Supplements and Heart Health: Updates on the latest research

Johns Hopkins Medicine
6 followers
103 Video Views·Jun 26, 2024
Today, Dr. Kelly Hedgepeth and I are going to be talking about some commonly used vitamins and supplements, and
as per our usual format, we'll be talking for about half the time and then taking audience questions.
And we also have a few polls in the beginning, so we're going to get some audience interaction here.
Thank you for those of you who've already submitted questions as well.
So I'm going to start
by showing you some slides here, and
next week we have Dr. Laura Frayne, who's a geriatrician, and she's going to be talking about the aging brain. But today we're going to talk about
vitamins and supplements,
and we're going to review the latest research and guidelines.
Supplements are
one of the biggest industries in this country. There's over 30 billion spent in this country every year on
supplements and vitamins, and over half of adults in this country use some type of supplement or vitamin, and I think
our patients probably well over half.
I would say in my practice, three-quarters at least of my patients use some type of supplements and vitamins.
So we see multivitamins, vitamin D, calcium, fish oil, vitamin C is probably the most common across the country,
and that's reflected in our practice as well. So how did this start with this craze about supplements? Well,
historically,
and usually starting in the 18th century, people think that this started with scurvy.
So sailors who were at sea for many, many months were developing a disease called scurvy,
where their teeth would start to bleed and fall out, and their bones were very painful, and it took
many years before people discovered that this was due to vitamin C deficiency, and that replacing
this vitamin C deficiency with a citrus fruit or ultimately vitamins, and this was in the 19th and 20th century,
resulted in miracle improvements in people's scurvy.
Similarly, rickets was found to be due to vitamin D deficiency, and correcting the D deficiency corrected the rickets.
So there was a real surge in interest in
micronutrients and vitamins, which are substances that need to be ingested
and have vital roles in the human body, and people started to say, well,
maybe we should take it to the next step. If replacing these vitamins helps cure a disease,
could we go further and take more vitamins and help prevent chronic disease and help promote longevity?
So there was a lot of interest, but not a lot of science, in taking vitamins and supplements to augment a
diet and to see if people could find
ways to live longer and live better.
In the 21st century, we find that the modern diet actually supplies necessary nutrients for virtually everybody,
and it's not clear that we still need to be taking supplements, minerals, or vitamins, and yet many, many people still do.
So it was coined as hope in a bottle, and that hope that taking an
additional substance in the interest of promoting health could indeed promote health. So that interest really outstripped the science,
and we don't have a lot of science to support that. But I want to start with a poll.
So Allie's going to launch a poll, and
we've got almost 75 people in the audience. I want you guys to vote and answer these questions.
So Allie is going to launch a poll here, and it's pretty straightforward to do that.
So the first question is, do you currently take supplements or vitamins on a regular basis? Yes or no?
I'm going to give you about 20 more seconds. Awesome. Okay. All right, great. Can you display that, Allie?
So we've got 92% of you say yes, and only 8% don't. So the 8% who don't take any supplements or vitamins
definitely in a clear minority.
Okay, and then
let's go to question number two. And
question number two is, which of the following...
Allie, I'm not seeing question number two yet. Which of the following do you take? And you can choose more than one. So calcium, D,
maltized, red yeast rice,
vitamin B folate, CoQ10, or something else? And again, we'll give this about 15 seconds.
Great. Thank you. Oh, goodness. You guys are excellent, excellent participants. We've got almost everybody voting. All right.
Allie, go ahead and share those results.
So obviously there's no right or wrong answer, but vitamin D's got the most votes here. 84% of you take vitamin D.
About half of you take calcium,
multivitamins, B12, CoQ10, and something else. And red yeast rice, not too many, about 6%.
Very interesting. Okay, perfect.
And then there's the third question here is just going to be, what's the main reason that you take these supplements or vitamins?
Again, you can choose more than one.
Did a doctor recommend it, or a friend or family recommended it, or you did your own research?
And I know that from many of my patients, you bring in newsletters and websites and articles you've found that promote these
vitamins and supplements.
So, historically, only about a quarter of people take supplements on their doctor's
recommendations, and most people take it on their own recommendation. And here it's about half and half.
Okay, perfect. So we're going to share that. So about half and half, doctor recommended it,
or you did your own research, and a few of you also had family members or friends recommending it.
Perfect. Thank you. So we'll get rid of that poll.
Okay, so today I'm going to talk a little bit about vitamin D,
calcium, omega-3 fatty acids, and red yeast rice. And then Dr.
Kelly Hedgepeth is going to talk about CoQ10, the folate and B vitamins, and vitamin C.
We're obviously not covering all the supplements out there. There are many, many more.
We just picked the ones that we see most commonly in our practice.
