Lecture 24- Features of the Novel V

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
Jan 10, 2025
Good morning and welcome back to the lecture series. So, we are discussing features of the
novel and we are talking about the modern novel and its criticism. We are going to talk about
fantasy, right. The essence of the modern novel is lies in not succeeding to achieve what they
attempt. We are talking about E. M. Forster's work, Aspects of the Novel. And Forster says that the
aims and ambitions of the modern novelist is never quite straightened out or never quite
determined from beforehand. To quote Forster, he says,
trying to lay an egg and being told you have produced a paraboloid.
More curious than gratifying, that is how the experience of the modern novelist is. And
sometimes this creation, this production of the paraboloid happens at the cost of the death of the
hen. So, here when we talk about the death of the hen, we are reminded of Hollaback's
proposition about the death of the author. We are actually entering into the realm of
poststructuralism where in order for a modern work to happen, in order for it to be re-read and
interpreted and reinterpreted in various ways, the author needs to die. The logocentrism,
the author's only meaning, dominant meaning has to go.
So, this paraboloid that is created, something that the author wants to create and something
that is created instead, this entire experience is more curious. The author is also a seeker
and pursuing the end along with the reader. And it is not a very gratifying process. It contains
the lack, the human flaw that defines human existence or life. And the author has to go,
like I said. But this is how modern novel is pursued. The modern novel has no predetermined
goal defined or conceived from beforehand. If a trajectory is set forth beforehand,
the journey and struggle of the author becomes false or superficial.
So, the relation between the artwork and its criticism through theorization is also something
that contains a gap between what the artwork is and how it is interpreted.
There can be no reconciliation. The two are always happening on two different planes.
Here, E. M. Foster would say, I quote, criticism, especially a critical course,
can be misleading. However lofty its intentions and sound its method, its subject slides away from
beneath it, unquote. So, the critic might carry on in a significantly intelligent and intelligible
manner, but in certain regions which have nothing to do with anything that has been said by the
author. So, there are two ways of looking at this. One is, like the post-structuralists would say,
there is no such thing called the original meaning or the author's intention. There is
no way of going back to the author's intention. There are only multiple derivative meanings
that emerge through re-reading of a text where every reader becomes a writer and there is no
such thing as the author, the godlike author. Now, on the other hand, E. M. Foster would say
that a criticism can bloom, it can evolve in its own essence, it can follow its own trajectory,
it can be a very good piece of writing in its own right, but it can take on or it can
happen on a different plane altogether, which is different from the original work.
To quote Foster, when we try to translate truth out of one sphere into another, whether from life
into books or from books into lectures, so when we are actually moving from one plane
of discussion to another, something happens to truth, it goes wrong, not suddenly,
when it might be detected, but slowly, unquote. So, a piece of writing happens on its own.
So, there are two things in classroom one could do. One is just read out from the book and then
experience the work firsthand. And so, there could be 10 different interpretations even when
10 people are reading a work together. The other is directly understanding the work
through criticism, which is, however, comprehensive, lucid and well written,
the criticism or the critic is, it is definitely shifted or moved away from the original work.
So, criticism or critic or a lecture on any work is always happening, evolving on a different
plane from the work itself. Fiction always makes some sort of demand on the reader.
What are the demands that a fiction could make? Curiosity, human feelings, such as happiness,
pathos, sense of value for the characters. So, once we read, we move along the plot,
we feel for the character, we have certain values that we develop for the characters in the fiction,
as well as intelligence and memory. These are some of the, we could say,
sophisticated tools that are required of a reader of the modern fiction.
Now, I am going to quote at length from E. M. Forster, what he says regarding fantasy and
prophecy. This is a new topic that he is introducing in the aspects of the novel.
He says, he refers to or he introduces, he defines fantasy and prophecy as follows.
I quote, there is more in the novel than time or people or logic or any of their derivatives,
more even than fate. And by more, I do not mean something that excludes these aspects,
nor something that includes them, embraces them. I mean something that cuts across them like a bar
of light that is intimately connected with them at one place and patiently illumines all their
problems and at another place shoots over or through them as if they did not exist.
We shall give that bar of light two names, fantasy and prophecy, unquote.
