Lecture 51- Science Fiction IV

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
1 Video View·Jan 10, 2025
Good morning and welcome back to the lecture series. So we are discussing
science fiction in the light of Donna Haraway's essay, Cyborg Manifesto.
In continuation from our previous lecture, we see that cyborg is a hybrid of militarism
and patriarchal capitalism and yet it is not exceedingly faithful to either. Cyborg is
located at a point where human and animal boundary line is transgressed. And rather
than walling off humanity from animaldom, cyborg renders a special status to bestiality, right.
So it is no longer a homocentric world. The human body bears animal traits and vice versa.
The borderline between organism and machine is blurred. In the age of dependence on micro
electronics, there are only copies without originals. So we could see the symptom of
simulacrum in the cyborg. Cyborg is very much symptomatic of the postmodern era in which
simulation does not correspond either with the real or the truth. So rather we are looking at
simulation as inaugurated by a liquidation of all referentials. So simulation entails
artificial resurrection of referentials in the system of or rather in the systems of science.
It refers to the hyperreal without an original reference.
If we go back to the origin of the postmodern era, what led to the postmodernism as a movement,
postmodernism in art and culture, we see that the postindustrial age and cultures
since the end of the 1950s marks changing conditions of knowledge and an entry into
the postmodern conditions. It is almost simultaneous with or coeval with the
reconstruction of Europe, the European society. Having largely eliminated the agricultural
workforce, postindustrial age is defined by manufacturing employment through creating new
automated technology. So what happens with the introduction of automatons
in the postindustrial society? The automatons increase manufacturing productivity,
but at the same time, the automatons or the machines displace human workforce.
So, Donna Haraway extrapolates this condition of machine replacing human workforce,
human productivity to humans themselves becoming mechanized and then partly machines,
the body parts having some electronic devices, some technical devices in them.
In the cybernetic cosmos, labor becomes robotics, sex, sexuality becomes genetic engineering,
and mind becomes artificial intelligence. So, communication science and biology has
blurred this gap between machine and organism. Mind, body and tool are all on intimate terms
and they are interwoven. The boundaries between base and superstructure, public and private,
material and ideal are also subsequently blurred. So, in the late 20th century, machines are
disturbingly lively, whereas human beings are very surprisingly inert. So, the margin between
what is artificial, what is synthetic, and what is natural or organic is getting increasingly
unclear. The cyborg myth basically tends to undermine and crack open the innocence,
the pristinity of nature and primitive culture in a very significant fashion.
The authoritative western epistemology's centrality is thereby transcended with the
concept of the cyborg. So, we see, however, that who the cyborg will be is a matter of survival.
In other words, whosoever survives in and as the post-western world, and this post-western world
is a world with reshuffled rules of gender, race, ethnicity, etc. Cyborg is therefore a creature
in the post-gender world which has no origin story in the western sense.
Now, movements for animal rights points to this connection that cyborg is bringing in
between the nature and the culture. And this kind of interspersing nature with culture
opposes the Christian or biblical creationism in which man is shown to be at the centre of the
world and the nature is at his disposal. This is homocentrism. This is also androcentrism.
Instead, movements for animal rights point towards biocentrism. So, while deep ecologists
oppose anthropocentrism in general, we see that ecofeminists oppose male-centredness or
androcentrism. A cyborg world is not afraid of a joint kinship with animals and machines. So,
human body kind of tied up with or linked to animals or machines. And it is also not afraid
of permanently fractional identities and contradictory standpoints. The cyborg world
directly flows out of and into the postmodern artistic conditions defined through features
such as anti-story or non-narrative, where meaning is not immediate and a priori.
And such postmodern aesthetics is burdened, therefore, with artifice and complex symbolic
meanings. The meaning lies in mimicry or constant deferment or doubling. We also see that in
postmodern art, linearity is replaced by the time being arrested in an eternal present,
an eternal present situation from which there is neither a movement, a productive
or fruitful movement towards the future nor a recoursing in a very significant way to the past.