So vitamin D, which happens to be the one that I think 84% of you are taking, and I'll tell you I take it myself,
can be obtained from sunlight,
from food, including food where it naturally occurs, or food where it's fortified, and
supplements. So sunlight, it comes from UV radiation,
UVB for the most part, and less so UVA.
The problem is that if you look at the ultraviolet
wavelength, the same wavelength that allows your skin to produce and convert vitamin D is the exact same wavelength that can
contribute to aging of the skin and skin cancer. So most of us
don't spend a whole lot of time in the sun, and if we do, we're using sunscreen and we're covering up.
So sunlight used to be a major source of vitamin D, and nowadays it is not so much. To get enough vitamin D,
you'd have to spend about 15 minutes at midday in the Northern Hemisphere
during summer months,
about twice that if you have dark skin, because it takes longer to penetrate the melanin, and you'd want to do that every day
without
sunscreen on and without covering up.
So to have most of your body exposed for 10 to 15 minutes every day in the middle of the day, and most of us don't
do that, again, because of concerns about aging skin and skin cancer.
So sunlight's no longer a great source of vitamin D for most of us. Foods that have naturally occurring vitamin D are egg yolks,
salmon, some mushrooms. Not too many foods actually contain D, though.
Some foods are fortified, like milk has D added to it,
but you'd have to drink about a gallon of milk every day to get enough vitamin D from your diet alone, or to have
salmon once or twice every day. So most people don't consume enough of those foods to get vitamin D entirely from their diet.
Most people don't get enough from sunlight, and so a lot of people end up taking supplements either because
they have their level checked and it was low, or because somebody told them to do it, or they read about it and thought it
was useful. Now, if we look at
observational studies, which means we look at a population of people, and we measure their vitamin D, and we look at a
associations with diseases, we know that low vitamin D is associated with many, many diseases,
including, as we know, an increased risk of osteoporosis and hip fracture, but also heart disease and congestive heart failure,
stroke,
diabetes, high blood pressure,
dementia,
falling down. Now, we know also low vitamin D is strongly associated with increased risk of severe COVID,
so the immune system, and when scientists look at vitamin D receptors,
they're found on virtually every type of cell in our body. They're found in our blood vessels,
they're found in our immune system cells, they're found in our bone cells. So vitamin D is an extremely important
vitamin that a lot of people don't get enough of. Now, the problem is if we see that low vitamin D is associated with those diseases,
does it necessarily follow that taking vitamin D solves all those problems?
That's the million-dollar question, and unfortunately, not necessarily. So just to briefly review the pathway,
diet,
supplements, and sunlight
produce vitamin D in the skin,
convert it in the liver to 25-hydroxy vitamin D, and convert it in the kidney to
125-dihydroxy vitamin D. And from there, it has actions on the skeleton, on the blood vessels, and on the heart.
We know so much about bone health and vitamin D, and we know that 600 to 800 units of vitamin D per day
recommending vitamin D3, which is the final step in that pathway,
that's probably the healthiest way to get it, is what we need for bone health. To achieve a level in the bloodstream of at least
25. So vitamin D for bone health, 600-800 units a day, 25.
But there's a lot of controversy about vitamin D, that that level is not enough to protect against heart disease
and to help lower blood pressure, that the other effects of vitamin D on heart health may be required more vitamin D than that.
Unfortunately, there have been many randomized controlled trials in humans, meaning we take a thousand of you and we give you placebo,
we take another thousand of you and give you vitamin D,
and they have not been able to prove that giving vitamin D helps reduce the risk of a heart attack or stroke.
So even though there's clearly an association out there, and even though in
rodents and in test tubes, we can see that the vitamin D has a very important role in healthy blood vessels,
healthy immune system, we can't prove that it actually reduces risk of heart attack or stroke.
I'm going to come back to D in a moment,
but let's talk about calcium, because D also helps regulate calcium. Now, any of you who have a diagnosis of osteopenia or
osteoporosis have probably been told that you should increase your calcium intake. And
the recommendation for bone health is 1,000 to 1,200 milligrams of calcium every day.
And that can be from food and it can be from supplements.
The problem is that when we give people these higher doses of calcium, used to be more 1,200, 1,800 milligrams a day,
we saw that there was an increased association risk of cardiovascular disease risk.
So CVD is cardiovascular disease, heart attack and stroke.
Also an increased risk of kidney stones, an increased risk of constipation, which can lead to colon polyps.
So there's this mixed message out there about calcium,
which is that it's really good for your bones and you should get more calcium.
But you've got to watch out because it seems to also cause calcium deposits in the heart arteries,
which can lead to heart attack, and calcium deposits in the neck arteries, which can lead to stroke.
So when we talk about heart health, we don't recommend calcium to promote heart health.
But obviously we're a whole body and we have to keep our bones healthy, too.
And we want to keep the rest of our body healthy. So what's the right answer?
Well, it's a little complicated and it's still evolving,
but we know that low D is associated with this increased risk of heart attack and stroke.
