PMQs: Sir Keir Starmer 'chose train drivers over pensioners', says Rishi Sunak

UK Prime Ministers
23 followers
10 Video Views·Jan 8, 2025
Sir Keir Starmer has faced Rishi Sunak at the first PMQs since parliament returned from the summer recess.
To the Leader of the Opposition, Rishi Sunak.
Thank you, Mr Speaker, and can I join with the Prime Minister in paying tribute to the
Grenfell community, and we're going to rightly discuss that important issue shortly after
PMQs.
Can I also join him in congratulating our record-breaking Olympians and Paralympians
on everything that they have achieved.
And lastly, can I just pay tribute to the hard work, bravery and dedication of our police.
This summer, in challenging circumstances, they served our communities commendably and
kept us all safe.
Now, Mr Speaker, government is about making choices, and the new Prime Minister has made
a choice.
He has chosen to take the winter fuel allowance away from low-income pensioners and give that
money to certain unionised workforces in inflation-busting pay rises.
So can I just ask the Prime Minister, why did he choose train drivers over Britain's
vulnerable pensioners?
Mr Speaker, this government was elected to clear up the mess left by the party officer
and to bring about the change that the country desperately needs.
Our first job was to audit the books, and what we found was a £22 billion black hole.
It's no good them complaining.
Richard Hughes, the chair of the OBR, was very clear.
He described it as one of the largest year overspends against forecasts outside of the
pandemic.
His words.
So we've had to take tough decisions to stabilise the economy and repair the damage, including
targeting winter fuel payments whilst protecting pensioners.
800,000 pensioners are not taking up pension credit.
We intend to turn that around.
We're going to align housing benefit and pension credit, something the previous government
deferred year after year after year, and because of our commitment to the triple lock,
pensions are projected to increase by over £1,000 in the next five years.
Rishi Sunak.
Mr Speaker, the Prime Minister also inherited inflation back at target, interest rates being
cut, unemployment low, and indeed the fastest growing economy in the G7, but that's not
the point because the Prime Minister now has to start taking responsibility for his
own decision.
And if, as he says, the public finance is a priority, it was his decision and his decision
alone to award a train driver on £65,000 a pay rise of almost £10,000.
And it was also his decision that a pensioner living on just £13,000 will have their winter
fuel allowance removed.
So can the Prime Minister explain to Britain's low-income pensioners why he has taken money
away from them whilst at the same time given more money to highly paid train drivers?
Well, Mr Speaker, we spent the whole election with him trying to tell the country that everything
was fine, and this is the result they got, a massive mandate on this side to change
the country.
And if he carries on pretending everything is fine for ordinary people across the country,
they're going to be there for a very, very long time.
And I remind him that we inherited absolute chaos from the party opposite.
We lost an average of 3 million working days a year to strikes under his watch, and you
cannot fix the economy if the trains don't work, and you can't fix the economy if the
NHS isn't working.
And when it comes to winter fuel payments, well, they're having a competition, as I
said.
They're going to be voting later on today.
Well, the Shadow Housing Minister, we found this.
She's the favourite, I think.
Some of them will be probably voting for her this afternoon.
She said, her words, I have people in my constituency telling me they don't need winter fuel payments.
Why do we not have a more sophisticated mechanism for mean testing?
That's their favourite, I think, in the contest that they are having.
Mr Speaker, again, the Prime Minister talked about the public finances.
The UK's public finances are more robust than almost that of any other major advanced economy.
Here we have it.
He inherited a lower deficit than France, America, Italy...
Order, order.
When I do point you to be quiet, I do mean it.
I don't need a reaction back like that.
Let's just...
Well, the UK currently has a lower deficit than France, America, Italy and Japan.
It has the second lowest debt in the entire G7.
And he opposed every difficult decision that we took to deliver that.
So I certainly am not going to take any lectures from him on that, Scott.
But he talked about protecting ordinary people.
Well, last year, under the Conservative government, a low-income pensioner with just £13,000
received not only the winter fuel payment, but also hundreds of pounds of additional cost of living support.
Both of which he has now scrapped.
Age UK have said cutting the winter fuel allowance is the wrong policy.
And only this morning, we've learned that the vast majority of the poorest pensioners,
pensioners in poverty, are going to see that vital support removed.
So can he tell the House, very specifically to the pensioners that are watching,
how much less support a pensioner on £13,000 will receive this winter?
He talks about tough decisions.
