Why professionalism in health care shouldn't depend on appearance

Johns Hopkins Medicine
6 followers
12 Video Views·Jan 6, 2025
Hi and welcome to the show. Subscribe at KevinMD.com slash podcast. Today we welcome Leilani Mae Acosta.
She's a neurologist. Today's KevinMD article is Putting On My Daily Mascara. Leah, welcome to the
show. Thank you so much for having me. All right, let's start by briefly sharing your story and
journey. Sure. So this article that I wrote, Putting On My Mascara, I wrote at the beginning
of the pandemic, essentially. And I speak a little bit of Spanish, enough to be dangerous,
because of the year I took in college. And I noticed that there were signs up all over the
hospital, of course, encouraging us to wear our masks in English and Spanish. And of course,
the Spanish word for mask is mascara on the signs we had in our hospital. And I thought it was
really interesting because I love words. I was an English minor. I do creative writing.
And so I noticed the similarities between the Spanish word for mask, mascara, and the English
word for mascara, which is typically associated with women's makeup. And I was going to be giving
a lecture to the neurology residents. And there is some video, but in case you have audio, I don't
usually wear a lot of makeup. I'm not wearing any makeup. I usually don't even wear any makeup.
But sometimes when I'm public speaking, maybe I'll put on a little bit of lipstick or some tinted
lip gloss just to look a little bit more animated when I'm speaking. And I was preparing to give
this lecture to the neurology residents. And I was looking for my lipstick, which, again,
I don't use very often. And I thought, Leah, why are you looking for lipstick to put on? It's going
to be under your mask that you're going to be wearing to give a lecture to these residents.
So what's the point of wearing it? And it just really got me thinking about the daily appearance
that we have, not only as physicians, but specifically as a woman physician,
how we appear to other people. And so why does it matter whether or not I was wearing lip gloss or
lipstick? Why do some women really commit to wearing mascara every day, or they feel like
they've got to have their face all made up in order to look like a doctor? And so it really got
me thinking about what it means to look like a doctor, so to speak, and specifically as a woman
physician, what people expect me to look like as a woman doctor. And I thought about not only just
makeup, but just about appearance. I mean, not to flatter myself, I have a fairly youthful
appearance. I'd like to thank my Filipino genes for that. And sometimes when I'm attending on the
inpatient wards in the hospital, or even just when I'm seeing patients in my dementia clinic,
because I'm a behavioral neurology specialist, I get a lot of comments, oh, you look so young,
you look too young to be a doctor. And sometimes I feel like I have to look older. Like when I'm
rounding with my team of residents, I got tired of the male intern being recognized as the attending
by the patient when I was the one who was the supervising physician. So I always wear my white
coat, and I feel like I have to look a certain way. And so I basically wrote this article as a
reflection of the expectations we have to look a particular way in medicine, again, specifically
for women physicians. And really, at the end of the day, as long as we look professional,
and we act professionally, how we look shouldn't matter as much. Certainly, we should be clean,
and kept, and look and act professionally. But I don't think we all have to look like, for example,
Dr. Barbie. So you talk about those expectations, especially as a female physician. Do you think
those expectations, do they come more from patients or more from your colleagues? I would
say the majority of those kinds of comments come from patients, because I mean, again, part of this
is because I'm working primarily with an older population. And so the comments of, oh, you look
like my child, or you look old enough to be my grandchild, those kinds of comments, and some of
them are meant to be kind. But some of them, there's this sort of undercurrent of, I don't
know if I can trust you, because you look too young. How long have you been doing this? Some
of those kind of unspoken questions sometimes arise with that. Thankfully, I don't really get
it as much from colleagues, even though sometimes, you know, not to be ageist in a stereotype in and
of itself, but sometimes I wonder if some of, you know, my colleagues have been doing this a lot
longer. Do they look at me, you know, no white hairs? Well, I had one, I plucked it out last
year, though. But you know, do they take me seriously if they think, oh, she must not have
been doing this for very long when I do have, you know, over a decade of clinical practices
and attending at this point? But you know, how do my colleagues perceive me in that regard?