Adding supplemental D doesn't appear to lower that risk.
But for bone health, probably the right answer is moderate amounts of calcium and D,
when possible, obtained from dietary sources, particularly for calcium, so dairy products, nuts, green vegetables,
weight-bearing exercise, which helps the heart health and the bone health, moderate sun exposure.
And then if you have D deficiency or osteoporosis, meaning if you've had your level checked or if you have osteoporosis,
then you should definitely take a vitamin D supplement, at the very least for your bone health.
And then there's some of us, including me, who believe that vitamin D is really healthy for immune health,
heart health, blood vessel health, even though we haven't yet proven it.
Now, there are ongoing studies, including one out of Harvard Medical School, to look at vitamin D,
fish oil, and other aspects and other vitamins to see if they can impact heart health,
that perhaps the studies that have been done to date have not been large enough
and haven't gone on long enough to prove what a lot of us have a gut feeling is probably going to show that D is healthy.
So, in the meantime, I can't say that there's scientific evidence that we should all be taking D,
but I can tell you that the basic science, the animal evidence, the test tube evidence,
would suggest that D deficiency is probably a very unhealthy thing.
And I'll add that the people who tend to have D deficiency, though, and this is where some of the controversy comes from,
are people who are housebound, so they're not getting out and getting stunned.
People who have obesity because fat cells tend to store the D and don't release it into the bloodstream.
People who smoke and older people.
And some people who have malabsorption syndromes where they don't absorb the nutrients from their body.
So, people who have low D, perhaps it's not the D that's causing this increased risk.
Perhaps it's the fact that they're elderly and housebound, living in a nursing home, smoking, carrying around more weight.
And those are the things that are putting them at increased risk.
So, anyway, it's a little bit complicated.
The science hasn't really caught up to the gut feelings yet.
But when in doubt, you can always have your blood level checked for vitamin D.
It's a simple blood test.
And if it's low, especially if it's below 30, it's definitely a good idea and safe to take supplemental D.
Okay, I'm going to shift gears a little bit and talk about omega-3 fatty acids.
So, omega-3 fatty acids are EPA, eicosapentaic acid, and DHA.
And these come from fatty fish, so mackerel, herring, tuna, salmon.
You can also get alpha-linolenic acid, which is converted in the body to EPA and DHA from plant sources like flaxseeds and walnut canola oil.
Most of the studies have been done on EPA and DHA, and we presume that healthy people convert alpha-linolenic acid to EPA and DHA.
So, we lump all the plant sources together with the fish sources, but that may be a leap of faith.
So, when in doubt, we generally recommend fish oil as a source of reliable EPA and DHA, unless you're a vegetarian, in which case it's probably just as good to get your alpha-linolenic acid from flaxseed and walnut.
So, another observational study has shown that people who eat a lot of fish have very low rates of heart disease and also healthier brains, lower risk of dementia, lower risk of Alzheimer's.
Again, does it therefore follow that taking fish oil will help lower the rate of heart disease and help lower the rate of dementia?
We know in test tubes that fish oil has anti-inflammatory effects.
We've seen in some experiments that it can help stabilize heart rhythm.
But again, unfortunately, the science has not borne out that taking fish oil supplements helps lower those risks.
What do we know?
The science shows for sure that high doses of fish oil, which would be four capsules a day of fish oil, four grams a day of EPA, DHA, lowers triglycerides.
It doesn't really affect LDL cholesterol at all.
So, we don't use it to lower your total cholesterol or your bad cholesterol, the LDL, but we do use it in those people who have very high triglycerides, like over 200, 250.
Okay, I'm going to stop with red yeast rice, and then I'm going to pass on to Dr. Kelly Hedgepeth, and we can take questions as we go and also at the end.
What's really interesting about red yeast rice is that the active ingredient is the exact same, identical ingredient in lovastatin, which is one of the statin drugs that we use prescription strength to lower cholesterol.
So, I have patients who can't take statins because of muscle aches, and they take red yeast rice instead, and their cholesterol comes down a bit, and their muscle aches really aren't a big problem.
So, you've got to monitor the liver. You should monitor the muscle. You have to watch out for interactions with drugs that interact with statins, like, for example, grapefruit.
So, if someone eats more than a grapefruit every day, or drinks more than a glass of grapefruit every day, just as we warn people who take statins not to do that, you shouldn't do that with red yeast rice.
The other downside of red yeast rice versus a statin is that the amount of monoclon K, or the effective ingredient, pill to pill in the same bottle, or bottle to bottle from the same company, or different company, different company, varies widely.
So, you could have one bottle where your dose is twice that of your next bottle, for example. So, in general, with supplements and vitamins, because it's not regulated, you can have variable amount of the effective ingredients.
There can be contaminants and unwanted things included in it. So, for example, some have gluten, and you might be gluten intolerant, et cetera. And that's not just for red yeast rice. That's true of all vitamins and supplements.