It's tough to inherit a tough £22 billion black hole, which the OBR did not need.
That is the inheritance. That's what they left.
Now, back when they were in government, they'd have pretended it wasn't there.
They'd have walked past it, put it in the long grass.
We're not going to do that, because we were elected to change this country for the better
and stabilise our economy.
No Prime Minister wants to do what we have to do in relation to the winter fuel allowance.
But we have to take the tough decision to stabilise our economy
to ensure that we can grow it for the future.
And as I've said, we are working hard on pension credits.
We're allowing housing benefits, which they didn't do for years.
And over five years, there's a projected increase of up to £1,000 for those on pensions.
We are making tough decisions, but they don't.
The Government doesn't have to choose to take money off low-income pensioners
in order to give it to highly paid train drivers.
That is a choice that he has made, and it will be clear to any pensioners watching
that he simply can't explain why he has made that choice.
But Mr Speaker, turning to another important issue,
the Government has suspended 30 of the UK's 350 arms export licences to Israel.
It's a decision that the Chief Rabbi says beggars belief
and will encourage our shared enemies.
Can the Prime Minister therefore explain how his decision
will help to secure the release of the 101 hostages still being held by Hamas?
Mr Speaker, can I start by saying I think the whole House will be shocked
by the horrific killing of six hostages in the last few days.
And I know I speak for the whole House when I say that.
The remaining hostages must be released.
And we need a ceasefire to ensure that that can happen,
that aid desperately needed can get into the region,
and we can begin the path to a two-state solution.
Now he asks how we arrived at this decision. He knows very well.
Because the legal framework is clear.
The latest guidance was issued in 2021 under his Government.
And that means that licences have to be kept under review,
as they were by his Government.
And I think he probably knows the advice that was given to his Government.
He understands the framework.
We've carried out the review in the same way
and come to a clear legal conclusion.
And shared that conclusion, the assessment, with Parliament.
We will of course continue to stand by Israel's right to self-defence.
But it is important that we are a country committed
to the international rule of law.
That gives us the strength of argument with our allies on important issues.
This is a difficult issue. I recognise that.
But it's a legal decision, not a policy decision.
And the Prime Minister knows the framework.
They issued the guidance. They know what the test is.
That test has been assessed. We've come to a conclusion.
And we've put that before the House to consider.
Mr Speaker, I appreciate the Prime Minister's answer.
But he'll know that decisions like this
also have important and broader geopolitical implications.
And he mentioned allies.
It's essential that we maintain transatlantic unity
in the face of terrorist threats.
And avoid any perception of splits between our two nations.
So can he therefore update the House or tell the House
what engagement he had with the United States
prior to taking this significant decision?
I acknowledge the importance of working with our allies
on all issues, as we have been doing.
As I was able to make very clear at the NATO summit
that I attended in the early summer.
And of course, as he would expect, as the House would expect,
we have talked this through with our allies.
They understand. They have a different legal system.
That is the point they made.
This is a serious issue. It requires serious consideration.
And the Prime Minister knows the legal framework.
He knows the legal framework very well.
He also knows that applying the facts of that framework
and arriving at a decision does not permit me
to simply then say, I'm not going to implement
the legal decision of conclusion that's been reached.
I don't think he's really inviting me to do that.
Mr Speaker, not only do these decisions have geopolitical consequences
but they also have emotional ones too.
And the Prime Minister took this action
on the very same day as the funerals of Israeli hostages
murdered by Hamas.
It's something that the Board of Deputies described
as a terrible, terrible message to be sending.
I hope the Prime Minister understands the hurt that has been caused
and can he take this opportunity to reassure Israel
and the Jewish community that the United Kingdom and this House
stands behind Israel and its right to self-defence?
Let me be very clear about that.
I've said it before, I'll say it again.
We absolutely recognise and support Israel's right to self-defence
and have taken action in support of that right to self-defence
and I've made that repeatedly clear
in all of my engagements with Israel across the region
and with all of our allies.
I absolutely stand by that.
But in relation to licences, this isn't an Israel issue
it's the framework for all licences that have to be kept under review
it's the same test for all licences that the Prime Minister knows
and having applied the law to the facts
and come to a legal conclusion
I don't think the Prime Minister is really inviting me
to put that to one side.
The Leader of the Opposition.
This is a serious issue.
We either comply with international law or we don't
and we only have strength in our arguments
because we comply with international law.
I appreciate the party opposite didn't think that international law mattered
and that's why we got into the WP.
