Reset would put the West in synchronization with China,
as we, the voting public, were deceptively pushed against our full knowledge or will
into the fourth industrial revolution. We've been talking about this, of course, for years.
And this solution, in their eyes, in the international community, the globalist
community, would prevent this reflexively inevitable, quote, monster under your bed,
end quote, Thucydides trap from actualizing on the world stage. But there is something else
at play. And just as there is more to eschatology than what Hal Lindsay had claimed,
there is more, in context and in total, than what wild-eyed prophetic doomsayers like Graham Allison
are saying about Thucydides. Context is king, you see. And the main thrust of Thucydides' history
of Palpatine is this. Order is fragile. The main question in politics today is how to deal
with this fragility. Some people are escapists, engaged in a futile effort to try to make
fragility, let's say, go away. And some people are realists. They accept fragility as an unavoidable
aspect of political and social life. They see an open society as the only way to manage fragility
well. Some political scientists will say that I'm misusing the concept of realism. In their view,
realism is strictly about foreign affairs, and realists are people who see global politics as a
brawl among power-hungry countries, much like the Hobbesian battleground that Jordan Peterson
uses when describing how Derridian concepts are fracturing our society. But to get a more well
rounded understanding of Thucydides is to understand that the epic described by Thucydides,
the main peril confronting Greek city-states, was posed by other states. But people had other
worries too. In some places, people lived in constant fear of revolution and lawlessness.
In other places, they feared drought, famine, and disease. Some felt an undefined fear of
the unknown future. That's chaos. These were Thucydides' realists, people who understood
that the world was a turbulent and dangerous place. Concern about fragility was shared by
later writers in realist tradition. Machiavelli feared that Florence would be attacked by other
city-states, but also fretted about the unrest within his own walls. The English statesman
Francis Bacon offered a list of conditions, including inequality, religious disputes,
and immigration, that could produce tempest within the state. A good leader, Bacon said,
looked for signs of coming storms. But these storms are not definite. They are not carved in stone,
and they don't have one solution. Especially when that solution is to assist a totalitarian,
draconian state against one that does value freedom and liberty. And so the prevention of
coming possible storms does not mean that all of civilization should reject liberty, freedom,
and capitalism for a stakeholder, circular, Marxist economy that is primarily run by a
bunch of totalitarian plutocrats and the communist Chinese party. Why is it that the equalizing
incredible force of equal opportunity and capitalism is always made the boogeyman in
all of these situations? Really, you need to ask yourself why. And why nearly everyone in
every affinity group has joined in on this? Because what is necessary is operational success
for those that are the totalitarians, for those that want to control your future,
that those that want to rob you of your cognitive liberty. We must resist this. Free people now that
do have their freedom, that do have their liberty, must resist this and have a wider conversation.
And so we stand at a crossroads. We have supranational entities that now have taken
the concept of autocratic authority, stakeholder capitalism, and the forced fit entrance of the
fourth industrial revolution due to the Wuhan virus, COVID-19, and now America's declined
and the West's decline has started. And where did this all begin?
Where was the fuse lit that sparked America's precipitous decline? Well, in China. And who
was taking advantage of this great decline? The World Economic Forum and China. I'm Michael O'Fallon
and this is something to consider as we continue to examine the causes of things.