There is a focus on dystopian narrative as well without suggesting any way out of it.
So, in the 20th century, US scientific culture, the boundary line between human and animal world
is completely overtaken, completely breached. So, people no longer feel the need for any
separation between the two. And feminist culture seeks pleasure in connection of human and other
living creatures. And its origin, the origin of blurring these boundaries that specify categories
could be seen in the radical libertarian school which stresses on androgynous persons and thereby
assumes both good and bad qualities of men and women in all the persons.
In fact, for example, we have Jorian Freeman stressing on becoming androgynous person and
celebrates a term such as a derogatory term such as bitch which contains ample traits of masculinity
such as arrogance and rashness actually prevents the female from being traditionally a
sweet person or a caring sympathetic person. So, the essential unity of gender, race,
class has given away and hence there is nothing about being female which naturally
binds women across all the different intersections. So, we have multiple
sites or multiple cases or points of jeopardy. We do not have one woman's problem anymore.
We do not have a unified feminist issue or a kind of development. So, there are multiple
points of development, multiple simultaneous development. The development of feminism
is not in a unilinear direction. So, each category of gender, race and class
are formed through contradictory social realities of patriarchy, colonialism and capitalism.
Fragmentation within feminism has caused womanhood itself to become an elusive category
within which one woman can dominate the other. As an example, we see that the socialist and
Marxist feminists. So, for example, we see that the socialist feminists point out how the bourgeois
woman is not unified with the proletarian woman or the proletarian sister but rather with the
bourgeois man for the protection of private property, profiteering, militarism and for
propagating racism. So, primary oppressor for the proletarian woman is not patriarchy
but capitalism. Now, the cyborg does not limit itself to boundaries of identity or identities.
In other words, there is no obsession with pure experience. There is no pure experience anymore
as a simulacrum. It can only have a doubled meaning, a displaced experience, an experience
which cannot trace back to an original referent. So, pure woman, pure human, these are all elusive
categories. Existence is assumed as irreversibly hybrid and consequently the cyborg defies a
social formation through categories of binary differentiations such as man-woman, human-animal
and so forth. The sophistication and intelligence of the machines and their capabilities lead to
breaking down of the idea of bodies which end at the skin or pairing away of the definition of
human. The human as a definition is revisited. It is paired off and it is no longer restricted
only to the skin of the human. Sheila Sandoval's formation of new political voice
called women of colour signifies breakdown of the western male-centric world and instead it
constructs a postmodernist identity out of otherness, difference and out of the desire
to focus on specificity. Rather than relativism or pluralism, Sheila Sandoval's oppositional
consciousness is about contradictory locations. So, the woman of colour has no essential criteria
for defining who she is. Her position will be defined through negative identities by the
non-black privileged people. The author here is looking for a brand of socialist feminism
which supports incomplete, contradictory, open-ended constructions which centre personal
and collective selves, not one self but multiple selves. Because put it very simply, whenever we
have a subject formation of the non-white, it is generally put in opposition to the white and it
reifies the binarism. So, the subject formation is not definitive and not forever. In critics
such as Sheila Sandoval, we see incomplete, contradictory, open-ended subject construction
or identity formation. Cyber feminists, according to Donna Haraway, should argue that we as women
do not want any natural unity in the development of feminism or in the discussion of the feminist
problem and that no one whole construction is possible. There is no construction is whole as
such. So, women's relation to the world and history is restructured through science and technology.
In the cyborg world, there is rearrangement of race, sex and class in high-tech social relations.
Familiar groupings are broken and new collectivities are formed due to the
fast mobility of capital. So, proliferation of information processing machines
which is very much symptomatic of the postmodern era have an effect on the way learning or knowledge
is circulated as well as on all other kinds of circulation. Let us see, human circulation is
also facilitated. The transportation system becomes more sophisticated. People move from
one part of the world to another more quickly and with the media, the fact that we are bombarded
with information, there is circulation of sounds and visual images at very high frequency.