All right, so I'm going to pause there. Allison, is there anything we should answer now, or do you want to hold questions for the end?
I'm muted. Hi, everyone.
I know, totally, yes. Well, it's nice to be back. So, there's no questions yet, but I think, you know,
this is really interesting from my point of view, because, you know, just preparing for this talk today, I'm sure you feel the same way.
Like, we are so blessed in cardiology that we have so much really fantastic data so that when we make recommendations to patients, we can really say, this is what we expect the outcome to be.
And really feel, you know, that we're basing our recommendations on real truth. And you're talking about vitamins and supplements and just reviewing the quality of some of the data.
It is so soft and so murky that even things that we take for granted, I think, are really, it's difficult to draw conclusions from.
So, I just want to, you know, preface that. So, thank you for those summary slides. I think, especially everything that's been in the popular press recently with COVID in our immune function, that the vitamin D story is so interesting.
Obviously, you know, when you and I are talking about things, we have the cardiovascular angle and, you know, when we were really looking at things usually through the lens of a cardiologist, but I think it raises a lot of interesting points, right?
So, do we really understand the dose of these vitamins needed for bone health? Do we really understand the dose needed for cardiovascular health? And, you know, is there a different dose for your immune health, right?
So, there really is a lot of unknowns.
We really get two months out of the year that there's the opportunity, right? And, you know, most of the year, even if we're outside all day, we're never going to make enough vitamin D, right?
So, most people need to be taking a supplement, and you might need more if you do have a darker skin tone, right? Because you're going to really make zero from your environment.
Sorry, I don't know if it was just me, but you just froze, and I don't know if you froze for other people. Will you just repeat what you'd like to get normalized?
Sure. So, when I checked vitamin D, I found a lot of levels that are super low. So, and I agree that less than 20 is low. And so, and when I get those levels normal, I found that your blood sugar and your blood pressure is much easier to get.
So, I do think there's something going on with not only inflammatory pathways, but pathways looking at vascular tone regulation and how we handle blood sugar, that vitamin D is really important.
You know, it's so interesting, and I didn't mention this, but low vitamin D is also associated with a much higher risk of muscle aches in people who take statins.
And a lot of people who've historically said, I can't take statins, my muscles hurt so much, we take a step back, we stop the statin, we put them on vitamin D for a couple weeks, and then restart the statin, and they can then tolerate it.
But that's, that's very true across the board. If you can't take statins for muscle aches, you should have your D level checked.
And I'm going to be talking about CoQ10 when we move on, which I think is really important also for that statin.
Yeah.
To round this out, if you are experiencing muscle aches from statins, we always want to be aware of what your thyroid function is and your vitamin D.
So, everybody should really be aware of that if you're on those medications.
So, there probably is some signal with level.
We just don't know if supplementing and how we supplement can prevent that.
So, some of the treatments supplemented in this one-time mega dose have not seen the robust outcomes, and smaller studies have shown that just increasing the regular daily dose might be a much better way to do that.
But again, there's a big world that we're not certain about.
So, a lot to think about and a lot to talk about.
I don't see any other questions on the vitamin D level.
Yeah, so people can put questions in the chat, but also in the Q&A.
But maybe why don't you go on with your slides, and then we'll come back to all this at the end.
That sounds good.
Okay, so let me share my screen.
And while you're doing that, you did break up for everybody.
So, the level of vitamin D that we aim for is typically 50 to 70, and I'm going to put that in the chat.
Great, and it says I'm logged on and secure.
So, if it happens again, I apologize, and I'll just repeat what you missed.
So, let's start talking about CoQ10, because in the cardiology world, this is a really common supplement.
We didn't have that in the poll, but I think, or maybe we did have it in the poll.
Did you ask this, Dara?
Yes.
No, I don't think it was in there.
You know, many of my patients are on CoQ10, which we're going to talk about why.
But if you're on a statin, it's really common to be taking this supplement.
So, this is the chemical formulation.
It comes in three different forms.
Typically, the ubiquinone is the most common supplement.
There are differences, genetic polymorphisms that are common in the population that may affect
absorption.
So, if we do check levels and we're not seeing a bump in your level, it might be that you have
one of these polymorphisms.
In that case, substituting or supplementing with a different formulation might make sense for you.
But we don't routinely even think about any of this when we're talking about supplementation
now.
So, again, this feels a little bit like the wild west, because we don't have a lot of
data to back up these different forms presently.
So, CoQ10 is a cofactor that is important for generating energy in our cells.
So, this is a schematic of a mitochondria, which is the workhorse in the cell, right?
So, this is found in all the tiny cells in our body.
But particularly, those parts of our body that are really needing to generate energy,
like our muscle cells or our heart, is where you might expect that CoQ10 is really important.