So you've been practicing for a while now. And sometimes when you hear these comments
from patients, oh, you look so young and things like that. Like, how do you feel? How do you
receive those comments? I mean, I try to put a positive spin on it in terms of, you know,
joking about just one of those things that I'm grateful as I get older that I still look young,
you know, and I try to take care of myself and, you know, all those kinds of things in terms of
maintaining that youthful appearance. But, you know, at the back of my mind, there is a question
of, you know, are they calling into question my authority or my knowledge base or my capacity
to serve in this role? And so I really just underscore, you know, I appreciate the compliment
when it's given and just emphasize that I do have the experience and the training to be a
well-trained physician in order to take care of whatever medical questions they have.
And do you talk about this issue among your other female colleagues?
It does come up sometimes, especially, you know, about just, you know, makeup or, oh,
what should I wear to this conference? You know, how does this blazer look? Should I wear a blazer?
Do I have to wear heels? You know, those kinds of questions, that kind of stuff comes up
not infrequently among me and my colleagues. Because, you know, the story I share in the
article was even when I was applying for residency programs, my favorite suit to wear at the time
was the navy blue suit. And I was stressing out because I didn't have matching navy blue shoes.
And I was complaining to a friend of mine who was in the medical school as well. And he said,
why can't you just wear black shoes? And I said, you're a man, you don't understand,
you can wear black shoes with a navy suit and nobody bats an eye. But if a woman has a mismatched,
you know, pair of shoes, then, you know, they perceive her as not, you know, not caring about
her appearance. And so having some of those conversations does come up more with my female
colleagues as opposed to my male colleagues. And that leads me to the next question. Do you
feel that male physicians, of course, are less scrutinized for their appearance?
To some extent, yes. I mean, I guess just based on my own personal experience, I haven't had
many conversations with male colleagues about worrying, you know, oh, is my mate, you know,
is this lipstick the right shade? Or, you know, should I wear something to highlight my eyes? Or,
you know, does this color look good on me on stage? And not to say that my male colleagues
don't care about their appearance, but don't really outwardly hear them having the same kind
of concerns or actively thinking about it on a regular basis like I do more from my female
colleagues. So how do you feel about all of this in terms of female colleagues having that implicit
association between their appearance and their professionalism? So what does that say about
larger questions about how society views both men and women physicians? I think it speaks to
an older stereotype that's existed about, you know, certainly for a long time, women weren't
actually even trained to be physicians. And so there's a stereotype of the older man who is the
physician, or maybe the female is the nurse or, you know, some other healthcare worker, but you're
not the physician. And some of those stereotypes still kind of persist, even if not spoken
explicitly, somewhat implicitly. And I think, you know, we have to educate people that actually
almost half of the women entering, well, half the students entering medical school now are women.
And a lot of departments and hospitals are really recognizing that we need more women to be
represented within their fields. And they're striving for equal parity, not only just in terms
of numerical representation, but making sure that we also have equal pay, equal opportunities. You
know, a lot of studies have shown that, you know, unfortunately, women are disproportionately
not as present in C-suite roles or leadership roles or chair department roles or division
head roles. And so really recognizing the role of women physicians specifically within the
healthcare fields and, you know, giving them that recognition and those opportunities that sometimes
historically have been purposely deprived of them. Now, of course, you wrote your article in the
midst of the pandemic back in 2020. Now that we've emerged from the pandemic, people aren't wearing
masks all the time. They're not wearing scrubs all the time. Have you noticed any changes in
terms of the scrutiny women physicians face in terms of their appearance?
I don't think necessarily for women particularly. I have noticed some trends just in the overall
attire of physicians. Because I know, especially during the pandemic, I wore scrubs all the time,
just because we didn't know earlier on about transmission and things like that. And I've
transitioned mostly to my regular business attire in terms of dresses and skirts and things like
that. But I've noticed a lot more physicians are comfortable just wearing scrubs every day,
you know, either in the office or in the hospital. And certainly there are some
specialties that are kind of known more for wearing scrubs, for example, surgical specialties.
But I've noticed even non-surgical specialties, a lot more people are embracing kind of the more,
for lack of a better adjective, casual attire that scrubs is typically associated with in terms of
instead of wearing, you know, the suit and tie every day. So I've noticed that in particular.