So, here we understand that just like the light in a room, fantasy and prophecy are not
separately visible in any plot, but all the characters, the turn of events,
the way the plot, you know, churns out, the way the plot is shaped is illumined because of this
all pervasive light in the room or in the plot, which is fantasy or prophecy.
So, the characters, the plots, everything are shown, they come to picture,
coloured by, tinted by and deeply enmeshed with the fantastic or the prophetic meaning.
The fantasy or the prophecy do not, you know, exist as individual separate entities. Everything
else is seen in the light of these elements. So, fantasy and prophecy in a novel reflect
temporality, human behaviour and causality in a new light that takes away their routine nature.
So, there are two things, the characters are illumined by or through the elements of the
fantastic and the prophetic and then the fantastic and the prophetic element supersedes and becomes,
you know, more than, greater than the sum total of all the characters and all the events brought
together. The mundaneness, the routineness, the ordinariness is taken away because the
fantastic or the prophetic is somewhere present in the storytelling.
So, they influence characters and events, but they become more than, they become bigger than
and they encompass the entire cosmos, they make it fantastic. So, everything is shown in a new light,
which takes away their ordinary or routine nature beyond the actions in the plot,
the work becomes a fantastic or a prophetic novel, regardless of or notwithstanding the
events that are taking place, we understand that we are in the realm of the fantastic.
The reality is an upturned one, it is a fantastic reality. So, fantasy asks of the reader to accept
that the book is not real in the naturalist or realist sense and thereby it tests the reader's
resilience in accepting what they cannot immediately relate or identify with.
So, will the reader go along with the plot? Will the reader withdraw their concession and stop
reading or continue reading with a certain degree of scepticism or sceptical aloofness? Or
will the reader let himself or herself be carried away with the flow of fantasy,
which is, you know, which in the third event or in the third instance, the reader is required
to actually give up on moral positions of believing or not believing or give up on the
parameters of real and unreal, unlearn the conditions and parameters of real and unreal
that they have grown up with. Even the traditional expectations of the reader
from the novel need to be revisited and drastically, radically, you know, altered,
refashioned. So, readership, expectations of the reader, sense of time, sense of space,
sense of what is true and untrue or not true, natural, supernatural, everything is revisited
and reshuffled, the meanings are drastically shifted in works of fantasy and prophecy,
especially when we are talking about fantasy, this holds true.
Fantasy entails taking off from the literal world and treating a work of art through its endless
fictional possibilities. So, some possibilities that might not work within the realm of,
within, so some, you know, possibilities that might not work in everyday life could happen
within the space of fiction. And how far is the reader ready to go along with the author
and the author's, you know, fantastic imagination in writing and participate in this journey,
that makes one a successful or a failed reader or a not so successful reader of the fantasy genre.
So, being too comfortable in the literal world of realism or naturalism, once we are very ensconced,
very comfortable with the parameters that have been set by realism and naturalism, the fantastic
can have several, you know, impact on the reader, it could thrill the reader, or conversely,
it could choke her. So, the fantastic basically tests how much the reader can adjust with the
alternate meanings, alternate realities. The reader's training is to recognize the fantastic
as such, not to judge it, not measure it through the laws of daily life.
So, how much can we adjust with the oddness of the fantastic as a method or a subject matter?
How much are we willing to kind of go with the flow? The readers that cannot reciprocate to
the fantastic do not have a poor imagination or a basic dislike for literature in general.
Rather, they simply cannot stretch themselves to certain demands that are being made on the reader
by literature. So, literature has expanded itself or altered itself, shifted itself to
accommodate the fantastic. Now, it is for the reader to shuffle or revisit his or her position
and assumptions and expectations. So, sometimes the reader does not object
the introduction of the fantastic elements in a work, but they are left a little
dissatisfied after the reading because they could not go with the flow of the writing.
They have suspected the plausibility of such a plot, because all along they have been
reading a work of fantasy through the prism of, through the criteria set by
realism or naturalism and that is not the way to go about it. Fantasy and prophecy
illumine objects with much more vividness than any commonplace or mundane perspective
ever could. So, both fantasy and prophecy are bound by a sense of mythology and yet we would
see that the gods in each of them are very different from the other. They differ in how
humans interact with the larger supra or transhuman forces that lie beyond the human world.