So, the bulk of the data we have is really related to muscle side effects, which a lot
of times we see with statins.
And also, in those patients that have heart failure, affecting the cardiac muscle as well.
So, I reviewed some of this data, and I'm trying to maybe simplify this as much as possible
with the caveat, again, that there is really nothing simple or straightforward when we're
talking about these supplements.
Again, CoQ10 is a factor in all of our cells, and we are really hypothesizing that it would
have the greatest impact in the heart and the muscle.
Other organs, like the pancreas, the kidney, and the liver, also have high levels of CoQ10.
So, when you take the supplement, it's absorbed through the small intestine, and then we see
a steady state reached in the plasma, in the blood, and that's the level we check.
We hope that that translates to a steady state in the organ system, but that probably really
takes weeks to months to have that happen.
So, being on a supplement for a longer period of time before you really draw conclusions
is probably important.
The good news about CoQ10 is it is really widely used and generally really well tolerated.
The most common reported side effects are GI upset, followed by insomnia, and, you know,
those are very subjective things.
You know, obviously, if you're taking a supplement, you don't want to have any, but I think, in
general, this is regarded as a pretty safe supplement to be on.
There are potentials, however, for drug interactions, and this is where it's important because these
supplements are not regulated the same way that we regulate medications, right?
So, there might be a lot of variations between company and company, but there is potential
for interactions between CoQ10 and medications that lower your blood sugar.
So, those diabetic patients taking insulin might want to follow their blood sugar levels
if they're starting CoQ10.
There also is a small body of evidence that CoQ10 can actually lower your blood pressure.
So, the data there is pretty shallow in terms of seeing a robust response, but if you are
somebody that's adding this supplement and you're already on blood pressure agents, you
know, you might want to just make sure you're not having an interaction or finding that
your blood pressure is running much lower with the CoQ10 in your diet.
It also has the potential to interact with warfarin, which is a blood thinner, which
we have to follow levels, so we might see a big change in whether you're therapeutic
or not.
So, if you are on warfarin, obviously, starting any supplement, you would want to make sure
that your physician and coagulation team knows.
Okay, so why do we care about CoQ10 and statins?
Well, statins block the pathway of cholesterol production in the body, and it turns out that's
the same pathway that we make our CoQ10.
So, by taking this statin, you're blocking your internal production of CoQ10.
CoQ10 levels in our blood actually decline as we age.
So, I can't stop you from aging, so if we're adding a statin in addition to that, then
we really see the potential for those levels to fall.
We have the ability to follow those levels, although I will say from reading the literature,
I don't know that supplementing to a specific level in your blood actually has bore out
to translate into, if you're hit this level, you won't have any side effects.
I think it's much more complicated than that.
But the bulk of the data I do have is in that subgroup of people that are on a statin that
have experienced muscle pain, muscle fatigue, or muscle weakness, and we kind of clump all
those people together into one group, what we can abbreviate as SAMs, or statin-associated
muscle symptoms.
So, this is a really busy slide, and partly I want to show it to you to show you the raw
data, but also to illustrate just the complexity.
So, this is data from a meta-analysis, and what a meta-analysis does is it takes all
of these little trials that have tried different small doses of CoQ10 in a group and may or
may not have shown an impact and kind of blends them together to see if we can draw some conclusions
by increasing the number of participants included in this trial.
So, you can see here that it does appear that when we do this meta-analysis and marry together
some of these smaller trials that we really do see a benefit in CoQ10 in reducing muscle
pain within those patients on statins reporting muscle pain, with reducing muscle weakness,
again, in those patients on a statin reporting muscle weakness, and a little more borderline
for those reporting cramps and muscle tiredness.
So, this is fairly robust data saying CoQ10 is safe, and if you're experiencing muscle
symptoms, there's probably some benefit, which is great news.
So, we, I think in cardiology, are pretty routinely using CoQ10 in those patients that
have muscle symptoms.
The dose studied is typically 200 or 400 milligrams a day.
Taking doses smaller than that may or may not have an effect.
And typically, you know, the same as Dara said, when we supplement with vitamin D, we
really want to reach a steady state before we reintroduce the statin.
The same ideas with the CoQ10, we would really want to build that up for several weeks or
maybe even longer to see an increase in the CoQ10 in the actual muscle, you know, before
expecting to have any benefit from that.
There is some data for other things besides skeletal muscle, but that data is much less
robust, as I said.
So, the role of CoQ10 for high blood pressure or for heart failure is less clear.
Since, you know, this is a cardiology lecture and we're talking about cardiovascular health,
even though I don't have great data for heart failure, I did want to just share some data
with you because I do think the downside is pretty minimal besides the cost of the CoQ10
in terms of adding that to your regimen.
So, the data for heart failure has really looked at those patients that are the most
sick and have recurrent symptoms or are in and out of the hospital, right?