These are all happening at the onset of the postmodern era. Professional and scientific
knowledge becomes the most marketable commodity during this era. So, under postmodern conditions,
knowledge is produced in order to be sold. It is consumed in order to be
valorized or celebrated in a new production. The goal of acquiring any knowledge is exchange.
Knowledge therefore ceases to be an end in itself. Knowledge ceases to be an end in itself.
It loses its use value and attains instead an exchange value.
From here, Haraway is also looking at the prototypical Silicon Valley. She is looking
at the case of the women who work in the Silicon Valley. The lives of such women comprise heterosexual
monogamy, negotiating child care, a distance from family and traditional community and
in the end, there is loneliness and economic vulnerability as they age.
So, Richard Gordon talks of a homework economy in which factory, home and market are integrated
on a new scale and here the places for women are crucial. New communications and homework economy
is an onslaught or an attack on and a process of decentralization from white men's unionized
jobs, the traditional unions that are formed, whose chief architects and protagonists are
white men. Homework economy is a move away from the unionized jobs of white men.
So, in industrial societies, we see men are in fact more vulnerable to job loss than the women.
So, cyber manifest or the cybernetic world, the world of cybernetic organism sees, you know,
cross-race and cross-gender alliances as very important, necessary for sustenance of life.
Haraway notes how women survive outside of a unitary self within dispersion and within a
diaspora, a diasporic condition such as one can see in the case of the prototypical Silicon Valley.
So, although it is useful in imagining a departure from traditional categories of
difference, the concept of cyborg one has to remember is itself fraught with a western
patriarchal violence which cannot be ignored in the greater context of technology and
technological innovation. If a cyborg is originally a military invention, then the conceptualization
of the female body as the cyborg is only a product of the idea of industrial war machine,
which has violence intrinsically, which has violence intrinsically associated with it.
The concept of cyborg has violence and war and militarism intrinsically associated with it.
So, the nature of such a violence, therefore, replaces imperialism with the military.
Mechanism of war and technology enable formation of family through army and technology
and Haraway calls such propagation caused by militaristic discourse as government-issued
children. And Haraway hints that in the cybernetic world, new pleasures, new experiences
and powers emerge as the rule of the game changes and keep changing. The units of socialist-feminist
analysis, which are the race, gender and class are constantly undergoing transformations,
they are in a state of flux, which leads to emergence of new kinds of unity, new
kinds of power groups, if we may. So, rather than being a feminist with a common
language among the women and thus totalized and imperialized outlook, Donna Haraway studies
how to survive within contradictions, where, let us say, human body itself, the basic assumptions
of all categories are reshuffled. The human body merges with animals and further merges with
machines. And this is also a way of disarming or disempowering the western male-centric viewpoint.
The traditional categories, existence of traditional categories such as class,
sex or gender, race, reify the western male-centric viewpoint. And this is what gets
spoiled or frustrated when the categories are reshuffled, when the entire power game, the rule
of the game is changed. When seen from women's point of view, the cyborg world is free from
virulent forms of oppression, at least the virulent forms of oppression that women have
traditionally and historically faced. It is symptomatic of the alternate path that is shown
by science and technology, where science could also play a feminized role. There is a point where
Donna Haraway says that I would rather be a cyborg than a goddess, which marks the departure of the
idea of the woman as a natural, biologically driven, essentialized goddess of the earth and
embraces the potential of science and technology in providing a shifted idea of the woman.
This is a rejection of the nature-driven idea of the woman or the goddess and replacing it
with the cyborg. However, the question remains, is the cyborg replacing one system of control with
another? Because cyborg is an image of both imagination and material reality, it reflects
the tradition of racist male-dominant capitalism too, just like it reflects the tradition of
progress, the tradition of appropriation of nature as reproduction of culture.