Fantasy's gods come as a suggestion and they do not confront the ordinariness or the ordinary
existence. They are less grand. So, fantasy's gods are almost part and parcel of our everyday,
everyday being, everyday existence. There could be the fantastic in little everyday things.
Fantasy derives its charm from improvisation, spontaneity, inventiveness. So, there is no
concept of the grand or the great god, the one god. There are just demigods.
So, fantasy brings in the otherworldly affairs and yet these otherworldly affairs, the
supernatural do not confront us. They are not happening in an expressed or grand manner.
So, Ian Foster would note that Hermes, who is the god of luck, fertility or thieves,
rule fantasy. So, when we talk of god, we talk of morality, we talk of sin and all the superlative
qualities that need to be achieved. So, god is the concentrate of all the superlative qualities.
But how about a god of thieves? That topsy-turvy is the entire assumption with which we,
the entire assumption or assumptions that we take to the meaning of god.
So, a god that could give us luck, fertility and also the craft of theft,
that kind of a god rules fantasy. He is the cleverest of all gods.
So, could one suggest that fantasy is about the dexterity, the skill of the author's mind
that touches on the ordinary, the everydayness like a fairy or a clever elf? It could be a gnome
or more like a shape-shifting trickster, a god that is very protean, very shape-shifting,
a very clever presence in the plot, which is like a Quicksilver almost.
So, fantasy questions the totality of our knowledge of what our culture regards as real.
Could there be a totality of knowledge or can we constantly play around with it?
Could we introduce something new so that the totality that we hitherto had gets unsettled
and needs to accommodate new meanings, new things? Fantasy is constantly a challenging,
confronting and contesting with that kind of totality of knowledge or meaning and its
aim is to allow the author opportunities for satire through revisiting traditionally accepted
parameters of reality. In Freudian criticism, fantasy as a literary phenomenon is a neat
record of an imaginary achievement, fulfilment of a wish, a correction of unsatisfied reality.
So, according to James McConkie, I quote McConkie, fantasy is a device by which the
writer achieves the creation of a backdrop distinct from phenomenal reality. A mythology
suitable to contain the author's own values, unquote. So, on the one hand, we have some
pre-existing values on which they are like the meta values, the grand values on which entire
community, entire society has agreed upon and then the author is imposing his own set of values
to play with the pre-existing ones. That is from that kind of an interaction, a contestation,
fantasy churns out. Construed far from its ordinary meaning,
E. M. Forster understands prophecy on the other hand as a literary technique which serves
neither as an agent of foretelling, foretelling of the future nor as an appeal for righteousness.
So, when E. M. Forster is using prophecy, prophecy is not synonymous with foretelling of future
or having any hint or inkling of righteousness. Rather what E. M. Forster would say is that
prophecy is a music-like quality, an ascent in the novelist's voice. Its theme is the universe
or something universal. So, once the prophetic is introduced to a plot, the pitch or the tonality of
narration changes. It goes on to a different plane only to come back to the ordinary.
There is a music-like quality that is introduced to narration by virtue of prophecy.
And such prophecy, as Forster understands, could rest on, as he says, I quote him,
any of the faiths that have haunted humanity, Christianity, Buddhism, dualism, Satanism and
so forth. So, unquote. Further, Wilfred Stone notes that Forster's notion of prophecy
relies the spirit embedded in the phenomenal world, the effect of which, to quote Stone,
argues the compatibility of human and absolute values and provides
meeting places for the dualisms of his aesthetics and his art, unquote.
So, Tristram Shandy is a work of fantasy. We would like to discuss now how Tristram
Shandy by Stern holds the fantastic element. This work by Stern comprises a hodgepodge
of digressions which leads to labyrinths, afterthoughts, delays and apologies.
Critics have often questioned if Tristram Shandy is a complete work. It is often read,
popularly read as unfinished. While Stern planned to produce multiple volumes, later critics see a
careful pattern in his madness and this recklessly compounded writing. Questions of form and
structural unity cannot be brought to the understanding of Tristram or rather cannot
adequately understand or encompass the meanings, the ambitions of the author.