So, these aren't patients that have a diagnosis and that are doing well.
Not all studies have shown a clear benefit, but one of the more recent trials that was
a larger trial that studied a little over 400 patients did show some positive findings,
which I think is still, you know, suggesting there could be a benefit is certainly not
part of the heart failure regimen, but I think it is interesting.
So, for the heart failure data, usually these studies look at higher doses than we use for
when we're treating statin muscle pain.
Typically, 100 milligrams taken three times a day or sometimes even 200 milligrams taken
three times a day is the dose studied.
And in this one trial, they looked at those patients with heart failure who got readmitted
to the hospital and how they did on a six-minute walk test and there did seem to be a benefit.
So, while it's not a first-line agent, I think if patients aren't doing well and they're
not maybe tolerating some of their other medications for heart failure, there's probably little
harm in adding this and maybe some benefit.
So, I say that with a caveat.
So, I don't know if we have any questions for CoQ10.
Otherwise, I'll just keep going.
So, someone was asking how we can measure the level of CoQ10, and I think that's
done in research, right?
We really don't measure it.
So, you can measure the plasma level through send-out labs.
It's not routinely done.
In my panel that I have set up with Boston Heart, which some of my patients are on, we
do some metabolic and advanced lipid profiling, and it can be included in that, but it's not
routinely done through the Brigham at this time.
Okay.
So, I'll keep moving on then because I did want to talk about the B vitamins.
So, this is a schematic of all the B vitamins, which are found in plants and some of them
a lot in animal sources.
So, B6 is found a lot in salmon and also in poultry, and then B12 is also found in animal
sources.
These B vitamins are grouped together a lot when we talk about cardiovascular health,
and there is some promising data that supplements might be beneficial.
It's, again, not straightforward, and when we're talking about B vitamins, I want to
mention homocysteine.
So, homocysteine is a metabolite that's found in cellular processes.
Did I freeze again?
My apologies.
A metabolite found in cellular processes, and it has a potential role in the propagation
of cardiovascular disease.
So, we see evidence of it when we look in the vasculature at cardiovascular plaques
where there's these really lipid-thick bone cells where there's inflammation going on
and also evidence of kind of that fat buildup in the vascular wall.
Homocysteine potentially affects how soft and relaxed our blood vessels are or how stiff
they are and also can affect the clotting cascade, so potentially important for cardiovascular
health, and I show that just because when we're talking about homocysteine, and this
is, you know, a busy slide, but this is an important cellular process, and to shuttle
back from these amino acids, cysteine and methionine, you kind of have to go through
homocysteine, and so this pathway goes back and forth, and lo and behold, here are the
B6, B12, and folate.
The B vitamins are really, you know, propagating this pathway both ways.
So, when we talk about, you know, supplements of B6, B12, and folate, we're really linking
it to hyperhomocysteine, right?
So, we have seen that these high levels of homocysteine might be more apparent in vegetarians,
and that's because they have lower B6 and B12 in their diet, certainly is associated
with malnutrition, which sometimes we see with alcoholism.
There's other medical conditions like pernicious anemia, where we have impaired absorption
that we see this, and then those patients with chronic liver and kidney disease, sometimes
with autoimmune diseases as well, and then there also are some genetic variations in
that enzyme also regulating that pathway.
So, a number of different reasons that we might see homocysteine elevated, but when
we supplement with folate B6 and B12, the trials individually have been very mixed.
Some have been positive, some have been negative.
Overall, looking at all-cause cardiovascular disease, there's not a clear benefit.
When you tease out just the stroke, and that's what's shown here, it does look in this meta-analysis
that there is a benefit overall with adding folate B6 and B12.
Again, this is not straightforward, but I think is really interesting for us to talk
about, especially, you know, if we can make maybe some personal recommendations and not
be trying to jump and supplement for everybody, but, you know, specifically for our patients
at the highest cardiovascular risk, there might be a benefit here.
When we look at just the folate alone, the data is a little more mixed, okay, and I don't
want to make this lecture too technical, but I also don't want to oversell the importance
of folate or the importance of really just being critical of the literature when we go
through it, so this is another forest plot, a meta-analysis looking at the incidence of
stroke with just supplementing with folate, and so the take-home here would be, oh, there's
a benefit of folate alone, but there's a big caveat because this data here is really driven
by this one large trial which had over 10,000 patients, which I think everybody can see
from this forest plot here, right, that it's really this diamond that's in the significant
phase is really driven by this blue square, which is this one trial, and so the difference
in China is that folate is not supplemented in their diet as it is in the U.S., so folate
is a B vitamin that is critical for pregnant women in preventing neural tube defects in our
offspring, so in the U.S., we supplement our cereals and our flour with folate. In China,
they don't, and so in this one study where homocysteine levels are very high and folate
is low, you see this robust reduction in stroke, but I think we're not seeing that extrapolate to
the U.S. population where we have much more folate in our average diet, so my conclusions
from reviewing this literature is that the benefit for stroke reduction from the B vitamins
include taking folate, B6, and B12, and that the reduction that we see is really hinged on the
homocysteine level, okay, so even though there isn't a clear benefit or reduction in having a
heart attack by homocysteine, it does seem that probably there's good data for stroke prevention,
especially if the homocysteine is elevated, and then the type of folate that we supplement
is sometimes easier or sometimes, if it's methylated, bypasses some of the genetic
abnormalities that we see in our population, so it is recommended to choose a methylfolate,
and then it's also recommended that we choose a methylated B12 because B12 can actually be toxic
at high doses, especially if your kidneys are not normal, so I tried to summarize a very
technical aspect of this, and I hope that that makes sense to people. Any questions coming in?