So, drawing on the pre-1990s technophobia and post-1990s technophilia, sociologist Judy Weikman
emphasizes the social studies of technology and Weikman insists avoidance of both technological
determinism and gender essentialism in order to understand a fluid and flexible gender technology
relationship. In her words, I quote Weikman, the possibility and the fluidity of gender discourse
in the virtual world is constrained by the material world. So, when technology is predominantly
controlled and created by men, the question of material constraints set the limits to how much
agency technology is capable of granting in redefining race, gender and sexuality.
Because technology, put very plainly, has always been the domain of the male
and it has been, you know, the medium of expressing very masculinist male-centric
ideas. It has facilitated wars, militarism, all of which are offshoots of patriarchy.
So, the cyborg could be seen as existing in the liminal space, not oppositionally,
but frictionally against other subjects and identities.
Like I was saying, critics have seen this idea of cyborg as a self-serving offshoot
of liberal feminism, which talks about gadgets and movements in technoscientific ecosystem
through looking at the animals and the automaton as an extension of each other.
Critics like Julia de Kook note that Haraway's notion of personhood is deeply seated in the
Western concepts. So, universality of the cyborg is problematic, as the cyborg allows for the
centrality of white identity and a techno-utopic worldview, where technology is
seen as emancipatory and technology is not examined for its limitations.
So, what de Kook is trying to get at is that technology could have its own limitations,
the concept of cyborg could have its flip side too. In her work Race After Technology,
Abolitionist Tools for the New Jim Code, Rua Benjamin shows how technological designs can be
discriminatory and in fact, they can perpetuate inequality or inequity through amplifying racial
hierarchies. Donna Haraway is not pointing to the many lapses of technology in the process
of fixing older problems. So, technology is being deployed to fix old problems of race and gender,
but technology has its own baggage of problems, which is something Haraway does not address in
her essay. So, technology and the desire to create and control machines is a realm that is
very prominently dominated by the man and thus technology itself may inherently be patriarchal,
like Whiteman observes. So, questions that come to our mind
are as follows. Is women's participation in cyberspace and the technological sphere
disruptive of the very basis on which technology is built? Does it debunk the problematics
associated with technology? Or is it merely, as Audre Lorde very correctly puts,
very significantly puts, a futile attempt at dismantling the master's house with the master's
tools? So, we are trying to challenge patriarchy with a tool of patriarchy that technology itself
is. So, the cyborg is supposed to shift the essentialized notions of gender and sex
away from the body, but does the technological revolution of the late 20th and early 21st
century further reify rather than move away from or challenge these definitions?
What possibilities can the woman, the people of color, the disabled, the queer persons find in
science, technology and the cybernetic identity, the cyborg identity? How much access to technology
do people from these categories have upon which the concept of cyborg is built? Unequal
technological access could in fact exacerbate, worsen the social inequality. So, does the cyborg
enable dismantling of traditional confines of identity and categorization of existence across
all levels? This is something we need to understand and ask.
According to eco-feminist Vandana Shiva, a spiritual eco-feminist that she is,
cyborg promotes a reductionist constructivism in its garb of integrating women's problems.
So, Vandana Shiva looks at how global power structures and the destructive logic of
techno-science tends to engulf the secret feminine principle called as prakriti or nature
as imagined in the ancient Indian cosmology. Further, Neena Likhi argues that the cyborg
and the goddess, we could call it the goddess or the Devi, which is the one as a proponent of
science or technology, whereas the other as the proponent of nature.
So, the cyborg being the proponent of science and technology, whereas the goddess or Devi
being the proponent of nature or prakriti are not as dissimilar as they may appear.
This is what Likhi has to say. In fact, they have much in common.
Feminists that are working within the techno-scientific paradigm cannot really
privilege cyborg over the goddess or vice versa. We would like to stop our discussion here today
and let us meet for another round of discussions in another lecture. Thank you.