In the fragmented narrative, very little of Tristram's life is narrated. So, the fantastic
in Tristram Shandy lies in the order of the form. The fantastic is in the different parts that are
not relating in any fundamental way to one another. A critic like Walter Begert would say that
Tristram Shandy is, to quote Begert, a book without plan or order whose greatest defect is,
quote again, the fantastic disorder of the form. To quote a critic like Walter Begert,
Tristram Shandy is, I quote, a book without plan or order, unquote, whose greatest defect is,
I quote again, the fantastic disorder of the form, unquote. Again, Ernest Baker says that Stern
produced, I quote Baker, Salmagandhi of odds and ends recklessly compounded, unquote.
So, Tristram Shandy was published in five parts over a period of more than seven years.
Some of the later parts contain materials that Stern could not have known at the time when he
began to write this work, the first volume or the first part. And this points to the work's
unplanned composition. Some later critics, however, suggest that large parts of the work
has been planned with more care than Stern's public attitude would actually suggest.
This is something I have mentioned before also. The work, like the later critics, see a careful
pattern through this recklessness and madness that has been posited by, or the mad position,
the position of the mad author that Stern assumes, posits through writing Tristram Shandy.
John Trugode observes that, I quote Trugode, ontological, vast, abrupt, the abysm between
ideas and reality, unquote, is present in this novel by Stern. Tristram Shandy has less to do
with epistemological question of how accurately our ideas reflect reality than with the ethical
question of how our ideas affect our ability to bear, to face up to or come in terms with reality.
Throughout Tristram Shandy, Stern projects a spontaneous writing which is least inhibited
by plan or form. Stern is preoccupied with the instability, the unsettledness of language,
as well as the linguistic embarrassment, which draws attention to the blank spaces
of the curses, where the curses have been used. And these blank spaces suggest that any name
could be asserted. Playing with the names is something that also shows in the chain of mistakes
that lead to Tristram's christening. Stern's subversion of literary form reappears
through his black page trick. Critics call it the black page trick, something that cannot be
justly reproduced through or reproduced in reprints. Similarly, Stern inserts this preface,
the preface of this novel, somewhere midway through volume three. And even the dedication
is delayed till chapter seven of the first volume. So, Stern subverts reason and rationality
and pursues the moral grounds of his reader to reconcile with the eccentricities or the oddities
of the Shandy world. So, in order, that is how the fantastic is read. In order for the reader
to be able to understand or get into the cosmos offered by Tristram Shandy, they have to
shed behind, they have to unlearn some of the social conventions that they have
grown up observing and learning. Life's secret springs are mentioned, as well as the hidden
resources. The secret springs and hidden resources enable the mind to bear the or cope up with the
overwhelming forces of reality, what reality demands of us, how reality imposes itself on us,
fencing against the minor evils of daily living. And this refers to the myriad
misfortunes that have befallen Tristram. And they add something to this fragment of life.
So, throughout Tristram Shandy, there are sartorial metaphors that illustrate the characters
never ending struggles to shield themselves from external evils, it could be the reality.
For example, the novel keeps mentioning and talking about buttoning and unbuttoning vexations,
which is comic, and they have a satirical undertone as well. So, critics comment that
Tristram Shandy is more a comedy than a satire on the human situation. Its incidental satire
makes its doctrine of sympathy artistically necessary, that kind of satire, which is
necessary to drive the comedy, drive the comedy well. Stern's work of comedy is as salutary to
the life force, it celebrates the life force as it is deadly to any premise of reason and
rationality. E. M. Forster says that Tristram Shandy is a fantastic work, it is a fantasy in
which a fantastic god called model renders everyday life chaotic. Stern adapts Jonathan
Swift's technique in conjuring a chaotic world where reason functions only to alienate and
confuse. One is disoriented through reason, only through shunning reason and rationality
can one be oriented back into the Shandy world, the world of fantasy.
So, shunning reason becomes one of the premises for reading Stern's work. The appeal of the
fantastic is personal. So, the reader can either accept the supernatural or not accept it,
but the fantastic may not be engaged adequately if one approaches it only through a universal
critical apparatus. With this, I am going to stop today's lecture here and let us meet in
another lecture with another round of discussions. Thank you.