The methylated type is something that you just buy in the drugstore. You just have to
look for methylated? Read the ingredients, and it'll have a methyl in front of the type of the B12
or the B6. Okay, and there's another question, which is, it applies to CoQ10, but also really to
everything, which is, are we dosing based on body weight? Should we dose more for someone who weighs
more, less for someone who's small? So, a great question, and I definitely do not have the answer
to that. I can tell you that the doses that we routinely use for the muscle symptoms is much
less than what's been studied in heart failure, and there is this body of evidence in neuromuscular
diseases that have looked at CoQ10, and they supplement at much higher doses as well, and I am
not as familiar with that literature, so I think it's really hard to make a blanket statement about
that, but those are all, you know, great questions. Should we be doing that, and does it matter?
You know, probably yes, but we don't have a lot of data to guide us. I think, you know, if you look
at pharmacology, some vitamins and supplements are fat-soluble and stored in fat. Others are
water-soluble and excreted every day, and so it really, there's a lot of things that determine
how much of a medicine or a vitamin or a supplement one should take. Warfarin, Coumadin, for example,
you can have a little tiny person who requires tons of it because they metabolize it so much
more quickly than a larger person, so it's not always as simple as weight-based. Sometimes it
has to do with fat percentage, blood volume, kidney function, liver function, et cetera, so
very good question, and I think the jury's out on that. Okay. Sorry, keep going if you want to.
Okay, sure. So, I just had a couple more slides. We'll leave the B vitamins and move on to vitamin
C. So, the data for vitamin C is not that robust. I think, I wanted to comment on it, though,
because, you know, I grew up taking vitamin C. I think a lot of people add it to, you know,
their daily supplements, and for cardiovascular disease, we just don't have that much data saying
that it's clearly beneficial for your heart. It is a potent antioxidant, and so I think everybody
feels that it is important in immune function. Some of the trials have looked at upper respiratory
tract infections, especially in kids, and I think that's probably where the most robust data is,
that vitamin C might be beneficial. The other issue with vitamin C is it does seem that the
ability to absorb or reach certain levels with oral absorption is very different than the levels
you can reach with IV vitamin C, so there is some data in the cancer literature that, you know,
supplementation with IV vitamin C might be beneficial, especially if you're undergoing
chemotherapy. I'm not going to talk too much about that just because that's really out of,
you know, our expertise. So, sticking with cardiovascular disease, I just want to show you
some of the data from a recent meta-analysis that, again, takes these smaller trials, you know, and
tries to really choose trials that can be married together and then look at them critically,
and we're just not seeing a really clear benefit from the cardiovascular aspect with supplementing
vitamin C. Oops. Okay. So, those, I think, are the end of my slides.
All right. And I'm just going to wrap up with my little summary slides here.
And oops. Sorry. I need to move forward. Okay. Thank you. So, just to summarize,
that as a general statement on vitamins and supplements, there's lots of observational
studies that have shown that people who take vitamins and supplements live longer, live
healthier, but there are not a lot of randomized data to show that taking those vitamins and
supplements is what is the cause of the longer, healthier life. So, for example, people who take
multivitamins tend to also not smoke and exercise and eat a healthy diet and see their doctors
regularly. So, is it the multivitamin that makes people live longer, or is it just the fact that
people who take vitamins tend to be healthier? And I would say that most of the data would suggest
that there's certainly a role for the fact that this is a bias of selecting people who are
healthier. And you could look at our patients, and I think our patients take a lot of vitamins
and supplements and tend to live much longer than the general population. And I'm not sure we can
all take credit for it, but healthier people tend to see their doctors and take these supplements.