And just for me personally, just kind of appreciating my own evolution and honestly,
my own self-perception about how I appear as a physician. So I don't wear my white coat as often
as I used to, mostly because of transmission purposes, because I used to wear my white coat
in clinic every day. And I don't do that as much just because it's a little bit easier. And I just
realized not that I was hiding behind that white coat, but I felt like I had to give that extra
stamp of I am the doctor taking care of you. And I've noticed that since I haven't been wearing
my white coat, I'm not really getting, it's not like the frequency of the, Oh, you look too young
to me. My doctor comments has, has gone down since I haven't been wearing it. So just noticing some
of those personal changes myself. How do you think that there's a balance between personal
self-expression, whether it's through fashion or through cosmetics? And is there a balance between
that type of self-expression versus professionalism? I think so. I mean, certainly those are not
mutually exclusive concepts because I think people need to be authentic in terms of how they
represent themselves. And I think they also have to bear in mind what it means to look like a
professional. And so, you know, for some women, they are horrified, for example, if their hair
starts to turn gray or white, and they're in a rush to die. And then maybe that helps give them
the confidence to appear more professional versus other women are fine with, you know, letting their
hair go white or gray. And I mean, there've been some interesting studies in terms of that perception
of, you know, do patients perceive physicians differently if they appear a certain way,
and specifically for women physicians, as far as, you know, the makeup and things like that.
But I think generally speaking, as long as you are presenting yourself in a professional way
and acting courteously, I think, you know, we have physicians of all shades of the rainbow
and all different kinds of, you know, fashion sense, so to speak. So I think as long as we
can represent ourselves authentically and still be professional, I do have a prop, if I may,
with this, I can show you. So I also happen to be an avid knitter and crocheter,
and I have a knit model of Einstein's brain that I made that was published in the journal
Neurology. And I put this on over my microphone here. But I often wear this around the hospital
because I'm a neurologist. And, you know, people often recognize it as a brain. And when I first
made this, you know, certainly, I was a little bit worried that people wouldn't take me seriously
because I'm wearing a knit model of a brain. But I've gotten so many positive comments from both
other colleagues and also just from people at the hospital, or even when I'm running my errands,
I had a lovely conversation one time with somebody at Trader Joe's whose mom was diagnosed
with dementia, you know, when they found out that I was a brain doctor. And so, you know,
that's just an example of sometimes, you know, we can worry about how we're perceived by other
people. But there's more to being professional than just quote unquote, face value as far as
how we look. And so that's why I just want to encourage, you know, that kind of personal
self-expression, which is so I think, well within the realms of what is considered professional.
You mentioned earlier that a lot of the attitudes towards how women are scrutinized
in terms of their appearance come from antiquated stereotypes. Now you work at an academic medical
center. So of course, you see the next generation of physicians, medical students, residents and
fellows. So what are you observing in terms of these new physicians coming up? Are they carrying
the same stereotypes that we're talking about today? Yes. So as far as students, I do think
that they're not necessarily as rigidly adhering to some of the stereotypes of what a doctor is
supposed to look like. I know even recently I've had discussions, I feel like, for example,
within society, tattooing has become a lot more commonplace. And some people have been nervous
about covering up, you know, they want to cover up their tattoos for fear of not appearing
professional. But I remember having a conversation once with a medical student that a patient who
also had tattoos really commented on the fact that the medical student also had tattoos. So
they had a bonding moment instead of that being something that turned the patient off, so to speak.
And so I think some of those more rigid expectations about how we expect a physician to
look have become a little bit looser with the current generation. We're talking to Leah Acosta.
She's a neurologist. Today's KevinMD article is Putting on My Daily Mascara. Leah will end with
some take-home messages that you want to leave with the KevinMD audience. I want to emphasize
that I hope that people feel comfortable expressing their authentic personalities as
far as their appearance and their dress and still be able to maintain a professional appearance with
their colleagues and with their patients. And I just want to encourage people to not feel like
they have to be so committed to a particular stereotype of how a physician is supposed to look,
especially for my female colleagues. Leah, as always, thank you so much for sharing your
perspective and insight, and thanks again for coming on the show. Thank you.