For now, what we do know for sure is that for the general healthy population, it's very safe and
very effective to get your nutrients, your vitamins through a healthy diet. And the Mediterranean
largely plant-based diet has certainly been shown in multiple studies to reduce risk of stroke,
heart attack, cancer, and death in general. And the exceptions would include people who have
restricted diets or are taking certain medications or have certain increased nutrient needs. So,
people who are pregnant, people who have malabsorption problems or bariatric surgery,
people with macular degeneration, vegans or other restricted diets, osteoporosis,
people who take proton pump inhibitors like omeprazole, prilosec, nexium tend not to absorb
the B vitamins and calcium as well. And older adults in general may benefit as well. So,
from certain vitamins like B12, D, and calcium. And a final statement is that if you do decide
to take supplements, please discuss it with your physician because there's certainly
interactions with other drugs that can make supplements unhealthy. So, just because something
is natural doesn't necessarily mean it's safe. It may be. And it may be great. But anything that
exerts an effect on your body, whether you've got it at CVS through a prescription or you've
bought it over the counter, it exerts an effect on your body that may be what you intend and
may be things you don't intend. So, remember that the FDA doesn't regulate the safety,
effectiveness, cannot regulate contaminants. And they're constantly pulling things off the
shelves and off the market when they find contaminants or dangerous side effects.
But they can't keep up with all the things that are currently showing up on the shelf.
And the advertising budgets and the things that people can claim are really not regulated at all.
So, again, drug interactions. If you are going to take a supplement, there are certain
independent verifying companies like the USP, the pharmaceutical industry that can
verify that there are a few contaminants and that it contains what it says it does. So,
look for a USP verified or another type of verified like Consumer Lab. And in general,
you don't want to exceed the US recommended daily allowance for what a vitamin should be.
And a couple of really good websites here. And we'll send these slides out to people.
Drugs.com, you can look for interactions. So, you go on that website and you write
interaction checker. And you can look for interactions with your drugs and your vitamins.
And WebMD.com, it tends to be an excellent website as well. The National Institutes on
Health has an office of dietary supplements that has some really good information.
And the Harvard Medical School health letter, which is free, has lots of different topics,
health topics that Dr. Kelly Hedgepeth and I have contributed to this over the last couple of years.
And they do a lot on supplements as well. So, I'm going to stop sharing. And I think we have
a few more questions. So, please feel free to put your questions in the Q&A. And can you tell us,
Allison, is there a type of CoQ10 that you particularly recommend?
So, I have recommended a brand, JAROW, J-A-R-R-O-W, which I think is just a brand that's
well vetted. And I've come across independent sites that, you know, have said it has what
it says it has in it. And it's a good source. I think it's really difficult to vet some of these
supplement companies. I don't know what your approach is, Dara.
Yeah. No, I think there are a couple of really good companies that are very good. NatureMade
is a good one. Thorne is a good one. If you look at, like, the Consumer Reports or other
independent websites that don't take advertising, they have independently reviewed the most reliable
ones. Most of them are made in the U.S. or mostly made in the U.S., where it's more
closely regulated. But each vitamin is a little bit different. So, for CoQ10, that's JAROW. And
for others, I'm going to put down here Thorne. NatureMade is an easy-to-find one as well.
Kirkland Brand, which is a Costco brand, is also very well regulated. Gosh, we're running
out of time, and there's a bunch of questions that have come up. Oh, so when you guys put things
in the chat, I just want you to know that we can see it, but the other audience members can't. So,
someone put in consumerlabs.com, which is a subscription service that tests supplements.
So, that's really helpful. Thank you. And now I don't know what now is. But let me see if there's
a couple more questions, maybe broad questions, before we wrap up. And one is hypothyroidism. I
don't know if that was something that was tying into a few of the topics we talked about earlier,
but is there anything that you want to add about hypothyroidism when it comes to supplements and
vitamins? Well, I think thyroid function is really critical to your metabolism. So, that's something
that routinely is checked, and sometimes patients are just not aware their doctor is checking it.
But certainly, if you are on a medication for your cholesterol, you have to be normal thyroid. So,
that's something we routinely check. And then, if you're having side effects from any cholesterol
treatment, that should also be repeated. Yeah. Great. I'm trying to…somebody wanted to see
that website again, so I'm just trying to put them back. There we go. Okay. Perfect. All right.
Great. I think…sorry that we did not get to finish all of these, but we should wrap up. And
it was such a pleasure to see everybody back again. We had almost 100 people by the end there,
and we really appreciate everybody's interaction and throwing the questions and the answers in and
sharing that with everyone. So, please, when you get…you're going to get after this email,
you'll get…we'll send out the websites. Allie, if you can send out the websites with the email
with the questionnaire. So, give us your feedback. Give us new ideas for webinars. We're going to
start a whole new season of webinars again, starting as the summer wraps up. And next week,
please join us for Dr. Laura Frain talking about the aging brain. She's wonderful, and she is going
to help us talk about what's normal aging, what's not normal, and when to worry. So, thank you all
so much. Thanks, Dr. Kelly Hidfeth, and thanks to Allie LeBlanc, our behind-the-scenes assistant
here. And thanks to all of you for coming. Great to be here this week. See everyone next week.
